Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 710565336.mp4

Downloads

Content

Hi besties 🫶🏼 This video is coming at you from the Vault as we are currently away in NYC !! Hope you enjoy this little track ranking, excited to here your favs in the comments 🫶🏼

Files

Comments

Katie LaFave

omg first the role model reaction now this!!! so much chicken content

Keri 🫶🏻

how dare you make me choose between watching this and the tucker reaction

Darya 🤍

I was just looking for something to watch while cooking dinner and this couldn’t have been more perfect timing

Katie LaFave

my ranking: 1. afterglow 2. untouchable 3. evermore 4. you are in love 5. the alchemy 6. starlight 7. new years day 8. peace 9. ours 10. bigger than the whole sky: sonically and melodically it's so beautiful, but it's just too sad imo

Kiki

1. You are in love 2. Evermore 3. The alchemy 4. Starlight 5. Afterglow 6. The manuscript 7. Peace 8. New years day 9. Ours 10. Untouchable 11. Bigger than the whole sky Here is my ranking, curious to find out yours 👀

Sabrina Tonolli

You are in love was my walking down the aisle song at my wedding in May 💕

Barb 🔆

I am thoroughly enjoying your long hair era - both looks healthy, full and silky !! ; and simultaneously I'm wondering if you'll get a haircut whilst on holiday in NYC (b/c personally I've had excellent experience with haircuts on vacation).

Fabiha Qureshi

peace was one of my faves on folklore before i even became a full blown swiftie bc it felt so removed from taylor actually. as someone with mental health issues, specifically BPD, it resonated in a way that very few songs have. i think aaron connected to this song in that way as well in the folklore long pond sessions

Katie LaFave

saying it now... JUSTICE FOR THE ALCHEMY

Barb 🔆

Yes I remember Aaron being quite open in that discussion. That song is special. After she and Joe broke up the rethathaming of Peace having sad relationship vibes took me away from the pure beauty of it. Now I'm back to feeling it more fully (detached from its connection to what wasn't right for her in that relationship). Thank you for reminding me how relatable Peace is for so many situations.

Noor Sm

I love you guys but Can we stop this random ranking 🤍

Katie LaFave

afterglow overall is soooo underrated!! the bridge tends to get love a lot on tiktokt hough which is funny cuz if i had to pick, that's my least fav part of the song

Katie LaFave

ours definitely grew on me with taylor's version, but it still is one of least favs on speak now!!! i do loveee the music video though

Katie LaFave

who a song is about & whether or not i relate will never affect my opinion on it

Grace

No I actually do need Emily to be doubling down on her the alchemy opinion bc it is the definition of a skip for me and I won’t be apologizing 😭 it’s so go girl, give me nothing

OurSong13

The sparse dinging piano notes in the manuscript I always imagined to represent tears falling (the tears fell in synchronicity with the score). The first note does have that sense of wait did I just hear a piano? Then it plays another note and you realize it is playing. It reminds me of how sometimes you don't realize you were moved by something or aware of your emotions or sadness until randomly a tear falls and lands on a surface. You maybe even deny it happened, until another tear falls and then you realize ok yup I'm crying. That's how the manuscript feels, a journey through sparse tears/piano notes lol

Alexandra Bennett

YAAAAS. I’m such a little slut for a ranking video

Jenn Hamel

I don’t know what it is about THESE specific videos but like…and how do I explain this…I feel like they are in a secret language only we can understand. Like I’m pretty sure a layperson would genuinely be like WHAT the FUCK are these people talking about. It’s the way randomly we veer off into a 3 minute conversation about Aaron Dessner and folklore “standing alone” and it’s like plain English to me but I think it’s actually gibberish which is so…fabulous? 😂

Katie LaFave

i just think her voice in the verses in the alchemy sounds so cool!! it's exactly how i feel about her vocals in the verses of elizabeth taylor and father figure!! i also love the drop into the last chorus after the bridge in the alchemy!!! it's so good i know you guys (mostly em 😂) don't fathom, but i love! and yes it is a love song

Darya 🤍

The entire manuscript instrumental playing over you two calling it not a song is comedic goldddd

Darya 🤍

1. Peace 2. Evermore 3. New Year’s Day 4. You are in love 5. Afterglow 6. Untouchable 7. The alchemy 8. The manuscript 9. Bigger than the whole sky 10. Ours 11. Starlight

Katie LaFave

i did not expect bonny to put peace over evemore!! maybe that's just because we've heard bonny talk about evermore more! i knew it would be up high though

Katie LaFave

um not you guys forgetting lover!!!! so diabolical to my girl afterglow

Luai Ahmed

"Ours is just there" oh sweetie.. that's not.... i.... we..... jail. actually no electric chair. Emily is actually so sweet because I would have dRAGGED YOU by ur hair.

scout

~ my ranking ~ 1. evermore 2. the manuscript 3. new years day 4. peace 5. ours 6. starlight 7. you are in love 8. untouchable 9. the alchemy 10. afterglow 11. bigger than the whole sky (like emily said, it is a beautiful song, i just haven't had my moment with it and don't find myself listening to it) i see what bonny is saying about the manuscript being more of a statement, but i think i feel about it the way she feels about bigger than the whole sky in that when it comes on, i have to sit down and listen and be present with it

Takara

OURS LAST IS DIABOLICAL BONNY!!!!!!!! I fear that I related to the "snide remarks about your tattoos" line so much as I am the same age as Taylor, and was also dating a tattooed man (whom I did marry lol). I just yeet the information about who Taylor wrote that song about out of my brain lalalalalalaa

Katie LaFave

afterglow is literally in my top 20 fav TS songs of all time!! it's sooo superior!! the way her vocals build throughout!! the drums!! the sound!! ugh it's sooo superior!!

scout

also what do u meeeaaaan the manuscript is not a song??? am i the only one sad-belting "AND THE YEARS PAAAASSSSED LIKE SCENES OF A SHOW, THE PROFESSSSOOOOR SAID TO WRITE WHAT YOU KNOW, LOOKING BACKWAAAARRDS MIGHT BE THE ONLY WAY TO MOVE FORWARD"???

