Home
Creators
Search Recent Missing Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Ranking the Vault Tracks (So Far!!!) (Patreon)

Published:
2025-04-20 20:46:25
Imported:
2026-09
Tags:

Videos

  • 453330332.mp4

Downloads

Content

Besties we thought it was about time we rank all the vault tracks we have, before Debutation infiltrates our worlds eventually!! We have never done this before and it was really quiteeee fascinating to see where they all ended up!

Please tell us your ranking below 🫶

Files

Comments

Ana 🌸

Can’t wait to watch !!!! Thanks girls ❤️❤️❤️❤️

Alana1989xox

Yes!! Can't wait to watch 🥰 happy Easter weekend!

farah abed

OMG IM SOOOO EXCITED 🥹🥹 and the different tier names are GENIUS 🔥🔥🔥

Hollie

I should never check Patreon on my way to bed. Guess I’m staying up another hour.

Terah Moxley

I love this! And, I saw this thing on TikTok the other day where someone was picking their favorite lyric per album. I would love to see you guys do that or do like a top 20 favorite lyrics.

Katie LaFave

saying it now before even watching… justice for the very first night! that song is a bop!! also justice for bye bye baby!! that song is soooo good

Nadily Perandin

*Stops a Chats & Reacts video to watch another Chats & Reacts video immediately*

farah abed

i just know before starting the video where you guys have ranked ‘we were happy’ and ‘bye bye baby’ 🥲🥲🤣🤣🤣🤣

kienan

This is so fun! I was just rewatching the original reactions to You All Over Me and Mr Perfectly Fine 😭😭 we were all such babies when Fearless TV was dropped

Katie LaFave

say don’t go is my fav!! it’s also one of my fav TS songs of all time!!! not including all too well 10 btw

Katie LaFave

my fav vault track from each album: fearless: mr. perfectly fine speak now: timeless red: babe 1989: say don’t go

Katie LaFave

do people not like joy?! message in a bottle is such a fun bop

Dominic Cuomo

Favorite from each album Fearless: Mr. Perfectly Fine Red: Message In A Bottle Speak Now: Castle’s Crumbling 1989: Is It Over Now?

Dillon Hayes-Pelletier

Fav vaults from each album: Fearless: Mr. Perfectly Fine Red: Message In a Bottle Speak Now: I Can See You 1989: Now That We Don’t Talk Excludes All Too Well 10 because nothing tops it, sorry message in a bottle.

Alana1989xox

Justice for 'Dont You'! It's my favourite fearless vault track! I get goosebumps every time 😭 Love y'all 🥰

Martina

Me i was just watching their ttpd reaction 😂

Anna Mehrbilder

Mr Perfectly Fine made me a swiftie. My child loved it and for a while we sang it every evening while brushing teeth. than we added more and more of her big hits - and than, one day, I was watching a real bad movie (german love movie) and there was a really good song, very good song and I thought, it sounded like taylor, but I had never heard it. it was Today Was A Fairytale. I was obsessed and I discovered the taylor behind the singles and oh my - what a world, I am so happy. so mr perfectly fine will be forever the most wonderful song to me.

Ran

Dear Bonny and dear Emily, I decided to just write this really openly and I’ve tried to find somewhere to send this to you- so first of all hi, I’m Ran, I’m 21 years old, I’ve been watching your YouTube and Patreon videos for really a while and I just wanted to say Thank You. I’ve been experiencing what was probably the toughest and most lonely and painful year of my life, And I discovered that the online Swiftie community content really comforts me and helps me cheer up and feel less alone, and eases all the anxiety and darkness. A few months ago I subscribed to your Patreon and your videos have been really saving me. I’ve encountered A LOT of crisises and brutal panic attacks and in a lot of ways just pulling up a video of yours to watch is one of the things that can kind of help me snap out of it and bring myself back and clear my mind and rearrange my thoughts. So a huge thank you for that. You are two intelligent beautiful women, funny, pleasant, and you have such a positive vibe. It’s always mesmerizing to listen to what you have to say and get such deeper exploration of songs and albums I love so much, and watch your delightful insights enthusiastic reactions for things I feel the same way about but have no one to share it with in me real everyday life. You treat everything and choose your words with such humanity, compassion, authenticity and care, Every song breakdown that you posted moved me and made me connect to each song in ways and depths I never felt before, You’ve made me shed tears and burst with laughter countless times, and it’s so nice that through the screen- you’re still able to make your viewers feel like they’re just your friends. Every time i got a notification when you posted a new video I had a breath of relief because I knew I have something interesting and fun and enriching to hold onto tonight if I start feeling bad. And I like to listen to your album breakdowns and stuff like that while I’m painting. I’m SO happy you got to receive those letters from Taylor because watching that video really made my entire week. It’s just amazing. Having said all that, I’m in better place and time right now but it was extremely important to me to express that and show gratitude to you two. Thanks a lot for your awesome content and personalities, i am really grateful for the fact you made this channel and I’m looking forward to keep on supporting you always. Best wishes, Ran

Ken Mazur

i'm so excited for you guys to dive into the ranking of all the vault tracks by album after Debut and Rep tv drops. For now, Red TV tops my list. Song wise, Mr Perfectly Fine, Nothing New, Say Don't Go, Run, and Electric Touch are my top 5. Better Man, Timeless, and Is It Over Now come next.

Ash2205

You’re losing me has left the chat

Richard

Sorry, I disagree with you Emily on Phoebe on Nothing New. She was great on the song. I love Taylor doing collabs. Phoebe can relate because she is a woman. Taylor should have collabs with other people. I don't listen to Phoebe albums but she was good on the song.

Marissa Turner

I agree with Bonny about Phoebe providing the perspective of an additional girl experiencing the same thing! For me, Nothing New is the other side of the coin from Clara Bow. I feel like both songs are made stronger by the acknowledgement that the industry is chronically looking for the next ingenue, and that tons of girls -> women are experiencing the same pipeline. Because the anxieties explored in Nothing New are deeply rooted in issues within the entertainment industry

Katie LaFave

happy easter to everyone who celebrates!!

ton

Hard agree You’re losing me is THE superior Vault Track! (wA10W)

EllActually

My take on The Very First Night is that she misses this person like it's the very first night that they've been gone, so maybe they've been apart for weeks or months or whatever but she still misses them that intensely? Like her missing of that person hasn't diminished at all

Luli Swiftie

I remember Hayley telling that Taylor asked for her to sing in another song but she did not liked and asked for another and then did Castles crumbling…

chel

Omg !!!!! You girlies are just the gift that keeps on giving!!!

Kiki

My top 5 vault tracks: Say don't go Better man Babe Forever winter Is it over now

Katie LaFave

well mr. perfectly fine was written after fearless came out so it couldn't have gone on fearless originally anyway

ton

My favs Fearless…Mr PF… the extension of “the way I loved you” using PF as well as use of casually cruel was a great example of her lyrical transitions. I love a vault that adds tea to the overall narrative of her music SN…..(my least fave vaults sorry) … I can see you maybe? Although might be because it got an MV. It does expand on how TS was growing at this time Red… A10W is gorgeous. Looove it as a true vault example. Otherwise IBUTAM, Better Man, Babe, Ronan, nothing new are all fantastic 1989… I love them all but IION adds lore so def a fav version of a vault Midnights…. You’re losing me… is beautiful and a perfect vault…

ella

We Were Happy & Don’t You are my favorite vault songs (alongside Nothing New & ATW10) but Timeless would fall into the “Nothing New” category for me so I guess it’s proof that Taylor truly has a perfect song for everyone!

Kiara Pugliese

am i the only castles crumbling stan 😭 that song is sooo good

Lynny Smith

Electric touch being in Emily’s top tier is healing to my soul - anyone in my life knows how much I love that song, it’s the besttt 😍😍 My favourites from each vault; Fearless: That’s When Red: ATW10 (obviously), so second would be Better Man Speak Now: Electric Touch - very closely followed by Timeless 1989: Is It Over Now? I think I also agree that the Speak Now vaults are my favourite (so far) - I always loved speak now however since the vaults, I find myself going back to the album more than I used to 💜

ella

My personal ranking of the vaults as a whole would be: 1) Red 2) Fearless 3) 1989 4) Speak Now

chel

Idk if this is really embarrassing to admit but whenever you do one of these ranking videos, i go on to tier maker, copy your categories and rank along with you hahahaahah

Terah Moxley

No love for “All of the Girls You Loved Before”?!?

Momo

We aren't including You're Losing Me ?

Linda

Nothing New is 🤌🤌🤌 Thanks Bon

chatsandreacts

Oh! Umm I guess not haha I think this was focused more on the re-records. But we all know that you’re losing me would be number 1 💛

subtle reads

Ok but my question is, where is Sweeter Than Fiction TV on streaming? I know that song gets left in the dust cuz not many people talk about it, but like where is it Taylor? It’s been 2 years since 1989 TV came out

ton

Here’s my stab at interpreting how I understand Very first night. For me I link it to her meeting HS at the first awards show. He left to go to to NY And she missed him so much she followed him there to continue the hookup. So she misses him as much as she did when he left on the first night.. it’s about that immediate giddy joy of starting something new

Darienne

I feel the same way! I couldn’t articulate what I was thinking so thank you for doing that lol

Fi🌸

I think it makes total sense to have Hayley Williams if you know paramore lore haha and what happened during that speak now time. How Taylor and Hayley have been treated because they are powerful women, so makes sense to me. Also I do love Hayley’s vocals but everyone has different opinion which I get xx

chel

love u girlies!!

elli

I usually agree more with Emily, but everything Bonny said about We Were Happy is 100% correct and Em needs to get over her daddy issues 😌 jokes aside, here is my top 5 of the vault tracks: 1. Is it over now 2. Say don’t go 3. Timeless 4. Better man 5. You all over me Left out ATW10 because I simply do not know how to rank that song anymore. You should also remember to include You’re losing me the next time you rank the vault tracks ❤️

Alexandra Bennett

I haven’t listened to any Fearless vaults since the day they came out 💀

Cathrine Ahm

Same. I was literally just rewatching the reaction to Speak Now vault songs and ICSY Music video release 🫣

paulina ⭐️

another day another completely different opinions than girlies 😂 1. forever winter 2. the very first night but i must say i will never get over the demo version of forever winter it physically hurts me how they changed the production but still top tier. also couldn’t disagree more about castles crumbling 😬 top 5 taylor’s saddest songs 🤷‍♀️ my rankings are always upside down to yours 😀

Nadily Perandin

I believe my top5 FTV songs is something like: 1) Is it over now? 2) ATW 10 3) Say don't go (my SS on November 26th, 2023 - Literally almost passed out) 4) Timeless 5) I bet you think about me

Nadily Perandin

I went to check it out, it's not tagged as a From the Vault song on Spotify.

