Home
Creators
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

SECRET SONGS Reaction: Houston, TX (Night 3) (Patreon)

Published:
2023-04-24 07:08:21
Imported:
2026-09
Tags:

Content

HOPE YOU ENJOY THE LAST OF THE HOUSTON REACTIONS BESTIES!

Comments

Hannah

Girls can you react to Boygenius The Record !!!

Dhanushi P

yesss was waiting for this!

kienan

I was so sure you had Cold As You down for your predictions this weekend… the implications of her surprise song choices. It’s too much for the heart actually!

Krystal

yay my morning treat is here! :)

kienan

Also did you guys see the tweet about how the songs for night 2 may have been a nod to the music video she filmed a few weeks ago?? A Place in this World was in a Joey King film and Today Was a Fairytale was in a Taylor Lautner film… interestinggggg

lexy

slay!!!

Brandon N

She burns the lover house with the lighter she holds on the midnights cover!!!

gaysofspades

GUYS. GUYS. GUYS. You know how in the Intro of rep you hear the boots clacking on the ground and there are some weird sounds. IF YOU REVERSE IT SHE SAYS "SPEAK NOW". Im not kidding

Aloha Record Sargent

Yay! I stayed up waiting for this (it's just after *midnight* in my time zone)

Farah Canicosa

well I've never seen a footage of joe say even her name "taylor" or even in print he never explicitly referred to her. :-( so it's not really far from the idea that if she "died" for him he wouldn't tell anyone.

Dhanushi P

I LOVE DOROTHEA hahaha

Dallas

These surprise songs are too much 💔 feels like the hunger games till my show in July 😩

Lea

Noooo I LOVE Dorothea!!!!🙌🙌

sammi snyder

i am a dorothea stan PLEASEEE

Lara James

As soon as I heard Begin Again I thought of how Emily and Emily’s Dad were going to react to this news

chatsandreacts

VBDHJLEFBVFESKUGEJKFBEJESEWJKWE IM DYING THAT YOU REMEMBERED THAT MY DAD IS A STAN

gaysofspades

I did a screen recording of it and put it in reverse. She literally says speak now ... I don't know what to do with my life anymore

urvi

Dorothea stan reporting for duty 🫡

Sam

Remember that by the time we get international shows we might have a tonne more vault tracks for her to perform! I may simply evaporate if I happened to get a 1989 vault track at a show I was in attendance for

chatsandreacts

OMG!! i'm going to need you to send this on discord or something!!

gaysofspades

I sent you guys an instagram dm like 10 minutes ago. @arthur.gtmn on insta. Im freaking out. I haven't seen anyone talk about this yet

Natalie

Yesssss! Such a great album

Sam

Deeply concerning

Emma

YES DOROTHEA!

Mackenzie

i'm going to the next show and i'm going to simply pass away!!! also i can't fathom not staying up until 2am for your reaction to the surprise songs

Shannon

cold as you hidden message is - time to let go

Silke Huybrechts

What if she sings London Boy in London, just as an ode to the city and kind of making it about the fans, like she did with The Great War?

Philippa

Silly pookie still got the key of cold as you wrong but we still stan the debut love regardless 😂😂😭😭

Emma

Dorthea Stan here 😙😙😙

Sofia

dorothea STAN right here!!

Helen Dunham

We might get Back to December on July 1st in Cincinnati because of the Swiftie campaign running for the fan that passed away. I need international dates immediately!!!

Fahmeen

Wait I’m a dorothea stan always!!!

The Penguin

Ever since the 1 replaced Invisible String all her surprise songs have been break up related the weekend she did DBATC and Clean. Even in the set list of lover she only has one love song

Lara James

Cutest detail ever given 🥹

Vera

I predicted Cold As You for this show 😭😍😭

Fahmeen

I think I’m the only one that loves inthaf 💀

Silke Huybrechts

Also love Dorothea! It’s such a cute song 🥺

Taylah Louise

But if she is doing midnights multiple times as secret songs, that will limit the total capacity she has to complete her discography!

