Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

ITS US, HI, WE ARE THE PROBLEMMMMMMM because we couldn't stop talking about this album so we thought we would give you (Patreon) an extended version.... I have noooo idea if you want this or even care BUT its like an extra 45 min of us just talking and fathoming so its here if you want it haha LOVE YOU

Files

Comments

Jenna Bolmgren

In reference to Bejeweled, when she said, “I made you my world,” could that be in any reference to Justin Bieber’s My World? — his debut album that Scooter produced??

Hannah

the bridge reaction!!!! >3

CAM

OMG, I just fathomed something ILLEGAL... In YOYOK, she is "I played MY songs in the parking lot"... OMG 🤯 my being yes hers and only hers and fuck Scott I'm going to reclaim the land energy with that one stressed note (obviously this is a rewatch haha)

Tracy Peterson

Rewatching this and can I just say that Bonny’s face at the beginning of Midnight Rain was most of us the first time we heard it! Best WTF is happening right now face ever.

Jenny MacRunnel

Another rewatch for me! I love your guys reaction to this album, and my reactions were pretty similar!

Rachel Thompson

Omg rewatching this now and your comment about the music after king of my heart on RRP tour? And now realising maroon is possibly about joe???💀💀💀

Lizzy Grace

on rewatch for me, i've kinda fathomed some connections between the RED album and question...? like if jg had some outside-relationship connections, maybe the questions in the chorus are exposing how the relationship broke down over the course of those last month, like he hooked up with a girl in a club or something. and the "i remember" recall does sound like OOTW but also, in ATW she says "i remember" so MANY times!!

Christina

I think about your reaction to YOYOK every time I listen, it's now ingrained and I love it.

Jim Lent

I come back to this every month just to watch your reaction to "Your On Your Own, Kid." Magnificence!

Courtney Graham

I love re watching a re fathoming your guess opinions are so what I think of too and more!

💯

Ditto

Nicole McCormick

Crazy how the Sweet Nothing genius description was maybe correct.. 😳

Julia Guedes

still can’t believe they didn’t make the connection between “the one i was dancing with in NY no shoes” and “barefoot in the kitchen” from cornelia street

Courtney Schwarzbauer

I feel like this album needs a whole refathoming. Maybe even after TTPD comes out.

Nan

Oh my gosh, how did I ever miss this extended reaction of Midnights?! I'm SO EXCITED! And now I know how I can fill my time to try to stay awake tonight for the Sidney Tour Night 1 streams that begin at about 3AM my time, being that I'm here on the U.S. East Coast!!! Yay! ;)

💯

Whose on 4+ watches?!?

Naderge

me! this is my favorite reaction of theirs 🥹

Tess7

Giving this yet another watch while waiting on Tortured Poets- I remember my own first listen- I thought wow, the sound is so different but the lyrics are top tier. I find myself listening to Lavender Haze every time I’m in the car, it’s just my jam. I love this album

Clive

definitely, but it's aged like fine milk. listening to their "we love joe" fathomings. hits different now.

Mavi💖

I'm rewatching all the midnights videos while it's still the last brand new album we got 🥹 So many memories watching this!!!! Midnights is so superior 😭

💯

Rewatching! Love the apology in the beginning. As I gaze at the coachella pictures I do feel bad for engaging in the parasocial. Its just because we see ourselves in her, her ability to help us process our own pain, and hope the best for her! Love Em and Bonnie so much!!!

isabel

just rewatched!!! getting ready for ttpd and LOL at some of the *** content 🤭🤣

Charlotte Irene

Just rewatched this and now I need a post-TTPD re-fathoming of Midnights. There is much new information to ponder, giving us a whole new lens to look through!

Katie Walmsley

Bonny and Emily! Am fresh off your superior breakdown of “Guilty As Sin?” and then returned here. (1) When breaking down “Down Bad,” be sure to re-fathom the “meteor strike” line in “Question…?” 🫢 (2) I am wondering when she wrote “Question…?” and when she wrote “Guilty As Sin?” and am thinking it could have been around the same time…both tracks are full of questions 🫨

Edith Ferrufino

Okay, but her SS last week or a few weeks ago i don't even remember 🥺

Megan C

Listening to the girls read the Sweet Nothing Genius comments 💀💀💀

Laura Mowle

Sorry gotta have a girly moment…is it just me or is Bonny’s top really illegal?

