Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

The third of the double album saga is complete (after The White Album and Physical Graffiti).

Files

Comments

Joey Crowley

I’ve been waiting for this.

Ben Oliver

1. Animals 2. Dark side 3. Wish u were here 4. Meddle 5. Division bell/the wall/ atom heart mother

Ben Oliver (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-24 20:00 Whatever you think about Roger waters you can’t deny his lyrics were ahead of his time
2026-09-23 18:09 Whatever you think about Roger waters you can’t deny his lyrics and concepts were ahead of his time

Whatever you think about Roger waters you can’t deny his lyrics and concepts were ahead of his time

J

best PF album after dark side. Unfortunately the hipster answer of recent years is Animals but the wall has so much more meaning and power behind it, not to mention the production is much more flawless imo, people just love to hate on Roger cos of the dumbest reasons, but he wrote every lyric and put the chords behind them for gilmour to tinkle over, sadly dave gets all the credit for having the canvas of the genius already put in order

Joshua Ellis

@1:12:55. You were right about the personality defect. He has disassociate himself to the point of "cult of personality" and becomes a Neo-nazi for a moment. Not sure if its actually happening or in his own head.

Strider

1- wish you were here 2- dark side 3- the wall 4- meddle, animals, division bell

L Loftus

Ever changing but: 1. Dark side 2. WYWH 3. Animals/Meddle 4. The Wall

frogpaste75

meddle has to be up next

Derick

Meddles gotta be the next move. Echoes will blow your mind

Derick

Obscured by clouds is also a great very overlooked album. Came out a year before DSOTM so I like to think that album is obscured by DSOTM

Connor Lindegreen

Apple Music have a very good album description explaining some of your questions!

Noah Kahan

The whole thing with side d is that pink in a drug-induced hallucination is hallucinating that he is a fascist dictator Also the war stuff is that Roger Waters and also the character Pink Floyd in this story lost his father in World War II and his father going and fighting was the first brick in the Wall This is my most recent ranking of all their albums 1. Wish You Were Here (1975) 2. The Wall (1979) 3. Meddle (1971) 4. Animals (1977) 5. The Dark Side of the Moon (1973) 6. The Piper at the Gates of Dawn (1967) 7. A Saucerful of Secrets (1968) 8. Obscured by Clouds (1972) 9. Atom Heart Mother (1970) 10. More (1969) 11. The Endless River (2014) 12. The Division Bell (1992) 13. The Final Cut (1983) 14. A Momentary Lapse of Reason (1987) 15. Ummagumma (1969)

Nam Lam

Wish you were here is my favourite, because of how immersive the sound experience is, along with the emotional aspects. The Wall is second for me; probably the most intriguing album listen ever, and the peaks are some of the best in their discography. Definitely their most experimental album as well.

Spencer Reed

Meddle next for sure! Meddle has one of their most iconic and beloved songs Echoes, and shows a slightly earlier and less polished DSOTM type sound which I think you’d love. Their earlier albums pre-Meddle are very experimental and vary greatly in quality song to song, throwing ideas at the wall to see which stick for their later albums. My ranking would go: 1. DSOTM 2. Wish you were here 3. Meddle 4. Animals 5. The Wall

Neemkeez Music

The stretch from In the Flesh to Waiting for the Worms stretch is obviously baffling on first listen, but I think it serves to elevate the album in such an amazing way. It is honestly uncanny the way this album foreshadows the recent far-right radicalization of young men in the US (a la Nick Fuentes, red pill, etc.), under the backdrop of a declining empire post-Iraq/Afghanistan war, economic uncertainty, and increased isolation. “Would you like to see Brittania rule again?” It creates a through-line between its exploration of personal trauma and the bludgeoning systems of war, chauvinism, and division. Even more so, it is a biting rejection of misanthropy/withdrawal from the world as a mechanism of coping with that landscape. “United we stand. Divided we fall.”

Antony Roles

loved the reaction. my go to pink floyd: Wish you were here animals Dark side division bell the wall the only part that lets down this album personally is the ending. I know how you looked into the background of the album being a 'rock opera', so the ending does make sense, but just not for me. I prefer the more ethereal music they make rather than the other stuff.

Gumbojones

Please go listen to comfortably numb live from pompey, gilmores guitar solo at the end live is something magical and just incredible i have no words just have to experience it

Michael Coy

The movie is excellent, explains is much more.