Jessie

Taylor does one strum - E&B 👀 👀 👀

Aloha Record Sargent

I totally agree about the "die for you" lyric parallel to Peace, but could she also be singing Cold As You to Scott Borchetta here? "And when you take, you take the very best of me" "Oh, what a shame, what a rainy ending given to a perfect day" "And you come away with a great little story of a mess of a dreamer with the nerve to adore you" "Every smile you fake is so condescending, counting all the scars you made" =Scott vibes???

Krystal

dorothea stan reportin! I manifest Ivy and Maroon for you guys :)

Petra

I agree, and Paris in Paris!

msjackyx

!!! Can you send it to me too please? 😭 @msjackyx

mieke

i‘m a dorothea stan!!

Shona Marks

Do you think it is a response to the photo of Joe on scooter 🤔

steph

dorothea and the lakes on the same night (melbourne pls) would kill me

Zoe

I am so desperate for international dates I am literally dreaming about being at shows.. Plzzz Taylor. Love these reactions, I actually stay of social media until I watch these so I can be surprised with you!

Maya

oh dorothea is my never skip song!! Love it

msjackyx

I haven’t been feeling well today but really wanted to watch your reaction to todays songs! So happy I stayed up!! Also love seeing all the Dorothea Stan’s! Ever since I hear it I fell in love with it! It might have been the one I played the most tied in with Ivy and Right Where You Left Me and Willow 💖💖💖💖

Shona Marks

I love Dorothea ❤️ 😍

Hannah Gilliland

I was at Arlington N1&3 and so sad she didn’t play it bc selena

Hannah Gilliland

I am going 4/29 & begging for high infidelity… what could be the second surprise song tho?

em ⊹˚. ♡

Cold as you sounds incredible in her more mature voice 🥲❤️

Marianne

Yess Dorothea stans!! Superior taste 🤎

Jenny M

I am gonna go insane over the surprise songs, they are simply too much to handle. I also hope she comes to Canada, she has not been here at least 10 years ago, cause i saw her in the Red Era.

kienan

Just read that this was only the second time she has ever performed Cold As You. And paired with Begin Again… it’s much too much

Rose Ellen

Immediately here to say that I am a massive dorothea stan!

Katja S.

In this moment and time, my hunch is: no.

Katja S.

The way she pretty much screamed “HE NEVER DIIIIIIIIID” 😱😱😱

Cole Jones

Fellow dorothea stan here 🙋🏻‍♂️

Maria Carmen

I LOVE Dorothea, it's a boooooop 💛🥰 Also, can I just say when she changed the "He never diiid" I died a little, omg! And Cold as you with her mature vocals?!? Absolutely offensive!

aubrey

I was watching a tiktok live last night of just a girl playing hangman with Taylor swift song titles and the only one I stayed on for was cold as you. I hadn’t heard it before so I was like wow what a coincidence that she played it tonight!

MarkH

Wow, she really went old-school this weekend. That is one way to avoid singing the Joe songs--do songs she wrote before she met him. Don't forget we also get The Alcott on April 28th, so it will be a big weekend. Its a lot that she said Cold as You was the best song on debut. I'm not sure that I agree, actually. Our Song, TTWAS, Mary's Song, Picture to Burn, Should've Said No are all great.

Nele

her vocals are killing meeeeee 😩🥰

Tracy Peterson

I’ll be at the same show as you two and I’d be down for Ivy and Dorothea or Long Live or really anything on your list so we can all manifest it together.

Julieta

it's time she comes to south america

Anna Miotello

Yes, I am convinced she will save London Boy for the London shows. Also The Lakes could be a UK secret song.

Jana Zielbauer

Dorothea stan all the way, his view on the giiiirl, I can’t 🥹

Silke Huybrechts

Paris in Paris would be sooooo good! She simply has to!

Ashley Wright

I LOVE Dorethea!! I Stan it with you! Thanks girls- best weekend treats ever!

Brittany Halvorsen

Dorothea is such an underrated clever, catchy, bop of a song! Such good vibes from this ICONIC made-up man 🥹 I think it gets compared to Betty too much and that may be part of why people don’t stan it with us. But I love this unselfish male point of view(I’m assuming from vibes), “I’ll love you forever” kind of song!!

