Home
Creators
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

One Piece - 475 & 476 (Patreon)

Published:
2025-08-25 00:17:16
Imported:
2026-08

Videos

  • 521501047.mp4

Downloads

Files

Comments

Manvelly

Am I first for once ? Lol super excited and love everything you two do always! Also: correct me if im wrong but this friday is a special episode lol , one of my favorites

Suf

WE are the first ones

Seb

Ron, be ready to say One Piece is your number 1 anime soon

Manvelly

Yeah #1 for Ron and Michelle!!

Delinger

It's the same reckless Luffy who would do anything for his friends. He raided Enies Lobby and declared war on the World Government for Robin. But of course it's even more extreme here since Ace is the closest person to him. There's a greater sense of urgency because he can be executed any minute. And the enemies standing in his way this time are way, way, way out of his league on top of outnumbering him, which makes the situation look even more desperate.

Corin Begay

Was watching the new superman, But I saw that u finally posted dawg!!!!

Corin Begay

Btw she looks adorable today , not tryna be rude compliments

Dandy Zoran

Ron, this is Luffy. He doesnt always plan things. The kid moves on instinct and feelings.

victoria t

Next video would be a great triple drop; 478 & 479 should be watched together!

Suf

Just clarify for you guys although its not important! Oars isnt a part of the Whitebeard Pirates but is one of the allied pirates with his own crew which are distinguishable with the bone jaws on their faces and weird hair and at the beginning when all the pirate ships are arriving to Marineford you see a ship thats at least 2-3 times bigger than the regular ones which has OARS written on the main sail because of his size.

Delinger

Fr and love his reason for saving Ace 😂

지원

so good i can't wait next week .. even more peak

RubberBuckyy

They already said they have it scheduled last drop in the comments.

Obstic Ty

Goes to show how smart the marines are at planning ahead and it’s crazy how the lava admiral canceled out white beards attack and power clashed with him and is it just me or do y’all also feel like Oda nerfed kizaru dude can travel the earth 7 times in a single second there is no way Marco should have gotten that close to ace in kizaru eyes time should feel like it’s almost completely stoped and he acts like he is slow or light headed I feel like if he switched fruits with the other admirals the marines would have won already

Suf

Fun fact: Aokiji and Dio share the same Voice Actor!

Robenson BADETTE

I forgot how shaky the pacing was even back then

Natacha

Sorry I didn’t see it

Spelner

remember DO NOT READ THE TITLE SCREENS

Aaron williams

Kizaru is definitely a mouth breather lol

Aaron williams

Ichigo’s voice actor is always booked and busy. He does video games too so get used to it. In fact his English voice actor is common too also in video games interesting coincidence. Tbh his English and Japanese sound the same

Michael H

Oda can’t help himself lol. Even with characters he actually kills off, he’s gotta give them at least one fake-out death beforehand.

Alya Nabila

all episodes next week will be more exciting. cant wait!!

Gab

Lets not go that far buddy 😂

Mr. A

I always felt like the way Kizaru's personality is - is basically his nerf because his power is so insane

The CulturedGentleman

I LOVE the screentime Izo is getting!! Oda is the absolute GOAT!! Btw Whitebeard now is Admiral level. Imagine how strong he was in his prime! Also Garp is by far the strongest soldier on that battlefield!

Obstic Ty

Pretty much his biggest nerf oda can nerf the speed of light power but giving kizaru that personality I feel like it’s to just save the story cause imagine akainu with that fruit

Aaron williams

Ace and luffy chose to be pirates garp chose to be a marine simple as that. Sigh

Mohamed Abu

Marco was NOT ready for that fist of love 😂

The CulturedGentleman

His devil fruit has to be one of the most busted in OP when you think about the properties of light. Its by far the strongest one here at this point in the story that we have seen thus far. He should be able to blind all the pirates there with his light and snipe them all with lazers shot at the speed of light while he goes invisible because with light abilities he should be capable of all that

지원

damn Garp is so strong 35:17 even Ace said "GG".

Obstic Ty

True and another thing that doesn’t make sense his fruit makes it so that him attacking at the speed of light he still has a physical form which would mean infinite energy that single kick would be enough to knock someone out of orbit plus destroying that entire country not only is this fruit heavenly nerfed but oda also buffed it by making kizaru able to retain his physical form when light speed kicking bro got done dirty

leisuresoccer

Next week is gonna be interesting

Obstic Ty

Kizaru is so slow that he is practically carried by his fruit he let low level pirates get close to him and doesn’t act when he needs to like what’s stopping him from shooting every pirate with a laser and he keeps stoping his attacks when something happens like when Jimbe and Ivan showed up

Betty H

And Zeke Jaeger!

