Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 725959458.mp4

Downloads

Content

Honestly, watching this AFTER Andor was necessary for closure, but there was no way the film could compete.

Files

Comments

Spongy Banana's

Not a good movie at all, especially now when it has to live up to Andor, but those last few minutes of Vader are sooooo good

Jon Denton

They are. Skimming through in the edit, there are some cool scenes, and the final battle was probably better in a theatre. But I couldn’t get past the first hour or so.

BigMoistPlatypus

I remember when they announced Andor as a TV show. Having seen rogue one and seeing this super dull, flat and uninteresting character I thought it was so dumb they were making a spin off about him. Who would have thought that’s how it’d turn out.

Calem

Lea looks bad because you know she's cgi. Grand Moff Tarkin is also cgi and you didn't notice.

Khan Battle

I remember thinking that Tarkin didn't look that bad when I saw it in the theatre, but I remember thinking Leia looked like someone trying to describe Carrie Fisher having an allergic reaction or something. It also helps that Tarkin is kinda supposed to be unsettling anyway so him having an uncanny look isn't the end of the world but for Leia it absolutely is lol.

Khan Battle

Andor absolutely spoiled us, and unfortunately, I think that it is going to lead me to expecting something that the current people running Lucasfilm aren't going to be able to deliver on.

Peter Gulka

Pretty much all of these critiques are why I had hoped you'd try watching "The Andor Cut" fan edit. The score is totally lifted from Andor, a lot of member berries and fan service is cut, and it shifts the focus to Cassian from Jyn.

rayman

this movie is much better seeing it before Andor because watching it chronologically you go from a well written story with Andor as the focus to a movie that doesn't have Andor as the main character yet it has the end of his story, where he's essentially the main side character. So it's not a satisfying end to a character we spent 2 amazing seasons with. Watching Rogue One first you go into the show exploring a side character where you see the rest of his story and how good it was leading up to Rogue One and A New Hope.

Bishey

I actually disagree with people saying that watching Andor makes this movie better. Before watching Andor, this was a decent Star Wars movie, with the big twist being all the main cast dies. Probably one of the better ones too, since this one does have the occasional grit and sauce, in between all the rushed exposition and paper thin character work. After watching Andor, spending many hours with those characters, seeing their journey and troubles, it shows you what stories in this universe could be like. It is a bit unfair to expect the popcorn blockbuster movie to have the narrative richness of a 20 hour prestige political sci-fi drama but I nevertheless do. All I see as I watch Rogue One are the flaws, and what it could have been.

Adrian Gell

Well, thanks for answering my debate about best viewing order. And really just helping my appreciation of Andor by comparison. Can't disagree with your assessment. Mind, it's different watching as a fan of the larger universe, because i went in hoping for a glimpse of events not yet told, the height of the Rebellion itself, the end of Saw's story who we met as a youth when he lost his sister in an animation episode, etc. So I loved the story even if the story telling wasn't skilled. But again, very much appreciate the critical lens on a film I wouldn't have been capable of seeing it through.

Anthony Gullotta

It’s hilarious to me that you actually did notice in real time when exactly Tony Gilroy came in to clean up the mess and put the pieces back together. Not even kidding, you were spot on. Public perception was the same too. Because of his part, it saved the film in the eyes of critics (and the box office). And that was the exact reason they gave Tony Gilroy a blank canvas and blank check to do Andor. Kathleen Kennedy just appreciated how he saved the film from utter disaster and let him do whatever he wanted in Andor (she drew the line at saying “fuck,” that was the only thing Disney stepped in to change).

romai

I caught up with all your reactions of Andor and just now Rogue One, and I'm glad I did. I liked Rogue One but after rewatching Andor again with your commentary on film making and writing, in comparison to Rogue One, I get it now. Even though I liked Rogue One I just didn't know how to articulate why it felt off for me... it felt "flat" as you said some of the characters felt. Honestly I feel that's what made the movie feel flat for me, they didn't feel as real as the characters in Andor... I also feel the more I watch along with you the more I begin to hate exposition 😂