Home
Creators
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Secret Song RE-FATHOMING: Chicago, IL (Patreon)

Published:
2023-12-16 22:00:02
Imported:
2026-09
Tags:

Content

Forgot how wild the surprise songs songs were this weekend?? We fear our queen was really going through it 😭 love her and love you guys

Comments

Emma Nelson

This was my weekend! Haven’t watched videos of my secret songs since the show on N3 on purpose wanting to save it for this energy 😊

Landon Talbott

Yay!! I went to night 3 of Chicago! I got to hear Hits Different live :-)

JC S

So glad you posted - thank you!! Sick in bed … you are my comfort viewing!

Joe Weaver

It's our last 3-show weekend until whatever we'd call the 6-show bonanza in LA (I'm guessing you'll split that into two parts).

Ash W

The first night was my night, and I'm still not over Taylor wishing us a happy Pride month. Also, The Lakes and Ivy were two of my dream surprise songs (she ultimately played Ivy on my birthday in my home state?! Kismet) and I feel so unbelievably lucky to have experienced The Lakes live (and have new appreciation for I Wish You Would, too). It was my little ones’ first concert and couldn't have been any better 💙

Ava Jeffs

may I just say the set up behind you (in the taylor swift fathoming office) is so iconic, can’t believe how far you guys have come since that first lover breakdown 🫶 love you besties happy holidays (holiday collection on 🔁)

Ava Jeffs

the actual full body chills I got during this whole era when mother walked over to that piano lips sealed out for blood

Riya💕

I don't think the next one will be TS11 because when you think about, it just doesnt make sense to add a whole new era into the world right now. I feel like she'll finish the eras tour and then drop TS11 so that it will become a standalone era and she can tour that maybe if she chooses to later on. I think she needs to finish the rerecordings first and close the eras tour chapter and then we might get something new and completely different.💖

Jessie

Just here to tell Emily’s she’s beautiful 🥰

Emma Nelson

Chicago is on Lake Michigan, which is one of the very large Great Lakes

Landon Talbott

By the way it’s Lake Michigan. It’s called The Great Lakes. Lake Michigan, Lake Erie, Lake Ontario, etc.

Jessie

Um NO, Richie just CASUALLY buying Era tickets!!! Definitely the most unrealistic moment in The Bear 🤣🤣

erin

THE BEAR! incredible

Rebecca

The Lakes was played because there is a huge lake in Chicago near the stadium

Jenn Hamel

Does anyone ever spend time fathoming that we have listened to Taylor Swift songs 100,000x more than Taylor Swift? Like how many times has she listened to the lakes? Because I’ve listened to it 4 million times Taylor. Of course I know it

Miantsa

I don’t understand how Castles Crumbling is not more of a fan fave because to me it is so important in the Taylor Swift story, and personally, think it is one of her best Vault tracks. It was actually one of my top 5 most played songs this year! So I agree it should not replace Long Live, but if she allowed space for an extended Speak Now section for the Europe leg, it would be AMAZING for her and Hayley to sing together 😍

Allison

I'm feeling a kelly clarkson collab on rep tv, i think it would be awesome if kelly were included in a track on rep. post would also be so superior. On debut I'm feeling a kenny chesney, faith hill, and/or tim mcgraw collab.

Ashley Marie

Or maybe even Shania on debut

iLaney90

You CANNOT say something like that in front of MEEEEEEE 😭😭😭 I would actually die if Shania did a feature on literally any Taylor album 💀

paulina

Until this day I never saw the ,the lakes‘ performance because it hurts to much 😭😩

Mia Gregorio

i love all these songs so much

Mia Gregorio

i loveeeee i don’t wanna live forever.. i really hope it’s on rep tv

Miantsa

An unexpected combo but I would have been beyooooond happy getting You all over me and I don’t wanna live forever!! Absolutely OFFENSIVE, probably one of my fave combos (there are so many good ones tho 😭) AND these performances were just perfection 😮‍💨🤌🏽🤌🏽

Denise Graves

I love Taylor's mature vocals on the re-records! I simply cannot wait to hear debut TV. She's gotten so much better with each new album.

