Home
Creators
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

SECRET SONGS Reaction: Foxborough, MA Shows (Patreon)

Published:
2023-05-22 06:53:02
Imported:
2026-09
Tags:

Content

WE ARE BACK and we missed you!! This video is for Secret Songs on all nights this weekend - 1, 2 and 3!

Files

Comments

Lea

Not gonna spoil it for anyone but I canNOT believe night 1!! Can‘t wait to see your reaction❤️

Laura Wylie

Been waiting for this one. So excited to watch

Sivan Moshe

CANNOT WAIT!!! MISSED YOU ❤️💜❤️💜

Josh G

LETS GOOO I LOVE CHATTING AND REACTING❤️🥰🕺💃

Zoe

I see the TBH merch!!! 🧡

Ava Joyce

just got off work (it’s 3am) and i will be staying up til 4 apparently! missed y’all this weekend 💜

Bea

Waiting for this the whole Weekend 😊

Jenny M

You two connecting Invisible and You Belong With Me was to much.

Inigo joaquin

Just a suggestion that i thought of, if possible if you guys still have the footage you guys should post the full footage of album reactions from youtube here on patreon😎 aka sour, superache, stuff like that. Ik yall basically post the whole thing anyway but i just crave content tbh

lexy

big slay - lexy and the mods <3

Susie

Ahhh my shows! my first time seeing Taylor. I was at N1 and N3! I just got back from N3 and MY MIND IS ALIVE

Dedew

I lowkey really want to hear RED on piano. I hope she still gonna play it on piano tho, since the piano broken today.

Sarah Woollam

I missed each video but love the one video format. Ps - Loooove your T-shirt Bonnie!

Laura Wylie

Not Bonnie predicting three of the surprise songs from the weekend

Evan

She's said almost every night that she's rerecorded her first six albums. I think the project likely started in 2019 but it has all been completed vocally-wise. However music videos and other era stuff still has yet to come..

Clash Fan

Excited for this! Feels like a lot happened so I'm looking forward to y'alls take on the last few days. :)

Jess.

The Studio in Ney York doesn't have a backdoor, there's no way in that particular place that she could leave through any door but the main one

Alba

Your reactions are my new favourite thing to wake up to! Good morning from Tenerife, Spain! 💜💜💜 I now proceed to watch it with my cup of coffee; gonna miss these moments once I start working next week!

Ashley Ontiveros

I love how you guys predicted one song from each night correctly 🤭😂

Jas

Night 1 killed me my favourite debut song and then my #1 TS Song of all time and I wasn't there 😭😭😭😭

Evan

You guys know I was hoping for Should've Said No @ Chicago

Jenny M

The song Question is linked back to Matt Healy.

Jordyn

I missed your reactions each night! So thankful you were able to hold out and react to them all once you were back together.

Laura Wylie

No because invisible was such a shock to me too. I really wasn’t expecting it.

Laura Wylie

5 of the 6 surprise songs this weekend were on my surprise song list. I’m so sad to lose them

Aloha Record Sargent

What a treat to get the notification for this video! Stayed up until 1am watching. So much to fathom from the song selections on all 3 nights this weekend.

kienan

Hope you had a great weekend, Em!! (And Bonny too hehe) This was so fun to watch and relive the iconic secret songs of this weekend. Wow. I really think that Bon Iver will be at the Minnesota shows because he lives in/is from Wisconsin which is the bordering state. He simply must. I need it. ((Imagine Renegade live — omfg))

Kate Aschoff

ok ok ok can we just..... the karlie and taylor kiss (??) was in a crowded room...at a 1975 concert

Courtney Graham

Love you girlies and your videos! Ty for your hard work! I wanna voice my opinion about the set list changes that Taylor said was gonna happen. My personal prediction is it will change when speak now hits 7/7. I’m really excited to see if it does! If not she lied babes 🤣

Alba

I agree soooo much about 13 being such a hideous age... my experience was similar to Bonny's, I felt everything too much and couldn't see outside my emotions. 0/10, wouldn't recommend or go back 😂 Thanks god I learnt how to process feelings with the years...

Ella Bowerman

I look forward to these videos every week❤️ !! Your reactions are always so superior! And the surprise songs this week were so good omg 😭😱

Rose Ellen

This weekend was an offensive group of surprise songs!

Aaron M

Justin Vernon lives in Wisconsin so I’d bet he comes out at either the Chicago or Minneapolis shows. Or maybe once at each city

Laurie A. V.

The way she sang "He'd better lock it down. Or I won't stick around 'Cause good ones never wait." Well Well.

Jentallygirl

Girls! 🤗 Re: your discussion about if/when Taylor has done each re-record yet… I think that since she’s shown sooo much enthusiasm for Debut secret songs, that makes me think they’re fresh for her now (and has probably re-recorded Debut)… but also since she’s basically ignored Rep so far, even beyond the Joe-connection, that makes me think maybe she has NOT done Rep yet. Just my 2 cents based on her excitement… And PS: I think Debut TV is going to be *gorgeous*…I’m so excited!! 🥰

dimple

We missed you chickens!

mieke

aaahhh, superior reactions!! i‘m a little sad that we lost question…? and ITHK, but it‘s okay :) theoretically, she could do question…? again ☺️ also, love the tbh podcast merch that bonny's wearing!! hehe 🧡

Maya

hey I am really struggling with the whole Matty situation at the moment because he is SO problematic (racism, misogyny, etc.). What are your takes on that? I need help.

paulina

Yeeeehy 🩵🩵

Hailey

is it just me, or are your forks abnormally long...? lol 😅

Haley Haas

Love that she played I think he knows I just wish it was in the original key like it’s supposed to be as high as lavender haze and it’s lower in this version but I’ll take it 🤷🏼‍♀️

Helen Dunham

I kind of feel like her discussing that she is the happiest she has ever been was her trying to talk to fans who may be unhappy with the matty situation. I’m not sure if you have seen the open letter that has been written to Taylor and her team and that the same group has encouraged fans to cancel their Speak Now pre orders. I think she has been trying to navigate that. Encouraging fans to cancel their pre orders is really lousy behaviour. I would never “cancel” Taylor for the actions taken by a man and frankly none of us know who he really is as a person.