Laura Mowle

Yeah that didn’t age well.

Emilia

Came back for the YOYOK-reaction!!!!! <3

Sonja

Just rewatched bc I woke up this morning and couldn‘t believe midnights exists. The Album concept to write songs about all the things that keep you up at night is so offensive, I‘m still im disbelief about how good this album is lol

Maya

Listening now I think she wrote midnights during a breakup/ on a break (best believe I'm still bejeweled! I want the penthouse of your heart - still wants Joe but could forget he exists when she meets someone new) and then getting back together (labyrinth "how'd you turn in right around", karma is my boyfriend, trying to see it in a positive light in "sweet nothing", he grounds her). And bejeweled, labyrinth, karma and sweet nothing is the exact order of songs..

Breezy Bumbles

Okay. So no one will see this probably because this is an older video but I am rewatching it now because it’s awesome! I feel uncomfortable even writing this because it’s absolutely NONE of my business and it’s so weird to speculate about this but Taylor has given us soooooo many hints about this that it’s not even subtle anymore. So………in All Too Well, Taylor said that the scarf was a metaphor and would not elaborate further. But in the song, she refers to the scarf as innocence. He can’t get rid of it because it’s not an actual scarf. It’s her “innocence”. Then in the video for I Bet You Think About Me, she literally “pops a cherry”. Then in Maroon, if we’re assuming it calls back to Red, she says the line, “the rubies that I gave up”. In the Bible it talks about a woman’s virtue (or virginity) being as precious as a ruby. So……..does this imply what I think it does? Also I absolutely am not trying to pry into Taylor’s most intimate details. I’m only trying to understand her lyrics and what they might mean and why the breakup with Jake was so devastating. Please don’t get mad at me!!!

Breezy Bumbles

Another random thought…in Vigilante Shit when she says “I don’t dress for villains or for INNOCENTS” reminds me of Innocent which is about Kanye.

Virginia

Refathoming, sweet nothing is a soft sweet diss track. Like he gave her nothing and he didn’t want her to be herself. She tells him she wrote a poem and he says, “ that’s nice, dear”. And this happens all the time?? Damn. That’s so sad. Like she thinks he’s a soft safe space until he turns into a cold castle.

Virginia

Refathoming again. I think Mastermind is about Matty Healy. 😬

💯

7 more song.... little did we know it be double that next time

Jess

Just CRIED watching you react to YOYOK it was so amazing

sierra

coming back to this bc what do you mean she gave us midnights 😭 so interesting to watch all this with hindsight too god NONE of us knew anything 😂

Ali ❤️‍🔥

Coming back to this and realizing that these chickens didn’t even know about the eras tour yet… HOW has time gone so fast

Jennie 🐍🖤

Re-watching in 2025. Genius on to something with sweet nothing lol

MJ

Omg I always thought the lyric was “I miss sparkleLAND” ✨

Cassy

in my midnights era today ✨ i’ve been so excited to get to midnights on my countdown to tloas and watch your midnights content! i’m really looking forward to more fathomings on this album. i love watching your first time reaction 💙. can’t believe you got to experience this album in paris !!!!! (and the fact you got paris in paris that’s crazy)

Cassy

having a huge fathoming over lavender haze being the first song you listen to where taylor describes wanting to stay in that love bubble she was feeling and then wrapping up the album by admitting to masterminding (new word) a relationship to even start and now you can see why it’s so important to her that she stays wrapped up in the love bubble because she created it!!! and she put in all this work to even make the relationship exist and now she’s feeling insecure about it and there’s all this outside noise that is just making it worse. you can see why it was so important to her to focus on the good of the relationship because she felt like she owed it to herself to make it work since she wanted it so bad in the first place

Agitated Afriyk

Here in November reminiscing haha Just had first snow today!