Christine Violet

The lakes is one of my all-time faves… but don’t kill me cause my favourite version is the original one, then the long pond version, and then the bonus version 🫣♥️

TD2002

Y’all should look at a map of Chicago. Lake Michigan is huge 🤣

Christina

I was there for night one, on the floor, and “The Lakes” and “I Wish You Would” are two of my favorite songs by her, so I screamed and openly wept when she played both.

Kat

I’m honestly clowning for a Brandi Carlile feature on debut tv just because they’ve both shown support for each other, her sound would work well, and we know that she was such an inspiration for Taylor during the time she would have been writing debut (it’s giving fall out boy on speak now tv). Taylor has mentioned how important The Story was and still is to her so many times so I could see how maybe working with Brandi would be really sentimental for her

Farrell Peka

If lorde is on rep tv… I’m actually gonna die

Jessie

Me again! So Joe gets a lot of shit for not showing up to Taylor publicly but didn’t they both agree that their relationship would be private? Like when did it suddenly change and she was unhappy with the lack of publicity??? Just genuinely so curious 🤔

Alex Parra

Chicago's right by Lake Michigan, one of the 5 Great Lakes that border Canada and America

Nathalie Richter

AS A MATTER OF FACT I am not from Chicago but I am! From Michigan and fully expected us to get the lakes and we were all literally shocked when she did it the weekend before us! Insane

cristinafaye

Yes, Chicagoan here! Lake Michigan is sooo big! My kids call it the ocean 😜

Laura R

Taylor actually talked more after Maren got on stage night 2 before they started singing. She was so sweet talking about how much she appreciated Maren doing the collab bc at that time the re-recording project was not guaranteed to succeed. During that time of them talking on stage is when Maren said she was nervous too. That was the night I was there--I have the full speech/song recorded if you want me to send it to you.

Laura R

Also, I was DYING while this was happening because I love Maren. Specifically, I love the Highwomen (Brandi Carlile & Maren Morris in a band together--STOP)

Candy

When I listen to IDWLF, it makes me realize that even at the beginning, this was Joe's way of being...not saying anything, not giving her anything, etc. Makes me so sad that she went through this so many times.

Nathalie Richter

Love you guys! Also my show was the next show after these so I am SO excited to watch you refathom. Get ready for some Emily losses!

Kat

also she would then have a feature on a Miley song, a hozier song, and a Taylor song like??? she’s slowly collecting the holy trinity lmao

Jack

The Christmas lights lyric in the moment I knew also made me think of Lover which is obviously about Joe. I think the songs she sings this weekend are very revealing…

Jenna Bolmgren

I’ve also wondered if she and Matty were ever actually a thing, or if she was just holding his hand those couple times like she does her other friends. Or was there more chaos that I’m aware of?

Natty Vee

I so distinctly remember listening to the livestream whilst walking through Coles shopping with my mum, and hearing her do the opening vocals of I Don't Wanna Live Forever and I literally screamed 'oh my fucking god' and got the weirdest looks from other shoppers

Jo

I think the numbers in the coffee mug in the Karma music video refer to the calendar month and the zodiac season. The zodiac calendar starts with Aries. Blue nail on the 8 meant announced in 8th month (august) and released in 8th zodiac (scorpio), and taylor announced 1989 8/9 and released 1989 first friday of scorpio season. Black nail on 2 means announced in 2nd month (february) and released in 2nd zodiac (taurus), so I think Taylor will announce rep 2/16 (112 days after 10/27) and release it on 4/26 (first friday of Taurus season.)

Jo

Also, the entire Karma music video is Tarot cards --> that's why it seems like astrology related too, because so much of tarot cards has to do with astrology

Lively_Ash

I think she was ok w that at first bc she was needing to hide away after all the drama of 2016. In the Miss Americana doc she says she thinks Lover will be the last time people will tolerate her at that level of fame. But even Lover has prices that show the anxiety she already had in their relationship. I think throughout the pandemic & having time to fully reflect on everything & then getting to re-record her old work she realized she wasn’t done w fame at a big level & in her true extrovertedness wanted to be out & wanted to be w someone she could be seen w in public…private, not secret…supportive…so the fact he was unwilling to compromise w her & from various things it seems as if he’s a bit pretentious & maybe even mocked her level of fame….