Nadily Perandin

I was watching the 1989 vault breakdown lol

Katie LaFave

can someone explain to me why they don't like elvira

Pix

nobody understands Don’t You like i do. it’s the most underrated t swift song everrrr. the multiple uses of “don’t you”, the subtle female rageeee ugh offensive. like i’m sorry “you don’t know how much i feel i love you still SO WHY DONT YOU?!?” kill me

𝐃𝐄𝐌𝐈💖

That’s when is one of my top Taylor songs ever it’s actually so superior and I always see people hating on it thank u guys for stanning it you girlies just get meee!

Jason

Emily!!!! I'm also a Suburban Legend truther! For me (34 year old millennial), it's the nostalgic feel that makes me love it so much. It just harken back to a time when we were in high-school and sort of care free.

Anna Mehrbilder

sp happy for you for your surprise song!!

The Renn Domino Experiment

There are only two vault tracks that still affect me today: Slut! and When Emma Falls In Love. Each time I hear them it sounds like the first time. I don't think Taylor has any other song in her discography like Slut! and her love and friendship with Emma is like a really warm hug. Her other vault tracks are great, but these two songs really do something to my heart and my ears.

Nadily Perandin

It's probably one of the most important moments in my entire life, I'm not even kidding

c

now that we don’t talk absolutely changed my brain chemistry because it came to me during a brutal friendship breakup

ton

Thanks guys I love your thoughts and reflections. Often makes me view songs slightly better when your enthusiasm shines through

Allie

You know I love to see justice for Foolish One !!!!!!!

Anna Mehrbilder

favourite vault: say dont go electric touch nothing new I bet you think about me mr perfectly fine and - of course - all woo well 10, even though I dont really consider it a vault song.

Fi🌸

Better man is my top tier number one such a superior song

Katie LaFave

i LOVE electric touch i literally never skip it, but sorry not sorry i HATE the fall out boy part!! i don't really mind that he gets a whole verse, i just wish it went back to taylor for the 2nd chorus! so i put it at the top of lovestruck

Anna Miotello

Same! I can recognize the synth is a little out of place, and perhaps the concept is not super original or whatever... but the melody mesmerizes me, and I just love it so much, I actively choose to listen to the song.

Kim

I think the Fearless vault tracks are very underrated. I love them and they fit perfectly on Fearless.

Manon

The whole conversation around 'Message in a bottle' is weird to me as someone who only ever listened to the TV version and does appreciate the electro vibe of the song, but I get your point if the song was that different before. Also, thanks for the love on Foolish One, that song is my fav of the Speak Now vault I think <3

Sophie

Don't You is CRIMINALLY underrated !!!!!! What a simple, gorgeous, perfect song

eeeee

Bonnie at 2:48 "Lovestruck - from our beautiful sl*t" 😂😂

izzy

YESSSS

Anna Miotello

Bonny, I feel so validated by your obsession with Nothing New. I will never get tired of that song, it means so much to me and there is not a day I don't want to listen to it. My overall take on the vault songs is that I enjoy listening to all of them (except Castle Crumbling and Ronan), but a lot of them never captivated me that much. Having said that, I still found tier-ranking them difficult. I don't know how you ladies do this, I always get a headache and get SOOO frustrated! Anyways here are the songs in my top two tiers: - Timeless: ATW10, Nothing New, Is It Over Now?, Babe, I Bet You Think About Me, Better Man, Slut!, Timeless - Lovestruck: Now That We Don't Talk, Foolish One, Suburban Legends, Don't You, When Emma Falls In Love Everything else I can't rank because I am just not that passionate about. They all have catchy melodies that I enjoy bopping to, but I don't find the lyrics that impactful. Castles Crumbling sits at the bottom because I just don't enjoy the melody of the song, so I skip it.

Jenny MacRunnel

I spent an insane amount of time figuring out my ranking. I'm not sure if its right, but it feels right for right now anyway. Speak Now is the best vault I think. For a long time, I though it was 1989--but the Speak Now vaults are always so listenable to me. Its insane considering Speak Now was completely a self written album--I do think that her self written songs are the best! And I agree, Foolish One might be the most underrated Vault song. Timeless category: All Too Well 10, Timeless, Better Man, Say Don't Go, Is It Over Now?, I Can See You, Nothing New, Foolish One. Lovestruck category: When Emma Falls in Love, I Bet You Think About Me, Don't You, Slut!, Suburban Legends, Babe, Mr. Perfectly Fine, Now That We Don't Talk Mr. Perfectly Fine category: The Very First Night, Electric Touch, You All Over Me, Message in a Bottle, Castles Crumbling, Bye Bye Baby, Run, We Were Happy, Forever Winter Nothing New Category: That's When (Don't hate me!) I still really like the song though. Something has to be at the bottom. While I agree We Were Happy is a bit cheesy, I love the bridge SO MUCH, it elevates it a bit for me. Bye Bye Baby--I actually do seek out that song sometimes. For me, its the melody of the verses, I just love it in my earballs! So how I take the Very First Night--I assume its a Harry song, about when they first met, and it sounds to me like they had a really fun date and fell pretty hard, but then he had to leave (Come Back Be Here) so they just had the one night together before that happened, and then she was pining for him for awhile after that. When they did get back together, it just wasn't the same as that one magical night. That's how I take the song, but no idea if that's right or not. And it might not have actually been one night, maybe it was a few, but to make it simple she phrases it that way in the song. And I will add that Come Back Be Here is in my top 5 on Red, so maybe the connection makes me love it more.

Sophie

And if acoustic LOML x Don't You on the Eras tour didn't make you realize that, there is no hope 🤦🏼‍♀️ lolol

Katie LaFave

girls i did this ranking with & why was it soooo hard??!!!

Annie

There’s just something about the 1989 vault that makes it so addicting. When TV came out it was my most played album of the year.

Diamond

The moment I knew slander hurt me so bad omg it’s one of my favs but I’m so happy that foolish one got its flowers

Jess

I will be a castles crumbling defender till I die. Possibly my fav vault track! And as a long time paramore fan it was the perfect track for Hayley to be on - knowing she was going through such a similar thing in her life at a similar time and there friendship at that time. It’s just perfect. I rewatch their live performance of it at Wembley alllll the time

Anna Miotello

well... they are not that memorable tbh. I do genuinely love Don't You, and enjoy the rest, but if they were to disappear from her discography tomorrow, I wouldn't lose sleep over it.

chel

agreed!!!! its my second favourite overall vault track and my third favourite song on fearless overall

chel

Top five vault tracks (Im not including atw10 because it doesn’t necessarily feel like a vault track to me but it would be number 1 ofc) 1-don’t you 2-i can see you 3-slut 4- forever winter 5- nothing new

Katie

Taylor said “The very first night” in her iHeart radio acceptance speech from this year when introducing the mirrorball surprise song recording and I went and listened to The Very First Night from the perspective of her singing it to the fans about the eras tour and it was so magical and sweet 🥹 Listening to it in that context totally changed the song for me!!

Katie LaFave

EMILY YOU & I HAVE THE SAME TOP 3!!! I LOVE THAT FOR US

MarkH

i may be an easier grader than both of you. For me, a song is timeless if I can't really imagine the TS discography without it. For me that is Mr. Perfectly Fine, I Can See You, Is It Over Now, Slut!, Say Don't Go, ATW 10 of course, Better Man, I Bet You Think About Me, Nothing New. I like the Speak Now vaults much less than you, and the Fearless vaults more than you. Can't decide if the 1989 vault or the Red vault is better, but they are my favorite vaults.

Katie LaFave

YES FOOLISH ONE IS SOOO UNDERRATED!! i have it as my 4th fav vault track

Brooke

My Top 5: 1. All Too Well (10 Minute Version) 2. I Can See You 3. Say Don't Go 4. Better Man 5. Timeless

Nadia Thew

My favs before I watch: Fearless- That’s When Speak Now- Timeless Red- I Bet You Think About Me 1989- Now That We Don’t Talk

Pippa

I would have counted if this was a movie, eyes open, aotgylb and safe and sound in this ranking (in that order from timeless to nothing new!)

Taylor Nicole

Timeless: ATW10, don’t you, when emma falls in love, suburban legends, now that we don’t talk, that’s when, slut!, run Lovestruck: message in a bottle, babe, is it over now?, i bet you think about me, you all over me Mr. Perfectly Fine: say don’t go, you’re losing me, electric touch, better man, timeless, I can see you, foolish one, we were happy, mr perfectly fine, the very first night Nothing New: bye bye baby, nothing new, castles crumbling, forever winter

Wendy Davis

Got lovestruck went straight to my head, got lovesick all over my bed.......UNREAL.

Wendy Davis

If I'm gonna be drunk, might as well be drunk in love............ONLY TAYLOR.

Alexandra Bennett

I’m so sorry I have to disagree about Speak Now🙈 Vault order for me: 1) 1989 2) Red 3) Speak Now 4) Fearless

skizzo

Unpopular opinion but Fearless vaults are my favorites, especially Dont You and We Were Happy. I actually LOVE the production of Dont You being different, it reminds me of This Love meets Clean, 2 of my favorite songs. Its so pretty.