Lively_Ash

Dorothea is a BOP!!! Such a jam! I would love I Did Something Bad acoustic, piano ME!, The Alcott on the 28, High Infidelity 29, but honestly, again, whatever she plays I will die…I stab her forever & I LOVE this attitude she’s had performing!!🫶💛 She only gets better! She has no peak! She’s on a whole other level!!

Katie K

Dorothea Stan here!! 🙋🏼‍♀️ This weekend I’ve been waking up (UK girly) and reacting to the secret songs with you two before I look at Tik Tok or IG and it is such a FUN way of finding out and fathoming with you! Loving all the content as always girls, thank you for all the joy you bring ✨🫶🏻✨

Sam Briggs

Fellow Dorothea stan 🙋🏻‍♀️ would absolutely die if she plays it in Chicago

Mina Maras

I ADORE you guys! Watching your reaction to Journey to Fearless and wondering could you maybe react to the live stream of the announcement of Speak Now? I vividly remember watching it in 2009 haha, it's a low-quality video but Taylor basically does fan-asked Q&A for about 40 minutes.

Stephanie

Dorothea is my no.1 on evermore, if you get it, you GET IT! so iconic 🤎

Alicia Bowie

DOROTHEA STANNNN 🙋🏼‍♀️🙋🏼‍♀️🙋🏼‍♀️

CK

🙋🏻‍♀️

Lynny Smith

🙋🏼‍♀️ Dorothea Stan!!

Staci DaSilva

I am a Dorothea stan!!! I went to Tampa night 1 and Dorothea was one of my dream songs. My friend thought I was crazy. It would sound so beautiful on the piano!!

Timothy

DOROTHEA STAN HERE 🖐️🖐️🖐️

Michelle Reis

I love Dorothea, it’s just so little song i want to keep for myself, because a lot of people do not appreciate it

dimple

We appreciate the contents bestie but ok, where's the chicken merch???

James

Jump Then Fall? Speak Now? Today Was A Fairytale?

The Penguin

Should’ve said most, but none have been recent love songs from rep forward

Eliza

maybe theres no rep songs coz of joee and the met gala coming up and stuff all very personalllll

Anjie Crow

I look forward to these so much! I stopped checking social media in the morning to see what the surprise songs were since I much prefer watching your videos and being surprised right along with you. Thank you for doing this!

Jasna

I feel that she does relate to both of this songs ... connected to Joe. It's a lot of energy going on from her, that it could be ...

James

I was teasing someone I know that missed YOYOK by one show and so they said "Well I hope you get Dorothea" and I was like THANK YOU!! I love Dorothea! I would honestly take any track from Evermore as a secret song, I love them all. My show is April 29 and I seriously cannot wait!

Natalie Buckner

I cannot believe I’m just now finding out you’re both Dorothea stans😭😭😭 it’s one of my absolute favorites. It’s such a happy song with a sweet message and “you know you always know me” is just magical writing

The Renn Domino Experiment

I'm not familiar with most of the songs from her first three albums, but the secret songs she has played from these albums are beautiful. I must take the time to listen to these albums.

Lauren

I’m devastated to lose Cold as You 😭

Alyssa Kay

Love Dorthea! If I had to pick at least one song from each album I would want as the secret song for the concert I'm going to it would be: The Outside, The Way I Loved You, Long Live, Come Back Be Here or Better Man, Out of the Woods or This Love, New Years Day, Cornelia Street, The Lakes, Right Where You Left Me, YOYOK or Would've Could've Should've

Michelle Lela

I was there in Arlington when she changed the set list. She also played Sad Beautiful Tragic(my absolute favorite ), it was such an energy.

Laura Kirby

I was there last night and it was the best night of my life! I made eye contact with TAYLOR ALISON SWIFT. The whole time she was playing Cold As You, I was thinking how Joe use to be warm, golden daylight for her and now he’s the coldest place she’s ever been. Heartbreaking.

Hannah

I’m the BIGGEST Dorothea Stan!!!

michelle stuart

Don’t forget she hadn’t announced Canada either !! Probably will be Toronto

subtle reads

Part of me thinks that she won’t ever play Would’ve, Could’ve, Should’ve because it might still be too painful and too fresh. Kind of like how she hasn’t played Dear John live since the Speak Now tour for the same reason 😢

Candy

Fierce is the perfect word!