Samir

So her comment before singing the lakes was because Chicago borders one of the Great Lakes (Lake Michigan) and thus makes sense why she sang this song here! Something else I wanted to say, purely from memory (so I could be mistaken), but I think the speech before The lakes was the last piano speech of the tour, at least up until Aaron comes out to make an appearance for a piano song but then the piano song is played first

Teri M

WOW this weekend had some offensive SS. Thank you for your re-fathomings!

Joe Weaver

I think it's the Patreon video office and downstairs is the YouTube video studio. 😂 I have no idea if this is actually upstairs but in my mind I've decided it is.

Lively_Ash

FUCK!!!!! I have NEVER fathomed the connection between I don’t wanna live forever & you’re losing me!!!! EXCUSE ME!! Illegal!! Now I need to go sit in the closet w my wine & fathom & cry!!

Rachel

OMG - The Bear! There is a line in the show (cannot remember which episode) "I just try to keep my side of the street clean" I've always wondered if its a Taylor reference!

Kristen

chicago n1 was my show!! we sit right on lake michigan and soldier field is right by the water. i nearly dropped when she mentioned the lake bc i am a massive the lakes stan. i thought she might do the great war too bc we’re at soldier field, but this entire weekend was offensive

Gab

the lakes was my ivy, it was so devastating and i love it so much 🥹🥹🥹

Corinne Karch

I was there N2 and she seemed like she was really going through it during the sad songs. The happy songs were still happy but the sad songs... my friends and I turned to each other so many times going "is she ok??" - then we were soooo fucked up during IDWLF we were barely singing along bc we were just processing all the emotion!!! I feel blessed to have been there to help her cope as an audience member

Katie LaFave

i really thought she would do the lakes in Minnesota because it's known as the land of a thousand lakes! like the famous navy pier stretches into Lake Michigan, but otherwise i don't think Chicago is known for their lakes

Emma Baumert

Chicago is known for being built next to one of the Great Lakes, Lake Michigan. Also, I was born and raised in Chicago and I was at the shows that weekend. One of the most nostalgic things about the lakes for me is that I grew up on a street called Windermere Way in Illinois.

kienan

Love the idea of Faith Hill and Shania on the Debut vaults buuuuuut um we need Kenny Chesney on debut tv omg !!

Lin Gill

Loving your secret song refathomings. Emily, your hair looks very cute like this! Not sure if you ladies are aware, but this week on Travis Kelce's podcast, New Heights, with his brother Jason, he dropped a little bit of tea. He said that he wanted to do some podcasts from Europe and Australia next year. It sounds like Travis will be joining Taylor on some international Eras Tour dates. Maybe you will get to see him in the crowd at your shows. Also, I am so hoping that Bonny gets the Reputation announcement at one of her shows in February.

Natalie T

Chicago is right on Lake Michigan! One of the Great Lakes of North America!! There is a river too, but if you look at a map you will see it is on the tip of Lake Michigan and there are many city public beaches right on the lake. The lake is so huge that it has waves and tides like the ocean!! 🌊🚤 Also The Bear is superior and Jamie Lee Curtis should win all the awards for her character!

Lin Gill

I agree. I feel like it would be too much for her to have all those new songs from TS 11 that she can't represent in an Era on this current tour. She can still incorporate Rep and Debut vault tracks into the Eras Tour secret songs, which will be amazing!

Emma Skilbeck

Hey besties, i loved your Sabrina carpenter fruitcake reaction, and I have a suggestion to do a breakdown on taylors holiday collection and/or Christmas tree farm! 🎄 lots of love and merry christmas to everyone💗💗💗

chatsandreacts

We did a breakdown of Christmas tree farm last year 💖

chatsandreacts

Omg that’s tea to know you noticed! Honey was definitely going through it 🙏

IsolLazy

Loved this! Also enjoying The Bear, it's so good.