Safa

Ok I can't watch this right now because finals but I WAS THERE TONIGHT my voice is gone I can't believe she played red, it was one of my top choices, and I think he knows was my brothers TOP choice we were freaking out. I can't speak and my feet are in pain and I'm tired and I'm behind on finals BUT my life is forever changed

Cornelia

Not gonna lie, I kinda loved this format of doing all the secret songs at once. As you were listing out all your predictions, I just kept saying to myself, oh just you wait, sis, just you wait. Massachusetts was blessed with a superior weekend.

Julia G

What blows my mind is that nobody had a problem with him when she turned up at his show and played. She has known this man for 10 years. She knows him.

Hannah13

I love the surprise songs so much because they make you appreciate songs so much more! I think he knows is right at the bottom of Lover for me but after the live version I see is completely differently and love it again

Katja S.

He talked a lot of shit but that’s basically it and many things got taken out of context. People act like she’s dating Alex Jones now. Also, in the end it comes down to the fact that she can date whoever she wants to. She’s a popstar and a human being, not a morally superior goddess.

MarkH

Can I ask you a question? If the piano was playing by itself on the 3rd night, why did it only play by itself when she was sitting there, and not when she was performing on guitar? Also, broken pianos go out of tune, they don't become haunted. I am suspicious!

Caleb Allen

Literally almost cried happy tears when I saw how long the video is. BEST way to end the day ❤️❤️❤️

Jess

MID VIDEO THOUGHTS!!! maybe her life finally makes sense because SHE FINALLY GOT ANSWERS TO HER “QUESTION..?” ahhhhhhhhhh help I’m spirallinggggggg

Maya

no she was playing but the wrong sounds came out of it. That can happen when it hits the high and low strings at the same time.

Maya

ah I watched it back, there must've been something loose in it! So it just kept going after she played (pianos have over 200 strings)

Katja S.

1) the internet was full of Joe-was-cheating rumors last week 2) she said she’s never been this happy in “every aspect of my life” she literally spelled it out for everyone, guys 😅 of course that includes love

Cassandra

I was at night 1 and I died ded

Lauryn Brown

I was at night 1 and I don’t know how I’m still alive tbh I’m still processing that we got should’ve said no and better man

Nele

this whole video was kinda iconic and as always so much fun !!! 💕💕💕

Jenna Aguirre

About to watch, but I already know you two DIED over Question and Taylor’s Segway into it

Emma K

Justin Vernon lives in Wisconsin which isn’t too far from Chicago!!

Jenna Aguirre

I really feel like 1989 TV and maybe even Rep TV are completely done because that’s what her and her dancers would have rehearsed to! Like do you think they’re rehearsing to stolen versions? No! Also, we know based on the handwritten by Taylor Setlist that was posted by her dancer that the Debut songs were listed as acoustic only. Don’t know if Taylor was deciding between 1 debut song and a surprise song every night, but that tells me that Debut is not re-recorded yet.

Joe Weaver

The stadium in New Jersey is home to football teams called the New York Jets and Giants. It's basically New York City. (It's closer to NYC than Santa Clara is to San Francisco in fact). The halfway point of the tour is after next Friday so I'm holding slight hope that maybe we'll get a setlist change at the halfway point? Anyway, loved the video as always and I do not think it's impossible that you could get that hat!

Joe Weaver

It wasn't doing it until she started playing it. That must've triggered something.

Joe Weaver

I'm sadder about Red since it's my #1 Red song. 🫣

Rachel L

SAME!! Such an amazing show. Honestly shocked we didn’t get Long Live but I love ITHK and Red so much!!

Joe Weaver

Chazzy reacting is superior.

Joe Weaver

Yes but waiting got us an hour long video! I'm trying to glass half full it here...

Christine Violet

The way she sings and acts during Should’ve said no reallyyyyy makes me wonder if the cheating rumors around Joe are true… and the fact that she also did Better man?! It makes the fact that she “moved on” with someone else relatively quickly make more sense, and the fact that so many of her friends (that were also friends of his) unfollowed him in social media… just makes you wonder…

Kenna Galloway

Watching you guys fathom her MY LIFE MAKES SENSE speech and just want to add that *knowing* what you want can be really euphoric and she’s really giving me that post-breakup energy where you start fathoming things. And maybe for the first time she’s able to visualize a path that was murky before.

Kenna Galloway

In peace, she really set up her life to be these two things that were in opposition to each other - her personal/romantic happiness versus her career success and the fame that comes with it. And maybe for the first time she doesn’t feel like they’re in opposition.

Julia

I was at night 3 and died! Can't wait to watch this! ITHK and Red were SUPERIOR surprise songs! (Made me feel better getting these after losing the iconic night 1 songs). Her reaction to the piano malfunction was so funny 🤣

Rachel L

Same!! Such a good show. Really thought she was tricking us with that piano

diya

couldnt have said it better. the internet too too stupid to recognise the difference between someone who has done and said a lot of positive things and occasionally puts his foot in his mouth and an actually horrible person. as a politics major y’all all miss the bigger picture. context is always important

Mia Gregorio

superior secret songs!!! should’ve said no is my favorite from debut and i loveeeeee better man and i think he knows, surprised that she said everything in her life now makes sense… ???? wtfff i need some context 😶

Julia Fisher

for my non-american friends, next week shows are definitely the NY shows - the stadium is the home of the NY Giants (NFL team)

andi

Agree. I don’t think Ryan Reynolds of all people would be so petty to unfollow Joe just a year after his endorsement piece for him in TIME magazine. Something seriously went on and we’d only know in TS11.

