Home
Creators
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

SECRET SONG Reaction: Singapore (Night 1) (Patreon)

Published:
2024-03-03 05:55:46
Imported:
2026-09
Tags:

Content

Sorry for the delay besties! WTF WAS THAT MEETING ABOUT?? We are confused

Files

Comments

Daisy

perfect timing yayayayayaya

tiamat

I HAD BEEN WAITING. CAN'T WAIT

Emily Eyrich

Mine X Starlight…. aka my two fav songs … JAIL JAIL FOR HER

Rachel

Post issues are literally the most frustrating

Emma

Soooo concerning!! What is she plotting?!

DML

SHE IS SCHEMING AND IM TERRIFIED!!!

Rebecca

I'm so concerned about the the Rep coding going on

Alysia Rene

At this point she's just messing with us to mess with us

Joe Weaver

We were all very, very confused!

Jordan Bush

SHES ONLY CRYPTIC AND MACHIAVELLIAN BC SHE CAAARRREESSS

Becky Tucker

Bonny, your curls are gorgeous!!!!!

Katie LaFave

please please please do another travis video when you get the chance!!!

Katie LaFave

she looked so happy during IDWLF

Lutfi

Singapore N2 is her 13th show of 2024. I can't wait for what Taylor has up her sleeves!!! 😱😍🤯

Josh

Taylornation and Taylor Swift were also using the black heart emoji last night...reputation???

khushi04

she knows she can mess with us and she’s doing it and we’re falling for it.

Yuli

missed you guys hellloooo🥹🥹🥹

Lindarose Farias

I’m convinced that she is hinting that the rep tour will go to Disney+ with the Eras tour

Ellie Vannest

the first time she played dress was on the guitar

lachdav

dress was on guitar last time with that offensive pairing with exile on piano

Alejandro Flecha

TN & TS comments i; regards to the second mashup all had black heart emojis, the lives title had a black heart and so did TNs tweets, both regarding the TTPD meeting

Jenny M

Mine & Starlight mashup totally illegal but awesome at the same time.

Alejandro Flecha

they used the black heart instead of the white one for TTPD, Rep TV is coming

Benson

I think something illegal might be happening tonight we need you to stay up for it for this once!!!

Kayla Smith

I’m wondering if this is Taylor telling us the tone of TTPD…..because IDWTLF and Dress have the same sort of sexy/dark vibe and I agree, there were parts of both songs that were purposefully not sung so is this telling us that this is what to expect for TTPD?!?! Superior!

Jeebs

Someone pointed out on Twitter that she last sang Dress on 8/7 (travis's number)

Helen Dunham

I don’t think her going live was an error. I also have no idea why she did it. Maybe she saw Tess wasn’t going to be live yesterday and wanted us to have those songs. 😆

Julia

Oh they need to see the little part before the piano where she plays the wrong note. That was this show right?!

christian scotlan

there was actually a teeny tiny speech before the 2nd song but its oh so very weird and curious, check it out and we need your guys' opinions

Jack B

I guess you could say that there was no explanation, only reputation 🤔

Jami Marie

I agree, don’t blame me performance is amazing & my fav song on rep <33

Christine Violet

I don’t mind the different versions, if you don’t want to spend that much money, just don’t buy them. But what does bother me is that there are different songs on each version… which puts into question if there will be a variant that has all the bonus tracks on it. It just sucks that you wouldn’t get all the songs on every version. Just like with midnights 3am songs not being in vinyl format at all. It’s hard for us broke completionists! 😂♥️

ttpd-24

There was a item on tiktok saying the album is in Taylor’s words “fiery” about coming out of a long relationship and only a few songs about Joe. Maybe that’s a hint!

Talia Adams

Wait...I don't think Singapore N1 was a Thursday...? Am I getting my timezones mixed up? It was 3am Saturday morning for me here in the US so it was a Saturday night show in Singapore. Anyways, mother has us all confused over here!

Katie LaFave

this night was giving travis to me

Liv

Please make a Taylor and Travis Super Bowl and after party fathoming soon!!!!

Rachel

I'm pretty sure yesterday was a Saturday in Singapore right?? the time zones make everything confusing.

Jessica

When Taylor went live last night, Taylor Nation tweeted “#TSTTPD , please come to order.👩‍⚖️ Our Chairman is speaking: (link to livestream)” Also she named the livestream “A message from the department 🖤”

Amelia Evans

yes I was lolling at how many times they were convinced it was Thursday

Sivan Moshe

Not you keep saying next show is a Friday show while recording this on a Sunday 😭

Kirrily Lewis

Definitely a REP easter egg. That’s why they went live with the black heart 🖤 what else could it mean. Not that it tells us much about when it’s coming but she is definitely going to eff us up

Caroline

Dress was on the guitar last time! I’m so glad she switched the instrument 🖤

Takara

Dress was on guitar LA night 4 (I was there) she did exile on piano that night 👀

Talia Adams

Haha okay it wasn't just me! I was like, I don't even know what day it is anymore in the TSCU!