Tess7

I enjoy these refathomings and little catch up videos so much! Emily, your hair is slaying. Bonny, I’m sorry you are in a sad mood. I am sending you both warm wishes for the holidays and fun times in 2024 😍

Katie LaFave

yes one of the great lakes called lake michigan is also in chicago

Rachael P

So interesting your take on the Bejeweled lyric. I took 'Do you have a man? I can still say I don't remember' is a threat, in a similar way 'I'm going out tonight' is. Like if some random guy comes onto her she might not say she's taken.

Jeebs

I Wish You Would is a top 5 song for me.

Julie

“A Song for Everything” is a great Maren gateway song if you want to listen to her more - there’s so much to fathom in Maren’s songs as well!

Lucy sloane

Hi guys! Love your videos so much - thank you for all the fun content and effort you put into each one! I have a suggestion for a cool series of videos. You could do a video breakdown of the best lyrics from each album. Then when you have done each album you could do a video compiling the best lyrics from each album? It could be fun as it could be both your personal favourites and objectively the best lyrics of each album! Merry Christmas xx

Erica

Hi I’m from Chicago 🙋🏼‍♀️ Chicago (the city) is literally right on one of The Great Lakes 😆 they are so grand that you would think they are the ocean because you can’t see where they end. That’s why Chicago is so windy. It’s the lake effect. ❤️

Katie LaFave

in the US we have Blake Lively and Ryan Reynolds!!! yes i know Ryan's Canadian, but they do live in new york so it counts

Jade

I got engaged in the Lake District and the reason I went there with my bf was because of Taylor’s song! Superior moment 🫶🏼

Courtney D

I love these (our little catch-ups!) Also, I Wish You Would sounds different now that we have the Vaults (Emily's hand motions, hahaha)

raheel

!!!!!!I BATHE IN CLIFFSIDE POOLS, WITH MY CALAMITOUS LOVE AND INSURMOUNTABLE GRIEF!!!!!!! Noo help actually every time I listen to the lakes I am unwell and this lyrics just absolutely fucks me up!!!! Help!!!

raheel

Also as a rep stan I am actually in desperate need of TS11… Idk I actually rly love the 2 re-recordings and then new album rotation… I just feel like there’s soooo much we need to know like give me TS11 and then next year REPTV+DEBUTTV. Kinda would slay!

Cristina

I really appreciate when you guys do a roundup of all the clowning around a certain topic that starts to get momentum! Really fun to see all the "evidence" together 😁 thank you!

Anna-Liesa

I had a fathoming about Hits different when we found out about the timeline: what if they were taking a break when he went away filming the movie? As in they are not really broken up but they are not seeing each other kind of trying to figure out what is happening and if they are over. Then the lyrics “cursed the space that I needed“ makes more sense. And “I heard your key turn in the door down the hallway Is that your key in the door? Is it okay? Is it you?“ makes also sense because she is like Are you coming home? Are we okay? Did we both realised during the time you were away that we love each other? Don’t know but these lyrics made no sense to be before but know I kind of get it

Angela.

The stadium is right next to a lake. You can see it in the nosebleeds. I want nothing more than to go back to Chi night 1 😩😩😩

Lin Gill

Just finished the whole video and I see that you did fathom Travis's tea! Love it!

sophie

i would absolutely not survive if there's a rep vault song featuring LORDE?!?!?, bonny you can't be saying these things

LadyQ

I absolutely LOVE your hair Emily! Very cute cut!

Shannon Gilhooly

Em your hair is looking quite adorable today

libby

hi! i’m from michigan. yes. chicago is right next to Lake Michigan. HOWEVER, the state of Michigan is surrounded by 4 of the Great Lakes, so being a michigan girlie, i was very upset that chicago got this song and not us😭

Geneva

EM YOUR HAIR LOOKS EVEN BETTER THAN BEFORE ESPECIALLY WITH THE BANGS AND I DID NOT KNOW THAT WAS POSSIBLE

Geneva

It's so funny how Bonny was like "I need you to be quiet" when she literally sings overtop of every rerecord the first time they listen to it LOL love you Bonny :'D

Jeebs

Legit question…I always thought IDWTLF was written specifically for the movie and books…