Caroline

we were so naive lol

Maggie Tallman

Rewatching in 2026 bc I was listening to antihero in the shower and holy shit this album is insanity illegal the best thing I’ve ever heard

Lynny Smith

🥲🥲🥲🥲 so happy right now

Ronan Jeynes

we will always accept an extended version !!!! 🖤🖤

Iga W.

We always want more! 💕

Kjersti

Aaaah we always want more!🎉🎉🎉

Mina Maras

wohoooo thank you! making my morning so much better

kienan

Omfg you two just hit the SLAY button!! I’m so excited about this :,) THANK YOU LOVES ♥️♥️

Shawn carni

I am so excited for this!

izzy

YAYAYAY IM SO EXCITED!!!!

Vilma

THANK YOUUUU🫶🏻🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼

Josh G

HONEY WAKE UP, NEW C&R PATREON POST!! 🥺💕✨

Laila

Oh I am so gonna watch this and push all the other life stuff away 😅😂😂 THANK YOU GIRLS 🫶🫶🫶

farah abed

YAYYYY THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU😭😭😭😩😩😩❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

Aubrey McMichael

bonny i would literally take the entire 8 hours of footage

Laila

Will you do a reaction of Anti-Hero ft. Bleachers? PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

Joe Weaver

Of course we're interested!!!

Josh G

LOVE Y’ALL MORE 💕

Goretti

I would watch the entire 6 hours you filmed gradly 💞

Moonlit Nomad

Hi there :) Was wondering if Selena’s single or maybe an upcoming album would be something y’all would react to? Selena being in the TSCU and all 👀

JC S

Can’t sleep (it’s 3 am!) and I am severely depressed right now. YOU BOTH HAVE APPEARED AT THE PERFECT TIME to lift my spirits. Thank you!!

Moonlit Nomad

Ooooo noooo you should react to Selena’s documentary :)

kienan

love you two LOTS!!! hope you’ve both been having a beautiful day

Renee aka ynotshsdow

Of course we want it lol is that even a question ? Wink wink

Wowzaceli

This is heaven 🤩 thank you so much!!❤️

Amalie Ø.

Yessssss! Give us everything!!!!!🤩🤩🤩 Just as much of a problem over here, hi! 🫶🏼

Cornelia

I was a third of the way through rewatching the original when this got posted… welp we’re starting from the beginning!! Also cannot stop giggling because Emily is full on deer in the head lights upon first fathom, while Bonny is just dying to already know all the lyrics so she can sing along.

Ana Joe 🌻

Amazing!!!!!!!!! Of course we want it! Love you guys!!!!

Fahmeen

We always want every version of everything you do LOL. Can’t wait to watch!

Victoria

Yay for this!!! Thank you lovelies

Vivi

Yes omg yes

Vivi

I didn't know this is what I was waiting for my whole life lol 😆

Emmie Kruger

Does anyone think of we were happy when listening to midnight rain?

Rachel Thompson

We want unedited 10 hour long footage please thanks x

mieke

love you, besties 💕💕💕

mieke

i think emily said that they will react tomorrow! :)

Pauli

you gals really do be out here making peoples days!!!! <3 <3 <3 and watching these feels like the watching the 2 halfs of my brain trying to comprehend the TS GENIUS 😂 loooooooveeeeeee

Jule

WE WILL NEVER EVER SAY NO TO AN EXTENDED VERSION. Thank you so much for uploading this, can't wait to watch this later 🙏💙✨

Jentallygirl

So cute!! 💜💎✨😻🫶

Andrea

God yes, finally someone who thinks the same :,)

CamilleC

Love how After lavender hase they feel called out for gossiping about her life and then Maroon came...🤣 Same !!

Yuli

NEEDED THIS

Patty Minor

This is the content I signed up for.

Katherine

OMG!!!! Yes!!! ♥️💗♥️💗♥️

S Conner

New Em quotes: Wait... wait... wait!!!!!! [One of them is called Paris] They are BANNED! (Pre-chorus ranking video)

Clara

I am just fathoming that this has been something of a side thing and now you are out here pumping out footage and cuts and reactions like nobody's business, and you guys have to understand that you have the best Patreon arrangement I have ever participated in. AND THAT's been the feeling the whole way, even when it might have been a super side thing that you felt you needed to commit more to. I am just so happy for you guys, you deserve this, and I am also so grateful for all of your effort.