TVTG

Who is waiting for the ep 479? rsrs 😆

The CulturedGentleman

Guys I want u to imagine this. Luffy at this point is made clear as day he was a big fish in a small pond and now for the first time seeing what the deep waters are like and realizing hes a minnow. He is outclassed in every way. He cant even help himself and hes the strongest on his crew. If they were here they would all be slaughtered already or he would have had significant losses. If u think back, Moria did tell him on thriller bark that he would not make it in the New World and he was 100% correct. Ace was about to DIE and if not for crocodile, he would be. Keep in mind that he has no clue if the rest of his crew is okay and here again he would have lost his ONLY brother as well without him being even remotely able to do anything to stop it. He is too weak and he KNOWS it!

Michael H

Garp’s inner struggle is one of the most interesting parts of this arc. It’s easy to say that he should switch sides and help his family, but that’s because his family are largely exceptions to the rule when it comes to pirates. Most pirates are not Luffys, Aces, or even Whitebeards; instead, they are Arlongs, Don Kriegs, and Crocodiles who basically terrorize the public for their own gain. Garp has been fighting against them for decades, and now basically the entire organization that stands between regular citizens and those kinds of pirates is in jeopardy of collapsing. He has to weigh the lives of his two grandsons against the lives of likely thousands of civilians who would die if the navy collapsed here. It’s a sticky wicket.

The CulturedGentleman

Hess for sure an interesting character. And I was just thinking about this...if he was serious, and Mihawk and all the others there on the Navy's side were all in alignment and actually meant to stop the pirates...this war would be over already. Garp alone would wipe out 90% of them without much difficulty

E

Man I hate garp.

PumpDaddyD

Boa absolute ride or die waifu she was about to charge at Aokiji.

King Tut

Why do they keep saying throw ocean water at the admirals. they just see luffy cover in ocean water and it didn't do anything thing to him

The CulturedGentleman

Sometimes I forget that even tho hes a Vice Admiral, if you rank them strength wise...I think Garp bodies even Sengoku and the three admirals

EnzoTorales

If garp has no haters is cuz I’m already dead

Blu3

These next episodes are about to be INSANEEE

GoundG

Im confused about why everyone that watch this show always expect garp to step in an betray everything he has done in his life up to this point I know we don't know why exactly he is a marine and his adopted grandson and actual grandson are in danger but they are criminals in this world by their own choice This next part I say I not confirmed or mentioned anywhere in the show or manga, this is my own explanation for the things garp does Who said garp isn't already protecting other innocent people by staying in his position at the navy The world government I already fine with commiting genocide on unborn children in order to kill a child that's not even born at that point The world government is not afraid to silence innocent civilians in order to have their way Garp, Dragon and Luffy probably all have the same birthplace, it's possible that garp have more then 1 kid, that is just not really important for the story so it's never going to be explored The town Luffy grew up in before he meets shanks What's going to happen to that place if Garp the Hero betray the world government? + World's most wanted criminal is potentially from there + Luffy the most feared rookie that declared war on the world government, punched a celestial dragon, broke into and out of the most guarded prison on the planet and spearheaded this rescue war so far I obviously don't know where Garp or Dragon are from but I imagine it's Luffy's town because Garp just left him there and I hope he was left with the closes relatives that weren't criminals or marines That town is as good as dead if Garp betrayed the Navy and the world government I have no claim to this being correct or anything, it's just the only thing that makes sense to me It means that Garp is stuck between saving his innocent civilian family or his criminal family Purely my own speculation and I'm just baffled that these thoughts never really show up when talking about Garps motivation for what he does

Mohamed Abu

That’s not even a crazy statement 😂 the admirals are sort of relatieve to each other and look at Marco we saw bro send Kizaru and Aokiji flying. Marco is THE commander of the first division for a reason, but the moment he Garp stepped in it was GG. Like Garp punched the actual bird shi out of him 💀 sitting on Akainu his chair, calling wb and all the pirates brats just shows you that he isn’t a regular “vice admiral”

Zzenitsu

you gotta remember that whitebeard is way weaker now that he's ill, injured, and past his prime

Ujab Gaming

garp is a marine hero and people praise him and many want to be like him who upholds justice.. like how coby is training with him now.. it's true that not all pirates are evil and not all marines are good.. imagine people who don't have devil fruits and they sit on an island and are oppressed by evil pirates.. and garp saves ace.. where will these weak people go? and their faith in the marines will be destroyed if garp saves ace.. and you have to remember that ace is not garp's grandson.. he's just roger who has an enemy and told garp to take care of him.. don't blame garp for this..

Faded Eclipse

Garp and Sengoku are equal in strength. Sengoku is the fleet admiral which is above the 3 admirals. Garp is only a vice admiral because if he was a rank higher he would be under the command of the celestial dragons and he hates them so he chose to be just a vice admiral. And maybe prime Garp could beat the admirals but when you get older you get weaker.

Jamaal

Once again you need to do more then splash people with sea water. Sea water does not affect devil fruit users unless they are submerged

Promanex(Alex)

Choosing your own path and your own family is a big theme in this anime, just because people are related doesn’t mean they will help them no matter what. Yes it plays a factor but also Garp chose to be a Marine, Ace and Luffy chose to be pirates. If Garp just helps them, what does it say about his own beliefs his own paths and his life up until this point.