Bri

I was at Chicago N2 and I was fully hoping it was Keith Urban, but Maren was great! Also IDWLF was amazing to see. I’ll never forget how long it took me to realize what song it was because I never considered it to be a contender for surprise songs. 😂

Filip d1930

Your hair, Em! Slaying!! No longer a mullet😆

Emma

My weekend!! I was there all three nights. Elite songs imo

Rose Ellen

Recently I've been feeling like Bejeweled might have been inspired by her outing at the Brit Awards in May 2021 - we hadn't seen her for a while and she wore that offensive bejeweled two-piece set. I've never seen her look so good!! I think that was when she got the Global Icon award or something? She had such a good time that night and looked so much like herself and so happy. Haim was there as well. I feel like she might have really fathomed that night that she could still light up the room and be bejeweled and that she enjoyed that side of her life.

Cassandra

GIRL reaction!! I love maren

Lin Gill

That's just illegal! I would not have survived.

Lin Gill

Yes. "The Bones" is an offensively good song. I love Maren too. I saw her in concert in Florida in 2019.

Ruby256

Well Bonny has just immediately made me extremely emotionally attached to the prospect of a Lorde or Hozier feature that we have absolutely zero proof or hint or evidence of ever happening I can’t 😭

Cher

I would give anything for another collab with the Chicks on debut TV. Soon You’ll Get Better was obviously perfect but an upbeat collab that is more appropriate for scream-singing would end me.

Cher

Agreed, I love these “currently clowning” segments!

Bella

Hope you are ok Bonny ❤️

chatsandreacts

The way I CHOKED when he got tickets like it wasn’t THE GREAT WAR

chatsandreacts

HAHAHAHAH us Swifties definitelyyyyyyy know Taylor’s songs better than she does 😂

Jenn Hamel

Like does she even know Christmases When You Were Mine exists??

Juliana Martinez

like she showed more emotion in sad songs in the set list? like champagne problems maybe? or…?

Swift and Swigs with Sibs Podcast

Emily! I don't know if we're talking about this officially or not....but your hair is V CUTE! Keep it going! Love you both, obvi!

Moni

the river flows into lake michigan which is a huge lake! chicago is known for its lake beaches across the city hahaha

Roxyy

I'm rooting for Beyonce on Reputation, might be a big wish but I can dream xD

Swiftie_mixer

Proud to say castles crumbling was my most listened to song in my Spotify wrapped this year 💜

forevermore

my fave part of this video so far is bonnie telling emily “i need you to be quiet” then exchanging an ily 💕

GIE

Ohmygood yes posty for rep tv 😭

Jake Bobrowski

From Chicago, Lake Michigan borders the city on the east side!

M3L

Ladies! Interview with Eras choreographer Mandy Moore just dropped!!

Katie K

As someone who will be going to a London show something I’m worried about is loosing out on Long Live and having it replaced with Castles Crumbling. I love that song but Long Live is LONG LIVE!! I need to scream that in a stadium. I’d be sad if either Long Live or Enchanted are replaced to be honest! But I guess we’ll have to wait until May to find out! 🙏🏻💜

Katie K

Also yes, have thought a lot about potential Rep & Debut collabs and think Lorde would be top tier on Rep 🤌🏼 I also thought maybe Sabrina would suit it quite well too or Troye Sivan, he was a guest on the Rep tour of course. Hozier I hadn’t considered but I would 💀 As for Debut I’m very much board with Shania Twain and Tim McGraw. I have a whole bunch of her old unreleased tracks on my laptop and I can already imagine which tracks would make perfect collabs with them too!! 😭💚💚💚

Anika W

chicago night 1!! soldier field is actually on the shore of lake michigan. from my seat at the stadium i was looking out at the lake behind the stage and could see all the boats on the water. sooo beautiful

Kendall

Loved this reaction! Also super random, but I just came across the Eras Tour choreographer talking about the tour and working with Taylor if you guys want to watch and/or react 🩵 The link is below or you can look up “Dance Dish” on YouTube if you haven’t seen it yet! Here is the link: https://youtu.be/tOKrEVW_ge0?si=Gk7CMBgK_PTM3Ce8

Annika 📍Melb, AU

This is a bit random, but I'm also an Annika W (just with an extra 'N'). It's an unusual name, so I don't often meet people with a similar name! Hi!

alex

Sending you a big hug Bonny! You’re not alone with your feelings🫶🏼

alex

Is there a possibility that you girls could put the melodrama breakdown on Patreon? I think it’s been taken down by YouTube and I would LOVE to watch it again🥺

Starsonscars

Kenny Chesney on a Debut vault colab!!! ❤️❤️

Ava Jeffs

Emily was my exact reaction when Bonny said lorde….SUPERIOR

Rhiannon W.