Eilidh

This is a stretch, but maybe Taylor skipping the "Dodged a bullet or just lost the love of my life" verse in IDWLF could be linked to "loml" on Tortured Poets. Potentially hinting at a lead single, or hinting that the "L" is the acronym for "Loss" rather than "Love." Or maybe the livestream was just a funny mistake.

Tess7

Last night was so confusing lol loved getting your thoughts on it. I did know Andrea was In Singapore as a kid - I swear she talked about it in an interview or behind the scenes in one of the tour videos…I can’t remember exactly where I saw her discussing it. Looks like you’ve made a lot of progress on the filming space at Emily’s . Sorry for the delay with DHL. Can’t wait for the full tour of the finished room 😊

Katie LaFave

this show is from Saturday not Thursday

Krystal

Doesn't adjourned mean postponed?

Katie LaFave

last time she performed dress on the guitar then paired it with that SUPERIOR performance of exile

Kiki

Basically yes! It means you started it, stopped for whatever reason and will resume at a later date

Takara

don’t blame me for what you made me dooooooo 🧎‍♀️

Laila

Girls, did you see the comparison between the last ttpd version's album cover and a shot of Joe from a movie he starred called The Last Letter From Your Lover?? Those are almost identical!!!!

Katie LaFave

absolutely disagree about call it what you want. top 3 on rep for me!!!

Erica

You guys didn’t even clown about Rep TV. I’m so surprised since it was two Rep songs mashed up!

Kaitlin Hilton

i highly doubt "🖤" was a mistake...

Maria McElroy

Guys when Taylor’s page went live, the caption was “A message from the department…..” and then it was just the end of the mashup and then her diving!?!?

Katie LaFave

yesss Em you need to fathom don't blame me!!! also top 3 on rep for me

Krystal

Thank you! Girls interpretation of that tweet confused me a bit.

Kiki

Taylor very well knows what she did - she's teasing us so hard. The black hearts, the blacked out website, the surprise songs being from Rep era (I count IDWLF since it's from 2017) ... The exile ends 2 3 (March 2nd) from the Bejeweled music video, the last time she played Dress she paired it with Exile ... The source code saying 2 months from now (May 2nd) which is the day of the infamous Met Gala ... I'm clowning so hard during the Singapore leg 🤡

Takara

taylorswifthockeybro on YT made a video about last night that has some really interesting theories 👀

chatsandreacts

Omg you’re right?! Woops, I’ve definitely lost track of the days 😂

Hannah

i was there it was insane

seefany

Oh my, realizing that I wasn't the only one clowning last night meant the world to me lol! Also thought there was going to be an announcement for the 4th edition of TTPD, never mind. Towards the last part, wanted to give a shout out to "Betty". I'm definitely a Betty stan and it is also my fav song on the album. (Now thinking back and realizing how funny it was when I got confused during my first hearing, thought it was about a lesbian relationship, then heard the name "James" and finally cleared up all my questions.

Mex

I will sometimes open spotify, go to rep, and skip straight to dress. the break at say my name and everything just stops is perfection. it's good to see you girlies and i look forward to whatever chaos taylor unleashes on us tonight!

seefany

Also, it seemed odd that she didn't sit in and savor the chant after performing "Champagne Problems" so it only went on for like 50 seconds

Jenna Bolmgren

Yes I don’t mind the variants either, and we know she’ll put them on streaming eventually, but I really don’t like having to pay for shipping each time (especially since they’re exclusive and won’t be in stores)

Lauren

BIG LOL to Bonny not realising starlight was a different song 🤣🤣 such a seemless mash up choice! Also looks like i'm staying up past my bedtime tonight for another board meeting tayloorrrr

Sam Jayne

I'm sure there is some deeper meaning to this weird live-with-no-annoucement incident (as there usually is), but I actually really, really just love the idea that she was supposed to announce a TTPD variant, everything was good to go so they went live and then she just... completely forgot. And the livestream team was panicking slightly, just being like "keep the live going, she might just say it at the end of the mashup instead..." and then she didn't. She just goes off-stage so they cut the live-stream and TN's tweet at the end of it is them trying to just play it cool and pretend that a non-announcement was the plan all along 😂 Especially because the stores were blacked out then re-opened with no visible changes... I just love imagining the behind-the-scenes panic of everyone if it really was that she just forgot to announce anything