Candy

Bonny, you are astounding the way you can name a tune with one guitar strum.

Alice

It’s absolutely amazing that Taylor wrote these songs as a teenager, not having experienced as much life and not knowing how deep the meaning could become and how much she may relate to them later in life as a 33 year old woman.

Katie LaFave

I don't think we should assume that every sad song she does has to do with Joe. Like it's fully possible that she was re-recording debut & realized that "cold as you" is the best song on debut because that's what she said

Alice

She could perform London boy in London!

tasneem

Because I’m a dorothea stan does it cancel out the fact that I’m not a how you get the girl stan

Alice

I think Taylor has 218 songs or something like that, she plays 44 songs on the regular set list, then 2x51=102 secret songs in the US, that leaves us with 72 other songs for international dates, or 36 shows if she really was planning to play every single song once originally.

Natalie Lyddane

hoping we get more street style taylor during the week to tide me over

Jaimie C

i absolutely LOOOOVVVVVVE dorothea!!! i would die if Aaron came back out and played those keys while she sang

Hannah S

I think we’re only getting London Boy if tour goes to London. That way she can make it not about Joe but about loving the English as in her fans.

Sarah LaForce

I named my cat in Stardew Dorothea, such a great song

lexy

slay <3

✨glitterfox✨

I think she said this before, that Cold as You is her favourite from Debut.

mya brown

DOROTHEA STANS RISEEEEE

Katryna Schuster

I'm definitely a Dorothea Stan!!! And I really hope she has some shows in Canada!!!

carxleigh

NO I AM THE MOOOSTTTT unwell with these particular surprise songs I CAN:T. I'm a wreck rn. cold as you means everything to me I can't stop crying~!!!

Chelsea

I’m going twice this weekend!! Send good vibes for Untouchable or New Romantics! ♥️♥️

Shanna gershman

This is the best part of MY DAY - thank you!!!

maddy

dorothea stans RISE!!!!!

Maria Gabriela

as a european swiftie i hope she reserves songs from lover such as london boy for international dates. i am also fine with the monologue song tho :D

Tara S

"what a rainy ending given to a perfect day" is such a fitting metaphor for the end of their relationship :(

Maria Gabriela

I am also a big dorothea stan and in general evermore. just recently realized how insanely good coney island is too. i love forgetting about a song's existence and then rediscovering how superior they are <3 the surprise songs are really helping with that

Maggie Tindall

UHM DORTHEA STAN OVER HERE - it’s on my secret songs list - hope she plays in Atlanta this weekend

Ileana Isabel

I LOVE DOROTHEA!!!! She's so cute and light and such a breath of fresh air after happiness, too! 🙈 Ps. Not me hoping you would include latin america in your international show predictions lol 🥲🥲🥲🥲🥲

Elizabeth Drake

I'm gonna be there on April 29th I CANNOT WAIIIIIT

Ria Shay

🙋🏽‍♀️🙋🏽‍♀️🙋🏽‍♀️

Ria Shay

my car is named dorothea

Ava Jeffs

Cold as you: And I know you wouldn't have told nobody if I died, died for you —> peace: but I would die for you in secret JAW ON THE FLOOR

Meech

Only the second time she’s performed Cold As You live (apparently) and I was their live 😭💚🙌🏻

Vanessa

I was thinking that maybe she is angry now because maybe they exchanged words about the public's reaction about the break up. So maybe he said something that just pissed her off 🤷

Joe Weaver

I'd think at least Toronto & Vancouver to hit both sides of the country. Maybe one more in between? Montreal? Who knows!

Joe Weaver

I think she'll reset for the international dates. She can't be saving superior songs like that.

Isabella Verduga

Pls if she doesn’t come to South America I will cry

Henry Sidford

The vocals of these surprise songs are mind blowing

Henry Sidford

We are not ready for the Taylor's Versions

Ava Jeffs

cold as you feels so hoax coded now

Ava Jeffs

"he always said he didn't get this song but I do" might be one of my top taylor swift lyrics of all time...begin again is deeply underrated

sam funk!

i LOVE dorothea... but i desperately NEED ivy

Ava Jeffs

"Of a mess of a dreamer with the nerve to adore you" reminds me so much of j*hn

Ava Jeffs

immediately need a list of all her "best" songs on each album excuse me Dr. Swift

Maggie

PROUD DOROTHEA STAN

Breejmc

Dorothea Stan 🙋🏻‍♀️

Sam

okay the crazy thing about her singing cold as you is that the secret message in the album booklet is "time to let go"... something to fathom??