MarkH

Thank you as always! Like everyone else, I confirm that yes, we want this! Since I never comment on Youtube because of my Internet paranoia, I'm glad to be able to comment on this here. You remember I was the one saying "OK, everybody, try to lower your expectations for Midnights; no one could ever match them". Well, obviously I was wrong about that! I do think, as you both said, that this album clearly reflects the processing she has had to go through in doing the re-recordings. But I also think it reflects her thinking about the fans and the music industry; she analyzed us and the business and gave us what we wanted and needed while completely taking over the charts. Given that attention she pays, I do wonder why she did not give Lana a verse--she knew we wanted that. Hope we find out why someday. I don't want to go on too long, but I did want to say that your original Bejeweled interpretation could easily be valid, as well as the Calvin and Joe interpretation. She is a master of double meanings, and it really could be both. Can't wait for the Anti-Hero featuring Bleachers reaction! I can just imagine her giggling as she released it anticipating your conniptions!

Jessica Barton

I love Taylor & respect her privacy—but she wouldn’t write such personal and detailed songs, like a song about how she cheated on her boyfriend and give the EXACT date, if she didn’t want us to gossip about her life. I think she wants privacy in her everyday life but i don’t think she minds if we dissect the meaning behind her music. She’s knows it’s part of the allure.

Shannon Gilhooly

I’ve watched your original cut so many times that i can too easily identify the new uncut bits 😂😂 love you girls!! 💜💜💜

CamilleC

Oh i agree i think she even likes it with the fans as long that it's stays respectfull. I think she really like fans like Bon &Em because they dissect the lyrics and music to understand the meaning

Tricia

I truly don’t know if anything will compare to seeing your reactions to learning there is a song called Paris🤣🥰

Lisa

Love the extra reaction material ladies! I love how Bonney, you pick up on all of the production straight away! And Emily, how you love the lyrical and your brain is just straight away working on the meaning and searching for the links. I mean I also see that you both live for both, but ... I just love the combo of your two together ... so much! The Anti-Hero reaction is so good! The bridge break down. Perfection! Taylor is such a gem for this Midnights serve! OFFENSIVE! So glad I'm here on Patreon! Do you guys think the next MV is going to be Maroon, I initially thought Lavender Haze but I think it's going to be Maroon. Who knows tho?! I can't wait to hear it!

Clara

Also, has anyone else gotten the impression that sweet nothing is about Taylor's mom...? It's just a question🤪

Jentallygirl

I’m obsessed with your gorgeous flowers btw!! 🌸🌸🌸

Richard

Hi will you be reacting to the remix of Anti Hero with the Bleachers? Really great.

Jaimie C

BEST 2 1/2 hours of my day!! 🤩 Thank you for for the extended cut....always love to hear more of you fathoming lyrics & production! OMG I can only imagine your extended breakdown videos!!!! (i'll be patient i swear) 💜

Hrishikesh Upadhyaya

What if that kiss you in a crowded room means the new year midnight when harry kissed taylor in the crowded street 😪😪🥲🥲

David B

the entire minute 54:00 is my new drug

Literally Natalie

SOMEHOW I LOVED THIS ONE EVEN MOOOOOORE!!! I love you guys!!!

Julia

I LOVED hearing more of your thoughts on Bejeweled! Thank you for giving us more of this reaction 💙

Samskie

Thank you for this!! Since the album came out i have also fathomed the Parer Rings / Bejeweled lyric parallel too about his friends been high the night that they first met / some guy said my aura's moonstone because he was high ....

Casey Kerrigan

LOVED IT!!! I was hoping to see you two, vlog style, eating a Paris Croissant in between midnights and 3am tracks haha! but alas SSSSuperior!! :)

Ally ❤️

Omg!!! I love Patreon 🔥🔥🔥🔥

Brooke Penniman

thank you for all the content!!! I can't get enough and appreciate it all!

chatsandreacts

YES! We will be reacting, and think we will make it a Youtube video :)

chatsandreacts

We have already watched it and by default heard the song at the end :( sorry bestie! It's been such a busy time, we figured it might just be best to stick with the Midnights content for a few more weeks!

chatsandreacts

Sending you so much love and I hope this video could help you feel just a little better! Thinking of you xx

chatsandreacts

HAHAHA perfect timing! You're right, that's always our reactions, Bonny dances and I literally cannot fathom whats happening and just have to sit and absorb lmao

chatsandreacts

I have seen a few people say this! There's been so much debate over who its about. Tom, Taylor Lautner, Connor Kennedy, the We Were Happy guy, the guy from the first verse of YOYOK, Drew, ahhhhhh!