Katie LaFave

no girlies we NEED need to be released!!! it's sooo superior!!! i see it talked about all the time

Katy

Was not aware that You Are In Love is about Lena and Jack?????

Katie LaFave

GUYS THE 7 YR LOVER ANNIVERSARY IS THE 23RD!!! LISTEN TO LOVER THEN FROM TOP TO BOTTOM!!! I SWEAR IT HELPS/FORCES YOU TO FATHOM AND HAVE A MOMENT WITH THE ALBUM AND SONGS YOU MAYBE WOULDN'T OTHERWISE!!!! I'VE BEEN SAYING & WILL SAY THIS FOREVER LISTEN TO TAYLOR ALBUMS IN ORDER ON THEIR ANNIVERSARIES!!

Katie LaFave

on the 23rd (lover anniversary) listen to lover from top to bottom like as you're getting ready to go out in new york!!

Nicole

Forgetting Lover for a moment 😆💕

Kelsi Ford

Em I also don’t fuck with the alchemy, you’re not alone!

Karen Valentino

Loved this! I view The Manuscript as an extended Outro to the album.

Amy Sawyer

it's that "your integrity makes me seem small" and "I talk shit with my friends, It's like I'm wasting your honor" that just irritates the hell out of me, i can barely listen to this song. And I felt that way about those lyrics the first time I heard them and was so confused as to why she was idolizing this guy at the expense of herself. Makes me legit angry, and especially now that we know the whole story, ugh! LOL feel strongly about this one I guess

Karen Valentino

Evermore is by far my favorite track 15. I love its reflection on pain and then the dawning of hope. I’ve experienced that process in my life, going from despair to beginning to get traction, to get my footing.

Aleah Goldberg

The albums in the background being fearless because fifteen is on it and evermore because the title track is track 15–i see you chickens!!!

Takara

evermore Ours Bigger Than the Whole Sky peace You Are In Love Afterglow New Year's Day Untouchable Starlight The Manuscript The Alchemy

Bella

my ranking :) 1 afterglow 2 you are in love 3 evermore 4 the alchemy 5 bigger than the whole sky 6 untouchable 7 ours 8 new years day 9 the manuscript 10 starlight 11 peace

Ebru

Watching the Peace convo took me back to your reaction to Folklore and the “this other random guy Aaron” comment. How far we’ve come! Taylor really does propel producers onto bigger things. Also thoroughly enjoyed the manuscript piano editing at the end. 🫶🏼

Yuli

I was really in the final stages of my relationship with new years day and emily hunt i think you’ve formally provided the actual last breaths of it with that connection with midnights genuinely fuck u (ily) but what the actual fuck i could’ve gone my whole life without making that connection jesus christ bro

Kamree Kelley

Ya’ll were a little unhinged those last few minutes with the manuscript 😂 I definitely listen to the manuscript as a song. 🫶

Wendy Davis

So perplexed that the story of The Alchemy is confusing to you. It's so simple and obvious. It's about meeting Travis. Period. Football references. Undeniable CHEMISTRY/ALCHEMY. Best melodic part is.........so when I TOUCHDOWN........blokes warm the bench refers to Joe because blokes are "casual boys" in British terminology. Someone who warms the bench isn't good enoough to be in the game/on the sidelines. It's so simple and sweet and just her joy in the initial CELEBRATORY phase of falling in love. It's all very clear. But it's ok if you don't love it.

Camila Dejesus

Evermore as #1 is SO VALID! I really think there are not a lot of songs like evermore. There are plenty of songs that say "It's gonna be okay," But evermore allows the listener to sit with the feelings of despair, to ruminate on them and to process them, and then, in an unassuming voice, guides the listener into finding whatever it is they need to cling to to have hope. It is so beautiful, and needed especially at the time it was released.

casserole

Starlight was my surprise song too!!

Justin

I’m here to fight for The Alchemy and its superior production. The instrumental has these noises during the chorus that I don’t even know how to phonetically spell out, but it’s like a drawn out electronic sound. Plus the higher, almost yelling harmony vocals that are so common on TTPD when she says “this time with an E” (similar to the backing vocals in “loved this place for…” in So Long London). Sickening song.

Katie LaFave

afterglow and i think he knows are literally both in my top 5 on lover lol

Katie LaFave

nahhh girls INTHAF is so good

Sydney Ros

slay emily, not an alchemy stan either!