Jenny MacRunnel

Begin Again is my 2nd fave song ever! (All Too Well 10 is #1) It was gorgeous and absolutely perfect.

Allee

OMG IM A DOROTHEA STAN! manifesting she’ll play it at one of my nashville shows🤞🏻

Belle Murray

Maybe she'll perform "London Boy" in London when she goes there! Another Joe song that is for the fans now :')

Miriam Hart

July 29th is my wedding date and don’t tell my fiancé but there is a high possibility I will be thinking about you two and Taylor at the Eras Tour during my reception or something 😂

Jade

“If you’re ever tired of being known for who you know, you know you’ll always know me” what do you mean OF COURSE we stan Dorothea !!!

Jaden

Omg I am joining y’all as a third member of the Dorothea stans along with anyone else here bc that song is offensive and nobody understands and that’s fine because Dorothea is our song ( ;) ) and no one else can have it

RuthGA

wasn't the secret message in Cold As You "time to let go"? I can't quite remember and unfortunately my original CD was lost when I moved so I can't check.

Tatyana

PROUD DOROTHEA STAN

Maggiemayyy

I love dorthea!! but my fav Debut song is Marys song and i feel like no one stans that but me ha

Lisa Briley

no i get it i LOVEEE mary's song!!!

Kenzy Moore

Dorothea stans rise up!!! It’s in my top 10 😭

Maggiemayyy

No she said she can repeat any midnights songs

Kristen

🙋‍♀️ dorothea stan’s rise!!! also, losing cold as you was devastating for me. but i am still hoping for tied together with a smile!

Katie

Dorothea forever

Emzies

🙋🏻‍♀️ Dorothea

Aracely C

“Oh what a shame, what a rainy ending given to a perfect day” . . . Daylight? 👀

Aracely C

Yes!!! I love Mary’s song too! It’s between Cold As You and Mary’s Song for fave!

Nele

Absolutely a Dorothea stan. The electric guitar? The ohh-melodies? Her lower register? Offensive. Also, I loved the seperate videos for each night!

Nele

I think she said something similar about my tears ricochet somewhere 🤔

Nele

And for Red it has to be All too well 10

angel (plnkblue)

A bit of a positive spin on her potentially relating to Cold As You in regards to Joe: you touched on "you wouldn't have told nobody if I died for you" vs "I'd die for you in secret," but I'm also thinking about "I've never been anywhere cold as you" vs "I'm a fire and I'll keep your brittle heart warm when your cascade ocean wave blues come." The original context of Cold As You is regarding a breakup in a negative light, where she's the one who's been hurt, but we know the context and relatability of her songs have shifted for her over time, and perhaps the lyrical parallels here make that "cold" into a positive thing. I've never been anywhere cold as you, and I loved being there.

angel (plnkblue)

There was a balance and stability between our elements that has now begun to shift with separation (sorry i cant edit my og comment on mobile to add this thought for some reason shkdhd)

Kira Wise

Dorothea is my all time fave Taylor song!

Will McNally

Bonnie I'm sorry but she's saving 7 and the Lakes for the London show I will be attending, sorry about that

Anna B

I love Mary's song too!

MORRO Q

Justice for Dorothea

Miriam

Dorothea STAN here 🤩

Kristina Key

I’ll be at the Atlanta show on the 28th on the field AND I AM SO EXCITED. I can’t wait to find out my secret songs!!

Sarah Valerio

We are all giving her our weekends. 😭

Ida

BIG DOROTHEA STAN HERE, but i got mean on my show so i can’t complain:’)

Courtney A

I wish she'd come out and be like "I was wondering how y'all would feel about me playing an unreleased song (crowd screams)" and she's like "Ok great. This is I'd Lie". I would evaporate!!!!!!