blake

GUYS Emma Laird (joes rumored new girl) is starring in a new Apple miniseries called Crowded Room!!!! I think that’s what question..? refers to, I think Joe cheated on her

blake

Emma Laird (joes rumored new girl) is starring in a new Apple miniseries called Crowded Room!!!! I think that’s what question..? refers to

blake

Emma Laird (joes rumored new girl) is starring in a new Apple miniseries called Crowded Room!!!! I think that’s what question..? refers to

andi

Loved your reaction!! I was getting a car wash and had to immediately tune in. Same reaction with Night 1 songs, and totally freaked out about Night 2 with the speech, and Question..? following it? I’m dead. DEAD.

mieke

i think a lot of us are feeling kinda lost in this whole situation, it’s basically what we all go through at the moment. i think it‘s incredibly important not to dismiss the criticism because all of it is so valid. none of it should be shoved aside because that's so invalidating for swifties of colour and other minorities who are personally affected and have been hurt by matty's words and actions - and now, by association, are disappointed in taylor for apparently dating him. feeling that way does not mean anyone's a fake fan. it‘s a perfectly valid sentiment - and i think most people are feeling that way BECAUSE they are such huge fans. it just hurts. all of those emotions can co-exist with still being a huge fan. it‘s just a lot to come to terms with for a lot of fans at the moment and i think we should give each other space to share those sentiments in this community. the way i see it is that one can only hope that MH becomes a much better person in the future. he should‘ve apologised a long time ago because even if he didn‘t mean to offend people, he obviously DID. maybe this backlash will make him realise some of those things. we shall see.

Lively_Ash

I think knowing Taylor they’re all done…bc she’s a planner…& if something god forbid happened to her, her music could still be released

diya

guys! question was playing pre-show in the december shows of the 1975. and taylor is playing about you pre-show during the eras tour (also with the lover music video int he background). about you is also about a missed connection and he says “do you think i have forgotten about you?” then in question she says “i remember”

Chris H

Hey haven’t watched this yet so have to ask did y’all hear about Leyton?

andi

as a 75 fan, sweet guy but i do admit that he needs to learn when to shut up and apologize when regardless if intended or not, offended people. not always will people read think pieces on the “context” of his actions and words and this whole situation now is the prime example. however, i also think we should be more careful throwing out labels far too loosely over something we just read/watch on a twitter thread that can conveniently crop out/remove context on what has been said. just thoughts, the past weeks have been a nightmare and i’m tired.

Candy

I've been looking forward to this all weekend! Missed you girlies!

Marcelo Gouveia

i am dying for the international dates. there are several rumours that she might be performing in latin america this year already. so idk what to think. I am from Brazil and I am so unweeeeell

andi

Can I just add that her singing SSN and Better Man just a day after Dailymail’s “Joe is distraught” article was so !!! I was screaming!

Lively_Ash

Should’ve said no felt like she was spilling tea EVERYWHERE & the to follow it with better man TEA

Amanda

Love your reactions everytime! Just also wanted to say I love seeing Ari walking around all the time in the videos! She is so cute! <3

Niamh

As a the 1975 fan Matty has such an ego problem and he will not apologise because I genuinely believe he thinks the world is out to get him and he has been ‘cancelled’ so many times now despite his intentions often being pure. I just hope he can prove himself to those of you that are concerned that he’s really kind hearted and there is a reason why Taylor, phoebe etc are so close with him.

andi

meanwhile jack producing both these songs: “👀⁉️👀⁉️👀⁉️”

Candy

The moment you both fathomed the combo of Should've Said No and Better Man....I was waiting for that. You didn't disappoint.

Nin Reckermann

When Bon said Electric Guitar Maroon and Em's entire body language like "do not even say that to me"

Nin Reckermann

I keep head-canoning that Taylor is secretly a Patron here (because we know she knows and loves you) so what if she really does play Ivy on your night? I think you'd just be so shocked to your core, they'd have to rebuild you atom by atom afterward

Jaime Kelley

I’m going to may 28th and I am 100% clowning for jack because bleachers perform in nyc on the 26th and 27th 😭😭❤️

Chase Sinnett

I was at Foxborough night 1 and am deceased. Illegal and offensive combo

Lively_Ash

Happy Taylor…music, writing/directing a movie, knowing who she can trust…she has a lot of freedom in her career to do what she wants…the Matty thing…I think there’s a LOT we don’t know & …

Grace Mower

So I was at night 2 and it was INSANE! I’m sure you’ve seen the picture of her during Midnight Rain when she’s opening her arms and the rain is just pouring down on her. Also someone actually went into labor in the parking lot after show! It was just so crazy. I was disappointed we didn’t get a song about rain (I was hoping for The Way I Loved You), but it was so much fun.

Kat Cooley

I think it's possible that Question...? is the mystery song that she and Matty worked on together, with the final version on Midnights being a different version from the one they created. with the OOTW sample I think it's too pointed at Harry to be about anyone else, but I'm sure being in a studio with an old flame would have been memorable no matter where in the timeline it was (and we know that she's been writing for Midnights for atleast the last two-ish years).

Lively_Ash

She had to be private while making Rep bc she chose to disappear after everything that happened, but I think being with Joe kept her being super private cause that’s what he wanted & she likely believed bc they started private they had to remain private.

Lively_Ash

HOWEVER….no one ends a 6 year relationship quickly…it’s something she was processing while together…we know from reports they separated a few times & I do believe something happened that finally put the final nail in the coffin & she able to fully let go of Joe even though she was already halfway out the door.

thesaltysorbet

I went last night and holy sh*t! Life altering 🤩

Mia Morgan

I was at night 2 and omg I was soaked from start to finish, it just wouldn't let up....she said herself it was the rainiest rain show that ever rain showed, ever...HISTORIC TO WITNESS! HOWEVER Taylor's love for rain shows truly showed bcause she was so joyful and kept doing funny/cute things like catch the rain in her mouth and wipe the rain off of the piano that made the show so damn fun! Being there felt like dancing around in one of those toddler wading pools with the water spouts, it was so iconic. When she told us how happy she was in her life it just made all of that even better, it was such a wholesome moment and I am so happy to have witnessed her at such a happy moment in her life! I was happy to get Question...? to be able to better fathom that song, but also SO HAPPY AND RELIEVED to get a Debut song and be able to say I heard all 10 Eras at my show! Invisible is a song I have really fathomed and fell in love with in the past few years, so everything really fell into place Saturday night. I am also giggling at the fact that our show turned her piano HAUNTED last night. ;)

Jenna Aguirre

Did you guys see who Taylor was hanging out with at Electric Lady? It was Florence Welch, Maggie Rogers, Kendrick Lamar, Michelle Zauner, Gracie Abrams, Jack, Margaret, Zoe Kravitz, Channing Tatum, Matty. It was such a random group, but I feel like some of them could be New York surprise guests? Maybe she’d bring out Kendrick for Bad Blood? Idk but I’m excited to find out!!