Jamaal

Ya a lot of people don't seem to get it. We are watching from Luffys pov and his enemies tend to also be the Marines so we tend to see the worst of the Marines but with one piece not everything is good and evil. People tend to look at it as good or evil when in reality it's closer to law vs chaos.

E

Yea I’m with you

NightingGale 496

Hey guys, just a heads up that episodes 482 and 483 should be watched together. Maybe you can do a triple drop for 481, 482 and 483. Can't wait for Friday's episodes!!

Usher

Remember when you guys first heard Marco and thought it was Franky and Bon clay's VA?💀

King Kai

Sorry to burst your bubble, but the way the live action is made, as slow as they are made, it will never reach this Arc. The best we can hope for is the show to end on Robin peak rescue and finish the CP9 Arc and be done with Live Action. By then, the actors will look too old to be teenagers

Natthorn Rangseesakhon

They showed that Vista and Mihawk agreed to stop fighting when the Navy was ordered to retreat because they were about to bring up the wall. That was a few episodes back you guys just forgot.

King Kai

Let’s hope for the best. I’ll ride the wave as long as it can go

Brandon Solerr

u remind of the same people that thought one piece was going to end at episode 500

Feignorance

There's no way, even if they could wrap Alabasta in season 2, there's still Bellamy/Blackbeard/Skypiea, Water 7/Enies Lobby/New Ship/Franky, Thriller Bark/Kuma/Brook, Saobody/Worst Generation/ Celestial Dragons/Kuma, Amazon Lily/Impel Down Infiltration and Escape and then after all that Marineford start and finish? There are so many characters in between all those arcs, that's Avengers level casting, too. Hell, they didn't even introduce Hachi at Arlong Park, who is an instrumental character in the Saobody arc. Enies Lobby would be a fitting conclusion to the series, imo.

Justin Bajado

Even Garp is strong he can't disobey Sengoku as he is more rank than him

Karaka

It’s not about disobeying Sengoku, he doesn’t care about orders

Karaka

Just goes to show how complex and well written Garp is…he’s my 2nd favourite character after Luffy

King Kai

Manga can go on forever. In my thoughts, I never thought one piece will end. Been riding it before it was legally here. Illegal vcd burn jap dub no sub. Always looking for the next adventure. When Dragon Ball end in the 89’ I was bummed, then dbz in 2000, dang there goes my childhood, then GT came and Super. Great manga and anime survive…but Live action that’s different. Chris Reeves Superman,Man of Steel Henry Cavill, now Superman whoever the hell he is. Human aged. Heck Brandon Routh Superman was the direct sequel to Chris Reeves Superman, but the feel isn’t the same. Just sayin they got a lot of work cut out for them if they think they can compress 20 plus years of Onepiece manga stories cutting here and there without sacrifices. And doing it in a snail pace too. Netflix notorious for dropping great series, even when that series is at the top. Still will ride as far as that wave can take. And if live action, or even manga should end, then I’ll ride the fan made story.

Muhd Irvan

Garp involvement can make,the whole island in wrapped w Pure hands

Justin Bajado

Why hate on him he is marine so of course he need to defend the marine side not pirate side i hate more akainu he used squard and disperect pirates

Mahti

Goat. D Garp ♥

Bob

rewatching this after being caught up just makes me lose so much respect for garp. he sits by for this but jumps in for some other things

Bob

GARP D SLAVER

Mahti

Yup except Marco would have saved Ace if not for Crocodile

Bob

Its hilarious knowing what garp will jump in for compared to what he wont. GARP D SLAVER

Mahti

Whitebeard is still above Admiral level but not by much

Mahti

he's right though

Bibi

Totally different situations..

The CulturedGentleman

I think hes stronger than Sengoku. Even as old as he is...like a Hashirama/Madara type of situation...the battle would be legendary but I think he would still come out on top. Remember, Sengoku only became Fleet Admiral because Garp turned it down

The CulturedGentleman

Yeah hes HEAVILY nerfed. You break the laws of physics when you go at the speed of light (which is 299,792,458 meters per second) so yes, that kick should send anyone flying into orbit or vaporize whichever part he touches. And yes...he should have infinite energy just by existing because light in itself is energy. Plus if he could control the wavelength of the beams, he could literally cut Diamond Jozu in half! His fruit would be too powerful if he wasn't nerfed.