Jenn Hamel

You simply need to be fathoming what Shyla realized about TAYLOR going live vs. Taylor Nation (it’s been HER account going live for all the TTPD announcements) it’s because JOE ALWYN follows her still and not TN…she wants him notified. She wants him SCARED.

ton

Here’s my theory… TTPD was on hiatus whilst they dropped a Rep vault Easter egg called IDWLF…. not sure if you were aware that the shop went white during each of the TPD variant drops as well so not that unusual

maya zutra

Dying about the confusion which day was yesterday today and tomorrow

Ana

Call it what you want is so Lover, though. For me it's "so it goes.." that only gets higher in my ranking for Rep. And I'm team Emily -- I will take LWYMMD over Don't blame me live on Eras tour any day

Kristen

ok is anyone else delulu enough to think that maybe she is pairing two songs with such opposite views of the same topic (like what Bonny says) because she is hinting that she’s going to surprise drop rep on us before tortured poets 😅 like we get no explanation, just reputation in March… then BOOM we’re smacked with the other half of their story in April?! and that explains all the twos ✌️ that have been happening? a back-to-back drop??? 🤡

Kristen

omg i didn’t even think of the exile connections!! now i’m clowning even more

raheel

OMG. But what IF?!?! The black HEART?! The REP SONGS? Going live but no announcement?! M sorry but there is nothing ever accidental with Taylor!!!! But I was like surely she is not just going to drop REP tv without no explanation?! Music gets dropped on friday… BUT IN SINGAPORE FRIDAY IS ONLY „TODAY“ 🤡 🤡 🤡 no m actually scared for today!!!!!!!!!!!!

anntallogy

i love how you don`t know the actual day of the week

angel (plnkblue)

i do want to say that for all the live streams these past few weeks that have accompanied the variant announcements, they ALL were on taylor's account--not taylor nation, or at least, not just taylor nation. i only follow taylor herself and was able to see the "going live" notification on her; her going live last night was not weird in an of itself. just what she decided to do sdfdsfds

Reese

Yes! You guys show make a video of like talking about your fav performance from eras or maybe one from each tour movie!

Emma

Wait you didn’t talk about this and maybe didn’t get the information.. as you said the website went down and required a password like it has been doing before every new variant announcement. BUT, before, the password screen has always been white (for TTPD) and now when you clicked on the like “shop now” and were redirected to the merch/shop password protected website the screen was completely BLACK!! Also when Taylor went live the title of the live was “A message from the department 🖤”, with a BLACK heart emoji!! The other lives she has done for the other announcements has had the exact same title but with white heart, why was it black now?!? And when it was black she proceeded to sing basically two rep songs.. And after the show Taylor nation tweeted “See you all tmrw for N2! 🖤” with BLACK heart emoji there as well. I find the usage of black all of a sudden very curious since it’s been nothing but white hearts and visuals so far for TTPD🤔 soo what does it mean?? Is she hinting at something

Annika

I don’t think they knew that the website was black and not white & that there was a black heart instead of a white one 👀

ton

I think it’s just IDWLF is in Rep vault is the message

Kimberly

Yes Dress is superior!!

Krystal

isnt it sunday in singapore? :D

Candice Plendl

Dress was guitar and exile piano - ALSO wearing the yellow dress, LA N4

Emelie

The 'I've been looking sad in all the nicest places' is giving me 'I can do it with a broken heart'.. especially when she was so broken when she did IDWLY last time...

raheel

Oh then I understood them wrong, guess they meant in australia the second night is a friday. 🤡🤡🤡 the clown came fast for me LMAO

karisa

i am SUCH A BETTY STANN i’m so happy you fathom emily 😭😭🫶🏼 i was SO HAPPY that it was on the eras tour!!!!!!!!!

Graciekay

Haha guys todays show is the Sunday show not the Friday 😭🫶🏼

Claudy

Call it what you want was always top 10 for me, but since the live version on the eras tour, it’s just sad. Kinda like Cornelia street. They were cute love songs, now they are super emotionally charged.

Filippa

I would looove that

M3L

So DHL sucks in all countries??

Sara🇸🇪

I am totally with you guys about call it what you want! I think it has lost its energy with the breakup maybe!

codi treacy

SO confused too?!! and the black hearts they have been using.. SORRYYY??