Paloma Bennett

My Ranking of Track 15s 1. You Are in Love 2. The Alchemy 3. The Manuscript 4. Peace 5. Bigger Than the Whole Sky 6. Afterglow 7. Ours 8. Starlight 9. Evermore (Featuring Bon Iver) 10. New Year’s Day 11. Untouchable

casserole

i keep having to pause so i can listen to the song being dicussed lol

Amy Vega

She’s said before that the lyric “hey you, what if I told you we’re cool. That child’s play back in school is forgiven under my rule.” Is what makes her think it’s about an on/off again relationship, but for me it’s simply referring to when Travis played marry kiss kill and didn’t say marry for her. That is literally a child’s game.

Katie LaFave

lets also never forget that bigger than the whole sky is self-written

Scarlet Woodland

I feel exactly the same as Em about the alchemy. I swear half the issue is the way it's sung, because she sounds so depressed and resigned. What even is the vibe? Also what is that one note bridge lol

Katie LaFave

i just find it so funny that you guys don't put ur rankings in a numbered list on ur notes app 😂

Katie LaFave

um the manuscript is a SONG!! the backing vocals during the bridge are gorgeous and give me chills every time!!!

Katie LaFave

well she's actually reading the lyrics to all too well in the book at the end of the short film 😂

Courtney

PEACE STANS RISE!! speak on it bonny!!!! i feel that song for the emotional burden i fear i bring as well, thank you for being vulnerable and sharing 🫶 peace is MY song i feel that so deeply 😭

Melissa S

You are in Love… (the structure of this song where she beings with two people in a dark room, then flashes back through their relationship, THEN boomerangs back to the present with them in the dark room and he pauses and says ‘you’re my best friend’.. brilliant) The manuscript Evermore Ours new Years Day Afterglow Untouchable Peace Bigger than the whole sky The Alchemy Starlight

Patrick B

lol not me forgetting Lover too

Courtney

I was just in NYC and went to the ATW10 short film bookstore and it's too superior highly recommend (it's called housing works)

Jade

I love seeing everyone’s rankings. It just goes to show how we can all love these songs and still order them so completely differently! Like… The Alchemy might be my #1 and Afterglow might be in the top 3 or 4 for me. Starlight is definitely at the bottom bc I just don’t gravitate towards it- but it’s a great story and a great song. Ours was the 1st song I learned on guitar, but it reminds me of that time and so I never listen to it. It’s so cute, tho. The manuscript just reminds me of the end of the Eras Tour now and it makes me extra sad…. Like the preface before a final goodbye.

Mex

bigger than the whole sky is just so relatable. i remember hearing "salt streams out my eyes and into my ears" on first listen and immediately recalling those devastating times when emotion has led me to the same experience

hauntedwillow27

i NEED NEED just for the melody ughhhhh i wish it didn’t leak so she could’ve used it for a different song it’s so goodddddd

Tess7

Exactly! I hate it for Taylor lol

Maya

Ours makes me think of that generic YouTube music YouTubers would use 😂😂😂

Tess7

lol the Ours discussion I actually love the song Starlight. Taylor can just tell a story like no one else. This ranking was a tough one, but I’d rank You Are In Love or Bigger Than The Whole Sky number 1

Alexina Derkaz

It's so fun that you do in depth song breakdowns where you really get to gush over every line and then we get to hear you circle back around in this format. This was a fascinating group of songs INDEED!

Sophie Williams

Oh yessss to the track rankings being back I'm such a sucker for them and love to rank them alongside you guys. 🥰🫶🏻

jordan bertges

my ranking!! peace starlight the alchemy the manuscript bigger than the whole sky you are in love evermore (ft. bon iver) new years day ours untouchable afterglow

CyrusNomadix

Bigger Than The Whole Sky is my emotional support animal

Kaylee O'Connor

I was also at that Brisbane show and had a full fathoming ! I actually didn't know the song but somehow knew all the words 😅 it was the moment I knew that I was a a huge fan and never really acknowledged that until that concert.

Maya

My ranking would be 1. The manuscript 2. New Year’s Day 3. Starlight 4. Evermore 5. Peace 6. Afterglow 7. Bigger than the whole sky 8. The alchemy 9. Ours 10. You are in love 11. Untouchable

Britney Fletcher

Thank god I witnessed the peace x New Year’s Day mashup on the eras tour

Marlee

the Alchemy is like a dream state in lyrics in production imo, she’s like so shocked by this connection the chemicals hit her like white wine . I think people get so hung up on how she says “what if I I told you I’m back” that they think its about a past love coming back. But really she’s like I’m BACK bitches! Like I’m done being sad (I’m an independent girly if you will) 🤪the hospital was a drag!!! (Matty), and then WOAH what the heck I wasn’t even looking for you and here you are calling on a megaphone for me… (the fate of Ophelia is a sister song) . And it’s early days of her meeting Travis being like what the heck is this guy and where have you come from, and I need to give him a chance (even though I’m scared of it a little bit and being hurt again)

Marlee

Also “the sign on your heart is reserved for me” again not a past love, but because he’s like been waiting his whole life to meet her so this whole time his heart has been reserved for her (again reminds me of themes of fate of Ophelia and opalite)

Jonna Kristina

I will not stand for the manuscript slander! but also it was a hilarious convo

Jonna Kristina

my ranking: 1. evermore 2. peace 3. you are in love 4. the manuscript 5. new year’s day 6. bigger than the whole sky 7. afterglow 8. untouchable 9. ours 10. starlight 11. the alchemy

Connie Forrest

I am SHOCKED how many of my favourites are track 15s apparently???? Madness! This is a diabolical ranking!!!