DuLee

Idk why they don’t just throw ocean water at akainu

Bibi

Garp is struggling between duty and family, he's the symbol of heroism in the marines and thus the whole world. I don't hate him for his decisions he's such a complex character and he's definitely one of my favorites

The CulturedGentleman

The only way we get there is if it becomes a weekly drop and they recast the characters after they get too old for the roles. AND even that's a stretch because the budget is just too much to do weekly and they couldn't do the sets in time and all that. Lets be happy if we get to the end of Skypeia or W7. id be happy with that but further just isnt realistic

Avery Burchfield

Same, i dont understand how anyone could defend his decision at Marineford. He is an awful grandfather and a hypocrite for staying in the Marines despite his hatred for the Celestial Dragons. But dammit i still love him😭

Phyllis

You can't begin to imagine what Garp is going through.. he’s torn by overwhelming internal conflict. As a Marine, he's sworn to uphold justice and protect his fellow soldiers. Yet, his own family stands on the opposite side: his son is a notorious revolutionary, his grandson is a pirate, and his god-grandson is the son of the Pirate King himself. Deep down, he wants to save them all but he can’t. Not with Fleet Admiral Sengoku standing right beside him.

Klaudio Ladavac

I remember watching this 15 years ago, episode by episode each week and cursing at 6min recaps or anything slightly non relevant happening..haha… it was just endless months of total stress ever since Sabaody all the way to this war and there is a lot major twists in store before it all ends….good old days

Tacosareneat

DBZ has long screaming, Naruto has repetitive flashbacks, one piece has those FUCKING recaps 😭. Between the intro, outro, and recaps, I swear some episodes are like 12 mins

Karaka

No matter what anyone tells me, Garp not fully switching sides was the right choice Let me explain for the people in comments who say “Garp is a bad person cuz of this”: Garp is the Legendary Hero of the Marines — the most famous and the biggest hero amongst them Him switching sides would not just be him sacrificing his career, if it was just that then he would’ve saved Ace when he visited him in Impel Down If such a legendary figure switched sides then the whole world would lose trust in the Navy & will label them “Pirates accomplices” and “Roger’s allies”, No matter how much Luffy looks up to Roger…the crime rate in the world of One Piece sky rocketed because of Roger There’s countless innocent people who have been murdered and harmed because of Roger and his last words that drove Pirates and evil people to the seas to look for his treasure To an average person, Roger did more harm than good (not saying Roger is a bad person who hurt these people outright but his ideals is what hurt them) So if Garp switched sides, the young navy people who look up to him, the young kids who aspire to be Marines and protect people will all lose faith and would doubt justice The normal civilians throughout the world won’t know who to turn to for aid, the world would straight up crumble Garp is a man torn between family and the uniform he chose. If he saves Ace, he stops being the pillar that even monsters and heroes alike measure themselves against, and becomes just another pirate’s ally. He refuses that for the sake of the world he’s spent a lifetime holding together, even if it breaks his heart So just imagine the struggle he’s feeling in his heart — in his own mind he’s clearly hoping that Whitebeard saves Ace and it can all be done with Garp is by far the most complex character in One Piece and Oda is a genius for writing Garps character in this way

Natthorn Rangseesakhon

If you notice, Whitebeard calls everyone “brats” or “squirts” including the Admirals, and just smiles or laugh while facing them. He only calls Sengoku and Garp by their names, and when Garp stepped up, Whitebeard had a very serious face

Karaka

By the way…I don’t know if you noticed but all those bullets, Kizaru’s lasers and everything couldn’t damage Marco and he was able to regenerate quite easily because of his devil fruit but when Garp punched him…he didn’t regenerate and had a bruise on his face Just one punch from Garp did that 👀

Karaka

He respects his Old Generation rivals and knows what they’re capable of if they took part in the battle 🔥🔥 plus Garp and Sengoku are older than him tbf would be weird if he called them brats

lazlo

Reason why Sengoku doesn't just "kill him there" is because this an execution by trial. He's the fleet Admiral and remember according to them they're are the good guys so they try to do everything the right way, they aren't just going to murder him without the executioners because that wouldn't be ethical

Karaka

You have to be submerged in sea water, getting soaked has no effect

Karaka

@Bob your rage bait isn’t working, give it a rest

Karaka

You can hate him all you like but his decision to not switch sides was the right one All he can do is pray Whitebeard saves Ace

lazlo

If Garp was the kind of person to disobey Sengoku because of rank he'd easily be an admiral lol

Chop Chop Chopper

I’m a bit confused as to why they think Garp would interfere. Wouldn’t he have done it long ago, e.g. in Impel Down if he has any intend freeing Ace?

Natthorn Rangseesakhon

Sengoku can’t just kill Ace like that. You have to remember, they’re Navy officers, which means they have to follow the laws and orders from the Government. Those laws are written in a way that makes the Navy believe they’re doing the right thing, so they have to execute him properly. Also from the civilians’ point of view, the Navy are the good guys and most of the em aren’t even bad people they’re just following a system and laws created by the Government

Tacosareneat

I don't think it's a matter of garp not willing to sacrifice his career, it's that he doesn't want to sacrifice his morality and sense of justifce. He's not worried about keeping his job, he's worried about doing what's right (to him).

Stew

It's one thing to plot to save Ace, it's another thing to just watch him get double-stabbed to death. Walking into a funeral home is a lot more impactful than getting dressed in the morning to go to a funeral.