Kat

Hiii girls! I just have a tiiiiny suggestion (that im sure everyone will LOVE hehe) and that is when u react (and chat) about the eras tour movie you could split it into eras -like a full 30 min video about one era like fave performances, live experience, outfit variations etc 🤩 we love your chats a lot and i think that you wouldn’t feel rushed (so that the video is not too long) also there’s a break coming in for the eras shows sooooo 😏😏

Nele

She was absolutely KILLING it vocally during idwlf x dress 🤌 she also had a slight rasp in her voice so I hope her voice is fine but it sounded so perfect for these songs

Alberto

OK BUT LIKE THE BLACK HEARTS EVERYWHERE??? THE TWOS?? they’re definitely up to somethingggg

Ayesha Sayle

Hate clowning for rep cause we know what's happened in the past butttt guys, this is the only time the tweet has had a black heart emoji!! its usually a white one...!?!? and everyone is also mentioning the continuous 'two' thing that keeps re-occuring. Also after she finished the piano songs, she played TWO extra keys... what is HAPPENING, I cannot

hauntedwillow27

complete overview of what happened: - taylornation tweeted earlier in the day something to the effect of “there will be a tortured poets meeting later” - during the 1989 set her website goes completely BLACK?? people went into the source code and realized it was on purpose and they put a black screen there. - she announced nothing, but that little wave at the end is giving rep tour to me - while she sang the second set, she went live on HER account (530k views in like 5 minutes btw) and it said “a message from the department 🖤” . curious because previously she used a white heart so this is why everyone is clowning for rep tv from the heart and the screen. - ALSO?? if you clicked the top right of the black screen it brought you to a “Password” page. everyone was of course trying to figure it out but no one did. - people in the source code found that it said “twoMonthsFromNow” which would be May 2nd, the 123rd day of the year. about a Fortnight after april 19th, so what is that date??? - after a while her website just went back to normal. no explanation. very odd. - oh also people were speculating something would happen on 3/2 because “exile ends 3…2..”. now people think something will happen tomorrow because it’s 3/3 and she’s been having a lot of “two ✌️” stuff going on. also 3 + 3 = 6. standard rep clowning 😂😂

Makayla

I feel the EXACT SAME WAY about call it what you want!! It’s so disappointing cause I used to looooove that song but it just leaves a bad taste in my mouth now😣

Katrien010

It was so confusing following everything live lmao, THE CHAOS😅

Ebru

So many people have complained about the different variants for one added song, and some even cancelled their preorders. I’m reaching, but I wonder if they’ll bring out a deluxe edition which MAY override the outer two 🤔 or maybe IDWTLF is getting a re-record?

Tiggy

Am I crazy for thinking she’ll release tortured poets and rep tv on the same day? I know it sounds insane but we never know what she’s gonna do! And rep is the first album about Joe and it’s them falling in love and tpd could very well be the last album about Joe and about them falling out of love and breaking up. I know it’s crazy but I kinda feel like this could happen.

Abby

i've always thought that some of the production in idwlf sounds a lot like dress! i can't explain it haha but i think they fit together so well!

Marcelo Gouveia

Tbh guys I’d rather u guys reacting afterwards, being able to stop it and stuff. Immaculate reaction, love u

Johanna

I think Taylor Nation might be taking over the streaming of the secret songs and potentially monetizing our ability to watch. This was a test run, I think.

Nancy

You guys simply need to be reading some of the hilarious tweets in the midst of the confusion after the live stream 💀💀

tommy

"there will be no further explanation, there will just be reputation" .....

ruby

Lots of people have been claiming that the reason she didn’t say anything and then played two rep songs was a nod to “there will be no explanation their will just be reputation” as an Easter egg??

Lisa

I still love Call It What You Want and I think it was very true for her at the time, but it definitely has changed.

Katie K

I know it was so confusing!! Wtf was even happening? Yes, that was the @taylorswift live you were watching there for the piano. That’s why it was so good! And Taylornation also prefaced the SS section on Twitter by saying “TSTTPD please come to order, our chairman is speaking…” which from what I’ve seen has only happened on the variant announcement nights so I guess there must’ve been some miscommunication going on! 🤣🤡 Superior duo of mashups though!!

Katie K

Also girls I don’t know if you’ve seen this in relation to The Albatross variant but I found it VERY concerning: https://vm.tiktok.com/ZGeUPgoG6/ The imagery being so similar and I’ve seen The Last Letter From Your Lover film that Joe was in and he plays a really cold toxic husband. I’m very alarmed.