Mika B

Me too girl🥲

Kayla

Gonna have to respectfully disagree about the Castles Crumbling take 😭 I think Hayley was the perfect choice to be on that specific track if we're considering the ppl Taylor has chosen to feature overall in her career. Knowing that both Taylor and Hayley were going through intense amounts of scrutiny and misogyny from the media (obvs Taylor's was magnified bc she was closer to pop music) at that point in their lives makes me believe that her being added to that track was a good and pertinent choice. I also think back to something Hayley wrote on release day about being added to Castles Crumbling. She knew hers and Taylor's fans were, more than not, expecting like a hard punk rock collab on a song like BTR, but I really enjoyed how they subverted people's expectations and showed a side of Hayley's voice people outside of the deep paramore fandom are less familiar with. Is the production not as exciting and not something people were expecting? I think a valid argument could be made for that. I'll die on the hill tho that Castles Crumbling is such an underrated gem on the SN vault tracklist.

Saray Checo

Loved this video! Do you not consider the 3AM vault songs from midnight album? Just curious❤️❤️

Kayla

I'm right there with you. castles crumbling defender til I diiiieeeeee

Alana1989xox

Yes!! What do folks guess would've been the other song? I'm so stumped!

Dayle

It’s my top Fearless Vault! 🫣 So thank you for confirming!

Trinity

Nothing New is my favorite vault on Red. Getting to see Taylor and Phoebe perform that live on the Eras Tour on May 5th was amazing.

Val Flores

I actually think Don't You it's mean to have that kind of almost quiet feeling to it because I always pictured it as that moment when there's a part of you that wants to be angry that wants to scream "fucking leave me alone" but you're just still so in it, with every breath still being a part of that relationship that you're just like "just... please stop." It's a quiet plea and almost like begging "why don't you feel this anymore" almost translating to that feeling of "wasn't I good enough?" And it just hurtss

Alicia Evans

My top 5: ATW10 Better Man Message in A Bottle Suburban Legends Electric Touch

Caseyv

Scrolling through looking to see if anyone else is confused why Ronan is missing?? Is it not a vault song? Do we all just respectfully avert our eyes???

angel (plnkblue)

It's not a vault song because it did exist beforehand, it just wasn't on the og Red album. It's like Sweeter Than Fiction in that regard.

Caseyv

Ah I didn't know! Thank you!!

scout

my favs fearless: mr. perfectly fine red: all too well 10, nothing new speak now: timeless, i can see you 1989: say don’t go, suburban legends i like phoebe bridgers on nothing new, but i think i’d actually prefer electric touch without fall out boy 🫣😬 also, mr. perfectly fine is like a perfect song. idk whhhyyy she didn’t include it on fearless originally especially since there really isn’t another song on the album like it — the sarcasm! the SASS! 👌🏻✨

Maggie

I'm not a Castles Crumbling fan (it's not bad I just gravitate towards other songs) but Hayley fits the song so well and people who disagree probably don't realize how of of an impact she had as a female lead singer in the pop/punk/emo scene back in the late 2000s early 2010s. P.S. I've been a Paramore fan since Riot and seeing Paramore in Milan open for Taylor was so special.

anna

my fav vaulties: 💛 mr. perfectly fine & you all over me 💜 i can see you & foolish one ❤️ atw10 & nothing new 🩵 is it over now & say don’t go

Amanda P

omg #1 very first night fan here!! think about your first time going to the Eras tour, how magical and exciting it was - you can only experience that feeling of the unknown once on the very first night!! She’s basically saying “I miss the very first night we met” because of the giddiness but also being delulu & romanticizing the relationship because the only time it was good was the very first night!! 🫶🏼

Hannah Grace

18 months since taylor told us the rep tv vault tracks were fire.. i think about this all the time

maya zutra

Will never forget that- now that we don’t talk was my number one Spotifywrap in 2023 LOL!!!! My top 5 (without Atw10) 1. Better man ❤️ 2. Timeless 💜 3. Now that we don’t talk 🩵 4. Babe ❤️ 5. WEFIL 💜

maya zutra

This is the space to admit that I have listened to we were happy & don’t you & bye bye baby & run , one time in my life and never again 🤡

skizzo

So my Timeless category in order of release: Dont You, We Were Happy, Better Man, Foolish One, Timeless, Slut, Is It Over Now? Slut! is my favorite vault track overall, not only is it melodically beautiful, but I love the "lovelorn" lyric that captures the feeling of the entire song: being unhappy due to unrequited love. There's a yearning and melancholy that's hard to capture in a song, but this song does it.

Jackie Savage

My ranking is: 1. All too well 10 ❤️ 2. Foolish one 💜 3. You’re losing me 💙 4. Better man ❤️ 5. Babe ❤️ 6. Is it over now? 🩵 7. Message in a bottle ❤️ 8. Castles crumbling 💜 9. Electric touch 💜 10. Now that we don’t talk 🩵 11. I bet you think about me ❤️ 12. I can see you 💜 13. Slut 🩵 14. The very first night ❤️ 15. Timeless 💜 16. Mr. Perfectly fine 💛 17. Say don’t go 🩵 18. Nothing new ❤️ 19. When Emma falls in love💜 20. Bye bye baby 💛 21. Don’t you 💛 22. You all over me 💛 23. Suburban legends 🩵 24. Forever winter ❤️ 25. That’s when 💛 26. Run ❤️ 27. We were happy 💛

skizzo

they are bonus tracks not vaults

Nicole

I love listening to these rankings, they make me go back and revisit songs I haven’t paid attention to… like Foolish One!!!!

skizzo

another Dont You stan! Its so pretty

Sarah✨️

In you saying we will get more vault tracks, but when. I honestly feel like Taylor could go a whole other year before releasing anything. I know we love her and just want MORE! But for her marketing and her life, a good long 2 year break could be good. The hype would be more intense waiting longer than releasing now.

skizzo

I think it might be my favorite Fearless song tbh

skizzo

I love all 3

Hayley

If I had to pick just ONE from each: 💛 Mr. Perfectly Fine 💜 Timeless ❤️ Better Man 🩵 Say Don’t Go 💙 You’re Losing Me

Brenda1989

I feel like “the very first night” means that feeling u get after u leave like a really good first date that u didn’t want to end like u don’t want to leave but u have to go home and u already miss the person…she’s saying she misses him like how she misses him after leaving him in the first night they met

Florence Lambert

Forever winter is definitely in my Timeless category due to its superior melodies..I was surprised by your placement !!

Cara M

Bonnie, I love you speaking for us Ed Sheeran collab girlies. I’m a musical theatre kid so their harmonies snd melodies send me into the stratosphere

Allison

I saw someone on instagram predict that maybe she will rerecord Karma the lost album as it was recorded and then scrapped so it's technically a rerecord.

Takara

Bonny I get you with nothing new! Def would rank it in my top vault tracks

nikki

Oh gosh we are so different on a lot of these, but I do want Bonny to know I am completely with you on Nothing New and I Can See You—they both go straight up to the Timeless section for me!

Brianna Washington

unpopular opinion: i literally could not care less about better man 😬 it goes into my mr perfectly fine tier

Casey

My Timeless tracks are: 1. Message in a Bottle 2. Now That We Don't Talk 3. All Too Well Ten 4. The Very First Night 5. Nothing New 6. Mr. Perfectly Fine

Jamie

you're posting so much lately! 🙌🏼 😍

Silvia

I feel surprised with your opinion on the very first night, I guess I hadn’t seen comments about people not liking it 👁️

Takara

Exactly!!! That moment is so fleeting and you forever chase it

Gina Gould

To Emily: in The Very First Night… she’s not trying to take him back to the actual first night. She wants to take him back to the moment the finally ended it for good, and instead of ending it, she’d say “I miss you like the very first night” where it was all good/honeymoon/happy love phase. And therefore, instead of ending it, they’d decide to tap into that feeling again and realize they love each other and are happy together and therefore NOT breakup. She’s taking him back to the breakup point, not the first night. ❤️

Daniel

Guys I gotta say I am a Castle's Crumbling stan that is miles above Nothing New in my head idk why 😔✊

Mia Morgan

Top 3 for each vault: 👑: Don't You, That's When & We Were Happy 🧣:ATW10, Better Man & The Very First Night 🏰: Timeless, Foolish One & Electric Touch 🏙️: Is It Over Now, Say Don't Go & Now That We Don't Talk

Kristen

ooooh, i don’t have time rn to rank them all, but i forced myself to do top 2 for each vault and i had trouuuubbbllleeeee getting speak now to just two. it is superior all around. also 1989! but in this moment in time: 💛: you all over me & mr perfectly fine ❤️: better man & ATW10 💜: timeless & foolish one 🩵: say don’t go & slut

Takara

I would like to point out that it’s a **Hayley collab** and not a Paramore collab. Hayley’s solo albums sound a lot more like Castles Crumbling (and as a huge fan of her solo work I will forever stan this song). Also Taylor’s voice breaking on “never wanted you to hate me” gets me every time

Bradi R

Neeeed to know where Bonnie’s dress is from

Eric Olivieri

Don’t forget You’re Losing Me! Technically it’s “From the Vault”

Giovanna Medola

foolish one is my fav vault track so i felt really heard with this thank you

✨Bri✨

Girlies, have you ever come home after a first date and just felt like you’re “enchanted”, you’re beaming, your stomach is full of butterflies and you see so much potential happiness? And you think to yourself…I already miss them! Even though you just said goodnight. To me that’s what she means in The Very First Night. She misses them like she missed them the night after their first date. That feeling of missing somebody who brought you so much happiness and giddiness. I feel like she’s trying to say that I miss that version of me who missed you after one day bc I saw so much potential and future happiness. Haha I do understand the confusion but this is how I always thought about it. Don’t know if this explanation was life changing or not but it makes sense to me 😂.

R 🌀

Unrelated but Bonnie looks so much like Linda Ronstadt in the 70s to me. Especially her smile and her mannerisms. I think about it every time I see her (this is a huge compliment- as Willie Nelson famously said, everyone had a crush on Linda Ronstadt)

Gina Gould

Thanks for ranking these! My top five: 1. All too well 2. Is it over now? 3. Slut! 4. Now that we don’t talk 5. Say don’t go Other songs in the “timeless” category: 6. When Emma falls in love 7. Forever winter 8. Better man

Gina Gould

I love better man, but I prefer the Little Big Town version 😬

Weeroz_x

I think red is probs got the biggest stand outs for me . But 1989 every song is consistently good. Faves from each tv currently are: Fearless 💛 Mr perfectly fine. Red 💔 ATW10, I bet you think about me and Nothing new. Speak now 💜 electric touch. 1989 🩵 Slut or say don’t go

✨Bri✨

My top 5: All Too Well 10 Slut! Better Man Now That We Don’t Talk I Can See You

Sarah

Regarding The Very First Night, I think the chorus is giving 'my missing you isn't fading with time.' Like she still misses him as much as she did the first night they broke up. The verses are her reminiscing about their time together and are the specific things she misses. Those are the moments in time she wants to take him back to.