Stew

They already cut the videos for the reporters, and they already rushed the execution time. Especially with Whitebeard only a couple of hundred feet away, I think it's perfectly reasonable that THE Fleet Admiral decides to execute Ace Himself. Maybe he's considering Garp's feelings about the situation, but a random marine would applaud Sengoku for taking action.

Kayso

I was mad at Garp for what he did the first time I watched but knowing his position, I understand at the same time. So I get Ron and Michelle's frustrations especially first time watching

Kayso

Nice little detail, never noticed that but makes sense ofc

Tamsin

They replied on a comment on last video or the one before I believe. They are doing 481-483, then 484 and 485 together

Karaka

Garps got the I’m Him Fruit (model: left, right, goodnight)

Stew

I would agree, but if cutting the transponder snails is acceptable and rushing the execution time is acceptable, it seems acceptable to me to have the FLEET ADMIRAL perform the execution when Whitebeard is less than a football field away. Desperate times call for desperate measures. Like Doflamingo said, the winners decide what justice is. Having the STRONGEST MAN IN THE WORLD at arm's reach is a very compelling reason. This isn't a peaceful execution like Roger's; this is literal war. The real reason is Ace dying during this episode would be horrible storytelling, we could argue about fictional creeds and ethics all day but that won't get us anywhere.

Stew

Ace wanting to be a pirate never made sense to me. If he hates his real father, why would he want to be just like him? Shanks is Luffy's inspiration; Ace didn't have someone like that. I understand that the D members want to be free, but Garp is a D too.

Anthony

Your opinions on garp are completely valid. Garp is my favorite character in the series, and its partly cause of him being so polarizing. I 100% understand people loving him and thinking him being true to what he believed in was right, or people hating him and thinking what his restraint was wrong cause thats still your family...., or a mix of both. At the end of the day feel however you want to feel!

Karaka

100% agree, I just can’t stand the people who call Garp evil or a bad person for this…

Jonas Teigen

Man, I feel so bad for Garp. I also think family is the most obvious and correct answer, but thinking more about it Garps family’s is literally fighting against everything he stood for his whole life. And are literal terrorists haha, in their pov. That’s brutal.

Natthorn Rangseesakhon

I understand but we have to remember “the real point of Ace’s public execution” it wasn’t just about killing him. They could’ve done that before Whitebeard even showed up, so why didn’t they? Because it was planned, this wasn’t some last-minute desperate move.. Doing it with Ace cuffed and helpless, and making it clear to the world that he was Roger’s son, was meant to signal the ‘death of the Pirate Era’ by ending the Pirate King’s bloodline. And don’t forget, a bigger reason is that Ace was bait to lure Whitebeard’s crew in, so the Navy could get rid of them and show off their power while controlling the narrative, like cutting some part of broadcasts that will make em look bad. Whitebeard showing up was part of the plan. Even if Sengoku killed Ace himself, it wouldn’t change anything they would still need to deal with all the pirates at Marineford as planned. Following procedure wasn’t about risk or convenience; it was his duty and part of the bigger plan. Again, if they just wanted Ace dead, they could’ve done it way earlier but that was never the point of this public execution

I_am_Knowledge

26:37 To be fair to Luffy, just a few hours ago he was in Impel down breaking into it, healed from Magellans poison and then broke out of impel down, headed to Marineford with no rest

bluelimekine

you both looking extra fooooine today

Nero Luv

Garp tried to get them to be Marines. 🤷🏾‍♂️ 😂😂

finaaaa

Were almost there~~

RorotheShadow

I understand being pissed off at Garp but I mean, you said you wanted to try to walk in everyone's shoes, so just to explain the situation Garp is in right now: Garp is, without a doubt, in the worst situation you can be in at Marineford. Garp would not only sacrifice his career, but much more so his entire self, his identity, his morals and ideals. He is a man who lives by the Navy's values ​​and rules and is committed to them, as they align with his own morals. If he were to turn against the Navy, he would not only lose his position as Vice Admiral, but also his entire identity and everything he believed in. And most importantly, the entire world would lose its trust in the Navy. Garp is the Navy's hero, something of a living legend. If someone like that were to side with the pirates, it would shake the world. Ordinary civilians would no longer feel safe, thinking that absolutely any marine could switch sides, and many would also stop looking up to the Navy. So Garp finds himself in a situation where he has to decide whether to put the life of one person (Ace) above the well-being and trust of many other people (basically all the civilians in the world and the rest of the Navy), or whether to sacrifice the life of this one person to save the well-being and trust of all other people. So no matter what decision Garp makes, it sucks. That's why Garp wanted Ace and Luffy to become marines so badly, so that he would never have to be in such a complex, shitty situation where he had to put the lives of his beloved grandsons and his ideals, morals, and the faith of civilization in the Navy on the line. So it's perfectly understandable if Garp would help Ace and Luffy, but it's also perfectly understandable if he doesn't. Garp is without a doubt one of the most complex characters in all of One Piece and just because of this inner conflict alone, and to be honest, you can't be mad at him no matter what decision he makes.