Rafael Pelegrine

As for now I don't think she'll release rep tv before TTPD. She wouldn't do that because it would impact sales and streams too much. Imagine for example a rep vault track being #1 and not the lead single from the new album. It would also diminish TTPD's impact and lower the chances of a Grammy

Sanya Sharma

When Taylor’s account went live on Instagram the caption also had a black heart (while all the TTPD announcements have been with a white heart) and Taylor nation also tweeted after the show with a black heart!! With all the two’s there is def something coming

✨Bri✨

I’m with you Bonny! Don’t Blame Me is one of the best performances on the eras tour. It’s in the top for me along with My Tears Ricochet and of course the chill inducing Illicit Affairs.

ImagineDragonlords

Don't Blame Me is such a stadium song, like I think it is DESIGNED to be played live to a huge crowd, that's when it's truly FATHOMED

Bruna Tendrich

Hey besties just to add on to something, there's a trend on TikTok that has IDWLF and Dress as a mashup. This has been there for more than year... Taylor has seen this for SURE

Hannah

I’m starting to tire of both guitar and piano songs being mashups. While I love not knowing what she’s going to blend together, I miss just getting to enjoy a song from start to finish.

Kenedy

OLD HABITS DIE SCREAMINGGGGGG OMGGG

Sara Rose

I MUST KNOW IF YOU GUYS ARE ALIVE AFTER TONIGHT'S SONGS.

GoldRush31

Exactly my thought too! She has to do Rep around TTPD, it’s the first chapter and the last chapter. And the anticipation is building so much that she still can give no explanation.

Megan

We need the reaction to LSS last night!!!!

Christina

As soon as I heard the IS IT OVER NOWWWW I immediately was like oh this is supposed to sound like ARE WE OUT OF THE WOOODS so 100% with you Bonny Also clowning for a TTPD/rep double release bc WHY else would she go live and sing essentially 2 rep songs?! And all the ✌🏻 that she’s been doing?!?!

noah

call it what you want is still one of my favs but it doesn’t hit the way it used to

pearcemcmahon13

omg Emily I totally agree with you about don't blame me!!! 😅 I've never fully understood the obsession either even though I know it's a good song!

Julia Fisher

I will say I am still a major call it what you want stan... Also, someone help me out why is the show being referenced as a thursday show when it was on saturday march 2?

Jennifer

On another note, The Black Dog (final bonus track name) was what Winston Churchill used to call his depression.

Jimmy Qin

maybe she chose “mine” for the line “city lights on the water” and “starlight” for the line “rocks on the ocean”. These lines are very Singapore coded because Singapore is an island. And also Singapore is known as the City of Star. This mash-up is totally dedicated to Singapore!

Katrina

I don't mind the alternate album covers, but I don't like them having exclusive songs because it feels like pressuring fans to buy multiple albums to get all of them (especially if they aren't on streaming for months). I don't care if other artists do it, it still feels greedy. I'll only buy an album if it has all the songs on it.

Karen Valentino

Ending her guitar mashup with the words “I can see it now” has me thinking she is optimistic her future is with Travis. ❤️

Griffin

I don't think so, they've had over a year of people streaming

Sacred_sunflower

Before she sings “reaching out across the sea” she says “guilty guilty!” Ahhhh guilty as sinnnn?????

Germaine Quek

lost my voice at this show and now idk what to do 😂😂😂

Camille

Probably went live for Travis, so that he can see the performance in nice quality 🥰😆

Hannah Rose

I’m sorry but Bonnie’s lover nail has come off, is that a sign? 😅

Mia

Yeah no I feel like these 2 mash ups & the way she chose only specific parts of the songs to sing was a completely different vibe from the previous ones obviously hinting to TTPD (sad, hinting at cheating, end of a relationship...)

Mia

Btw she performed Dress with the guitar on 8/7 in LA last year

Emily D

I fathomed don’t blame me a few months ago!! The part about “something happened for the first time” combined with the “ohs” makes me think it’s about the first or***sm?? or some other sexual thing she hasn’t done before. my jaw was on the floor when i realized

Mia

Also watching the last variant cover & theme today, the black heart would make sense ; I just wished people would focus on TTPD instead on being obsessed with Rep being released especially when she's made clear how that album was important & personal for her to make. Like clowning was fun before but some be doing too much

Karen Valentino

If someone hasn’t already said it, the black heart is because of the Black Dog Edition. Not Rep. I’m totally confused that I found out about TBD edition from TN and not Taylor herself announcing it. The new edition does have a stunning photo. 😍

Becky

No explanation… just reputation

Amanda H

I was with Bonny - that was the most seamless mashup transition ever🤯

Jaimie C

CIWYW thought - maybe bc there's the video of her singing it to Joe in Miss Americana is why the shine has worn off? makes it harder to change that imprint of her saying 'i love you' to him near the end? otherwise the song lyrically is kinda similar vibes to lss which we're still wild about

Zosia Dabrowski

This is what I did too! Took a few seconds to realise it was a different song, and I'm so excited that when she started playing Mine I predicted Starlight!! It's in writing on Dim That Spotlight on the discord haha

Jennifer

Honesty the Beatles didn't do 37 vinyl variants!! They didn't even put their singles on their albums as they thought that would be unfair.

