Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Team Black Trailer: https://youtu.be/csSaSrJJPRs

__

Somehow, I felt like it would be longer before House of the Dragon returned.

Yet, here we are enjoying the beginning of what will be a long (long) cycle of takes, divisions between book readers and show watchers, and HBO trying to pretend they haven't been making weird decisions on the backend regarding how they treat actors, writers, crew, artists, etc.

Since the first season of Game of Thrones, I have been too invested in the world of Westeros. Despite leaving the series in season five and returning for the final season, the television version of the world has left me with mixed feelings.

Still, when I was working at The Mary Sue, I got the opportunity to write and talk about House of the Dragon there, and so I wanted to continue that here because I really enjoy writing and talking about television. I also am trying to work on being more (eh) structured.

When I knew House of the Dragon was coming out, I read Fire & Blood (Part 1), but only up to the part I figured the show would be covering. I was familiar with the entire storyline from my late nights on the ASOIAF wiki to argue with people online, but since the book was there, I decided to listen to it on audiobook.

I could go on and on about the flaws of the first season (and I did discuss them with Hillary in podcast form here on Patreon), but despite that, I am deeply invested in this incarnation of the story a bit more than I am in the book version for a few reasons. Some of them are shown in the trailers themselves.

As someone who tends to prefer books to their show/film adaptations, I sometimes feel like I gave Fire & Blood too much authority. The book is meant to be seen as a flawed historical text from sources that can not be trusted. The story contains elements of fatphobia, sexism, and general ick that are typical of the series. Some of these elements can be deconstructed, and others are debatable.

Something is compelling about that ambiguity in Fire & Blood.

The way in which it asks you to believe in the petty and sexist ideas of the women at the center of the "Dance of the Dragons" (Alicent Hightower and Rhaenyra Targaryen). And, for a lot of readers, it makes "sense" that beauty would be at the root of disdain rather than the more serious issue of inheritance and rights.

I don't think it is as much of a mirror to the fantasy genre as the main series is, but more of a mirror to the way we are taught history textbooks. The way we need to question what someone wrote as "truth" that we learn in school and then keep sharing that. The way in which history can always be re-written to re-structured to maintain an agenda.

When it comes to HBO's House of the Dragon, the way it is told is meant to tell its own truth.

It is not always done well. I think it is trying to say things about female authority and sexuality that it has struggled with due to not fully understanding the complexities of certain themes (i.e., the scene between Rhaenyra and Criston Cole, which has been a subject of debate for several reasons). I think because of how it handles race there are a lot of discourses that have popped up around Rhaenyra that did not exist and are handled in the messiest way (but I'm also waiting to see how it might change now that many of those Black characters will be doing more interesting things beyond ... existing with dreads).

Because Game of Thrones was based on a series where multiple characters had complex inner lives and allegiances, and the ultimate evil was larger than any one person on the throne, we could easily have favorites from across the lines. As someone who came to love Jaime Lannister in A Storm of Swords (Book 3), the idea of him being up against someone like Arya, Sansa, or Dany was thrilling because it was possible to root for both of them.

The conflict in House of the Dragon is, in many ways (in my humble opinion), not that nuanced. Or, more so—the nuance is much more diminutive than it was in Thrones.

We can argue about how the morality or actions of certain characters would have made them unfit. We can argue about the Targaryen's roles as imperialist rulers who maintain their authority by having essentially weapons of mass destruction, good PR, and a lack of centuries of pre-existing bad blood to make them almost more ideal rulers than other houses in Westeros.

But at the core of the "Dance of the Dragons" (this civil war)—in both the book and the show—is the idea that Rhaenyra, because she is a woman, should not be able to inherit the throne. She is a threat to the Hightowers, and her rise would mean their (possible and likely) undoing as one of the most powerful and influential houses in Westeros.

And now the small folk (WHO DO MATTER DESPITE WHAT SOME WRITERS WILL TELL YOU) will suffer.

Both sides will do (and have done) horrible things for power, and it will only make them weaker. And for what? Vanity and ego and sexism.

I do think that the writers are more careful about Rhaenyra because of how things ended with Dany and their writing for female characters in GOT largely being ass. Yet, I think it is a good instinct, not simply because I'm #TeamBlack. But because essentially, she is in a more outwardly sympathetic position.

We know terrible kings don't just ~lose~ their thrones from the main series. She may be stubborn, proud, and have an ain't shit husband, but when has that kept a man from inheriting?

I want there to be character complexity, but I think that Alicent is the character with the most interesting layers. She has duel loyalties, her own pride and faith, her own struggles, and (I believe) does think that her husband wanted their son to be king.

Why? Me nah know.

