Out of the Aeons 7: Crime and Punishment (Patreon)
Downloads
Missing 2 files, as this post has not yet been imported.
Content
"April is the cruellest month," begetting
Arcane Horology in the darkness, commingling
History and fantasy, birthing
Scenario seeds with unseasonal hailstorms...
(For avoidance of doubt, this post contains significant ‘spoilers’ for the attached scenario seed!)
The Skull and the Book
On 13 April 1821, the first public hanging took place at the newly established Bristol New Gaol—a "commodious building...commanding extensive views of the surrounding countryside".
A charming final vantage point.
The condemned man's name was John Horwood, just three days past his 18th birthday; his crime, the murder of Eliza Balsom, a girl he had known since infancy. The prosecution in his trial (which took place at the nearby Star Inn) claimed that Balsom had died as a result of an infected head wound, caused by a stone which the then-17-year-old Horwood had thrown at her, after seeing her with another boy. Horwood and Balsom had been briefly involved in a relationship, but she had broken it off, and he had continued to be infatuated with her.
The evidence presented by the prosecution certainly appeared damning: they claimed that Horwood had threatened, harassed, and attacked Balsom prior to the incident which led to her death, that he was a known troublemaker who was involved with the notorious ‘Cock Road Gang’, and even presented a phrenological report attempting to prove his guilt by analysis of the shape of his skull. (As a curious side note, the phrenology report in Horwood’s trial was prepared by the delightfully-named Mary Anne Schimmelpenninck, a walking contradiction of a woman: at various points in her life, a Quaker, a Moravian and a Roman Catholic, Schimmelpenninck may have been a phrenologist but was also a leading writer in the abolitionist movement. Joseph Chance’s next Investigator, anyone?)

John Horwood appears resigned, in this courtroom sketch, as he awaits his grim fate…
However, in Horwood’s defence it must be noted that while the stone was thrown on or around the 25th January, Balsom didn’t die until February 17th, and later research suggests that the infection could just as easily have been caused by a dirty dressing as by the initial impact. In fact, the death itself occurred during trepanning surgery carried out to investigate and relieve pressure on the wound. An article in the British Medical Journal entitled ‘A Skull and a Book’ (absolutely worth reading in full for those who have time), published around 50 years after the Horwood trial, points out that the surgery itself was just as likely the cause.
The surgeon, Dr Richard Smith, had spotted Balsom in a hospital waiting room, with a dressing on her head, and insisted on operating on her. After her condition worsened, he alerted the authorities, and became a key prosecution witness at Horwood’s trial. Curiously, whether by means of thanks for his co-operation or merely by coincidence, Dr Smith also took receipt of Horwood’s corpse following the execution…
"John Horwood, convicted of the wilful murder of Eliza Balsum, Let him be instantly hanged by the neck until he shall be dead on Friday the 13th April instant, and let his body be delivered to Richard Smith, of the City of Bristol, Surgeon, to be dissected and anatomised."
The late 18th and early 19th centuries marked a period of transition in the source of corpses for medical science. Until that point, they had been hard to come by, and grave-robbing was a widespread practice. Ostensibly to create an additional disincentive to murder, but more likely to address the shortage of bodies for anatomical research, the Murder Act of 1752 allowed for the bodies of executed murderers to be dissected. However, this supply was still limited (and grave-robbing persisted), until the passage of the Anatomy Act in 1832, which made fair game the bodies of any executed criminals—and indeed any corpse from a hospital or workhouse which had not been claimed in 48 hours. Before 1832, medical professionals had to be resourceful in their acquisition of cadavers, so perhaps Smith’s special request was not uncommon.
However, what was more unusual was what happened to Horwood’s skin. Smith insisted that it be used to bind the book of Horwood’s trial notes and associated evidence, and the resulting document (embossed ‘Cutis Vera Johannis Horwood’) is, apart from anything else, a fascinating reference source for 19th century legal proceedings.

The infamous Horwood Book, currently on display at M Shed in Bristol
Anthropodermic bibliopegy
Books bound in human skin exist in unknown number—there are some which have gathered the reputation for being bound in man-flesh but are in fact goat-hide; conversely it’s probably fair to assume that there are many books bound in dermis homo sapiens whose owners don’t even know it. The Anthropodermic Book Project (a small team, benign of appearance) has developed a test to confirm the provenance of a book’s binding, using peptide mass fingerprinting (PMF), which matches mammalian collagen using its unique amino acid sequence. So far, with 31 books tested, they have confirmed 18 as genuine human skin.
Reasons for using such a unique binding vary. In some cases, it was thought appropriate to the subject matter—six copies of Hans Holbein’s The Dance of Death, for example, two of which reside in the John Hay Museum in Providence. In others, the former owner of the skin made the unusual request (or bequest) themselves—highwayman James Allen famously asked that his skin be used to bind his memoirs, with one copy specifically intended for John Fenno, a man he had attempted to rob but whose strong resistance had impressed him. Supposedly, a lady friend of French astronomer Camille Flammarion bequeathed her skin to bind one of his books, and indeed, at his observatory, there is a copy of his La pluralité des mondes habités on which is stamped reliure en peau humaine 1880.
However, as the Horwood Book demonstrates, the skin in question is not always given gladly. One assumes the nobles executed during the French Revolution would be less than pleased to hear what (allegedly) became of their remains...
Another confirmed example is Arsène Houssaye's book Des destinées de l'ame (The Destinies of the Soul), which was bound in the skin of an unclaimed female mental patient who had died of natural causes. Houssaye’s friend, one Dr Ludovic Bouland, was responsible for having the book bound in human skin, apparently as a reflection of the book’s exploration of the human condition. Bouland also had a book on female virginity bound in human skin, revealing in the good doctor an unsettling fascination with the practice.
Indeed, one might argue that the use of women’s skin for anthropodermic bibliopegy perhaps represents the objectification of women taken to the nth degree. Another intriguing rumour concerns a copy of the Marquis de Sade's Justine et Juliette, which is said to be bound in the skin of a woman's breast, with a visible human nipple on the cover—although the book in question has either been lost, hidden away in a private collection, or never existed in the first place...

One of the creations of Dr Ludovic Bouland, BBEG in an as-yet-unwritten French campaign…
The macabre concept of books bound in human skin has long captured the imagination of horror writers, many of whom have incorporated the idea into their fiction. It is difficult to pinpoint the first reference to such a book in horror literature, but Lovecraft's 1924 short story The Hound is a notable early example, featuring a portfolio of horrific drawings bound in “tanned human skin”. Of course, many a Keeper may have described with some relish the Necronomicon as being bound in human skin and inked in blood, although this particular description originates from Sam Raimi's Evil Dead film series rather than the original Lovecraft.
One way or another, the concept of anthropodermic bibliopegy continues to fascinate horror writers and fans alike. And I have at times wondered about the provenance of the beautiful leather used to bind Chaosium’s 40th anniversary Keeper Rulebook...

Keeper Rulebook: Binding unconfirmed.
13th April
As hinted above, John Horwood has been somewhat exonerated by history—for more on the subject, seek out An Unjust Hanging by Dave Halliwell—but we will probably never know the full truth behind the death of Eliza Balsom. One thing we can say for certain is that the story of a poor unfortunate used as a convenient scapegoat to cover up the guilt of someone with far greater power and social status is an all-too-common one throughout human history.
There is a postscript to the tale of John Horwood—although one not completed for another 190 years. While the book bound in his skin is still on display at the M Shed museum in Bristol, his skeleton was finally interred in a formal funeral on 13th April 2011.
Please enjoy Crime and Punishment, which is attached—and do let us know if you attempt to play it!
-DW