Kelly Vance

Totally agree with you guys about CIWYW, it’s the one of the reasons that invisible string has fallen to the bottom of folklore for me.

Alyssa Kay

Since y'all have now been to all your Eras Tour shows could you do a ranking of all the performances and rank each Era set? 🤍🖤

Meghan C

I agree! Especially for songs she hasn’t played a full version of yet. I would’ve loved to have heard a full version of long story short last night (although maybe this is her way of not having to sing the Joe-coded parts of songs, like the dress bridge for example)

Mad Esme at the Plaza Athénée

I'm wondering if she specifically took a night off from TTPD vibes to speak to Travis (as she did in Melbourne N3) and that's why she didn't make an announcement. Both Mine and Starlight are romantic and hopeful for the future. The parts she sang both reference being by the water and ocean, which could be a happy memory of their time on the yacht in Sydney. IDWLF and Dress are songs of desire and longing. She left out the sad/negative parts or Joe-coded parts and only sang about wanting to be with him and the impatience of that feeling. I think the whole SS session was for Travis. Maybe she went live anyway so he could get a clear livestream of her message to him 😅.

Carly

Oh no! Invisible string is my #2 favorite song ever in my entire life. But it means so much to me personally - I relate to it so much. And it came out when my (now husband) and I were still in early stages of our relationship. So totally understand if you don't have that relationship with it that it would fall for others.

Michael

Totally agree with the call it what you want . It was one my tops on rep and now like it’s not hitting the same

MelTooWell

DHL is the worst. Americans deal with being told they were not home when nobody showed up to try and deliver stuff, ALL THE TIME. Everytime I see something is coming by DHL I groan, because it's drama. I think the mashup is a hint for TTPD, probably the vibe. I think she's been doing that since she announced the album though. The mash ups she is doing are not random. Look for eggs in all of them.

Alex Engstrom

I was just thinking, she said there would be multiple surprise songs on the eras tour for Disney+ so maybe that is why it is so professional? 🤷🏼‍♂️

Annie

I agree 100% about call it what you want...and I hate it because I LOVE that song...but its actually just sad/irritating-lyric wise now. 😫

Marie S.

i know i'm too early for this BUT after poets comes out i would love if you girls do a deep dive on all the songs that are connected/nods to other ones (either an actual lyric or themes/vibe), specially now with all the breakup stuff etcc would beee very interesting/educational LOL but definitely a video for after poets reactions etccc

Margaux

I DONT KNOW WHY PEOPLE ARE COMPLAINING! We're getting 4 bonus tracks!!!! That is so nice of her to do lol

Chloé

About the ocean she also says in long story short "my waves meet your shore ever and evermore"

lizzy

It's the way they basically tell one story the way she mashed them up, starllight fits as a verse within mine.... "sitting by the water" "skipping rocks on the ocean saying to me".... THE LYRICAL CREATIVITY INT HESE MASHUPS.

Jason

I've sort of been able to put Travis into those songs (dress, call it what you want). Buzz cut hair also applies to Trav, and baby fit like a daydream is even MORE so applicable to Trav than J-word.

Liv

I LOVE Bonny’s hair in this

Lili

It will be interesting to see how these friday mash-ups on the piano then fit with each bonus track ...

Veronica Phillips

And then the mashups tonight had long story short and evermore. Very curious

airjohnpro

Bonny keeps looking into my SOUL and I love it 🥰 (and her curls!)

Jack

Call it what you want - It’s been my fav on rep since it came out and it overall hasn’t changed at all for me. It was really hard to listen to while all the breakup news was going around, but being a actual fan since rep and the connection of the song to becoming a fan I think has helped it remain really special for me personally. Also love you guys both so much ♥️

Jayluxx

as the resident dress stan of existence seeing the dress APPRECIATION in this video is everything to me

Emmy

Can't wait for N2 reaction!! 🤍🖤

Brandi Brock

Can’t wait for your reaction to last night

alysha

oh my god i’m so excited for your reaction to last night! also the confusion was 100% mutual 😭

Natalia

Loving Bonnie’s hair

Nan

I completely agree that the end of "Is It Over Now" is similar to "OOTW" - and I believe that was intentionally done. The song is clearly about Haylor, so it would make sense that it incorporate aspects of "OOTW." YES - AGREED! I think you're correct!