Rudy Lee-Barks

Really glad you liked it. But I struggle with The Wall. Purely from a musical perspective, only a handful of songs compete with the quality of Wish You Were Here and Dark Side imo.

ADI1992

Thank you for reminding me yet again that David Gilmour is absolutely GOATed

Tom

Please do meddle or the devision bell next

Keagen Fritz

I think it skipped the show must go on

Keagen Fritz

Agree with those suggesting Meddle. If not the whole album at least do echoes!

Trent Pierson

Given your past and what i assume the impact of how you perceive this album is, you getting through it and enjoying it for the masterpiece it is is so inspiring!! Thank you Jon but also… Watch the movie!!!

Trent Pierson

If you wanna know what’s going on in this album. WATCH THE MOVIE!!!!!!

Trent Pierson

I mean seriously, this album only truly makes sense if you watch the movie!!!!

Natee Huynh

for my rankings i put The Wall at the top easily, the overall sound and concept and writing is so amazing and for me beats everything else, then wish you were here then dark side

E

Very interesting that this is the story you take from this. I hear a story of a society training its population for war and the traumatic degradation of their minds from what they saw and their cries for help from the future not to repeat it. (This is also my first time listening to it.) also writing this comment part way through the watch.

Alex Leonard

The division bell has always been my favorite and I’m still waiting for your reaction video to it

Jake Powers

Have to watch Comfortably Numb from Pulse.