Rhaenyra's desire to go to war to avenge her son and her "right" to rule will always be rooted in "entitlement," but I bristle at the way that in this series, whenever the women are fighting for what they are actually entitled to it is treated as an inherently villainous start.

Nearly every character in this series feels entitled to something. I'm not going to begrudge Rhaenyra's entitlement to her imperialist throne when the other option is ... another person with imperialist blood who happens to be a male.

I'm excited to see how the discourse will evolve with new people working on the show and more elements complicating the allegiances. Blood & Cheese is going to be ... a lot.

Still, I look forward to talking to you about it.

I'm rooting for Team Black, but mostly, I want more of Emma D'Arcy and Olivia Cooke being sapphic together. D'Arcy is an amazing actor and has proven themselves to be capable of reaching so many emotional depths. It's also great having a non-binary actor in this role, and every time they speak, I'm so impressed by how much they connect to Rhaenyra. Olivia Cooke is just glorious as Alicent and I can't imagine anyone else in the role.

I know Alicent is often compared to Cersei, but I feel she has much more in common with Sansa. While I don't stan, I have a lot of empathy for her position, and Cooke really brings it.

Random thoughts:

*Daemon can still choke, and he still doesn't get any eyebrows.

*Aemond, unfortunately, is still hot and serves. He will never get me to turn allegiance, but I hope we get more of him.

*Rhaena and Baela both got new hair upgrades, and I'm excited to see these two do more this season. I'm still mad we were robbed of Rhaenyra and Laena's friendship.

*If Criston Cole has no haters, I'm dead.

*Alicent, you are gonna need a stronger bath.

*Will anything be done to make Aegon seem like a good king? The show has not at all, and the book spoke poorly of both him and Rhaenyra, but they made Rhaenyra incompetent. They make Aegon a sex pest who is also incompetent.

*"My uncle is a challenge I welcome" —we shall all be seated for that.

*I enjoy Rhaenys, but she's always saying some weird shit. "[...] we won't remember why the war began?" Um, I'm sure she'll never forget that a dragon ate her son! And didn't you bust through the basement of a church like a Tomb Raider with a dragon that could have ended the whole thing? Maybe you should have taken that shot when you had the chance.

No book untagged spoilers plz for the tv show watchers <3

Files

House of the Dragon | Official Green Trailer | Max

The Green Trailer is here. #HOTDS2 premieres June 16 on Max. #TeamGreen About Max: Max is the culture-defining entertainment service for every mood. With a variety of genres that include your favorite series and movies from iconic brands and treasured franchises, it delivers irresistible stories every time. From reuniting with life-long favorites to uncovering new ones you haven’t discovered yet, there's something for every moment, every feeling, every you. It’s all here. Iconic series, award-winning movies, fresh originals, and family favorites featuring the worlds of Harry Potter, the DC Universe, and HBO. Discover the best entertainment for every mood. Introducing Max – the one to watch. #WarnerBrosDiscovery #streamonmax #theonetowatch SUBSCRIBE TO MAX https://streamonm.ax/3vgR69B GET MAX https://streamonm.ax/3TpcvWA FOLLOW MAX Follow Max on YouTube: https://streamonm.ax/YouTube Follow Max on Instagram: https://streamonm.ax/Instagram Follow Max on TikTok: https://streamonm.ax/TikTok Follow Max on Twitter: https://streamonm.ax/Twitter Follow Max on Facebook: https://streamonm.ax/Facebook

Comments

SwamplingLvr

I have a hard time with the marketing this season as a "Choose a Side" thing. Like Team Hightower has any merit. Alicent's kids are nuts and her dad is a misogynistic asshole who's basically brainwashed her into acting against her own interests. The fact that this war happened because Alicent couldn't be bothered to clarify with Viserys who he was talking to is all kinds of frustrating. She could have just said, "Wait, what? We weren't talking about this before. Who were you talking to? Oh, Rhaenyra? Hold on, I'll go get her. Hey, Rhae, your dad wants you!" There, conflict over. I know they needed the plot to happen somehow, but this is one of those, "The dumb thing happened because the plot needed to happen." Whatever. This just gives me an excuse to make more "X with Yoshis videos".

Arsha Venkat

I also found that very confusing, shows usually try to make both sides more sympathetic but after season 1 I could not see a reason why anyone in the audience should support Aegon. In Fire and Blood it's clear that people should support Aegon because he's a man and that is the most important quality in that society but the "modern" audience so to speak has been given little reason to consider Aegon legitimate. Rhaenyra is the elder, educated as a future ruler should be, and actually wants the responsibility. Her being a woman isn't a deterrent to the audience so why would anyone be Team Green when Team Green means unrepentant rapist.

delmar

Where can I listen to the podcast mentioned at the beginning of the post?