Jenna Aguirre

Stop it please I can’t lose Maroon I’ll simply die 😭

Jessie

I imagine it was probably acting out the whole time but we couldn’t hear it because its mic/sound was not live until she sat down to play.

Chelsea Brown

I think Speak Now is like if the sounds/themes of Rep and evermore had a baby. Those are my three fav albums!

Mia Morgan

Same, that's how I feel after seeing Bad Blood and Question...? live Saturday night!

Sarah LaForce

If Jack comes as a guest it will only be the first night, he's playing a show with Bleachers on the 27th and the 28th

Mia Morgan

I had never fathomed....

Stephanie Orman

I was at both the Saturday (rainiest rain show to ever rain show) and Sunday shows this weekend. She was six feet away while talking about being the happiest she’s ever been and pushing the water off the piano. On Sunday everyone thought she was doing a jokey bit for Haunted with the broken piano before we realized🙃. Far and away the best shows of hers I’ve seen. I’m so excited for you two to get to go!

Becca C

Been waiting for this one! i was at N1 and N2 and Better man is in my top 5 so naturally I simply passed away and have not yet returned to my earthly body

lightingfiresinjuly

So excited cause next week (May 28th) is MY TURN!!! And suggesting Maroon on electric guitar was NOT OK I would die

Becca C

And Emily I thought of you instantly when she sang question! I promise I sang loud for you !

andi

THIS. when people say “how can you end a 6yr relationship just like that”, I’d like to say as someone that just got out of a 4yr relationship, that relationship was ending before it actually formally ended. This is months and months of unresolved conflicts and issues that were swept under the rug.

Becca C

On the 1989 convo: the Harry stuff was dead and gone and buried when 1989 came out: he was around before that, then she wrote about him and released: but she may associate Matty with 1989 era because that’s when they had their sotuationship

Amanda Mittelman

I was at night three and it was SUPERIOR BLESSED AMAZING ILLEGAL ELITE

Amanda Mittelman

It was my first TS concert and I seriously couldn’t have asked for a better night

Sami Wiens

UGHHG the way she missed the Red outro killed me

Meghan Carty

Bon Iver lives and has his studio in Eau Claire, Wisconsin, so I'm betting he'll show up for a midwest show. Most likely Minnesota or maybe Chicago.

Courtney Miller

Going to Chicago n3 and PRAYING for exile. evermore will also cause my premature death.

Courtney Miller

The hottest girls think that speak now/ rep/ evermore is the holy trinity !

Kira Wise

I’m convinced debut is coming out fall 2026 as a 20th anniversary celebration for it. And maybe even she’ll just tour debut on a smaller tour and that’s why it’s not in the eras tour.

Patrick B

I'm going to Friday's show in NJ! I live in New York. Yes, Metlife Stadium is the closest stadium to New York City; it's actually where the New York Giants & the New York Jets play, so a lot of New York things happen there, despite it being technically in NJ. It's the same concept with Foxborough - it's the closest stadium to Boston (and it's where the New England Patriots play).

Laura Donovan

I was at Last night and it was so fun!! I am so happy with the secret songs they were so fun!!! I did like after red she said this was probably more fun because I had a really sad piano version planned or something like that.

JC S

What strikes me about Matty Healy when I see interviews is he is passionate about art, music, words, and people. I think Taylor can be herself with him and share their passions with one another. That must make sense to her - she can be herself with him and not hide herself or her passions.

Katie

I want you guys to get ivy SO bad like I will be crying with you if she does it without you

txmxcxnx

National paper airplane day is on the 26ththth!!!

Clash Fan

I found a good stream to watch it on and she really seemed like she was on FIRE on Sunday night.

Laura Bolanos

E M I L Y!!!! I cannot even beginnnn to tell you how fucked up I got just now when you mentioned losing Maroon to this weekend! I will be there Saturday night and I will die dead if she does!! The last two weekends have just about ended my daughter and I (she’s 12). She’s a Stan of her earlier work (debut, fearless, speak now) so to lose Teardrops on My Guitar, Forever & Always, Hey Stephen, and now Should’ve Said No had her in a fighting mood 😂 but then- she had the audacity to sing Better Man, Question…?, I Think He Knows, AND Red?? Check me out on the fighting corner too 🤣 I’m a Rep and Lover Stan so I’m walking in not expecting much because all of the Joe songs are my absolute favoriteeeee 😫 but if she sings Maroon all will be forgiven 🥲

OldestSwiftieEver More

I agree! I think she was in exile herself. For a 6 yr relationship you literally can count in short order how many times they attended award shows together or wernt out on the town. Maybe she starting feeling isolated and lonely being inside for 6 years! In the beginning you're so in love you don't care but as time goes by it really probably takes a toll. Especially for a natural extravert. Folklore and Evermore were made during the pandemic over zoom. Midnights she was finally able to work with some of her best friends in person and reconnect with old friends too. And to be able to create her music and share it with the world is all she ever wanted. She probably was like "Damn there is still a world out here and I feel really good....there's no way I'm going back inside!" She seems so free and joyful... like she's been released from captivity! I'm sure it took awhile for her to process everything. It was "A death by a thousand cuts" kind of breakup. It's long, hard, painful but ultimately freeing! Damn! Sorry that was so longgggg!!