I second this! I went to look for it and would love to watch it again.

T

Did you guys see that the choreographer for eras tour said the first time taylor saw the choreography for willow she cried???? Ugh. I love this information

Joe Weaver

Wait, you randomly started talking about The Bear when she's in the stadium for the Chicago Bears. I love the coconut hair now, Emily! At first I wasn't a fan but I think it's really working now! My rep theory is announcement in February and it comes out before she goes to Europe in May.

Joe Weaver

I'm pretty sure the no speech era starts when Long Live joins the set list. The lakes...I'm surprised she didn't save it for Minnesota since it's the land of 10,000 lakes!

Joe Weaver

If I'm remembering correctly I'm pretty sure I was convinced Keith Urban was the guest on this night. And then Maren Morris!

Joe Weaver

How does Taylor Swift know the most about Taylor Swift songs? It's so unfair.

Joe Weaver

Fighting the urge to go figure out how many times she mentions red during Red...

Erica Robinson

Can’t wait to see Detroit. I was there and she was definitely sad.

Erica Robinson

I was also hoping she would sing The Lakes in Michigan

Erica Robinson

Yes so shocked! I’m from Michigan too

Nick S

I want a Halsey collab so badly!

Taylah Louise

The cinematography of the bear is unmatched!

Hannah S

Chicago N2 was my show! 💗

Katie K

I would definitely be here for a Maren Morris album reaction video sometime 🤍 I’d really love you guys to react to Kelsea Ballerini’s EP Rolling Up The Welcome Mat too

mon

Chicago N2 girlie here!

Tsukiakari1203

i wish you did the whole speech because Maren talked for a bit before they played the song and it's adorable

Chloé

Not sure if it has been said before but I think Maren Moris is actually moving from country to pop and I believe is working with Jack Antonoff !!!

Elis Llinares

5 words: Don’t Blame Me feat. Hozier

Sacred_sunflower

The Lakes she’s referring to in Chicago are the Great Lakes. The one in America is Lake Michigan, the others are in Canada 🍁

Nathalie Richter

Yes! As soon as we figured out that she was doing songs connected to the places I thought we were getting London boy or KOMH because they mention Motown! But then I figured if not we’d get the lakes or a song about cars like getaway car! But nope none of those hahaha

subtle reads

You can count how many time she says "red" on the red album by looking in the lyric book of the original album or the re-record (I don't remember which one it is) because she highlights the word in red font every time it's mentioned in the lyrics

Gulce Akpinar

I have always heard as “wasted” 🙈

Alexa Foster

Maren Morris is such a freaking QUEEN and I’d love for you fathom!

Evan

I was there night 1 and she was so excited that we knew IWYW, she was very social that night haha

Curt Decker

Hits Different was my number 1 song on Spotify wrapped heheh. Hits Different on repeat foreverrrrr

aubrey

I love that she referred to the lakes in chicago kind of being more like oceans lol! Maren was such a slay. Every weekend has so much! Ah!

Meghan Carty

This Minnesotan must tell ya that they all border the US and Canada ;)

Mia Morgan

The Moment I Knew recognition ❤️

EJ1989

Sorry but like no as a Swiftie and a Directioner I just need ZAYN on that song if it’s on Rep TV 😭

ToadHemain

always gonna cry about the fact she played the lakes in chicago and NOT minnesota the state of 10,000 lakes...