Sam

She would also be VERY well aware that everyone would be hyper analysing these secret songs post break-up. She would make them chaotic and random if she wanted them to not mean anything. She is 1000% sending a message.

Brittany DeLara

You know what I really want? The Last Time with a Lightbody appearance. People sleep too hard on that song. It’s like number 3 for me on Red.

Daphne

Dorothea stan here!!!

Austin Lay

You all should do an updated songs ranking battle with Midnights. I think that’s the name of that. Where you pick between two songs.

Alice

Omg the Alcott is SO FUCKING BEAUTIFUL I teared up the first time I heard it. Can’t wait to see your reactions!!!!!

Alice

Have you guys ever seen the music video for Both of Us by B.O.B ft Taylor? I loved the series when you guys were watching the music video from each era, and hopefully you’ll get back to that after this leg of the eras tour is done. And would love to see you guys watch/breakdown songs and music videos that are not on Taylor’s albums. There are so many good ones!!

Jamie Speese

A friend of mine is going to see Taylor this weekend in ATL, her dad works at the venue and he told her she was sound-checking Maroon last night. That’s myyyyyyy song. I’m going next week. I’m going to be so sad if she plays it

KCK

Dorothea is Tis the Damn Season sister song - how could we not love it?!?! especially Tay’s low vocal register - like honey!

Mimo

Dorothea is a superior song 🤭✨

Cinetati

I still cannot cope with missing Begin again </3

Amanda Watts

This was my show!!! My video of cold as you is SO GOOD bc I didn’t sing in the background HAHAH and recorded the whole thing but I hope you girls can hear her voice because WOW, that performance was insane! Her voice has matured so beautifully!!

Hayden Brice

here forever late but absolutely a dorothea stan - its so good

Lauren Compasso-Yoder

I’m very behind and catching up on videos but I had to drop in these comments to say that I, too, am a Dorothea stan….especially with the connection to Tis The Damn Season. It’s just TOO GOOD 😍

Katie

I’m very VERY behind lol but i just need to agree Dorothea is a cold hard classic

Jules

Just joined this Patreon and Catching up on videos and reliving the tour from this past year. I am sooo looking forward to Cold as You TV!! This is one of my favorite surprise song performances from 2023.

San

Been watching y'all on YouTube since folklore reaction era 😭😭 always wanted to support your Patreon and now I'm in uni and financially stable enough to do it. Just catching up with videos 🥹

Jaana

Watching these reactions a year after the tour started is one of the best things I’ve ever done. Also knowing the songs you got in Australia is killiiiiing me 💀

Emma

Begin again was one of the first songs I truly fell in love with

emma 🌷

this aged so sweetly after your eras shows 🥲🥲🙂‍↕️🩷🩷

Corey

Going back through all these reactions because I joined in after TTPD. And I wonder if this is when her and Matty started up again because 2 weeks after this is when they were spotted kissing.

Becky Tucker

My god being a part of this community and having these videos to go back to is a TREASURE TROVE… it’s a time capsule of the Eras Tour….. I can’t believe the gift you’ve given us here…. You guys have a magic that is unmatched 🫶🏻🩷🫶🏻🩷🫶🏻🩷🫶🏻

WestonMacMom

I love how the 1sr one y’all are like maybe we’ll keep doing these and now I can’t imagine you not! 😭

Deborah

You got so so many of the surprise songs you hoped for over the course of the tour!!

pearcemcmahon13

the fact that you guys talk about WCS in this video and then y'all get it...manifested

brenda 🌸

OKAY now with hindsight this was straight after the break up — she sang Begin Again (for matty situation) and Cold as You (situation w Joe) and with all the info we have now we know she was DEFINITELY relating to the lyrics of Cold as You like in the slammer vibes, i hate it here omgmgmgmm

McKenna

little do these chickens know they would be getting london boy

Emelie

And would’ve could’ve should’ve and Ivy!! Nevermind they’re saying so many the like and they ended up getting SO MANY of them!

Stacey

Dorothea........my only skip on Evermore.

JC

Don’t worry chickens you get London Boy, Would’ve Could’ve Should’ve, Ivy, Maroon AND All of the Girls in front of your eyeballs!!!