Michael

I almost threw up over night 3 bc the broken piano seemed too perfect to not be an ‘oh no it’s almost like it’s…HAUNTED’ bit to introduce haunted as a surprise song 🙃😮‍💨

Kaila

night 3 won 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 that version of ithk NEEDS to be on spotifyyyyy

V. Babida

Omg I would die dead if she did a small tour of just acoustic debut - I’m such a debut Stan, like that would be so iconic 😍😍😍

Marie S.

I'm going to May 26 (this friday) and its the only date Jack can make it ( becusse he has a show 27/28) if they do getaway car and/or maroon I will actually faintttttt ALSO May 26 is national paper airplane day sooooooooooo maybe some 1989 related happening im soo exciteddd

Nicole Winn

Yes! And maybe the OOTW interpolation was a reference to 1989 without being literal.

Lauren Paiva

I was at Night 2 in the water park!!!! Still water logged 2 days later. Hearing her say right now is the happiest she’s been in her whole life then playing Question as her happiest moments song gave me whiplash harder than the rain. Still processing!

Clash Fan

I was just watching this again and something occurred to me about Question. First I've watched some 1975 fans talk about the lyrics and why they fit Matty and it's compelling. It's about the "I remember" and the OOTW reference at the start. That for most have solidified this song as being about Harry Styles but what if she's not referencing the person OOTW is about but the feeling? She played it 2nd night Nashville as well. It does not make the OOTW about him but it has to reflect the anxiety of what she's been feeling in the current climate.

Clash Fan

Makes sense to me too now that I watched a bunch of his interviews. He is not the demon some are trying to portray him as.

Will McNally

Now I only there aren't that many songs left but it is interesting that she hasn't done Folklore since the 2nd ever night...

Abrielle Wright

I got Red as a surprise song at the Reputation tour. We were at The Rose Bowl and she chose that song because Rose's are red 😅

Eric Olivieri

I was there on Night 3!!! Both I Think Knows and Red were SUPERIOR!! I’m so happy. Can’t believe how much I WON 💖♥️

Leijette Riopel

I am getting my hopes way way too high for Bon Iver showing up on June 23 in Minneapolis to do exile (though I would happily accept evermore, also). I have convinced myself it’s likely because he lives in Eau Claire, Wisconsin which is just 2 hours from Minneapolis. I am pretty certain we are the closest tour venue to him if he’s there. One of my friends is going on the 24th, so if Taylor could just bring him out to do exile on my night and evermore on hers, that would be a dream. Probably I will be wrong and very sad about it, but I am holding out hope!!!

gracie

I'm so sorry but ootw is and always will be a harry song to me.. thus making question the same... some people out there need a swiftie history textbook refresher

Catherine (YOYOK stan)

So on n2 she really fucked me up when she mentioned that she’s the happiest she’s ever been both and off stage so it truly now has me thinking that the relationship of joe and her has been over for a long time. To us it feels so soon since we only just found out about it, but I think to myself this is the queen of karma and she wouldn’t do anything that she isn’t in a good state of mind for. So therefore I truly believe that relationship was long done long ago and she has processed and moved on and she is in a better place and good for her! I support her happiness 💕

chatsandreacts

Oh gosh this footage is loooong gone I am sorry 😫

chatsandreacts

That is so exciting!! Hope you had the best time 💜

Laura M

My theory is she is re-recording debut right now which is why she’s playing them so much right now. Also what she said before question makes me think about this book idea personally 🤷🏼‍♀️

chatsandreacts

She's said that she made the decision to re-record her first 6 albums, but she's never said that she has actually done that. She even corrected herself last weekend, where she went to say she'd recorded them all and then said something like "most of them" or "a lot of them"!

chatsandreacts

Even so, she's worked from Electric Lady for years but we never got pictures of her leaving!

chatsandreacts

Thanks Kienan! 💜💜 omg that is such a good point, wow those shows are so close too. Renegade would be soooo offensive!

chatsandreacts

I think you're right!!! I don't want to get my hopes up but I truly will be disappointed if we don't get more for the speak now set when SN TV drops!

chatsandreacts

ohhh this is such a good point! she really has been saying nice things about debut songs before she performs them!

chatsandreacts

OMG!!!! It sounds like you had the besttttt time and I am so happy your brother got his top pick for secret song!!! 💜

chatsandreacts

Hehe I am glad you enjoyed! I don't know if we will be able to keep doing it though as it is too hard to be off the internet to avoid spoilers for 2 days 💜

chatsandreacts

Agree with Jessie that it's probably just that the mic wasn't on or near the piano during the first song, so we couldn't hear it!

chatsandreacts

absolutely SUPERIOR secret songs for you!!! I hope you had the most amazing time 💜

Becca C

Me too!!!!! Happy to be soaking in the rain with a fellow Patron!!

Becca C

As a N1 and N2 girl, I think you made the best possible decision 😆

chatsandreacts

I think it's a good point that they wouldn't be rehearsing to the stolen versions! However I don't get the impression that she's excluded a Debut set from the tour because she hasn't re-recorded it, rather I think it's just already such a long show with so many huge hits she has to perform, and she knows that debut is the least known/listened to album, and obviously the oldest, so just decided to leave it out!

chatsandreacts

would LOVEEEEE a setlist change at the halfway mark, Joe!!

chatsandreacts

It definitely makes me wonder!! But I also can't help but feel like she would still be struggling a lot if the love of her life, the man she thought was the one, betrayed her like that. Then again, healing isn't linear, so the fact that she seems and says she is happy is not necessarily an indication that he didn't cheat!

chatsandreacts

You're absolutely right!!! She is so successful, she knows who her real friends are now, her mum seems healthy, she's on tour reconnecting with her fans, she's on top of the world in so many aspects of her life. She is FATHOMING that she has created the life she envisioned for herself, and all of these things are true despite a breakup!

chatsandreacts

AHHHH oh you WON with your surprise songs, Julia!!!

chatsandreacts

omg! this year?! AHHH she better get a move on releasing dates and tickets then!