Delinger

Exactly. You can't blame Garp, especially since he wanted them to become navy men.

E

Bruh no it wasn’t

Kurofi

Idk if anyone told you yet but Aokijis voice actor is the same as Dio’s from Jojos 👌🏾 ararah

Karaka

@lazlo - I think you mean “to obey Sengoku”

Rocketboy

Maybe I'm biased because I hated the live action (everything but the landscape/cgi probably)... I expect this to look HORRENDOUS lol, nobody will have the right body shape since its all unrealistic designs, costumes will look shabby or cheap, fight scenes will have no weight (you could already see mihawk was holding a plastic prop and holding his strenght so it would break lol)

Usher

If it was that simple, we could say that about 70% of the show

Usher

Yep. Also Zeke from aot

Luker

Biggest hater energy I’ve seen against the live action

Luker

CROCODILE IS MY GOAT

Delinger

Plus, his plan was for them to join the navy. But they chose their own path, now they have to face the consequences. In particular Ace brought this upon himself for not listening and going after Blackbeard. Then again, he had a fair point for not becoming a navy soldier. He's Roger's son after all.

lazlo

If THE fleet admiral would execute Ace on the spot he would be no better than the pirates. Just how one Marine would agree with it, there will be be dozens of Marines who will disagree . Ask yourself this - would the “good guys” really just execute a man who’s tied up, with their own hands?

DuLee

Why don’t we throw ocean water at kizaru then

Ivandro Moreira

Is important to note that Ace and Luffy are criminals, and not just some type of criminals they are murderers. Is the same situation if you had a son, and he killed multiple people and was sentence to execution. Would you help them escape the execution? And if you were a Police official? And one of the Top Brass?

Ivandro Moreira

Family is not the most obvious and correct answer at all. The family are criminals. Pirates and Murderers. Don't forget that Ace murdered multiple people and was even trying dozens if not hundred of times to kill Whitebeard. And that just to become the top Dog. I hope that in real life, you don't think that in that case choosing a criminal, but family is the correct answer.

Usher

The recaps are wild, but one piece's biggest issue is definitely the pacing

Jonas Teigen

Yea i kind of phrased it wrong, so of course DON'T choose the criminal irl haha. I meant more like family FEELS like the right answer because the story is from the POV of Luffy, and we love luffy. And we wants what's best for him, even though he is a terrorist, and that's kind of crazy lol. But i really like Garp reflecting on what to do, because both decisions are bad for him personally. Just great character writing, love it.

wram

The next batch of One Piece reactions are gonna be GOOD.

wram

Murderers? Where did you get murderers from? Luffy has yet to kill a single person as of this episode. He's a criminal in the eyes of the World Government sure but he is by no means a murderer and I'm sure Garp knows that. I can't say much due to spoilers but I'll just leave it at that. Also, pretty sure Ace has never killed anyone either.

Rocketboy

I wouldn’t call that hating lol. Hate is usually baseless, there is clear and valid reasons I really disliked the live action + I clearly praised the landscapes and cgi… It did look cheap/shabby. The proportions issue is also a really valid point as one piece doesn’t have realistic proportions. I just feel like overall a very poor adaption as live action always have it’s limits when it comes to anime. I’d have love a great cgi for unrealistic characters tho. CGI wasn’t bad and landscapes looked good. Can’t wait for a slightly muscular whitebeard with a disturbing cheap mustache and a thin cape that has no weight because it’ll be made out of thin fabric…

Kai

I don’t dislike it but I absolutely do not see them making this look good either😂 that would have to be its own season entirely due to budget

Kevin

Sometime next week better on Sunday u should watch 3 episodes. I did the math and the last episode you guys will be seeing is almost a must with the one we’ll have to wait for the week after that

Rocketboy

yeah there is a world in which this looks good, we sadly just dont live in that world lol. It's require way more time and budget given to the vfx studio to produce a great cgi that includes fully digital characters for very unrealistic characters (like marvel wonderfully did with Hulk and Thanos)

Harug_

And Kizaru's is Joseph's

Feignorance

After the transponder snails are cut, there are still approximately 100,000 marines who are present to witness the execution. Sengoku cannot serve as an inspiration to them if he disregards the rules and practices he endorses and preaches. There has to be some measure of order that the Navy can aspire to.

eden

You make it sound like something big is about to happen

eden

The liveaction sucked in comparison to the anime. However it was an impossible expectation to even think it was gonna be great because of how unrealistic the One Piece world is. Unless they were given a Game of Thrones kind of budget, it was never gonna be great. They did a good job with the budget they had.

eden

The Navy is full of murderers so what's your point exactly????

eden

What are we almost there for??