Takara

the lakes is my all time fav. That night broke me

Madison McIntosh

Hahahahha Chicago in on one of “the Great Lakes” and it legit looks like an ocean you can’t see the other side of it

Chloe

No one understands, I deeply, deeply need The Lakes at Liverpool N2😭😭😭😭

Taylor

So about the lakes, us Michigander Swifties thought we might get the lakes, and our weekend was next after this. Yes Chicago is at the end of one of the great lakes, but Michigan is in between 2 great lakes and we have a million smaller lakes scattered across the state. It was definitely a blow that day 😂

Ellie Vannest

right!! I remember being so mad cuz Michigan is literally "The Great Lakes State" 😭

Lauren S.

You can literally see one of the great lakes from the stadium

Laura

The fact that you guys predicted the Post Malone collab 🤣🫣

Makayla

When Bonny said “I need you to be quiet” to Emily I also stopped singing🤣 I was just immediately like yes ma’am!🫡

Talia Adams

Chicago is on Lake Michigan which is actually quite huge and is the length of the city of Chicago into the suburbs. It essentially just looks like a whole coast line

yuki 🤍

alksjdlfk Bonny literally manifested a post malone collab into existence SLKDFLDKS

Jennifer Lopez

Not you guys manifesting the posty collab. Also you guys totally manifested getting red, getaway car and I wish you would

Megs

watching this on April 15th, and it so wild to hear you say "we're just assuming an announcement in Feb 2024" as well as, "The taylor that burns the house down looks like her current style, enters the 1989 room which is what she just released" ... and she sits down at a desk... this woman is truly a mastermind and it's offensive and concerning EVERY. TIME.

boleynns

literally came over here after I fully fathomed the level and depth of the heartbreak she felt from the matty breakup, and thought "wait, when was that overly sad surprise song..." -- and here it is, the exact weekend, I am dying. I need them to do a full re-re-fathoming of this, because we were all so SO off base.

Andrea Valdivia-Gago

OMG, my thoughts exactly! we were SO off base! i feel like maroon, now that we don't talk and question? are all about Matty, so much to re-fathom!

boleynns

I have such egg on my face for thinking Maroon was simply a sequel to Red 😂 but yeah, Question for sure, labyrinth, I think also Snow on the Beach, High Infidelity, the 1, cardigan, illicit affairs, gold rush, ivy, cowboy like me, and probably others and more all need complete re-fathomings. Its wild.

GIE

👀 — it was about Matty fckn healy

GIE

SHE SANG THE LAKES WHERE ALL THE POETS WENT TO DIE WHEN SHE WAS GRIEVING ON HER RELATIONSHIP WITH MATTY!!!! I am unwell

GIE

Lmao- this doesn’t aged well

Gabriela Mariotto

coming back after TTPD is released and see the amount of easter eggs is just crazy, the lakes, the little smile while saying "or have they come to take me away?"... I just canttt

C

Then... "or just lost the love of my life" at 46:55 to now... "you're the loss of my life" in loml. I just can't 😭

Courtney Schmidt

Watching this for the first time (as a Patreon newbie) because Chicago N3 was my show, i missed Maren by one night!...Bonny and your fathoming of a Post Malone callab!? 🤯 This aged well! 😄 🫶

Deborah

the loml easter egg here is TOO MUCH FOR THE SOUL

Breezy Bumbles

We had no idea how much Matty meant to her. It’s hard to watch this after TTPD.

broccolit0

POST MALONE MENTION!!

Breezy Bumbles

“There’s absolutely nothing that could convince me that this is about Matty Healy” - Emily 🤣😂🤣😂🙃😵‍💫🙄🤦‍♀️🫠😭

Brenda1989

Do we think she went and wrote imgonnagetyouback right after this??

Jennifer K

Can we get a RE-re-fathoming of these shows?

Mary Massed

I feel like you need to re refathom this now that we know how she was actually feeling after the Matty breakup! 😂😂

Mary Massed

I just typed that then saw your comment! I feel like post ttpd it’s necessary!

Hoostock

Emily really love your backing vocals

Sana 🇵🇸

Chicago is legit on Lake Michigan 😂

JC

Lost the love of my life — You’re the loss of my life. Also did she ever mash up Maroon with I don’t want to live forever? Because at lease the verses could totally be played over each other musically as well as thematically