Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

“Lisa’s Rival” is where we’re introduced to Lisa’s classmate Allison Taylor (voiced by Winona Ryder, yes this is important) who is basically everything Lisa tries to be but better. And Lisa does not know how to handle competition; especially when it comes to things that make her stand out, like playing saxophone and being the smartest in her class, including getting bullied. And the thing is, Allison is really just being herself, not even trying to beat her or anything. She’s even quite friendly towards Lisa and invites her over to her house, telling her how much she wants them to be friends. This inadvertently makes Lisa feel even more inadequate when she meets her wealthy and intellectual family and sees she has her very own trophy room in her house. They’re literally 8 years old in the episode (Allison is 7—which makes Lisa feel even worse—so her having so many academic trophies is insanity. But whatever, some suspension of disbelief is needed here, as with most things in The Simpsons.)

At Bart’s suggestion, Lisa sabotages Allison’s diorama for the school diorama competition. As Principal Skinner is chiding poor Allison for not meeting his high expectations of her, Lisa’s guilt starts manifesting just like in The Tell-tale Heart by Edgar Allan Poe until she can’t handle it anymore. Appropriate, because Allison’s diorama was about The Tell-tale Heart by Edgar Allan Poe.

Now, call me biased but Allison choosing Poe for her assignment—and the fact that she’s voiced by Winona Ryder—made it SO easy for me to imagine her teen self as goth-adjacent. She sounds so giddy and fascinated by how macabre the story is when she’s describing it to Lisa, much like how Lydia Deetz would act. This episode came out in 1994 so Winona was at peak popularity and widely considered a goth icon for starring in Beetlejuice, Edward Scissorhands and Bram Stoker's Dracula.

I thought making Allison go full goth would make her unrecognizable so I opted for something in the middle. Something more similar to Lisa, but effortlessly cooler, so Lisa has something to compare herself to and feel envy.

Also this isn’t a universal experience but when girls are still figuring out how it feels to like other girls, sometimes they think what they feel is envy and that they want to be like her. Lisa’s wondering if that’s the case here or if it’s something more. She does think she’s really cool and she's also one of the only girls in the school who are nice to her.

And since we're talking about them, I also included a doodle I've never shared publicly that I drew for ccnr_b because their Lisa/Allison comics are just delightful!

I may be ✨CEO OF NELISA✨ but Lisa being canonically bi is incredibly important to me as a bisexual myself so I need to make sure people know my Lisa is not straight. She just has terrible taste in guys. I had a short side plot planned for Those Springfield kids involving her struggling with a little crush on Allison and awkwardly trying to find out whether or not she felt the same way or if she's just nice.

Files

Comments

No comments found for this post.