P.R. Dayvonne

the manuscript feels more like spoken-word poetry than a song *snaps*

Savanna

Love when you girls do these ranking videos! 💕 For a video suggestion it would be fun if you guys did a ranking of your least favorite Taylor swift songs from each album. I also think it would be quite funny to see what would make it to the top of that list

Alba

I love rankings fav type of videos ever

Annika 📍Melb, AU

I didn’t even notice that you forgot Lover 🩷 I’m dyingggg 💀

Septima

This energy is killing me 🤣🤣🤣 the manuscript is not a song

RL

I love waking up for work at 5 and realizing my two favorite chickens have uploaded!! You two are the narration to my work day when I’m craving some intentional discussion and positivity. Sending love from upstate NY!! It’s blowing my mind that we’re in the same time zone rn!! I hope you’re enjoying the city!! Stay safe and have fun!!!💛🐣✨

Anna

Peace is out of this world beautiful, lyrically, musically, emotionally. „I’m not sure if any lyrics have ever hit me harder“ - same! Thank you Bonnie. And you’re right Emily, the music Aaron wrote is incredible. Peace was a big moment in my relationship to Taylor‘s music. Quick ranking: 1 Peace 2 Bigger than the whole sky 3 New Year‘s Day 4 Evermore 5 The Alchemy 6 Ours 7 Untouchable 8 Afterglow 9 The Manuscript 10 You are in Love 11 Starlight I could speculate about why, but for some reason „You are in Love“ irks me. Sorry.

Magda

1. evermore 2. Untouchable 3. Bigger Than The Whole Sky 4. Afterglow 5. The Alchemy 6. New Year's Day 7. peace 8. Starlight 9. You Are In Love 10. The Manuscript 11. Ours

Morgs

As a nostalgic gal I totally agree with Emily on how superior Ours is🫶🏼🫶🏼

Bobhog

Evermore is one of her best songs. Ever. Period. Top 5 for me!

Antoinette

The Manuscript is one of the songs I play for my kids so they’ll fall asleep 😅

Bethany Andrews

I get Bonnie's indifference to Ours. While I think it's a good song I can separate it from the John Mayer of it all post Would've Could've Should've being released

Julian

I completely agree that the manuscript is an epilogue. 1. evermore 2. You are in love 3. peace 4. Untouchable 5. Ours 6. BTTWS 7. Afterglow 8. New Year’s Day 9. Starlight 10. The Alchemy 11. The Manuscript

C

Bonny I have never been so flabbergasted as when you revealed Ours was LAST on your ranking lmaooo a fathoming is in store for you, my friend! Someday. Let this be a lesson to all, we have got to be able to separate Taylor's experiences from the music!

nina

It’s so interesting to me when people say BTTWS is ambiguous because it is so apparently clear to me what it’s about. And i’m not saying this happened to Taylor but she was definitely writing with this in mind on behalf of someone she knows, and if it has happened to you, you’d be sure it’s about that too. A very raw and neccessary song. Thank you Taylor 🙏🏼🌌 🤎 evermore 🩶 peace 🖤 New Year’s Day 💙 Bigger Than The Whole Sky 🩷 Afterglow ❤️ Starlight 🤍 The Alchemy 💛 Untouchable 🩵 You Are In Love 💜 Ours 🖤 The Manuscript

Annika 📍Melb, AU

I just love how all of us knew Emily was going to rant about The Alchemy 😂

Bradi R

Sometimes I’m getting ready for work and I watch these videos and Bonny just fucks me up ! The way she is talking about Peace being Taylor’s song rather than the couple’s song is a lot

Jacob

1. Peace 2. Evermore 3. New Year's Day 4. Afterglow 5. Untouchable 6. The Alchemy 7. You Are In Love 8. Bigger Than The Whole Sky 9. The Manuscript 10. Starlight 11. Ours :)

Hayley

Emily chicken I completely understand what you mean about The Alchemy. I pretty much always skip it at this point and it has nothing to do with the muse confusion. It’s just boring 🥱

chi

1. Bigger than the whole sky 2. Peace 3. The Alchemy 4. Afterglow 5. New Years Day 6. Starlight 7. you are in love 8. the manuscript 9.Evermore 10. Teardrops on my guitar (pop mix) 11. Ours 12. Untouchable

Regina Phalange

I will die on this hill: the alchemy yes is in part about Travis (the trophy lyric for sure) but the whole energy and the vibe is about her fans and the eras tour!! She’s celebrating the undeniable chemistry we share with her and the fact it’s propelled her to such great heights. “I haven’t come around in so long” - she hadn’t toured in 6 years “I circled you on a map” each stop on the tour “call the amateurs and cut them from the team” - stand aside all other pop stars “forgiven under my rule” - rule as in like the reign of Taylor, those two years she was doing the eras tour were crazy she literally was the queen of the world. And I think storytelling wise it actually makes a lot of sense for Travis to then come along in the bridge because she’s describing how she’s been built up during this tour and she’s at the height of her powers and this is when Travis comes running to her. We know how important it is for her to have a partner that doesn’t feel uncomfortable by her success and wants to celebrate her for it. I think that’s why I get the vibe it’s kind of rep coded in that sense like both a love song but also her feeling empowered by herself

dorothy lou

justice for the manuscript !!

