Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi folks, I'd like to talk about save points.

Some people love 'em. Some people hate 'em. Speaking personally, I like both options for different reasons, so I thought I'd solicit feedback from the community to gauge the general consensus.

From my perspective, having save points is a design feature that adds a layer of thoughtfulness and planning to a JRPG if implemented intelligently, but it can also be frustrating if implemented poorly.

It also adds a bit of extra weight to narrative decisions, because you can't just "save scum" it and try every choice right away. That said, for many, NOT being able to try every choice easily can be a deal-breaker.

So let me know what you think! I've been going back and forth on it in my head for a while. Initially I'd always sort of told myself it was a feature coming down the road, but as time has gone on (especially for testing purposes), I've found the menu-saving handy.

Comments

Anonymous

I think maybe once the game is closer to being completed then save points would be ok

Hartmanns Youkai

Outside of platformers and arcade style games, I've never seen a game where specific save points made the game better (at least in my opinion). Without save points, players that want to play through the story in a sort of "my choices matter" style are always free to simply not reload and/or stick with their choices and select them again if they do need to reload. On the other hand, adding save points now forces additional tedium on everyone, be it replaying a scene every time you die right after it, wandering all the way back to the save point in order to stop playing for the moment, or everyone's favorite moment of "the save point is way back there, and I think I'm almost done with this area anyhow, I'll just push forward... oh... I died... time to do the whole dungeon over again." There are many obnoxious moments and backtracking that can happen in games that free save ability makes way less of a hassle. I like your game enough to play even if you do add save points, but I think they would only make the game worse for the player and be a waste of time implementing on your end.