Christine Violet

You make a really good point! But also, if we are going to believe all the articles that came out when they first broke up, didn’t they make mention of them having grown apart, and also being on and off again for the last few years? So what if they initially decided to take a break because of them growing apart, and then later she found out something happened? It’s all speculation at this point, and at the end of the day if she’s happy that’s all that matters (even if I really really wish it was with a less controversial person!) Anyways love all your reactions!!! I don’t have any swiftie friends so watching your videos allows me to pretend I do have some! ♥️♥️♥️

chatsandreacts

it is definitely interesting to consider it being about him. even though we know OOTW is about harry, I guess interpolating it into Question...? could more just be that the narrative fits this other on/off relationship. Rekindling during the making of Midnights and wondering, are we out of the woods yet? could we work a second time round?

chatsandreacts

Oh Mia, it sounds like you had the most amazing night!! I think it's so incredible how Taylor can make a rain show feel like the best experience you've ever had (if it was anyone else it would probably be miserable)! So glad you had an incredible time xxx

chatsandreacts

OHHHH there is no returning to your earthly body for a long time I fear

chatsandreacts

2026 feels like such a frightfully long time to wait 😫 but would LOVEEEEE a small debut tour!

Susie

Thank you!! I had an incredible time <3

chatsandreacts

Agreed, despite everything I guess I can understand why she would have a connection with another musician where they can really share their passion for music and songwriting

Susie

Haha yes, I was low key glad I didn't go to N2 and get absolutely soaked! And was happy to have a day in between to recover

chatsandreacts

why do acoustic live versions of lover songs always hit different???

chatsandreacts

omg GETAWAY CAR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! would be so illegal. Praying you get this bestie

chatsandreacts

I do love this idea!!! It would make sense that she is really connecting with debut right now because she's recording it!

Bianca Dornellas Pesquero

But I just saw somewhere saying that she used to talk that she was the happiest or something like that in 1989 era and now we know that is not so true. So they think maybe she just said that to stop the scrutiny about her and MH. Like, not that is miserable of course. We can see every night that she is happy and apparently ok, but maybe "the happiest" is a bit too much. Idk if I agree with this 100%, but it got me thinking...

Chris H

Yeah I saw it was so cute and special seeing that this weekend them connecting again I remember watching that swiftmass video ages ago

Kayleigh

I laughed so hard when you both had no clue where Gillette stadium was but over here we were all freaking out because it was the first stadium she played at ever (13 years ago) the first infamous rain show, the reason she wrote long live and her 13th time playing there 😂. I was at night 1 and it was EVERYTHING 😩

andi

I’d like to think she is genuinely happy now as oppose to 1989 era (fake squad parade, ED, she attends everything she was invited to etc). Now, she’s on her biggest tour to date, her re-recordings, works on her art during her free dates, a new love that understands her better (?). For me it makes sense that it makes sense for her. Again this is all speculation and we will never know, but I see the contrast between this “happiest” vs 1989 era “happy”.

Jenna Bolmgren

Constructive criticism (hopefully you’ll take it as such), but would’ve loved to hear your commentary (esp during Question…? (Night 2 in general)) after the video or paused to chat, esp because you weren’t watching it live. 💛

Alex Engstrom

Thank you!!!!!! No one talks about how debut wasn't on the ERAS Tour. My friend and I were majorly bummed. Like it's the ERAS tour, why aren't you acknowledging the first album?

andi

Can I just share.. last week, I was trying to understand a friend and her lack of taste for not enjoying TS music. She says “There’s just too much going on.. and it makes sense that you like her songs, the same way you love stuff like Marvel and Game of Thrones. You enjoy that kind of stuff” and that made me remember what Bon and Emily refers to as “TSCU”, the LORE of it all and this past weekend was an example of that! I still cannot get over about Questions..? being about Matty, how it relates back to 1989, how “About You” is a probable answer to her Questions..? or the other way around? ILLEGAL! The TSCU is such an experience.

Meg

Has anyone ever talked about what I had thought was an Easter egg in lover video- it popped up in my memories. In lover video there is a Devils roll the dice Angels roll their eyes game box (Cruel Summer lyric) that has the numbers 0527 on it. I am convinced that she had been planning to release Cruel Summer as a single 5/27/2020but then didn’t when the pandemic hit.

Lisa

If Bon Iver pops out it will be Minneapolis given Eau Claire is 1hr down the road! Got tix to Sat night show. Would be floored from the nosebleeds if he played!!!

Lisa

I’m dreaming w u on this!

Starbuck1234!

Is Question a happy song? I think it is. kinda. She is reminiscing about an old lover, but fondly. There are fond memories. She thinks about him and the time they spent together, fondly. And she wants to ask him, do you still want to touch me? Do you remember leaving and not putting up much of a fight, why not? We had good times. We had something, even though it didn't manifest itself. Do you remember? I remember. So I think, it brought back happy memories of their time together, the time they spent and she obviously thinks fondly of, not sadly. Seems like it is about Matty all along and "I remember" is a red herring.

jillelizabeth

nooo cus this weekend got some superior surprise songs I am unwellll

Morgan Ostertag

Yes! I'm going to Minneapolis n1 and a bunch of us in an instagram group chat fathomed this a few weeks ago! I NEED exile!

Fahmeen

I just don’t understand that cause she was with Joe when she was wearing that blue midnights outfit post VMAs last year

Joe Weaver

I agree with you but everyone is trying to change what they've always thought now in light of recent developments.

Joe Weaver

It is crazy how she's made the idea of a rain show so much fun.

Joe Weaver

There's so much we don't know and yet people act like they know everything.