Brittany Diamond

It's so fascinating (genuinely) how Emily can't pick up on what's going on with The Alchemy, especially because I hear the lovey dovey-ness SO strongly. I can practically see Taylor physically smiling while singing the chorus, it's so clear to me and I'm not even a particular fan of the song lol. I can see the verse melodies not giving the 'so in love that I'm unhurried and zen and calm' that I think she was going for, they come off a bit boring to me too, but the overall lyrics and chorus melodies *scream* love and bliss. She goes for a very similar energy in Slut but I think she nailed the melodies top to bottom in that one so we're all on the same page, whereas Alchemy missing the mark even a little suddenly loses a lot of people's interest.

Katie J

The Alchemy is my favorite song on TTPD and my fave in this batch, so have to defend! It gets lost in the discourse about who this is about (personally, think it's an amalgamation of both guys and the fans), but I believe this is less of a love song and more of an empowerment and self-confidence type of song similar to a Bejeweled/I Think He Knows vibe. It's less about how can this couple fight our chemistry, more how can someone resist the awesomeness of the singer. Which we can all relate to since we also don't know how to resist the awesomeness of Taylor Swift. It makes me think about the Eras tour and coming back to Taylor being on the top of the music industry (she's the one to beat, she's coming back to where she belongs). But it's the same confidence that you can feel in a new relationship (whether brand new or reuniting) or when you accomplish a life goal.

Mathieu

I do need need tbh it's a neeeeeeeeeed

Katie J

My ranking: 1. The alchemy (wrote about my interpretation on the feeling of the song in my other comment, but this isn't the first time Emily and I have had opposite tastes :) 2. You are in love 3. Afterglow 4. Ours 5. Peace 6. The manuscript 7. Starlight 8. New Year’s Day 9. Untouchable 10. Bigger than the whole sky 11. Evermore (loved the Eras tour version with just Taylor, but when Bon Iver comes in the bridge, I press skip almost subconsiously; beautiful message, I just don't love how their voices blend on that song)

Michelle

Emily being radicalized by the Alchemy is one of my favorite chats n reacts bits lmao! WE FEEL YOU EM. also well said about the manuscript - a statement for her life, but nothing we could really relate to or find anything for ourselves it. It’s very closed off, compared to BTTWS for example which is so open and expansive in it’s little microworld.

Riley Bidwell

I COMPLETELY agree with what you’re saying about Need. It just never really jumped out to me as “wow we neeeed this”. I think it’s romanticized because we “don’t have it”… you know?

Magda

Those rankings are my comfort videos! There is something so peaceful, calming and joyful in listening to you talk about those songs and doing my personal ranking on my phone in the meantime. When you're done doing those, I think maybe a good idea would be to rank (not tier rank) each album - that would be a fun activity!! Enjoy your trip girlies 🩷

Julia

Yeah I know what you mean. It feels artificial. This is of course speculation,but I always thought it used to be a different song/story and she changed it after a certain relationship ended and another one began

Ally ❤️

Justice for evermore h the song! My number one across the whole discography. That song came at a critical time and I will forever be grateful to Taylor for this gem.

Laura

I really love hesring Bonny’s appreciation for starlight, I was so obsessed with that song when red came out with no real reason other than I just loved it and no one gets that😂

Courtney McAlexander

speaking my truth: if the manuscript isn’t a song, then neither is Peace or Hoax :::::runs away from comments section::::

Meesh

thank you for being an Ours fan Emily 😊

Magda

Oh that's a great one!

Amanda Christon

PEACE IS UNDERRATED. EVERYBODY UNDERSTAND PLZ

Kirrily Lewis

Totally!! Thank god at least Bonny likes it. I hope Emily fathoms one day. But we all have a song that we just don’t really connect with I suppose.

Kirrily Lewis

Absolutely. It’s plain English to me. I don’t understand what’s not to get 😂 it’s such a sexy vibe and a perfect introduction to their relationship. Honestly I have an alchemy moment so often where I just simply neeeed to put it on and sing and enjoy the vibes.

VadersPetPig

The alchemy hate is so valid Em 😭 the way Bonny was moving as you were roasting it sent me 💀 i love you guys sm 💗

Kirrily Lewis

Top 5 of this list are some of my all time favourite TS songs 1. Evermore 2. peace 3. The alchemy 4. new years day 5. Bigger than the whole sky The rest of the songs I don’t have a strong enough opinion of to rank against each other. All good songs but not in my top 5. Thanks for the chatty chat ranking ladies. Hope you’re enjoying NYC!

Juliane

The fact that Taylor made the Ours MV at an office and she says elevator buttons and morning air, strangers..... it brings me to my terrible job and subway life, and I don't think of John Mayer not even for a second, thank God, I love that song and I relate to it so much, not working with my boyfriend.

Juliane

I'm curious how this is gonna work with tracks 20, tracks 21 etc... are you going to do them for example considering Fearless TV and Red TV... but then in that case you're not including TTPD since you already did the anthology tracks... and if you don't do those, then what happens to The very first night and Bye bye baby etc...???

MarkH

Don't forget Aaron working with honorary pop girlies Noah Kahan and Marcus Mumford! I'm sort of joking, but not really--Noah and Marcus have the similar characteristic that the pop girlies do of really dealing with their emotions in an honest way, and that's what Aaron brings out so well.