Rocketboy

I actually 100% agree with everything you said! I think the quality reflects the budget, but I also just think even though they pulled it off with that budget, it's still very "meh". It requires A LOT of ressources to even be truly decent + the whole universe is designed to be cartoony 2D illustrations, you just can't transfer it into live action (without full cgi), this will never ever works

Avery Burchfield

I would abandon my ideology to save my family in an instant.

Karaka

Garp disrespect shall not be tolerated when I’m around 😤 He’s the one suffering the most during this War no matter how you wanna put it

Avery Burchfield

Garp is a hypocrite, a Marine, and an awful Grandfather. I still love Garp as a character 100%, but I can’t respect his decisions throughout the series

Karaka

Garp is not a hypocrite first of all what even makes you think this? You can call him an awful Grandfather all you like but his Grandchildren themselves wouldn’t agree with you. And yes…he’s a Marine. You’re talking as if this is a bad thing? He legit saves people’s lives on a regular basis — I guarantee you that Whitebeards allied fleet is full of murderers and grapists. Their legit pirates…not all of them are the same as Luffy, Ace, Whitebeard etc… And if you wanna say “Oh…but the Celestial Drag—,” Garp don’t like them either, the Marines and the World Government are separate, Garp loves the Marines and can’t easily change such a corrupt system with evil mfs pulling the strings from the top, so best thing to do is change the system slowly and gradually from the inside by building up the next generation of Marines I hate the way some of you people lay all the blame of such things on Garp but there’s individuals like Whitebeard who have the ability to “destroy the world” but instead of saving it…he just roams the seas doing whatever he likes, recruiting criminals on to his crew….and all the while Garp is saving innocents with his strength and by trying to make the world a much better place If you think all the good Marines should leave the Navy…then who will the normal people rely on for help from evil pirates, bandits and criminals? The hate for Garp is so forced. He doesn’t have the freedom that Luffy has, he can’t just recklessly do the things he wants because it can have a ripple effect on the world itself

Avery Burchfield

The Navy is an extension of the World Government. They have carried out countless genocides in the name of absolute justice. Garp, by staying in the Marines and not challenging the Navy’s ideals itself means he is still fighting for the World Government. The only good Marines in the story are Smoker, Tashigi, Koby, and Kuzan cause you know why I wont spoil for other people. Remember what Dragon said about the Marines? “I saw no Justice there”, and the Revolutionary Army are the best organization in the whole series. And to your point about pirates, THEY ARENT AN ORGANIZED BODY THAT SYSTEMATICALLY OPPRESSES OTHERS. They are all individuals that should be judged as a case by case basis. The Whitebeard pirates are shown to be loyal and good people. We see this in Marineford and Wano. So dont act like the Marines are a force for good, because they are an extension of the main antagonist of the story, which in turn makes them even more of antagonists.

Karaka

He has challenged the Navy’s ideals multiple times — this is exactly what I’m talking about Please read this from start to finish 🙏🏾 The World Government pull the strings and have manipulated the world and the Marines for centuries on centuries When something so corrupt like that has been going on for that many years, it’s not easy to change it. The people in the One Piece verse today don’t even have great great grandparents who have lived in a world without the corruption of the world government So you gotta put yourself in these characters shoes Their moral compass is not nearly the same as ours…in fact, its drastically different What Garp is doing is good, he’s changing it from the inside by building up the new gen. You can’t just expect him to challenge the system straight on and get himself killed…that won’t change anything And the Whitebeard pirates are all morally grey, and so is Garp (I’m not denying that) But Whitebeards allied pirates are for sure not innocent — take Squard for example. And them being loyal makes them good? Ppl can be loyal to others all they like but that doesn’t confirm that they are good ppl

Avery Burchfield

I concede my point on loyalty being an indicator on virtue, but i dont think you’re understanding my point. The Marines are not “tricked or deceived” by the World Government, they ARE the World Government. Whenever an atrocious act is being carried out, who are the ones committing it? The Marines. I do agree that it is hard for one man to change it. But Garp has soooo much influence. He is the so called Hero of the Navy. He has the power to push back against the Marines, but he doesn’t really. He kinda just sits idly by. I am not expecting one man to change a century’s long system. But I would like to see him fight back. The perfect example is Fujitora (my goat). Look what he does in Dressrosa and Egghead. If Garp took actions like him, I would respect him, but he doesnt (as we have seen so far in the series). I don’t hate all marines. Hell my favorite character in all of One Piece is a marine (Rosinante), but if they do not actively push back against the system, I can’t call them a morally good character.

Avery Burchfield

I’m not trying to invalidate your opinion, you have made good points, but I think we just have some fundamental disagreements regarding the world of One Piece as a whole.