Joe Weaver

Ari cameos are the best

Miantsa

Something I believe about her songs and songwriting in general (especially when listening to Midnights), is that One song can actually be about different things/situations/feelings/people for her. So to me, Question...? and other songs can actually be about two relationships that made her feel that way (which makes sense), or even half complete "fiction". Personally yes sometimes I attach some songs to her relationships, but in general I just take them as an expression of her experiences in general - blurry and all! As we know she uses very specific details that immediately make us think of one situation, but maybe it's actually not just that and she blends and match them for artistic reasons (and to stay elusive). Also, one link I haven't seen a lot online is that the "a color I've searched for since" is a specific imagery she loves and has also used in illicit affairs! "You showed me colors you know I can't see with anyone else" so one can say these are connected to the same person/situation, but maybe absolutely not and its romanticized reality/fiction! Anyway all this to say that to each their own process of fathoming songs haha (sorry for the long message)

Karen Valentino

When Taylor surprised everyone by talking about how happy she is *in every aspect of her life,* to me it was 100% about the open letter chastising her for her relationship with Marty Healy, and her meta message was “you who are trying to dictate how I should conduct my life right now can just STFU.” And she put the most charming, disarming spin on it. She’s a mastermind.

Joe Weaver

Don't forget the Jets! I know they are usually forgettable but they should be better this year.

Joe Weaver

That's what I've been thinking. Everyone immediately wants to read into that statement for the juicy relationship stuff where I think it's mostly that everything is going so well right now. But that's not fun to talk about (for some).

Joe Weaver

Haha, I don't think anyone loves being 13! It really is a terrible time.

andi

Perhaps there were attempts to still make it work. To me, 6 years is still 6 years and I understand if there were attempts to salvage what you still can.

Emzies

I don’t mind having context for songs. In fact, I owe Bonny and Emily tons of gratitude for getting me up to speed with a crash course in Taylor’s music, but I could go without the hyped up speculation. It seems we get carried away sometimes with reading too much into a performance or a look or a song choice. Don’t get me wrong; Mother has trained us with Easter eggs but I just ask that we all remember that we don’t know anything. Taylor’s genius music and writings stand brilliantly on their own without the gossip. Much love to you all! 🫶🏻

Rose

I was there on night 3 and was screaming so hard when she started playing Red!! I had been so sad it wasnt on the main setlist so im so happy I got to hear it live

Amyisaswiftie13

speak now girlies are lover girlies and red girlies are folklore girlies

Sinead Kate

i also saw that tik tok and am also a rep girly but not a speak now girly haha! i’m with bonny and can’t wait for SNTV to fathom 😍 also agree with haunted, the spooky dracula vibe of the opening melody gets me 😂 haunted acoustic tho 🥹

gaysofspades

As much as I dont like it and dont want it to be real ... if she is happy I'm happy. I just hope she knows what she does and doesn't hurt herself in all of this kerfuffle

gaysofspades

Guys I'm telling you, she used the OOTW intro thing to distract us further from wtf this song is about

Lisa

And The Alcott! That would make me very happy!

Kimberly

Can't believe Better Man is gone 😭 😭 😭

Caroline

missed you guys last weekend! so happy i can watch this now 🥲 it always feels like i’m watching it with friends and i am so grateful. I’d also love to put out there that i love all your commentary and am usually thinking the exact same things right along with you 😂💜 thank you thank you thank you!!

Karen Valentino

This makes so much sense - she would be relearning all of the songs and it wouldn’t be a stretch that she has them on hand to perform live.

Emzies

💯

Georgina

Do you think that maybe the piano wasn’t actually broken and it was someone playing the evermore piano (or another one) behind the scenes just so she could play two guitar songs??

Jessie

You guys predictedddddddd 👀

Kira Wise

It will be worth it as long as I'd Lie as a vault track. Been waiting all my life to listen to that song on something other than youtube.

Elizabeth Murphy

I was at THE RAIN show on Saturday! I was so so grateful to be able to go🙏🏻 and Taylor truly didn’t miss a beat (icon behavior!👏🏼) buuuuuut everyone saying you’ll get an epic show if it rains is kind of like saying that to someone on their wedding day😅 Obviously it will still be a superior day but…couldn’t get good videos or pictures (monsoon vibes lol), couldn’t wear my outfit I spent weeks hand-making, etc. I had such high hopes for the surprise songs as a treat during the chaos so was disappointed by Invisible (also confused because..debut songs two nights in a row)? That being said, of course I still scream sang every word to it haha. Forever mourning my fave WCS and to know that was also after a rain delay…💔 Still a superior show and would stand in a monsoon for Taylor any day!🙃

Madeline

I think it’s interesting that she played a lover song with red because in lover she references many times that love is golden where in the song red she literally says loving him was burning red. In daylight she also said that “I once believed love would be burning red but it’s golden” referencing the burning red again. I wish she would’ve played daylight with red tbh. Plus the idea of love being golden is such a reference to Joe. Maybe I’m making this connection up but it was the first thing that came to mind when i heard red and a lover song together.

Nicole

im so unwell to have missed i think he knows and red on the same night ??? i just need international dates at this point, at least something to look forward to 🫡

Becca C

She did mad woman a few weeks later , Right?

Becca C

I was there too!! Unforgettable !!

Starsonscars

I’ll go completely off here but… what if Question is about her sexuality? Like, all those past relationships and Harry helped her question those and see the truth? Even the 1975. I think that’s a part of the puzzle. Who knows? Just a guess. Word tho, cause it was my initial reaction to this song. “Do you wish you could still touch her…?”

Ruby🌻

YOU HAVE TO REACT TO THE NEW TRACKS AND THE ICE SPICE VERSION OF KARMA AND SOTB FEAT MORE LANA!!

aiyla

HAVE YOU SEEN THE MIDNIGHTS TILL DAWN ANNOUNCEMENT!

gracie

thats very true, and im sorry to inform the revisionist history swifties but taylor and matty were never linked until after 1989 was released in 2014 so all the 1989 girlies (myself included) can rest at the thought that there is really no way she could've written ootw or anything on 1989 about matty

SequinSmile

i preferred the separate videos of every show :(

Adélaïde K

I also think that 6 years is also a long time to really get to know someone, to have spend so many time spiraling over the same issues and with that might come acceptance and freedom when you finally let it go and accept that love is not enough. That you have done everything you could to make it work but people evolved and change. Sometimes love is not enough and being finally allowed to embrace yourself fully can surpass the loss and the heartbreak. Don't know if she is going through that but that's what I keep thinking because everyone says it's so hard to get out of a 6 years relationship, but maybe sometimes it's not... sometimes giving up is the one thing that will find you the right thing. And that thing might be yourself.