Emily Christine

This is a SUPERIOR list of songs. Also justice for the manuscript 😩 one of my favs from ttpd lol

Emily Christine

I LOVE when she says “this time with an E” in the alchemy 😩😩😩

Wendy Davis

Beautifully put, Kirrily, thank you for your response! And thank you for pointing out that it is a sexy vibe--I hadn't picked up on that because at the same time, there's a purity and innocence to it. ALSO, THE BRIDGE explodes with JOY!

Wendy Davis

I just recently realized that The Manuscript is a masterpiece :) .

Wendy Davis

What a beautiful fathoming. I hope Bonny and Emily read it. I'm going to listen to The Manuscript with the tears in mind next time.....thank you!!

izzy 🪷

peace is the best song she's ever written, argue w the wall :3

Marithe Carrera

🤣🤣🤣 I was thinking the exact same thing. Like if my bf watched this video he would understand 0% of it

Moni

BONNNYYYY THANK YOUUUUUUUUUUUU FOR REPRESENTING US PEACE GIRLIES i know you will always have my back

Zain

I’m with Emily on The Alchemy and Ours!

Barb 🔆

Thank you for this comment. It's when I could "hang" with these conversations - know what they are saying, not need to go to Google for album tracks or Spotify for lyrics - that I felt "inducted" into Swiftiehood.

Jenn Hamel

It literally is a wonderful, wonderful secret language 😍💕

Barb 🔆

Emily could have said more about New Year's Day.. Like how about THE lyric "don't ever become a stranger whose laugh I could recognize anywhere" 😭 And "Hold onto the memories. They will hold onto you." 😭

Barb 🔆

Amy. That's how I take it also!

Barb 🔆

This is beautiful

Barb 🔆

Yeah crazy who knew track 11 was such a special place!!

Barb 🔆

Thank you for this comment 🙏

Maria

1. You are in love 2. Evermore 3. The alchemy 4. Peace 5. Starlight 6. New Year’s Day 7. Ours 8. Afterglow 9. BTTS 10. The manuscript 11. Untouchable It was so hard to order the 6th to 10th place omg

Sophie

Emily I'm Sorry (superior song btw), but you are not the world's biggest The Alchemy hater!! I despise that song with a burning passion and it's even worse because it comes after Smallest Man which is superiorrrr

Fran

It’s such a sexy vibe, YES! Where’s the trophy, he just comes running over to me??? OMG! For me, that feels like someone sees ME. Nothing else matters, I’m the only one that is important. It gives such off such a teenage romantic feeling. It IS that type of alchemy. The same as in So high school, “tell me bout the first time you saw me” ooooh to be seen ❤️

Sammi

Oh my God, the girls have to watch the Marc maron stand-up about bigger than the whole sky

Sammi

I understand the “it’s not a song” as its not a stand alone without the story or lore maybe. But man it is a masterpieceeeeeeee

Sammi

The dings over Emily singing 🤣

Emily Steward

I got in only me when I’m with you at reputation and my whole section was silent while me and my friend were SCREAMING! I think people thought we were crazy 😂

Emily Steward

Bigger than the whole sky was so healing for me. I had a miscarriage with my first pregnancy and this song just the perfect representation of those feelings. I honestly can’t listen too often because of how sad it makes me but it’s so important. Just love it

Sara🇸🇪

I am so excited to see what love songs will come in the future🥰 because in my own experience when you meet a person you really want to be with and that compliments you another type of love grows❤️ in my experience it other starts crack and not be good or the love just grows into something deeper, a love that you didn’t knew and that is so special🙈🥹❤️

Val

This week has been the first rainy and non hot week in Germany since months, it was very autumny and I made myself a cup of tea with a serving of biscuits and thought of y'all hahahaha

Maren

I feel the same way as Bonny about The Manuscript, I don't ever really listen to it tbh.

Feride Eron

look i love u guys and trying hard not to judge you for putting THE manuscript in such low spots but bonny judging emily for putting the manuscript above starlight -that i can't :') wdmmmmm they're not even on the same level

Jessikah

My ranking: 1. Evermore 2. You Are In Love 3. New Year’s Day 4. Afterglow 5. Peace 6. Bigger Than The Whole Sky 7. Ours 8. The Alchemy 9. Starlight 10. The Manuscript 11. Untouchable

Rossella Promontorio

You know what would be funny, that you guys make a summary video of ALL of your tracks ranking and see to which album/s the songs consistently on the first 2 spots or even the podium belong to! I am pretty sure it's gonna be folklore and/or evermore :) it's funny how we always say that TTPD is the most superior album ever created but actually is not, I feel nothing will ever top Folklore or evermore, even for a Midnight girl like me I have to admit superiority when it comes to those 2! :):)

Crista W

How can I both be agreeing and not agreeing so hard with both of you in this video 😂 Ours, Alchemy and Manuscript are being so misunderstood right now but you guys make great points and fathomings as usual

Abby Thaine

1. You Are In Love (top 10 TS song for me) 2. Evermore 3. Peace 4. The Alchemy 5. Untouchable 6. New Years Day 7. Afterglow 8. Ours 9. BTTWS 10. The Manuscript 11. Starlight

marysia

1. New Year’s Day 2. Evermore 3. Peace 4. The alchemy 5. Bigger than the whole sky 6. You are in love 7. Untouchable 8. The manuscript 9. Afterglow 10. Ours 11. Starlight

Laura

Same here - it encapsulates the loss in the lyrics and production. My miscarriage was in 2005 and the song is healing to listen to.