Juliana Martinez

i still really love CIWYW! the melodies, the cadence, the vocals, the bridge. it's all just so good! i do understand why it may be hard to fully appreciate it though because joe is being painted as a villain at the moment. but i just--- i just love the vibes and the backing vocals and everything lol

Rick V

WHAAATTTT! Emily oesn’t like ‘Don’t Blame Me’ ??? Are u kidding me? That along with Delicate is like the Reputation national anthem. Holy shit!

Kristen G

ahhhhh i can’t wait for night 2 reactionnnnn!!! GUYS!! guys.

Maddy!

Ladies I have a request. Can you all please do a breakdown of IDWTLF!!!! I need one asap. the lyrics fuck me up

Maddy!

Okay, okay. I have a little theory breakdown for the people. Kinda longwinded, but stick with me. Ive seen talk in the fandom about how suburban legends is hard to interpret. But as I was listening, I kind of got the sense that Taylor had a strong idea about what she wanted this relationship to look like. Her and her lover were national treasures-- all eyes focused on them. Their love was highly publicized and romanticized. I think it's about her grappling with the disillusionment of the relationship. She and the rest of the world wanted it to be a fairytale story. In actuality, her lover was unfaithful and maybe non-commital, yet she fantasized about the legend of what their relationship would become. Hence, the references to 1950s gymnasium prom scene (i immediately think about the "it" couple portrayal in shows like stranger things, or even real 50s couples like Elizabeth Taylor and Micheal Wilding). So essentially there's a duality she sings about: what she wants the relationship to be vs. what it really is. Maybe her feelings of love for this person, are driven by a strong desire to be the saved princess riding off with her prince charming, thus becoming a tale shared with generations to come. But she's not a princess, this is not a fairy tale, and unfortunately, she will not be saved by the perfect kiss (lol-tying in those references). SOsoso soooo, all of her mash-ups I feel like kinda resemble this same theme. Joe came into her life when she needed "saving" per se. Despite her true feelings for him, this reoccuring desire is still there-- her prince will save her and they will live happily on and on. In reality, taylor has said she was in a very dark place when her and joe got together. Now that's she's experiencing success and is in a happier place, she can reflect on the dynamics of this relationship similiar to what she did in suburban legends. Her fantasy may have clouded the truth of the relationship which is that there was some incompatibilities between what she and her partner ultimately wanted. So these mash-ups of anxious songs and desperate love songs speak to that tension in her relationship with Joe. Thank you and good night.

Skye Moffitt

wasnt this a saturday show or am I loosing my mind?

Cara M

Am i the only one that thought the live was Travis coded like maybe she just wanted to subtly dedicate them to him cause she’s missing him? She deliberately made the message of the mashup be positive by those clever cuts, and she looked soooo happy while singing it!

Kellie Mahoney

Thank you for talking about the variations! I was starting to think I was the only one who thought the complaining was ridiculous since everyone does this.

Heidi

BETTY REPRESENTATION

Stephanie Stevens

thank you bonny!!!!!! Dont Blame Me into Look What You Made Me Do is the most SUPERIORRRRRRR part of the eras tour! I die every time

Meghan Raap

same, I could never move on from call it what you want lol one of my all-time rep favorites

asquared13

I don't think any of us have to buy anything but I do feel it's predatory to know the pressures fans feel to buy variants just to access bonus songs. Just saying people don't have to buy it is super invalidating for fans who want to enjoy the new music without the pressure to spend spend spend, not to mention the crazy bad issues so many experience with her online store. I personally have stopped pre ordering and purchasing from her store and just wait til release day to buy in person. But that doesn't mean everyone else should accept the pressures, the costs, or the bad purchasing issues from her store or her. Still super excited but definitely bummed that so many aren't willing to validate the issues fans have faced just trying to access her music in ways that directly support her.

Grace Tapulgo

I wonder if these songs will be on the Eras tour movie on Disney since she said there was going to be new acoustic songs in the movie?

alex

Ohhh I’m here with you! This song does something to me I can’t even explain.. like only the beginning sound makes me wanna cry in happiness

alex

Love to see fellow dress stans! 🥹🥹

Kim

not you guys talking about calling it what you want and her playing it hahah

skizzo

Call It What You Want is my #1 but Dress is in my top5 for sure. It probably goes CIWYW, I Did Something Bad, King Of My Heart, Dress and Delicate for me on Rep.

iw

Mine/Starlight is sooooo travis-coded. the 2nd verse in starlight is almost verbatim something he'd say (he has a LOT of quotes about dreams, dreaming big, not letting other people's opinions get to you, etc.). he also very vocally wants to get married and have kids lol. she could have easily cut that starlight bridge ('we could get married Have ten kids and teach 'em how to dream') because she already had done the bridge from mine...but she kept it in. food for thought lol.