Alex

He’s sticking to his ideals. If he saved a pirate just because he has a personal connection to him THAT would make him a hypocrite

Karaka

@Avery — I can respect that opinion of yours but the best decision Garp can make is to not help Ace with the whole world watching and to just pray that Whitebeard manages to save Ace Him switching sides legit causes a ripple effect on the world itself - I gave an explanation on this deep in the comment section if you wanna take a look at it

Karaka

And your giving examples like Fujitora but Garp is legit the original Fujitora, he was the Marine who was doing all that in the old generation You’re just not seeing it now because Garp has already passed that phase and realised it’s useless…so he decided to change it from the inside A full backstory on Garp will show you that he has clearly challenged it and I can already see that he did without one

Avery Burchfield

I dont see Garp attacking Mariejois…and if we’re getting a full Garp backstory its gonna involve Dragon leaving the Marines, and Dragon’s beliefs and motivations are much more righteous than Garp’s imo. But anyway im done arguing, u can read it how ya wanna read it. Have a good one

Quitzx1

"guys you're not allowed to dislike what I like, because you're simply just a hater at that point" get a grip dude

Ivandro Moreira

He is no murderer? So what did he do To the Billions? And what was he trying to do with Whitebeard? And what did he do with the navy ships when he was burning them? What did he do to Hanafuda? Page One and Ulti are orphans because of whom? What did you think happened with the Marines in the ships that Luffy destroyed? And what do you think happened with the Marines and WG workers that were sent from Ennies Lobby to the fall? And with the Guards in Impel downs sent to the Boiling blood? They are definitely murderers. And not just one person, multiple ones.

Ivandro Moreira

The navy is a militar force! Luffy and Ace are civilians. If Ace and Luffy want to murder people legally, they should have joined the Navy or CP9. Just going out of their ways and kill people is not acceptable at all!

Ivandro Moreira

I hope you're joking. If in real life you have a family member that his a murderer and criminal, I hope you don't go out of your way to save them from the repercurssion of their actions.

Ivandro Moreira

Celestial Dragons are not the Marines. When there was kings and nobility, and the places that still have them, one or even all of them being bad, doesn't make any public worker bad by association. This is even more relevant because we are talking of World nobles, that rule basically the entire world. So there is a much bigger separation between them and the rest of the public.

idkwhy

(some spoilers below) I want to add to Karaka's point, look at the marines that you mentioned as the only good: 1. Zephyr instilled values in Smoker -> Tashigi (Garp respected Zephyr as the strongest believer in justice) 2. Garp instilled values in Kuzan (admiral) and Koby (hero) So you can see that Garp's values ​​are spread from within the system through his influence and the influence of his famous students.

Rocketboy

usual one piece community lol, everything is perfect, oda is the greatest author of all time (all genre included), nothing was never made up later, oda thought of everything before starting the manga, no piece of fiction will ever come close will ever come close to OP. Disagreeing with any of this will make you a "hater" lol. You're not allowed to dislike anything, criticize anything or even dare to think another manga/anime is better

Luker

wtf are you actually talking about i didnt even know peolple were still replying to this i called you a hater because u literally just shit all over the live action LMAO how were you not hating and i said none of those things u claim to be from "the usual one piece community". get off dick.

ava_aster_parmessur

personally i liked the live action, maybe because i had very low expectations. live adaptations of manga are usually way worse

Natacha

They said in the comments section of the last upload that they’ll watch 3 episodes on Sunday

Natacha

@Avery Burchfield How is he an awful grandfather when his own grandchildren never even wanted to join the Navy? And how is he a hypocrite when he actually stood by his principles?? He hates the Celestial Dragons, that’s exactly why he refused the position of admiral, so he wouldn’t have to follow their orders. People forget that Garp isn’t just a grandfather, he’s the Hero of the Marines. His role is to inspire future generations of Marines and protect civilians who see him as a legend. The Marines, despite the corruption of the World Government or some bad apples inside, are still the ones standing between order and chaos. Pirates like Luffy and Ace might be exceptions, but in general, the Marines are the ‘good guys.’ At Marineford, Garp wasn’t heartless, he was torn between family and duty, and that’s exactly what makes his character so tragic and powerful.

Rocketboy

I agree there are WAY worse adaptations (I also there are a few better ones like 1 or 2)

Rocketboy

no you just called me a hater for disliking something you like. How is it hating when I'm literally giving arguments and reasons as to why I disliked it? This is not just "random hating because im grumpy" that's me saying why I disliked it which are actually very valid and legit critics lol

Iriasu

Garp hate the world is healing

N1rvana

You guys don't rly know how strong Garp is xD But you will see

Beck inthanin

A certain orange haired woman would disagree with that statement you just made ^

klairvoyage

ain't no way people are defending that bootlicker💔

Misael Matute

I feel like most people don't actually understand Garp. It's not about his "job" or "carrier" . He genuinely believes the marines are good for the world. That's why he insisted on Luffy and Ace to be marines. He belived they could help get rid of the corruption and do what they stand for. It's much more than he is doing this for a paycheck per say...

Gene B

Then your ideals were never that strong to begin with

Gene B

Bruh was out of his depth so he ran away. Averys ideals are paper thin lol

Lukash

istg dragon is the most repeated name in these reaction series and for no reason as well :D