Laura

1 Ours "People Throw Rocks at Things That Shine" 2 New Years Day 3 You're In Love 4 The Alchemy "Where's the Trophy? He Just Comes Runnin' Over to Me" 5 Evermore 6 Afterglow 7 The Manuscript "The Professor Says to Write What You Know" 8 Peace 9 Untouchable 10 Bigger TTWS 11 Starlight

Hannah

No honestly I will probably never listen to the alchemy again in my life. Life is just to short 🫢

Hannah

Bonny’s smile and ”that’s our ranking of the track fifteens” is the cutest little outro 🥹☺️

Barb 🔆

I never ever in my life heard one word about Need until this moment right here.

Barb 🔆

I've never seen it. Tks for the rec

Brittany DeLara

Not very similar to either one of you today!!! 1. evermore 2. The Alchemy 3. You Are In Love 4. Afterglow 5. New Year’s Day 6. BTTWS 7. peace 8. The Manuscript 9. Ours 10. Starlight 11. Untouchable

sleepless_dream (Lauren)

I absolutely LOVE Need and I am always hoping she'd release it one day. I just love the sound and lyrics so much 🩷 apparently Afterglow was supposed to have an Ariana grande feature? I think I heard that somewhere. I also LOVE I Think He Knows. I actually think Lover is a no skip album personally. Marc Maron did a standup bit where he talked about grieving and listening to midnights and he heard Bigger than the Whole Sky and fell on the ground it hit him so hard and he blacked out! it's absolutely hilarious, he's great, he paid to use the song and he even texted Jack about it. I hope you guys see it sometime.

sophia

oh my god YES peace is the best song i’ve ever heard. and its SO good to see someone saying that relates to the lyrics because i do from the very first moment that I heard it. something only the emotionally damaged girlies understand lol

Mandy BNE 🇦🇺

What do you mean the manuscript is not a song??? She could be singing a cappella and it would be a song! 😅 I love It so much as a piano player and classical music lover!

Sara Garrity

I feel similarly about the manuscript as I do about eldest daughter - the bridge to both songs are everything to me - but I don’t care for (don’t want to listen to) the rest of the song. But I’m glad both exist 🙂

McKenna

Emily I’m with you on the alchemy!! I cant with the metaphor and melody. My one and only skip on the main tortured poets album.

alex

This is why I will never be a peace stan. She gives Joe way too much credit

Barb 🔆

The Alchemy is so obvious to me. She and Travis word for word (although first verse I hear her singing right to me😉)

Cassidy

no it’s a masterpiece and one of her best.. and i’m dead serious

Cassidy

starlight forever

Linda

*ding* hello? 😂😂

Laura

1. Evermore 2. You are in love 3. Peace 4. Ours 5. The Alchemy 6. New Years Day 7. Afterglow 8. Untouchable 9. The Manuscript 10. Bigger than the whole sky 11. Starlight my ranking :)

Gemma

I adore the manuscript, makes me tear up all the time

Gemma

Afterglow is definitely rising in my lover rankings, been loving it the past couple of months

Chelsea Brown

Love these interpretations!! I also like to think about the Alchemy as a song about how falling in love again. True love is such a rare experience in our lifetimes, but it CAN happen more than once (in my opinion) and you know that feeling immediately. I completely agree there are TONS of Travis references and I think that's ultimately what the song ends up being about. But I also like the call back to "once in 20 lifetimes" in cardigan and the idea that her previous loves are her past lifetimes.

Aracely C

The alchemy is amazing! It’s Taylor Swifts “Like I Do” from Ariana’s Petal Album. To me it’s about her relationship with Travis helping her embrace her fame as a positive instead of a negative because it doesn’t matter to him (the bridge). It is a mirror/ sister to Miss Americana and The Heartbreak prince. It’s a metaphor about her relationship with the world while weaving through her relationship with her current partner. The Alchemy is elite!!

Gi

The manuscript is really like spoken poetry with beautiful piano behind it! That piano can be truly piercing but I agree it doesn't feel like a song. It's a different type of experience

Beth

Bigger than the whole sky is one of the most beautiful songs ever written 🩵 so glad you fathomed!!

Paweł

1 YAIL 2 NYD 3 AFTERGLOW 4 evermore 5 STARLIGHT 6 The Alchemy 7 untouchable 8 peace 9 BTTHS 10 The manuscript 11 ours

imgonnagetyouback

I feel like you have to listen to the whole album to listen to Manuscript lol İn a sense it is an ending to something bigger

Michaela

nothing in her entire discography makes my soul ascend the way the bridge of the manuscript does. THE PROFESSOR SAID TO WRITE WHAT YOU KNOW.