Carlee Unger

DHL and Lis working together

Tess7

Lol

Brittany DeLara

I am also not mad about all the variants. I really shouldn’t be buying them all but this is what makes me happy and where I want to spend my splurge-on-myself money. I am so excited about all of them. Ordered the vinyl and collector CD in all 4 variants. I’m a happy girl. We just have to learn to accept that Taylor will always be held to a different standard than others and will always have a negative light shining somewhere on her. It’s their loss for missing out on such superiority.

Claire Williams

ok yes to everything said about call it what you want! why is it just not the same

Philippa

Taylor is definitely not the only artist to do the multiple versions with different bonus tracks. However, I do think people have a right to be frustrated because she seriously doesn't need to because her record sales are going to be sky high irrespective of the bonus tracks. Additionally, much of my sadness is that there is probably going to be a long wait for the bonus tracks from the variants to come onto streaming for the many who cannot afford multiple vinyls feels like we're being kinda punished for not having the disposal income to spend on 3+ records. I'm all for different covers and agree with you Bonny that they are so lovely to have different imagery, and those allow people can just pick which ones they like and have a choice without missing out on songs. I would not that it's her fans "complaining" and feeling sad about the tracks, not necessarily non-swifties, so it's not exactly the same as the private jet issue. I think it's overall just bit tired with the clear money grab (not saying there's anything wrong with Taylor being a Success woman) but it is to the point of feeling a bit exploitative of the fans, just like her merch (insane number of poorly made, poorly designed and ethically questionable in the production). If she makes all bonus tracks available on streaming immediately, I'll eat my words, but even then, that may mean people felt compelled to buy more than they would have had they known they'd be available... TLDR: she has the fans to make record sales numbers without depriving fans who can't afford purchasing multiple vinyls from hearing the songs untill much later, it feels a bit exploitative at this point

Tara

Can so relate re CIWYW - Invisible string is that song I have to skip now that T and J have broken up

Cinetati

CIWYW is still my top 1 on Rep mainly because it is a superior song and because I feel like some parts definitely work with her and Travis.... Also I did have a few months not listening to Rep outside of the songs on the tour and when I went back to it to rank my songs on Rep it's definitely still top 1!! <3

Jen B

Agreed on CIWYW. I initially felt like in CIWYW Joe was portrayed as protecting her from the hate, but now the narrative seems to be more akin to Taylor being "put in the basement." Which taints the imagery of the chain 'round my neck/high above the whole scene/boarded up windows to feel a bit more toxic/icky and a little less daydreamy.

Lizzy Williams

You're SOOOO right eras tour helped me fathom Betty

Jeebs

I might be getting my timing wrong, but what if Taylor went live with the nice recording, was she supposed to mention TPD on Singapore night 1? And they had everything lined up but she announced it at the grammus

Hanna Kulla

not emily doing the naaawrr from should have said nawwrr version😂

Georgia

Wait wait. Hear me out. What is idwtlfXdress is one of the surprise songs on the Eras Tour (TV) on Disney!!? What if that’s why she went live and that’s why the quality was so good?!?!

Aurora

with these surprise songs in particular the chairman of the tortured poets department really said "I have a message for the athletic director....you guys can be there too i guess"

Jade

I’ve been thinking on all this too. In hindsight, when she met Joe, it was probably what she needed- to be in a bubble, windows boarded up and keeping her safe and away from the hate & scrutiny, but it wasn’t ever supposed to be the way it stayed. It fit Joe’s vibe, but not the heart of hers.

Jade

The good news is- there is an Invisible String linking her to Travis, too. So it’s not irrelevant or completely about Joe anymore- it applies to her new relationship ❤️

Jade

Yes, a TTPD Reaction, Fathoming, Breakdown and then a Refathoming once it has marinated for a couple months.

Jesse Conner

What if…this was an Easter egg for TTPD? This whole set was very “Guilty As Sin?” coded - “Mine” and two of her sexiest songs?

Laura Houston

The harmonica on Betty, especially live kills me and gives me life at the same time. It’s the most sarcastic thing I’ve ever heard and I LOVE it!!

Breezy Bumbles

Did she livestream this for Travis? Because he wasn’t there?

SwiftViewer

So proud seeing this because I'm from Singapore 🥲🥹