Abby Thaine

My top 5 vault songs (today): 1. All Too Well 10 2. Slut! 3. Is It Over Now? 4. Foolish One 5. Timeless Bottom 5: 1. Say Don’t Go 2. Don’t You 3. Bye Bye Baby 4. We Were Happy 5. Forever Winter Vaults Ranked: 1. 1989 2. Speak Now 3. Red 4. Fearless

Laura R

TIMELESS: ATW10 Babe (Idk what to tell you; the breakdown/outro of this song DOES THINGS to me) Electric Touch Say Don't Go I Bet You Think About Me Now That We Don't Talk LOVESTRUCK: Suburban Legends Is It Over Now? (Don't come for me; every part of this song is SUPERIOR, except that "caw" in the production. It doesn't bother me on Midnights, but in this song, it sounds like Scuttle during Kiss the Girl, and it takes me out of the song every time.) I Can See You The Very First Night (No, I cannot explain it to you; I just love it) Mr. Perfectly Fine Forever Winter When Emma Falls in Love You All Over Me Better Man Nothing New Message in a Bottle Foolish One Bye Bye Baby PERFECTLY FINE: Run That's When Don't You Slut! NOTHING NEW: Timeless (I'm so sorry) Castles Crumbling We Were Happy

Karen Valentino

I agree with Bonnie’s reasoning and sentiment about Phoebe being featured on Nothing New. I like how Taylor zooms out, starting with the personal, then expanding to include her peers, represented by Phoebe. It has to be a pretty universal dread for young women in the music industry. And Phoebe has such an unusual voice, you can instantly tell it’s her by her unique rasp.

Madeline

For me even if ATW10 never existed the Red vault is far and away the best vault… 👀 and I was legitimately shocked at what you both said about The Very First Night! It has always been my favourite vault track. I also think it’s interesting you both feel the way you do about it because it’s giving so much Electric Touch energy. Let me explain: The detailed imagery of all these private moments she’s had in this relationship - “notes on the Polaroid picture” - “dance in the kitchen chase me down through the hallway” - “I’m the one in the phone as you whisper” - but shes looking back at the relationship knowing that it didn’t work out and they “broke each others hearts” therefore she misses you like it was the very first night because she misses the time when it was all perfect and fun and nothing bad had happened yet. Aside from all that the production totally encapsulates the energy of Red perfectly. Like an almost confusing but incredible mix of pop and country. Totally undeniable bop but with a… banjo…? Strummy guitar? Big drums? Plus a fade out outro. CHEFS KISS.

LeafyJean

I think Speak Now is the best vault cause it has the most songs that could’ve seamlessly fit onto the original album!! All the other vaults while they sound good I can understand why they didn’t make it onto their albums! My timeless category is: All Too Well Ten You’re Losing Me(!!) When Emma Falls In Love Foolish One Better Man Timeless Nothing New Now That We Don’t Talk I Bet You Think About Me Suburban Legends

Ryls

Agreed, best way to explain it. I feel like it’s sooo hard to match the feeling you get from the ‘the very first night’ you meet someone

Ryls

Castles crumbling is my Fav vault song

Ryls

My top 5 goes… 1. Castles crumbling 2. That’s when 3. All too well 10 4. I bet you think about me 5. Babe

Lauren

My top 5: 1. ATW10 2. Foolish One 3. Is it over now 4. You're losing me 5. Say don't go Honorable mentions: 6. Mr. Perfectly Fine 7. I bet you think about me 8. Castles crumbling (sorry girls have to disagree with you on this one)

TScout

Should we also include All The Girls?

Georgia Double

Absolutely AGREE with the Mr Perfectly Fine take. Why is it such a favourite? It’s an always skip for me 😬

Jenna Aguirre

These are mine: Timeless 1. All Too Well (10 Minute Version) (B: T / E: T) 2. Better Man (B: T / E: T) 3. I Bet You Think About Me (B: MPF / E: L) 4. Is It Over Now? (B: T / E: T) 5. Nothing New (B: T / E: L) 6. Electric Touch (B: L / E: T) 7. The Very First Night (B: NN / E: NN) 8. Babe (B: L / E: L) 9. Mr. Perfectly Fine (B: L / E: MPF) Lovestruck 1. Timeless (B: T / E: T) 2. Now That We Don’t Talk (B: L / E: L) 3. I Can See You (B: L / E: L) 4. You All Over Me (B: MPF / E: MPF) 5. Slut! (B: T / E: L) 6. Say Don’t Go (B: L / E: T) Mr. Perfectly Fine 1. Bye Bye Baby (B: MPF / E: MPF) 2. Forever Winter (B: MPF / E: MPF) 3. Foolish One (B: T / E: T) 4. Don’t You (B: NN / E: NN) 5. Suburban Legends (B: MPF / E: L) Nothing New 1. Castles Crumbling (B: MPF / E: MPF) 2. Message In A Bottle (B: MPF / E: MPF) 3. That’s When (B: L / E: L) 4. Run (B: L / E: MPF) 5. We Were Happy (B: NN / E: NN) 6. When Emma Falls In Love (B: T / E: T)

Chloe Amelia

TIMELESS: * All Too Well 10 * When Emma Falls in Love * Slut! * I Bet You Think About Me * Nothing New * Foolish One * Better Man LOVESTRUCK: * Say Don’t Go * Now That We Don’t Talk * Is It Over Now? * You All Over Me * Babe * Message in a Bottle * Timeless * That’s When * Mr. Perfectly Fine MR. PERFECTLY FINE: * Forever Winter * I can See You * Electric Touch * Don’t You * Suburban Legends * Run NOTHING NEW: * Bye Bye Baby * We Were Happy * Castles Crumbling * The Very First Night

Jaime McKee

Emily, I think Suburban Legends is for us TTPD (song) girlies! It gives me a similar energy and I adore them both so much.

H29

Timeless: All too well 10 You're losing me Say don't go Better man Is it over now Timeless Now that we don't talk Surban legends Message in a bottle I can see you Mr perfectly fine Love struck: Slut Don't you That's when Electric touch You all over me Babe When Emma falls inlove Nothing new Mr perfectly fine: Foolish one Bet you think about me Forever winter Nothing new: Castles crumbling We were happy Bye bye baby The very first night

Paige Jacobsen

Wait…. I understand now! I have never understood the song really either !! I hope they read this!

Annie

Em it's actually shocking how good you look with silver on!!!! When you used to wear gold all the time I thought it looked so good and especially loved your accessory choices but seeing you wear silver is deeply offensive and I need you to know that.

Brant

An absolutely offensive video!! I have to say I completely disagree with your placement of Don't You, for some reason that song is quite literally a top 3 taylor song for me- following ATW10 and Better Man. Great ranking though, I love watching these!!!

S.C

I remember the first time I heard Nothing New, I had the same opinion with Emily. Then I just didn't listen to it that much compare to other vault tracks on Red. AND, one night after maybe 1-2 years since it came out, I unconsciously played it on accident, I cried so hard over it. Then I knew that I grew up...... OMG this song cuts so hard.

Rose Ellen

WHAT DO YOU MEAN Mr Perfectly Fine is such a superior song!!!! It’s easily Top 30 Worthy for me.

Feride Eron

I decided to do the tier ranking in real time as i watch the video, and i simply HAD to put a category between "lovestruck" and "mr perfectly fine" and the category is "still love it though" 🫠

chatsandreacts

I respect that, “don’t you” is one of our friends fav vault tracks ever! It just hits different people differently I guess.

chatsandreacts

It’s really a lot isn’t it haha I felt the same way the first time I saw her in the silver 😂

Esther

Timeless 1. All Too Well (10 Minute Version) 2. I Bet You Think About Me (feat. Chris Stapleton) 3. Nothing New (feat. Phoebe Bridgers) 4. Is It Over Now? 5. I Can See You 6. Babe 7. Say Don't Go Lovestruck 1. Better Man 2. You All Over Me (feat. Marren Morris) 3. When Emma Falls In Love 4. "Slut!" 5. Foolish One 6. Now That We Don't Talk 7. We Were Happy Mr Perfectly Fine 1. Forever Winter 2. Run (feat. Ed Sheeran) 3. Mr. Perfectly Fine 4. Suburban Legends 5. That's When (feat. Keith Urban) 6. Electric Touch (feat. Fall Out Boy) Nothing New 1. Don't You 2. Castles Crumbling (feat. Hayley Williams) 3. Bye Bye Baby 4. Timeless 5. Message in a Bottle 6. The Very First Night

lotts 💘🪩🍒

IHATETHESEVOICESTELLINGMEIMNOTINLOVEBUTTHEYDONTGIVEMECHOICESANDTHATSWHATTHESETEARSAREFOR like wtfdym

Linnea Steen

As a Phoebe stan, I couldn’t imagine Nothing New without her. But I still get you Emily, I would prob feel the same if it was someone other than Phoebe.

Kirstine Eklund

Bon I totally get you with Nothing New!! I love that song so much and loooove Phoebe on it. Its always(!!) relatable and can hit you different ways depending on the day.. I remember biking home on a really bad day during a tough period. It randomly came on, and I cried so much to the line “How did I go from growing up to breaking down?” and the line about knowing everything at 18, but nothing at 22. I was 22 at the time and it completely captured how I felt. So so special

Lou

Bonny, I get you a 1000% for what you say about Nothing New!! And thanks for expressing so well why Phoebe‘s presence is so meaningful! Loved watching this❤️

S.C

Hands down to Bonny’s description on “zooming out and see all the girls”, I’m one of them indeed.