Anna

You are me, haha. I’m so hyped for Fall, this weather is a godsend

Ellie

I absolutely appreciate this video for You're in Love getting its flowers (this will one day be my first dance song, I swear) and for The Alchemy chat. I feel very validated by Emily so thank you

Foxy_Tatty

Emily, Ours was number 3 for me as well! Starlight was last, Bonnie 😝😂

Ashley

“So you’re putting Starlight below the manuscript?” 😂😂😂 I think the edits of female olympians running to their husbands (specifically one of the American track and field runners to her husband) made me fall in love with the Alchemy. It’s almost like when you see a music video for a song that wasn’t your favorite but having a visual makes it an infinitely better song

Amanda P

Couldn’t agree more!!! the “child’s play back in school” makes sense when you think of Travis as someone who also had a BIG reputation = football player, party guy, heartthrob, literally had a dating show at one point 😂 she decided to put that aside & trust his intentions = forgiven under my rules!! I kind of take it in the same way as “cancelled!” - I’ve been there before so I’m not going to judge you for it 🤍

Chloe Amelia

The Alchemy is just NOTTTT ITTTTTTT Emily I completely understand! Its not a bad song its just not it. I dont get it!!!!!

Val

Thankkkk youuuu Bonny for putting peace as number one and representing us, peace stans 🫶🏻 it's my number one favorite song by TS!!!

Linnéa Thunberg

My ranking: 1. Evermore 2. Ours 3. You are in love 4. Starlight 5. Untouchable 6. Afterglow 7. The alchemy 8. BTTHS 9. Peace 10. New years day 11. The manuscript

Shar

I feel the same way about the alchemy! I can’t really even put words as to why, but it doesn’t really make me feel what I think it is supposed to? Like sure it’s kinda fun, but I don’t know I’m just a bit stuck on what it’s about I guess? What’s going on here? I also don’t love the “heroin but this time with an e” lyric and that’s hard to ignore lol. Like I get what she’s saying I guess? But I also feel odd about it. Whole song just kinda feels off???

peachysxnrise

1. the manuscript (you girls are crazy for this) 2. nyd 3. yail 4. bttws 5. peace 6. evermore 7. afterglow 8. starlight 9. untouchable 10. ours (sorry em) 11. the alchemy (I'm with you em)

Katie J

For me, what gets lost in the debate about the muses is that The Alchemy is not entirely a love song; the main theme is actually self-empowerment and feeling like you're the best, similar to Bejeweled or I Think He Knows. Less how can this couple can fight their chemistry, more how can he resist the awesomeness that is Taylor Swift (very relatable). The song is about the euphoric confidence anyone can feel about a new or rekindled relationship, but also her being back on stage at the Eras tour and back on top of the music industry. The Alchemy is about someone who's winning in every area of life and isn't afraid to celebrate it. She's simply feeling herself, and the song revels in that confidence.

sammychandler

🤎evermore 💙bigger than the whole sky 🤍the alchemy 🖤the manuscript 🩶peace 🩷afterglow 🖤new years day 🩵you are in love 💜ours ❤️starlight 💛untouchable

Chevonne

HOW do you not understand the alchemy babe 😂 that was my song when i finally decided to date my best friend

Chevonne

emilys bottom 3 is my top 3 😆 bigger than the whole sky, the alchemy, starlight

Amanda Laura

I'm DEEPLY offended as Afterglow is my number 1 on this list and top 3 on Lover haha Evermore would be my second! Also I NEED NEED please

Samskie

Happy to see a Starlight Stan, it's one of my faves

Samskie

I feel the same about The Alchemy unfortunately - I just do not enjoy how it sounds and I have tried 🙃

Gabi (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-26 01:00 1. You are In Love 2. New Year's Day 3. Evermore 4. Untouchable 5. Afterglow 6. The Manuscript 7. Starlight 8. Bigger Than the Whole Sky 9. Peace 10. Ours 11. The Alchemy I'm with Bonny on this one, Speak Now may be my favorite of Taylor's albums but Ours does nothing for me LOL And related to what Emily said, the most overlooked line on New Year's Day is "I want your midnights BUT I'll be cleanin up bottles with you on New Year's Day." Whoever she wrote this song about, she not only had to hide their relationship from the public but was not even able to kiss them at midnight in front of her friends. This has always been a super heart wrenching song to me for that reason.
2026-09-23 15:11 1. You are In Love 2. New Year's Day 3. Evermore 4. Untouchable 5. Afterglow 6. The Manuscript 7. Starlight 8. Bigger Than the Whole Sky 9. Peace 10. Ours 11. The Alchemy I'm with Bonny on this one, Speak Now may be my favorite of Taylor's albums but Ours does nothing for me LOL

1. You are In Love 2. New Year's Day 3. Evermore 4. Untouchable 5. Afterglow 6. The Manuscript 7. Starlight 8. Bigger Than the Whole Sky 9. Peace 10. Ours 11. The Alchemy I'm with Bonny on this one, Speak Now may be my favorite of Taylor's albums but Ours does nothing for me LOL

ryles

the manuscript is the ttpd book closing. the painful chapter of her life is over and she’s choosing to get it all out and then leave it behind. i think it’s a song you’re meant to listen to enough to understand, and then put it away.

Rex

1. peace 2. New Year's Day 3. Untouchable 4. The Alchemy 5. evermore 6. Starlight 7. Bigger Than the Whole Sky 8. Ours 9. Afterglow 10. You're in Love 11. The Manuscript

Emzies

I’m with you all the way on The Alchemy, Emily. Gag me! It’s the melody, it’s the endless sports references, and (more importantly) it’s the way she chose to use “alchemy.” Dreadful! I’m also sharing that bombastic side eye you gave about Bonny ranking it over Ours.