Moonlit Nomad

So true, Taylor IS feeding us at the moment

chatsandreacts

hahahah we just can't help it! I agree with Jessica, as much as I don't want our reactions to be all about her personal life or anything (because there is so much more to her music than who it is about!!!) I do think sometimes she includes songs and details exactly for the purpose of speculation. I mean, in some ways that's what got her to where she is in the first place, and she knows that we all love to link back new lyrics to past lyrics and people :)

chatsandreacts

Clara this means so much!! We definitely have a lot more time these days to put into this, thanks entirely to you guys here on Patreon, and it's really special to hear that you enjoy what we're doing on here with the additional content. Thanks so much for your support always xx

Marie S.

ladies.... we would literally watch you do anythingggg haha

chatsandreacts

Hi Mark!! Awww, I never knew you felt anxious to comment on Youtube, but I am so happy you feel comfortable to do so here!! We always love your commentary :) You are totally right about her also doing this album for the fans as well as for her own processing recently. I think this is why the album has been so successful. It's a perfect means of seeing where she's at today after re-recording, but it also feels like it was made for us diehard fans to dissect, all the throwbacks to older songs and stories, it really is a perfect album for people who love Taylor Swift lore!

chatsandreacts

Hahaha I also don't think we could ever experience such a weird coincidence again in our lives and capture it on camera. Then again, weird timing stuff continues to happen with us and Taylor, so who knows!

chatsandreacts

Yes we will, Richard! I think we will upload the reaction to Youtube :)

chatsandreacts

We had fully intended on doing croissant style mukbang for this reaction and honestly just COMPLETELY forgot when we woke up, we were so consumed with excitement and overwhelm for the album, food did not cross my mind hahahah

Richard

Ok that's great. Can't wait.

JC S

Thank you.

Lauren Levitt

I’m sorry but just like how the 3am edition the superior version of midnights, this extend addition is the superior Chats and Reacts midnights video! So much fathoming!!!

Joe Weaver

You all are OK, I guess...😂🥰

Joe Weaver

It's amazing. We're so spoiled now. But it's a wonderful thing.

Alandra

I loved this reaction so much! I just can’t get enough of your fathoming! Especially since in the YouTube version you had cut most of the talk about Jake out of Maroon and I completely didn’t even make that connection.

Lycinda Rodriguez

Best way to spend an evening 💙 I’ll watch anything with you two in it. I laugh with you, I groove with you, I fathom with you, and I just experience so much joy ☺️

Trish Proper

Watching you two again and love it even more! Hoping To get tickets to Glendale, AZ opening or the Tampa, FL shows next week!! Can’t wait to hear what mashups She does! Keep it up - we. Love watching you❤️❤️❤️

Whitney

The answer is always yes - we always want more Bonny & Em!

LanaJulie33

I loved every second of this! And to echo the shared sentiment, the answer is always "yes, please give us more of it" I cannot wait for the album breakdown 😆🤍🙌

Clash Fan

I thought of "that's the way I loved you actually". It has such a similar theme. I'm convinced that song is about Fearless era as well because, hello? rain. It was the main theme of Fearless almost every song had some kind of reference to rain it.

tasneem

I always thought with anti hero she was saying like how she's always so willing to root for some of the worst characters and give them a chance despite all of the harm they have caused but when it comes to her she's the harshest critic. "I'll stare directly at the sun, but never in the mirror"