Karis Gorst

oh i actually love message in a bottle and i really don’t hate the production at all. i very much disagree that elvira ruins it 😭 i love the bops on red

Feride Eron

My "Timeless"s : Atw10, Better Man, IBYTAM, Foolish One, You All Over Me, Timeless, Now That We Don't Talk, Is it Over Now, Don't You 💗

Jaana

I’ve actually never done a Taylor ranking of any kind because it just feels so daunting! But maybe one of these days I’ll get to it

Eirini

Guys we NEED a video of the songs that are important to the lore of her life! A ranking or sth…

Jenny

Guys 😭😭😭 castles crumbling is one of my favourite songs of hers help is anyone at all with me hahahaha

Lily

Bonnyy, your perspective of Nothing New was perfect! It’s the best vault track in my opinion (except for atw10), it tapped into that feeling and collective experience that we all have and I still love it SO much❤️

alex

Love these ranking videos 😍🥰 My top tier vault tracks are: 1. ATW 10 2. Better Man 3. nothing new (when this song clicks you will never not appreciate its superiority) 4. Sl*t! 5. Babe 6. Now that we don’t talk 7. is it over now? 8. I bet you think about me 9. Timeless 10. TVFN

Thad

For me, ATW10 and Nothing New are a one/two punch that put them at the top of the list. While many of the other songs are terrific, ATW10 is an instant masterpiece and Nothing New should be required listening for every male on the planet! I’ve struggled with songs like I Can’t See Clearly and I Bet You Think About Me. I tie the music video so closely with the songs and the videos elevate the experience above what just the song alone would do for me. By contrast, I can’t easily separate ATW10 from the short film. Hope that makes sense!

Mathieu

I just want to say that these Forever Winter ranking give me headhache

Katariina Blom

I feel like my most controversial/unpopular opinions are that Better Man, Timeless and When Emma Falls in Love simply do nothing for me… I really want to love them, I do! On the other hand, I also feel like I am one of the only Castles crumbling stans 😭 Anyway, here is my ranking (though I don’t feel very good about it lol) TIMELESS - ATW10 ❤️ - is it over now? 🩵 - electric touch 💜 - castles crumbling 💜 - now that we don’t talk 🩵 - mr. Perfectly fine 💛 - babe ❤️ LOVESTRUCK - suburban legends 🩵 - say don’t go 🩵 - nothing new ❤️ - I can see you 💜 - foolish one 💜 - better man ❤️ - you all over me 💛 - slut 🩵 MR. PERFECTLY FINE - that’s when 💛 - message in a bottle ❤️ - forever winter ❤️ - I bet you think about me ❤️ - don’t you 💛 - timeless 💜 - the very first night ❤️ - when Emma falls in love 💜 - run ❤️ NOTHING NEW - bye bye baby 💛 - we were happy 💛

Hayley Rawsthorne

This was so good! I’ve never given the vault tracks enough attention post the album release frenzy. Totally going back to listen to them again and get my own ranking together. Also, just re ‘The very first night’, I remember feeling like this hit the ear wrong when it was released and though the same, ‘it doesn’t make sense.’ I ended up fathoming (I think!) that it means that she still misses him like she did the first night after they broke up. So, I miss you now even still after all this time in the same way that I missed you on the first night after it was all over’ ‘I miss you now like it was, that first night when I was so heartbroken, it still hurts as much now, ‘I miss you, like it was, the very first night’. Doesn’t make me like the song any better but that’s how I hear it now and it at least doesn’t feel so wrong’ 🤷‍♀️

Lo

Wow that dress looks really cute on you Emily 🩵. Another tier ranking yes :)

Jade

I’ve always loved Message in a Bottle… it gives me windows down, driving and feeling free vibes every time lol

Jenny

Castles Crumbling is one of my all time favs!! I see you!!!

Jenny

Interested to hear other perspectives on The Very First Night but I've always interpreted it as the first time (and also very early days in a relationship) and when they leave/you go home - that feeling of not wanting to be apart/instant missing them is so strong even though you were literally just together. Also could potentially be hinting at something more intimate like how it feels to be separate/apart after the first time..

Jade

I am on an island alone here, it seems, bc Foolish One is my least favorite song.

Amber

I deeply feel like 'run' is one of the prettiest songs EVER. And I'm not saying its the best ever, like timeless or something because I don't think it has the lyrical content, but I don't see enough people talking about the harmonies between Ed and Taylor like when they say the "that I gave to youuuuuu". Shivers. Absolute shivers. I'm always in the mood for it and this might sound weird but when I listen to it its like as soothing as someone playing with your hair if that makes sense, idk I feel like a fairy or something.

Amber

I love the very first night as a bop and I guess I've never dwelled too much about what the meaning is because I'm too busy boogying, but I was watching and thinking like maybe its been sometime after the breakup and then something kinda triggers the memory or makes you think of them and she's saying I miss you as bad as I did the very first night after I lost you maybe. This would also makes sense with the lyric "I drive down different roads but they all lead back to you", kind of like I'm trying to move on but everything reminds me of you and then I'm right back to that very first night where I lost you and those feeling are back and the wound feels fresh all over again.

marysia

FINALLY SOMEBODY UNDERSTANDS THE SUPERIORITY OF FOOLISH ONE!! My ranking: TIMELESS: atw10, foolish one, nothing new, is it over now?, electric touch, better man, timeless, forever winter, slut! LOVESTRUCK: now that we dont talk, suburban legends, i can see you, i bet you think about me, you all over me, mr. perfectly fine, when emma falls in love, say don't go, we were happy MR. PERFECTLY FINE: babe, castles crumbling, the very first night, bye bye baby NOTHING NEW: run, don't you, message in a bottle, that's when

Will McNally

I will never understand the complete under appreciation for Forever Winter, the instruments the melody, the lyrics, the vocals? Omg that song is so heartbreaking and beautiful and not getting on the eras tour once is so upsetting.

Mika B

Yes!!!

sofie sandrini

I love a ranking. This is absolutely no shade to you Bonny (like at all!<3) I love how you Emily always looks in the lens when your talking it feels like you are looking directly at me ahah and that’s really nice ♥️

Dawn

WHERE WOULD YOU PUT ALL OF THE GIRLS? 🩷🤭

sofie sandrini

I LOVE Castles Crumbling 😩💜 but I do agree Hayley should have been somewhere else or Taylor should have been on their album even though you can’t argue that ahahahah - anyway you have to fathom please. It says SO much about going from girlhood to womanhood

Jen Mays

Your ranking of Castles Crumbling hurt my heart. I love that song so much.

sofie sandrini

RANKING TIMELESS: ATW10 Nothing New Say don’t go Timeless Better man Is it over now? When Emma falls in love I can see you “Slut!” LOVESTRUCK Run Electric touch Now that we don’t talk That’s when Mr perfectly fine Forever winter IBYTAM Surburban legends Castles crumbling Foolish one The very first night (I’m sorry babe it’s a bop I wanna jump around to with my best friends) Babe Message in a bottle Bye bye You all over me NOTHING NEW Don’t you We were happy

Cassy

“talking about your daddy’s farm” cracked me up omg 🤣🤣🤣 she does not sing it close to that!!! but i get it. i had a moment with we were happy and i think i could have a moment with it again so its placed in lovestruck for me! it is a really sweet song. it has a real pure innocence to its lyrics and tone that we don’t really get anymore bc taylor has experienced so much more life and tbh horrific heartbreak since this time. and maybe that’s why you don’t connect with it as it doesn’t feel mature or relatable enough?

Annika 📍Melb, AU

I love Suburban Legends, but it sounds like it should be on Midnights 🥲

C

"You can ~feel~ the potential....unfortunately, Elvira's there" lmaoo 😭😭

Kellie Mahoney

Suburban Legends is the best vault track, it’s so illegal

Martina

The outro is offensive

Gustav Lucas

I have informed my partner that Timeless will be our First Dance song at our wedding 🤭

Hannah

Forever and always also had the sass of the Fearless tour set where she’s in the red interview chair and dress from when she said ”if guys don’t want me to write bad songs about them they shouldn’t do bad things”.

Lison

omg no don't you is so good 💛

C

Let me try to explain The Very First Night in as few words as possible Imagine you just had the most perfect first date of your life. You go home afterwards, and you can't even sleep. You're just so electrified by this person that you're already missing them.....it's new, it's the unknown, but it's already Something. That's The Very First Night. If it helps, it's a similar energy to Come Back Be Here.

Cassy

i’ve always taken “i miss you like it was the very first night” to mean she misses this person as much as she did the very first night he left her not the very first night they met. basically another way to say the pain of him leaving her has not left at all, that’s how much she misses him that it’s like he only just left.

Leander

‘Meet me tonight lala👅la’

Nina 🤎🇳🇱

The underappreciation of The Very First Night is CRIMINAL!!! Let me explain the way I see it: In the song she explains multiple times how magical the relationship was and how much she misses those moments. Verse 1 indicates how alone she is and how no one understands her pain in missing her ex(relationship). “My friends all say they know…” She tries to think about anything else but all the roads lead back to him… In the pre-chorus we get a look into where those roads lead, and then proceeds to explain how her friends couldn’t understand her pain, cause they weren’t in the relationship. In verse 2 she describes how fast everything went. “but we did like children running” explains how extreme her love was for that person. And how it ended so fast, which led to more pain and confusion. In the pre-choruses and the bridge she explains the rush of the beginning of the relationship and how special it was for her. Now that it’s over she is lost and heartbroken. She wishes she could go back in time… back to him… back to the beginning. So in the whole song we get a description of how in love she was with this magical person from the beginning on. “I miss you like it was the very first night” therefor means that she would give everything to go back to the very beginning where everything was magical and she wasn’t brokenhearted. I hope this helps you fathoming X 🙏🏻❤️

Hannah

I NEVER get tired of Suburban Legends. The melody just tickles me. It’s my fave 1989 vault and I don’t care that I’m alone in the world with that take 😅😍

Sofia F

SAME!! I love it so much, it's my favorite vault track after ATW10

dotty

so sorry emily silver is simply superior on you HELP

Savvy

I love foolish one!! So glad you guys see it.

Savvy

I love run as well. It just pops up in my head and I find my self humming it.