Antonio Iniguez

Summary The Wall is the story of a man named Pink and how he builds up a wall of isolation out of his trauma. Every time life hurts him, he adds another brick. His father dies in WW2, his school beats the individuality out of him, his mother smothers him, and his marriage falls apart while he's on tour. The first half of the album is his real life, in order, ending with the wall finished. The second half happens inside his head, because once he's sealed in there's nothing left outside for the story to happen in. The wall was supposed to protect him. It becomes the thing destroying him instead. 
Please use the entries below as a way to clarify any parts of the story that seem confusing. If you feel lost, read an entry after the song you feel lost on In the Flesh?: This first song is a prologue to the story. The main character, Pink, takes the listener back in time so you can "find out what's behind these cold eyes." The Thin Ice: The story starts at the beginning of Pinks life. This song is still sort of a prologue, warning Pink and the listener that life is like thin ice. If you slip it can be difficult to recover. Another Brick in The Wall pt1: It's revealed that Pinks father died in WW2 when he was a baby(The plane crash in the beginning foreshadowed this). Pinks grieving leads him to grow bitter towards his late father and starts to build his wall of isolation. The Happiest Days of Our Lives: The title of the song is sarcasm. Your childhood is supposed to be the happiest days of your life, yet like many kids after ww2 Pink has to grow up without a Dad. In addition, the school system was very physically and verbally abusive. Another Brick in the Wall pt2: The abusive school system leads Pink to add the second brick to his wall. Mother: Pinks Mother was overprotective and hindered his growth. She means well but the death of her husband forces her to be extra careful with her son. She also helped construct his wall. "Mother did it need to be so high" Goodbye Blue Sky: This is a traumatic memory of the bombings of Britain during WW2. He was a baby during the raids, so this isn’t his memory; it’s his mother’s and his country’s, handed to him. The fires are out, but the fear survives in the people who raised him. It’s the last brick of his childhood, and the song where that chapter closes. Empty Spaces: Can be treated as a transition in the narrative. The end of Pinks childhood and the start of his adulthood. It forshadows that Pinks is looking to finish his wall Young Lust: Pink is a young rock star trying to fill the void with women. He's looking for a "dirty girl" to make him feel like a "real man". Young Lust also reveals that he's married and that his wife is cheating on him. At the end you hear Pink try to call her. A telephone operator says "This is a man answering... Is there supposed to be someone else there besides your wife to answer?" One of My Turns: Pink brings a groupie(fan girl often looking to hookup) to his hotel room. Pink has a mental breakdown caused by his wife's affair. The line "I feel one of my turns coming home" implies Pink has habitual fits of rage. An "axe" is a slang term for a guitar. Pink is probably smashing things in this hotel room with his favorite guitar. Don't Leave Me Now: The previous song ends with "Why are you running away" directed at the groupie who was frightened by Pinks breakdown. This song starts with Pink saying "Don't leave me now" but it's directed at his wife. This song reveals that Pink would verbally and physically abuse his wife which led to her cheating on him when he was away. Instead of taking accountability, he blames her for leaving. Another Brick in the Wall pt3: Pink concludes that he needs to totally isolate himself from the world. Pink finishes his wall. Goodbye Cruel World: Pink says his final goodbye to the outside before closing his wall. The first part of the album described real events in Pink's life. The second half mostly describes events in his head. Hey You: Hey You represents an internal narration. Pink can see that the wall was a mistake and tries to muster up the courage to reach out for help but "The wall was too high" Is There Anybody Out There?: The direct follow-up to Hey You. Nobody answered, so Pink asks the empty room whether anyone is still on the other side. The song is mostly instrumental, and the fact that the question just repeats with no reply is the answer. Nobody Home: Pink takes inventory of his life from a hotel room. He lists off everything he owns and none of it adds up to a single person he can actually call. This is the loneliest point of the album: the wall worked exactly as designed. Vera: Built around Vera Lynn, the British singer whose wartime song promised soldiers and their families they'd meet again someday. Pink circles back to his father. The bitter joke is that the promise didn't hold for him, and he wants to know if anyone else remembers being told it would. Bring the Boys Back Home: The most direct anti-war moment on the album. At the end all the voices from earlier in the album come flooding back at once, which drags Pink out of the memory and back into the hotel room. Comfortably Numb By this point Pink is suffering from catatonic withdrawal and has shut down entirely. He's been alone in that room since Nobody Home, and the wall he spent the whole first half of the album building has finally sealed in both directions. That would be his own private problem, except there's a sold-out show that night and an entire business built on him walking out on stage. So a doctor is called in to make him functional and injects him with something to get him upright. The verses are the doctor getting almost nothing back. The choruses are Pink inside his own head, drifting to a childhood fever, and they're the most lucid lines on the record. That's the trick of the song: he can hear every word, he just can't send anything back. This is based on a real event. Waters was given a tranquilizer shot before a show in Philadelphia in 1977 and played the whole set feeling completely detached from it. The Show Must Go On: The last flicker of the real Pink. He's being loaded toward the stage and briefly panics, asking whether it's too late to back out and how he ended up here. Nobody stops it. The title is the response he gets. The machine around him doesn't care what condition he's in as long as he walks out there. *Everything from here until the end is a hallucination Pink is having from the injection* In the Flesh: We are where we started the album. We are in the present. Pink starts the concert and hallucinates himself as a fascist dictator and the concert as a rally, picking people out of the crowd and ordering them lined up against the wall. The significance of this is that Pink now sees himself as the very thing that took his father away. Run Like Hell: The rally spills out into the streets. Pink's imagined fans turn into a mob hunting down anyone who doesn't fit, and the song is sung from the side doing the hunting, telling the victims to run. Waiting for the Worms: The mob gets organized. The worms are rot, and they showed up earlier when Pink was decaying behind the wall. Now they've become a political movement with marching orders and a route through London. Underneath the shouting through the megaphone you can still hear Pink's real voice, quietly waiting for the worms to finish him off. The German shouted in the background makes the Nazi imagery impossible to miss. Stop: One word, one moment. Pink snaps out of the fantasy and shuts it down himself. Pink recognizes that he might be the one at fault after all. He asks himself, “Have I been guilty all this time?” and puts himself on trial to find the truth. The Trial: Pink prosecutes himself. The judge, the prosecutor, and every witness (the schoolmaster, the wife, the mother) are all built out of his own memory. Pink finally accepts the harm he’s caused to those around him. The charge is showing feelings, which is exactly the crime he's been punishing himself for since he was a kid. The sentence is to tear down the wall. Outside the Wall The wall comes down and Pink is exposed for the first time. The song is small and quiet on purpose after all that noise, and it points out that the people who loved him were out there the whole time, they just couldn't get through. It isn't really a happy ending so much as a starting point, because the record doesn't actually stop. The final words of “Outside the Wall” break off mid-question, and the mumble buried at the very start of “In the Flesh?” is the second half of that same sentence. Put the album on repeat and the two halves click together, which makes the whole story a loop. Isolation is a habit, not a one-time decision, and Pink can build it all again.