Gary

I had similar thoughts as you two when I first heard Midnight Rain, thinking Tom, but after fathoming it for a while, it makes me think it could be referencing the boy she talked about in We Were Happy on Fearless. She mentions the night/darkness several times, marriage, that she was at fault, and then of course rain was a huge thing on Fearless as a whole. "I wanted that pain" also could confirm the link from that song to The Way I Loved You (which, btw, randomly has a clock as the background on its official lyric video). To me it fits better than Tom, especially for "making my own name" and "chasing that fame" since she was already more famous than him at the time of their relationship. Just some random 3am thoughts I thought I'd share while watching this reaction for the 3rd time 😂

Leilani Willcox

I enjoyed this soo much! Fathoming Midnights more and more each time, and I loved listening to it again with you! Also just fathoming how Taylor's earlier music was often about waiting and hoping for the fairytale Love Story (which is how women are often shown in movies) and now Mastermind is so self empowering and it's beautiful to see the growth and perspective shift! It's so much fun being here and fathoming with you guys :)

Georgia Thompson-Chase

When she says in midnight rain ‘and he never thinks of me, except when I’m on TV’ I feel like that could be 1. The obvious, when she’s on television but 2. TV - Taylor’s Version Like he never thinks of me, until I re record my old album that is about him, then he’ll be thinking of me again when that’s all re released! I don’t know, might be a stretch but I feel like it could have a double meaning!

Nin Reckermann

I just thought what if she brings Joe on stage for Sweet Nothing and he plays piano and then in that end part where there's two voices kind of overlapping it's a duet - I literally have tears in my eyes

Hunter Kuehn

Thank you both! I've given you a few dozen YouTube views, but I didn't fathom a vault release for this reaction. All 2 hours is offensive and superior. Maroon, Midnight Rain, Labrynth, and Mastermind stand out but this album is frigging superior.

Daniela

Dare I say 🤭 I liked this one better lol. You guys feed your Patreon peeps so much better!!!!! Thank you!!!

Victória Martins

I haven't seen anyone touch on this, but the first time I heard "in the shoes I gave you as a present", my mind immediately went to frightful adam and this is what she came for!! The whole song feels its about a boyfriend that took her for granted

Maria Carmen

This is my evening plan, I CAN'T WAIT TO WATCH! Thanks for keeping us fed besties. So grateful for you 😘 and on a side note, this Patreon community feels so intimate and comforting and it's really nice to have this space beyond YT!

Maria Carmen

So interesting Georgia!! great insight

Rachel Thompson

I have a feeling the edited voice is Joe. Just saying. Imagine how superior them singing labyrinth together would be “i’m falling in love”. I would die.

Joseph Lorraine

I agree that it’s probably about a pre-fame boy, but I like to think it’s Taylor Lautner, because if she was his bride she would literally no longer have “her own name” (as actually happened IRL with his actual wife LOL)

Arcel Espinosa

i know this is a long shot request but have you considered reacting to Norman Fucking Rockwell AKA Lana's best work of art? 🥺

Juicy Dragon

Ok listen...I'm throwing out a guarantee - that every single person to have seen this reaction video, specifically for Karma, does the side to side cat paws during the chorus. Not recommended while driving.

Marissa

All the extra fathoming is my favorite!!!

Katie

Immediately need a gif of Bonnie and Em's reaction to the "You're On Your Own, Kid" bridge

Roger Anderson

I am SO GLAD you were able to do this together in Paris. And I am thrilled to have contributed to it. What fun to watch you two losing your minds. I was right there with you.

Terry Cassar

Hey fellow Chats and reacts , Bonny and Emily, and Taylor Switf fans! I'm looking for a place to get out an idea and need your help. And while I'm sure I'm not the only one with this idea, I've not seen anyone bring this up, so I'm hoping with your help maybe we can get this out into the TS universe! With the recent disaster with TM handling of the Earas tour I think one solution to the problem would be for TS to do a Streaming concert where we can buy tickets and be able to see her in concert! Imagine the streaming parties her fans could have and we would All be able to see her in concert! Anyway, If anyone likes this idea please do what you can to push this out into the Universe and hopefully some one brings this to actually happen! Thanks for any help and as always thank you Chats and Reacts for all the awesomeness you do!

Ally ❤️

Watching again!!! Thank you queens 👑👑

devin dear

Still by far my favorite video reaction to midnights!