LindseyMarie

I LOVE THE ED COLLABS!!!! I feel SO validated when Bonny sticks up for them! I just LOVE Ed and their friendship🥰

alessia

Don’t you was actually my original fave of the fearless vaults 😂 I think it’s second now but still up there for me!!

Alicia

Mathematical corner: If you assign a number (1-4) for each song based on the category they fall into (1=Nothing New, 4=Timeless), then take the average of each album, you can rank your results to determine mathematically which is your favorite bonus track album. A perfect score would be 4.0. Bonny: Speak Now: 3.333 1989: 3.2 Red: 2.778 Fearless: 2 Emily: Speak Now: 3.5 1989: 3.4 Red: 2.667 Fearless: 2

Lara

i always feel like i'm the only one whose favourite is the fearless vault 😭 i think they're all soooooo good

Nish

YOU GUYS, WHERE IS YLM?? THE MIDNIGHTS VAULT TRACK!

Sofia DiNapoli

I have obsession with the very first nights it's just such a happy bop. I guess I never really fathomed the meaning and I kinda also don't understand it lol. How I take it is when she says "I miss you like it was the very first night", she is saying I miss you like that first night we had together. Although you may think, wdym you just met how can you miss someone you just met? I am thinking the first time they met they had the most amazing time and she missing how they used to be. Also how she says "I'd pick you up and we'd go back in time" also makes me think that she just wants to go back how it used to be between them when it was good such as the very first night they were together. Also how she said they fell in love "like children running", it must have happened very fast, so she could have felt those feelings on the very first night. We need Taylor herself to explain this one I'm sure she would explain it so well and it will all click for us lol. Also bonny im loving those curls they are looking fab.

UnicornFlower

You guys should check out the Fat MAX G remix of message in a bottle its so much better thats the version i have on my playlist

Rachel

Suburban Legends is one of my favorite Taylor Swift songs! Sonically it just transports me, I love it so much 🥰

Rachel

It’s my favorite too!! Thank you 🙏😂

Rachel

I’m so glad other people feel this way too!

Holly

If the very first night has no fans I am dead

sophie

THE DONT YOU SLANDER

Talia Adams

There was some interview with Hayley where she said Taylor played her multiple vault tracks and there were obvious other ones for her to feature on but she related the most to castle crumbling and wanted to be on that one

Sofia F

Same! I'm happy to hear that I'm not alone

Leah Rose

SLUT! was my favorite vault track immediately. Still is honestly. And I mean that out of ALL the vault tracks we have so far. Vulnerable/love struck Taylor, with dreamy production is my favorite. I'm glad it wasn't the power house feminist anthem people thought it was. It was a perfect bait and switch and it actually lands better as an uncertain love song. We already have Blank Space, which was the other side of the coin like Bonny mentioned, and SLUT! is the more soft side of it all. It's just so beautiful. I LOVE IT.

K

Castles crumbling's placement hurt me. I love castles crumbling melodically and production-wise so so much. It is so haunting, floaty and flowy reminding me of safe and sound, which is a sound that Taylor does not use often at all.

K

agreed!

Kayla Michelle Smith

I am SO offended about this Castles Crumbling slander! I think it's one of the saddest and most beautiful songs she's ever written. I could weep every time I hear it.

Val Flores

Timeless: Foolish One, TVFN, Suburban Legends, Timeless, IBYTAM, ATW10 Lovestruck: Say Don't Go, Electric Touch, Better Man, Nothing New, Castles Crumbling, WEFIL, That's When, I Can See You, Is it Over Now? Mr. Perfectly Fine: Slut, NTWDT, MIAB, Babe, Mr. Perfectly Fine, Forever Winter, We Were Happy, Don't You, Bye Bye Baby, Run Nothing New: You All Over Me

dorothy lou

The very first night slander was NOT OK!!!!!

Annika

Girlies, you look fabulous in this video!!

Erin Corey

Timeless; All Too Well 10, better man, timeless, is it over now?, I bet you think about me, nothing new, foolish one Lovestruck: the very first night, slut!, forever winter, Mr perfectly fine, electric touch, now that we don’t talk, suburban legends Mr perfectly fine: you all over me, I can see you, when Emma falls in love, don’t you, message in a bottle, bye bye baby, babe, say don’t go, we were happy, that’s when Nothing new: castles crumbling, run

Amanda Oliveira

TIMELESS: ATW10, Nothing New, Timeless, When Emma Falls In Love, Is It Over Now?, Better Man LOVESTRUCK: I Can See You, Mr. Perfectly Fine, "Slut!", Now That We Don"t Talk, I Bet You Think About Me, Foolish One, Say Don't Go, Babe, That's When MR. PERFECTLY FINE: Message In A Bottle, Electric Touch, The Very First Night, Run, Castles Crumbling, Suburban Legends, Forever Winter, Don't You NOTHING NEW: Bye Bye Baby, You All Over Me, We Were Happy

Christine

I will say the Eras tour version of Castles Crumbling is soooo good, maybe better than original?

FJ

TIMELESS: All too Well 10 Better Man Forever Winter Now That We Don't Talk Timeless Is It Over Now? LOVESTRUCK: I Can See You Slut The Very First Night Bye Bye Baby When Emma Falls In Love Foolish One Say Don't Go Nothing New MR PERFECTLY FINE: Babe Electric Touch We Were Happy Don't You You All Over Me I Bet You Think About Me Run Castles Crumbling NOTHING NEW: Message In A Bottle Suburban Legends Mr. Perfectly Fine That's When

Laura Bolanos

The Very First Night to me is interesting when you think of the lyrics. I just love it so much but I can’t place the WHEN it the cycle of a relationship. Is it after a breakup? Is it when you feel feelings fading from a relationship? I have no idea. But I mean… “and so it goes we never saw it coming, not trying to fall in love, but we did like children running” HOWWW does that not just make you smile and want to hold onto that feeling??

💯

You forgot Youre Losing Me! Its tech a vault ;)

Julia Fisher

i fear i am don’t you’s biggest fan

Julia Fisher

obsessed with the foolish one love!!!

Lauren

i feel like one of my most controversial swiftie opinions is that i just don't care for timeless lol

Grace

Besties I’m not sure if you ever saw the interview, but Hayley said that Taylor initially asked her to be on a different song — not Castles Crumbling. “When Taylor asked me to feature on Speak Now TV, she originally suggested another song, and I was honest with her that though the song may have been closer to what a casual Paramore fan would expect me to feature on, I didn’t relate to that sound as much…She then, within minutes, sent me ‘Castles Crumbling,’ and not only did it feel more like a fit, I related to it lyrically on a deeper level … She respected my gut feelings and still pushed me to stay in it with her.”

Lauren

what kills me about the red vault is like... you kept off better man and i bet you think about me but put starlight and stay stay stay on the album???

Verónica Contreras

For me The Very First Night has a BIG spot in my heart because it was one of my surprise songs 💓💓💓

Nicole

IM TIRED. IM FALLING ASLEEP. 💀😂

Lauren

timeless: i bet you think about me, foolish one, atw10, babe, castles crumbling, is it over now, now that we don't talk lovestruck: say don't go, nothing new, slut, message in a bottle, the very first night, better man mr perfectly fine: i can see you, run, don't you, we were happy, mr. perfectly fine, you all over me nothing new: suburban legends, electric touch, timeless, forever winter, bye bye baby, when emma falls in love, thats when

Linds K

I had ChatGPT help analyze “the very first night”: “The lyric “I miss you like it was the very first night” is deliberately a bit paradoxical, and that’s what makes it so powerful. On the surface it sounds like “I miss you as much as I did on the first night,” but the more poetic reading is: “I miss you with the same intensity and freshness as the very first night we were apart.” That first night of missing someone—whether after a breakup, a fight, or even the first night you realized you were falling for them and couldn’t be with them—tends to hit the hardest. It’s when the absence is brand new, raw, and unprocessed. You haven’t yet built up emotional calluses or distractions. It suggests that time hasn’t dulled the ache.”

Amanda Christon

Loved this video 🙏🏼 always curious to hear your current rankings and feelings towards songs

Ariel

This is so interesting to watch because I became a Swiftie after all of these re-records had been released, so I never paid attention to which songs were vaults vs. originals. Better Man is my favorite. I must admit I’d written off most of the Speak Now vaults, but am going to revisit them now that you love them so much!

Amy

TIMELESS: atw10, is it over now, say dont go, electric touch, timeless, when emma falls in love, LOVESTRUCK: castles crumbling, i bet you think about me, slut, better man, now that we don't talk, babe, I can see you, message in a bottle MR PERFECTLY FINE: suburban legends, the very first night, thats when, mr. perfectly fine, nothing new, we were happy, run NOTHING NEW: foolish one, forever winter, you all over me, don't you, bye bye baby

intandem

What’s wrong with me that I just do not care for the speak now vault tracks 😭

Abigail Collins

i absolutely love how confused you girlies are with the very first night because it’s so not confusing (relatable content)

Alyssa Kay

EMILY, I appreciate your love for Suburban Legends 😭😭I LOVE Suburban Legends it's my second favorite 1989 Vault song (Is it Over Now is ofc my fav 1989 Vault song) and people do not appreciate it enough 💙💙 My favorite lyric is "I broke my own heart cause you were too polite to do it" 👏🏼 From the moment I first heard this lyric my brain automatically thought of Belly and Conrad from TSITP

Bella

Saaame

YunWon

At some point ... Emily and Bonny are going to have to rank the albums

farah abed

thank you so much for the love for ‘Foolish One’ because it’s always been my favorite and i’ve always felt like it’s my special song 🥺😭 i relate so so so deeply it’s unreal

Claudy

TIMELESS: All too well 10, Say don't go, Is it over now?, I bet you think about me, Foolish one, Forever winter, Better man, Nothing new, Now that we don't talk LOVESTRUCK:Electric touch, Mr perfectly fine, Message in a bottle, The very first night, Slut! PERFECTLY FINE: Suburban legends, I can see you, Babe, When Emma falls in love, Timeless, You all over me, That's when, Bye bye baby, Run NOTHING NEW: Castles crumbling, We were happy, Don't you

Claudy

I don’t know whether the world was ready for I bet you think about me though

Enzo Reis

TIMELESS: You're Losing Me, Mr. Perfectly Fine, I Can See You, Electric Touch, Forever Winter, Better Man, Babe, Foolish One, Bye Bye Baby, It's It Over Now, Slut!, Now That We Don't Talk, (These are divas in my house) I CAN SEE YOU (Sorry girls I changed the category name for something that made more sense for me): Nothing New, That's When, When Emma Falls In Love, The Very First Night, Message In A Bottle, Say Don't Go, All Of The Girls You Loved Before. (Saw the potential, I like it but it's not there). Mr. Perfectly Fine: Timeless, You All Over Me (I prefer the original demo has an country/pop - rock element to it), I Bet You Think About Me, Don't You. (Okay songs) Bye Bye Baby: We Were Happy, Run, Suburban Legends, Castles Crumbling. (They were left out for a reason, and the reason is that they aren't that good).