Darya 🤍

They mentioned they weren’t able to do that this weekend

Lily

The special thing about foxborough is it’s at Gillette stadium which is where she had her first stadium show!

Layla4124

Agree, when you give so much and don’t even realize you’ve given a part of yourself up to try and keep that relationship. I think being so private for 6 years and now having the freedom to be out when she wants, that has to feel good.

Curt Decker

I want a secret song album so bad

Elizabeth

I'm still under the belief that since the debut album was her first album she didn't fully know the ins and outs of truly owning a song. I figured that legally it's also easier to sing a song once instead of performing it every night since technically Big Machine can ban her from performing her older songs if she's still in the process of being able to re-record them. Hence the reason she has never messed up a debut secret song (as far as I know). However, it would be odd for them to block her considering it would just make them more money since people are buying and streaming a lot of songs she plays. Only Taylor knows what's going on in her mind.

Kristin Murphy

I was at the Foxborough Saturday show which truly was, as Taylor said, "the rainiest rain show that ever rain showed". I hate to sound like I'm complaining because I was so blessed to have gotten tickets and of course had an AMAZING time. But just a perspective of someone at a rain show..tbh it's maybe not all it's cracked up to be. Hard to describe how wet we were- like Taylor said it really was like standing in a shower for 3.5+ hours, wind & rain coming from every direction, absolutely pouring, my sister dumped probably 2 cups worth of water out of her rain boot after the show. We couldn't wear the outfits we hand-made for weeks, couldn't do some of the fun makeup looks we had planned, my sister got a huge rain droplet in her eye that somehow got behind her contact so she couldn't see properly for much of the show, you couldn't really take your phone out at a point out of fear it would get ruined and hard to get good pics / videos. Silver lining was hoping we'd get an illegal surprise song (like the Nashville night 3 rain show with Would've Could've Should've) and cause of her connection with Gillette Stadium (if you remember from Journey to Fearless this is where they highlighted it was her first ever stadium show) but we got...Invisible (ILY Debut but it was very random). However it was definitely memorable and Taylor showed just how much of a pro she was for powering through. But still, praying for everyone's future shows that mother nature blesses you with good weather so your experience is A+!

lizzy

I think the other thing I've started to think about especially now that she's shown she reflects on her past albums, and can tell stories and interpolate her life with folklore/evermore is that Taylor can probably do what we do when we listen to her music? She captures a feeling so well that maybe "Question..." was about Harry but now in the same way we can listen to it and imagine someone else and the way it fits our lives, she can do the same and it could also fit Matty for her, OR even have been a mixture of feelings and experiences with different people at the time.

Quinta Oenema

no no she is gonna do evermore in amsterdam. when the bridge starts, a piano comes from under the stage and bon iver is playing it and he starts singing and then taylor is going join him.

Leanne22

Watching these late, but it’s insane how close you guys get to guessing the surprise songs!!! 🩷

Sacred_sunflower

Flash forward to 300 take out coffees later ⏰ aaaand you guys get red AND you’re losing me 😭 I’m so happy for your guys and an EPIC eras weekend 🫶

Caroline

Watching way late 😂but I’m Wondering if her saying her life finally makes sense means at this point she had re-recorded all her albums 👀 because she hadn’t even met Travis yet so it had to be something else besides a relationship

Nate Cady

I was at Night 2!!!!!! It was such a special nigh and it rained mostly the whole time! Just joined patreon and so glad you fathomed my tour thats almost been a year now!!!!

Anna K

I’m watching all these for the first time now and it’s just so crazy and actually so sad knowing TTPD tracks. Ugh. She really WAS so happy. 😭 God bless Travis! ♥️

C

Feeling exactly the same. Paying particular attention to the dates and song choices now, and this would've been just after the MH break up. Both songs now seem very pointed 💔

pearcemcmahon13

this is sooooooo fascinating watching back oh boy

Abbie

Rewatching to live my nostalgia from being at Gillette N1🥲 should’ve said no & better man had my literal mother and I SOBBING💀

lyntara

i deeply need a midnights refathoming in light of ttpd's revelations 😭🙏

Breezy Bumbles

Oh wow. Night 2. It’s so painful to watch in hindsight. She thought she finally found him. But obviously we all know what happened.

Deborah

“Things will make sense when we get TS 11” - Emily Yes!

Sophie kelly

Watching The night 2 speech in 2025🥺💀🤯

Emelie

The MH breakup was a bit later though! She was still with him here. Isn’t that where ‘how you don’t miss me in the shower’ from the black dog comes from? Matty and her broke up in mid June or so I think

Wanda🖤

watching this in june of 2025… oh how far we have come

ton

Yeah this was peak MH

ton

It was peak MH for her… she was SOOOO HAPPY

Janie

her life finally makes sense or cents? she was headed towards owning her work...so I wonder...

JD IHateItHere

Same as I await Life of Showgirl. Finally joined Patreon for this because I can’t do it anymore with crazies outside a paywall who aren’t able to let Taylor Taylor.

Ally ❤️

Love a boxed set - standard set lists (please separate folklore and evermore!) and the elite surprise songs!!!

Jamie

I truly believe The Black Dog refers to Night 2 at Foxboro… because she referred to this show as performing in the shower. “you don't miss me In the shower And remember How my rain-soaked body Was shaking Do you hate me?”

Rachel L

Watching at the end of 2025 and reflecting on my show at night 3. Truly insane that we got the only night with 2 guitar surprise songs!

Drew

She can’t just say that

Drew

Watching it going into 2026

Cait13

You should have said no, and better man.... ummm Mattey was being spoken too

Stephanie

Watching this forever later for the first time and seeing her do Should’ve Said No in a similar way to the iconic award show performance that lives in my mind rent free for over a decade is something else!!! 🤯