Ella

Yes!!! I love we were happy

olivia

nooooo don't you is my fave fearless vault 😭😭

Sarah (not in her sunday best)

I love Don’t You!! Such a relatable concept and feeling that has never been put into word for me before!

Ella

Don’t you is so beautiful, one of my fave fearless vaults ❤️

sillychicken

The very first night - I have always understood this song to be metaphorical for the magical feeling you get in the early stages of a relationship (butterflies, electrifying chemistry - honestly very similar to the feeling she describes in everything has changed). So when she says “I miss you like it was the very first night” to me, she is saying she misses that feeling of butterflies and excitement that she felt initially for this person and wishes she could feel as strongly as she felt in the beginning, but those butterflies/magic is fading away. The whole song is her longing for a more simple time when they were falling in love fast and deeply, before that magic faded and before things got complicated and they hurt each other. She wishes she could “fly”and “go back in time” to times that felt like their “very first night”. (Which maybe is not literally their first date, but just that more magical-lovey time in their relationship).

Ella

How can you possibly think we were happy and don’t you are boring, but simultaneously love when Emma falls in love so much 😭 😭 I feel the opposite way about those tracks, we were happy and don’t you do so much more for me!

Alexandra Bennett

I LOVEEEEE your ranking videos. I could watch an hour long video of you guys ranking best types of bagels lmao

Ella

Ok, here goes with my ranking… (as always, subject to change 😂 ) TIMELESS: ATW10 Better Man Is It Over Now? Say Don’t Go Foolish One Now That We Don’t Talk Don’t You LOVESTRUCK: Suburban Legends Babe That’s When Forever Winter Nothing New Electric Touch Run We Were Happy Mr Perfectly Fine I Can See You MR PERFECTLY FINE: Timeless Message In A Bottle The Very First Night Slut! You All Over Me I Bet You Think About Me NOTHING NEW: Castles Crumbling When Emma Falls In Love Bye Bye Baby

Meghan Cisar

You girlies are such my comfort show. ❤️

Natalie T

Ok... here's an idea, maybe the girlies did this ranking but, I'd love a ranking of best backing vocals. Sone songs would be skips for me, but the backing vocals are amazing and make the song SO BEAUTIFUL - for instance : imgonnagetyiuback... I'd love to hear how our chickens rethink/rerank songs because of the backing vocals!!

Shanna

Yesss! And their voices complement each other só well. Love their vulnerability and strength and I can hear both of their characters in this song in a beautiful way.. which is unique as with a lot of T's collabs I either wish it was just T solo, or I feel like the other artist isn't present enough.

Shanna

Love this!! You can really hear that Hailey has her personal connection with this the song

Shanna

My fav's: 💛 Mr. Perfectly Fine & Bye Bye Baby 💜 When Emma Falls In Love & Castles Crumbling ❤️ Better Man & Forever Winter 🩵 Slut! & Say Don't Go

Cassandra

Slut is #3 overall discography for me. Can never get enough

Quintin

are you guys gonna react to Lana’s new singles ?! they’re soo good

Sam

Love the suburban legends love <3 thanks for this offensive video ladies! One thing that got my shoulders up lol, the Hayley take - wdym! She's the queen of emo ballads! When I heard castles crumbling I immediately connected it to brick by boring brick - iconic Paramore song about burying the castle. It makes perfect sense to me for her to be on that song but I agree it's a bit boring and too simple.

Veronica Key

Timeless- Timeless, Electric Touch, Nothing new, All too well 10, Is it over now, I can see you, Suburban legends, Say don’t go, I bet you think about me Love struck- When Emma falls in love, slut, Better man, The very first night, Babe, now that we don’t talk, Don’t you, Mr. Perfectly fine- Castles crumbling, Foolish one, Forever winter, message in a bottle, We were happy, That’s when, Mr. Perfectly fine, you all over me, Nothing new- Bye bye baby, run

msjackyx

Would you ladies consider You’re Losing Me a vault track? And if so where would you place it?

Jessie Anderson

Came here to say a similar thing but you’ve said it perfectly! I love this song as it reminds me of the feeling when you first start liking someone - such a sweet innocent feeling x

skizzo

Same. WEFIL is a skip for me

Emmie Kruger

I love Castles Crumbling, it's my fave vault on Speak now TV 😅

Anairda

I think that what Taylor means with "I miss you like the very first night" is that she misses the person with the intensity she felt towards them on the very first night. The very first night together with someone you love is like a fever dream, you feel overwhelmed with emotion and desire. So missing them with the very same intensity is incredibly powerful for her.

Katie Niad-Thames

I am loving the love for Foolish Love. It was my favorite Speak Now vault track from the start!

Madison McIntosh

Totally with you guys for the foolish one and timeless supremacy and its underrated ness. From the release those two have been my absolute favorite vaults and dare I say fav tswift songs of them all. And they just bring back all that joy of summer 2023

Amanda Laura

Timeless 1. All Too Well 10 2. Say Don't Go 3. Foolish One 4. Is It Over Now? 5. Slut 6. Better Man 7. Nothing New Lovestruck 1. Now That We Don't Talk 2. When Emma Falls In Love 3. Electric Touch 4. I Can See You 5. The Very First Night 6. Timeless 7. Suburban Legends 8. Mr. Perfectly Fine 9. That's When Mr. Perfectly Fine 1. Message in a Bottle 2. Babe 3. Don't You 4. Run 5. Castles Crumbling 6. Forever Winter 7. I Bet You Think About Me Nothing New 1. Bye Bye Baby 2. We Were Happy 3. You All Over Me

Jenna Aguirre

According to my math (ranking songs based on the tier list and averaging per album), Bonny’s ranking of best vaults by album would be 1989, Speak Now, Red, Fearless. Emily’s would be 1989, Speak Now, Red, Fearless. Mine would be Red, 1989, Speak Now, Fearless!

Amber

I knew this was going to hurt my feelings as someone whose favorite vaults are fearless tvs 😭

anna

i'm so biased towards red tv because the red tv era just felt so special. she's been so busy with tour that I don't think we've gotten a proper era in terms of public appearances and interviews since then! like it makes it hard for the albums to really capture a moment in time if that makes sense!

Meghan Carty

Electric Touch sounds like a song from a Disney Channel movie to me lol. It's fun, but it I cannot take it seriously and I don't like how their voices sound together.

McKenna

bonny ur hair!!!! It looks so good im so jealous

Briana Senez

Timeless 1. ATW 10 2. Now That We Don’t Talk 3. Is It Over Now? 4. Slut! 5. I Bet You Think About Me 6. Foolish One 7. Nothing New 8. Say Don’t Go 9. When Emma Falls in Love Lovestruck 1. Better Man 2. Mr. Perfectly Fine 3. I Can See You 4. Forever Winter 5. The Very First Night 6. Message in a Bottle Perfectly Fine 1. Timeless (sorry girls) 2. Electric Touch 3. Castles Crumbling 4. Suburban Legends Nothing New 1. Babe 2. Run 3. Thats when 4. Don’t you 5. You all over me 6. Bye bye baby 7. We were Happy

Trillionaire

Lorde just released a new song

Trillionaire

What was that??? By lorde henny

T and S

I love Foolish One! And it was my surprise song! 🥹🥹🥹

Laura

I always rank along with you! So fun. Timeless: All Too Well TMV, I Bet You Think About Me, Say Don't Go, Better Man, Is It Over Now?, Timeless. Lovestruck: Nothing New, When Emma Falls In Love, I Can See You, Foolish One. Mr Perfectly Fine: You All Over Me, Mr Perfectly Fine, That's When, Babe, Slut, Now That We Don't Talk, Electric Touch. Nothing New: Suburban Legends, Message In A Bottle, Forever WInter, Bye Bye Baby, Run, The Very First Night, Castles Crumbling, We Were Happy, Don't You.

Lucia

I LOVED THIS, but I DEEPLY disagree with hayley being a wrong choice for castles crumbling!! as a huge Paramore fan, this was the colab of my dreams <3 I love this side of hayley and it is such a heavy and important side in every Paramore album, when she sings like this its often for a song that has the heart of the album in it, so for hayley to bring this softer, deep, conflicted side of her to a Taylor song, and THIS taylor song! ugh, it just made it so much more meaningful to me.

Cat Tulo

I actually have always thought We Were Happy is SO important to the lore BECAUSE it’s now the first song where she talks about being the one to break her partner’s heart! Prior to it, Back to December was the first song like that, and it’s really interesting to know that she felt those feelings even younger. Especially because her avoidance and feeling like the “problem” is a theme that exists to this day in her music. It does feel a little immature but I think that’s the charm of Fearless; when you’re 15, of course you think you’re going to buy your boyfriends daddy’s farm 😭😭 I also cannot believe you said “falling out of love with someone who didn’t do anything wrong is a nice concept and I wish she would revisit it today” because that’s Champagne Problems. She dropped his hand while dancing and she couldn’t give a reason other than “the voices told me I’m not in love anymore”!!!!!!

sierra

it’s gotta be right after atw10 that’s my guess 😅

Evangeline

No All the of the girls you loved before??

Hyla Sorenson

I don’t either! I really like I Can See You and Electric Touch is decent but the others I’m just so bored by. I can’t begin to understand the hype around When Emma Falls in Love. Timeless is cute but doesn’t do anything for me. Foolish One for some reason just makes me roll my eyes. Maybe I relate to that one too much haha. And Castles Crumbling is just kind of meh as well.

Theo DePina

Don’t You is perfect, I don’t care.

V. Babida

I heard a Taylor radio interview when she was promoting RED TV where she mentioned that when she was originally recording OG Red, All Too Well and Better Man were contenders for track 5 but she ultimately chose ATW and decided to leave off Better Man - maybe at the time she felt it was too angry and had too much of a country vibe when she was trying to lean more pop? I’ll never fully understand LOL but imagine if we didn’t get ATW during OG red era!!

Jessica F

💜 Timeless: All Too Well (10-min) / Is It Over Now? / Timeless / You All Over Me / "Slut!" / Better Man 🩵 Lovestruck: Now That We Don't Talk / When Emma Falls In Love / Mr. Perfectly Fine / I Bet You Think About Me / Don't You / Foolish One / Say Don't Go / Babe 💛 Mr Perfectly Fine: I Can See You / The Very First Night / Message In A Bottle / Nothing New / Bye Bye Baby / That's When ❤️ Nothing New: We Were Happy / Electric Touch / Castles Crumbling / Suburban Legends / Forever Winter / Run

skizzo

the TASTE! Indeed it is

skizzo

I agree, it also fits with Hayley's taste, didnt she say Hoax was her favorite song on Folklore?

AshZ

Message in bottle could've been a bop but unfortunately it's too immature sounding for me and got old reeeealllly quick.

Alyssa Kay

Timeless 💜 All Too Well 10-min Is It Over Now? Better Man Suburban Legends Timeless Lovestruck 💙 Say Don't Go Foolish One I Can See You Now That We Don't Talk Mr. Perfectly Fine The Very First Night Message in a Bottle That's When Mr. Perfectly Fine 💛 Babe I Bet You Think About Me Electric Touch Castles Crumbling Slut When Emma Falls in Love Run Nothing New Nothing New ❤️ Don't You We Were Happy You All Over Me Forever Winter Bye Bye Baby

AshZ

Castle's crumbling appreciation post, not everyone can love her but I doooooo!!!!!!

Lucy Kelleher

I've always taken the lyrics "I miss you like it was the very first night" as Taylor saying she wishes she could meet this person again and feel the way she felt on that very first night that they first met, as the rest of the song suggests they broke eachothers hearts in the end and she's reminiscing of the feeling before the heart break!

Saray Checo

Even the you’re losing me? I didn’t realize that! Thank you

Kaci

Vaults for me: When Emma falls in love; Mr perfectly fine; Suburban legends; slut; and NOW THAT WE DONT TALK (superior)

Kaci

Also love the outfits 🤍💙

Honey

I also think it’s so poignant Taylor and Hayley sung this song given Hayley’s existing song with Paramore “Brick by Boring Brick”, which features the lyrics “and we’ll bury the castle”. The meanings of the two songs intertwine and so I think it was no coincidence they sung this song on Speak Now. Also Hayley a masterful vocalist and perhaps she wanted to show this off more which is why she chose a more lyrical and slow tempo song than something more fast tempo with a lot of backing and effects. LOVE this song x

TScout

Re: the You’re Losing Me and ATGYLB as vaults discussion… I have agree they should be ranked as vaults because a vault is a song that that we wouldn’t have except that circumstances surrounding the album changed. Even though YLM came out in the Midnights era, if she hadn’t broken up with Joe, it probably would’ve never been released. And with its release, it re-contextualized the album. It’s might be more chronologically linked to the original album, but if anything, it’s impact on the framing of the original album is as impactful, if not more so, than the 1989 TV vaults or ATW10 for deciphering her emotional state and thought process at the time of making the album. And if you don’t rank ATG with the vaults, where do you rank it? It doesn’t give us the same emotional re-contextualization for Lover, but it does give us insight into her creative decision making process and was a game changer because it proved that no album was safe from future bonus releases. In my mind, they both have to be counted as vaults because we never would have had either if her personal agenda had gone to plan. All this being said, obviously you didn’t create the game, so no ding on you, just an interesting perspective to weigh in on when you play such games in the future! 💜

AshZ

Beautifully put 💜

Phoebe 🌷

Oh my Christ! Justice for the very first night 💔

Lindsay

They just don't seem to care for that electronic/club sound

Brittany Fitzgerald

Timeless: All Too Well 10, Timeless, Is it Over Now?, Slut!, Say Don’t Go, Suburban Legends, Now That We Don’t Talk, Better Man. Lovestruck: I Bet You Think About Me, I Can See You, Nothing New, Mr. Perfectly Fine, Foolish One, Message in a Bottle, Electric Touch Mr Perfectly Fine: Castles Crumbling, The Very First Night, You All Over Me, When Emma Falls In Love, Bye Bye Baby, Babe, Run, Forever Winter Nothing New: Don’t You, That’s When, We Were Happy. ATW10 and Timeless are Top and then I just love the 1989 vault songs so much, like I want to PERFORM them consecutively as one piece set to a montage of my life lol. I LOVE Suburban Legends, it’s so cinematic. I feel like the only one sometimes but whatevs lol.

Emma

Thank you for giving When Emma falls in love the recognition it deserves. Its one of my favorites ever💜💜

Roni Regev

Girls I love you but what the fuck 😭😭😭

Mario Tadeo

1. - Mr Perfectly Fine - ⁠That’s When - ⁠Better Man - ⁠I Bet You Think About Me - ⁠All Too Well (10min) - ⁠Electric Touch - ⁠Now That We Don’t Talk - ⁠Say Don’t Go 2. - Babe - ⁠I Can See You - ⁠Castles Crumbling - ⁠Timeless - ⁠Slut! - ⁠Suburban Legends - ⁠Is It Over Now? 3. - Bye Bye Baby - ⁠Nothing New - ⁠Message In A Bottle - ⁠Run - ⁠The Very First Night - ⁠When Emma Falls In Love - ⁠Foolish One 4. - Don’t You - ⁠You All Over Me - We Were Happy - ⁠Forever Winter

kenna🪽

justice for the very first night, “slut!”, and don’t you💔💔💔

Breezy Bumbles

I will also be a spokesperson for ED SHEERAN collabs and ED SHEERAN in general for all of time! I love him. Deeply.

Chevonne

Suburban legends is the best 1989 vault and is SO catchy and gut-punching. :) justice pleaseeeeeee ngvldfoldhfidndg

asquared13

Timeless: slut, suburban legends, all too well 10, nothing new, is it over now, say don't go, better man Lovestruck: now that we don't talk, message in a bottle, the very first night, electric touch, that's when, bye bye baby, forever winter, babe, I can see you, don't you Mr Perfectly Fine: I bet you think about me, run, Mr perfectly fine, we were happy, castles crumbling Nothing New: you all over me, when Emma falls in love, foolish one, times

Rex

Timeless: The Very First Night, Forever Winter, Suburban Legends, Foolish One, Better Man Lovestruck: "Slut!", Electric Touch, I Can See You, Babe, Message in a Bottle, When Emma Falls in Love, Mr. Perfectly Fine, Is It Over Now? Mr. Perfectly Fine: Timeless, That's When, Say Don't Go, I Bet You Think About Me, You All Over Me, All Too Well (10 Minute Version), Now That We Don't Talk, Run Nothing New: Don't You, Nothing New, Castles Crumbling, Bye Bye Baby, We Were Happy

Amely

Just watched this video now and I‘m so curious where you would place You‘re losing me 🫢

Sara _

Unpopular opinion - Suburban Legends is not only the best vault track but also the best song on 1989

Ferone

we were happy is the best fearless vault, better man is the best red vault, timeless is the best speak now vault and say dont go (or slut) is the best 1989 vault

kenny

you get it. 😩 suburban legends stan’s rise!

Britney Spears

YES! You get it! And top 5 in her discography!

Emmie

I think hayley said in an interview that taylor wanted her to sing on a different song for speak now tv as a vault track but hayley felt that that song taylor chose, was a song that "was expected " for her to be a feature on. And hayley wanted to be on castles crumble instead. Dont remember which interview but 90% sure I saw it somewhere when SN TV was released.

Emmie

"When Taylor asked me to feature on Speak Now TV, she originally suggested another song, and I was honest with her that though the song may have been closer to what a casual Paramore fan would expect me to feature on, I didn't relate to that sound as much," Williams recalls. "She then, within minutes, sent me 'Castles Crumbling,' and not only did it feel more like a fit, I related to it lyrically on a deeper level ... She respected my gut feelings and still pushed me to stay in it with her." This is what I was referring to. https://people.com/taylor-swift-haim-hayley-williams-talk-friendship-artistry-8411154

Kim

I know this is an old video and this is a random comment but please react to all her old vlogs on YouTube. I have core memories because of those vlogs. Especially during Fearless era. Those vlogs are so fun and show what made so many people love Taylor, she seemed like your friend.

Austin Lay

What’s really jarring is the difference in quality between Fearless vaults and the other re-recorded vaults.

Hannah S

I know I’m late to commenting, but I just need to say that the more entertaining take on We Were Happy exists and it’s called Champaign Problems! 😭

LiliaC

If you add a redhead you are the Charlie's Angels but for Taylor lore.

Chelsea

I bet you think about me is straight to timeless wdym 😭

Chelsea

Timeless: ATW10, Better Man, WEFIL, IBYTAM, That’s when, bye bye baby, Castles crumbling I wishhhh I could explain my love for bye bye baby but it’s too hard over text! The beatsss and the absolute drama of opening with “IT WASNT JUST LIKE A MOVIE….THE RAIN DIDNT SOAK THRU MY SKIN” it’s unbeatable I grieved the Hayley Williams collab potential as u said but actually castles crumbling is giving a lot melodically I love how it sounds and it’s like almost 6 mins you can really get lost in it

Jacky Resnik

Timeless: ATW10, when Emma falls in love, timeless, I bet you think about me, better man, is it over now?, Mr perfectly fine Love struck: thats when, suburban legends, bye bye baby, foolish one, don’t you, slut, Mr perfectly fine: say don’t go, now that we don’t talk, babe, electric touch, we were happy, forever winter, the very fist night, message in a bottle Nothing new: I can see you, run, castles crumbling