Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content


SPOILERS FOR SEASON 1 OF BRIDGERTON/QUEEN CHARLOTTE AND HOUSE OF THE DRAGON 

My relationship with all Shonda shows is complicated. I enjoy the ambition. I'm glad to see a Black woman’s name being attached to must-watch television, and I’m even able to put my socialism slightly to the side to enjoy all the BIPOC and female/femme faces getting money. Since it was announced, Bridgerton has always been a complicated watch for me.

On the one hand, as a fan of period dramas, I’m so pleased to see so many Black and non-white faces at the forefront. I’m glad that a romance series has been given so much press and attention (yet is still missing from any kind of serious awards recognition). The books are white and hetero-normative as all get out, and so with one of those diversity milestones met, I’m still waiting for them to stop being cowards and make Benedict a queer man. His book is boring enough to need all the help it can get.

Make it a darker-skinned trans woman of color, and I’ll even shut the fuck up about any weird racial politics for the entire season.

Season three is something I’m looking forward to because I love Nicola. She’s hot, and I’m so excited to see a fat, short woman in her 30s be the main love interest in a major romantic protection. Am I in love with the fact that she’s with Colin (even after reading the book?)? No, but that’s because he has not seemed very compelling. One of the downsides of wanting to give everyone a side story is that they get all these love interests that are not the endgame—it is frustrating, but I get the need in an ensemble.

So, once again, as I face flight anxiety, I have chosen to double dip and craft this recap as I re-watch the first season of Bridgerton. I have a few hours, so let's see where it goes.

General Thoughts

I don't think it is possible to explain how much Daphne's actions against Simon ruined the rest of the first season. For most of the season, there is a lot to enjoy, not only about the show, but its characters. Some of that becomes even clearer if you've seen the second season for characters like Anthony. Anthony is such a fucking menace in that first season, but the time spent in season two discussing his trauma at being thrust into adulthood by the death of his father softens a lot.

Still an arse, though.

I do appreciate how the story illustrates gender with Daphne and Anthony. Both are the eldest of their gendered siblings with different responsibilities. Daphne needs Anthony for hers, but Anthony is divisive about what Daphne truly needs.

Violet Bridgerton (who is also the hottest one) is probably my favorite character. She exists in this realm of trying to prepare her children for happiness while working within very strict confines of respectability. She has been blessed with money, status, and true love, which makes her sometimes not the best person for bigger talks. That will come into play later, but Daphne is so frustrated by then that I'm just mad at society.

 “Are you an older brother? Or are you the man of this house?” Bars! From the hottest Bridgerton family member.

Marina's storyline feels icky still. I am on the 5th Bridgerton book, "To Sir Phillip, With Love," and it does not speak to a great fate for her. Knowing how much she is changed from the book, much of her story feels frustrating. She is the only woman of color to go through a romance arc, darker-skinned women in this season are in the margins, and the only Black woman of debutante age is in a weird pregnancy storyline where she has to trap a boring white man.

It also adds a lot of ick to the romance between Penelope and Colin. But that also happens when we see the boys sleeping with women we know they won't attach to. The romance with Siena is so intense, but at the same time ... kind of deeply shallow, when we know Anthony will end up with someone else. I'd forgotten that Benedict was with Genevieve Delacroix.

Eloise remains one of my least favorite characters on the show. She is the Mary Bennett type taken to its most elite white feminist conclusion, and it is grating to watch. The only people she is kind to are her brother and Penelope. She uses Penelope as a soundboard, and she respects the men in her life because they represent the freedom she herself doesn’t have. Fine, but that doesn’t mean smoking cigarettes and complaining is a personality. The conflict between her and  Daphne is so Arya and Sansa coded.

I love Penelope, I know she messed up, but I blame that green eyed boy! I forgot that Colin does help Penelope during one of the dances. But I’m also like Penelope, which is the best, so of course you should have done that. He is very different from his book counterpart so I'm the most curious to see how things will end up in season two.

Watching this episode made me wish that Queen Charlotte had more about Lady Danbury and Simon’s mother. She calls herself the late Duchess’s closest friend and I think seeing that relationship with another Black woman would have been really impactful to the story. Especially since part of her friendship with Charlotte in the series is rooted in class elevation. The Queen being a flighty drama seeker because of her own sad personal life is touching and makes more sense in retrospect.

Now to the frustrating part.

Daphne and Simon have good chemistry. The Pride & Prejudice trope has remained undefeated for a reason: I fear even more than enemies to lovers (because P&P is NOT enemies to lovers, and I stand on that). Add on fake dating, and it's just so good. It is depressing that Daphne's violation of Simon's consent is not taken seriously by anyone in the show. At least in the books white Simon is allowed to be angry, but Simon's Blackness makes his anger much more subdued.

Do I agree that he should have properly communicated and explained things to Daphne? Yes. Do I think his rationale is childish? Yes. That doesn't make Daphne's actions correct and the fact that no one seems to get that is jarring.

Oprah Daily had this article by McKenzie Jean-Philippe who wrote this::

"On social media, articles, and amongst my own family and friends, I've seen the moment spark intense debate. One side offers the possibility that the couple mutually consented; Simon simply lost willpower on his own account, while Daphne took the opportunity to empower herself in a society that put women at a sexual disadvantage. The other side argues that this scene is plain and simple: it depicts rape.

Regardless, in my opinion, it should have never existed in the first place.

The creators of the series should have, in fact, seen this coming, thanks to the book season 1 of Bridgerton is based upon: The Duke and I by Julia Quinn. This very same scene in the novel has been inspiring intense discussion amongst readers since its publication in 2000. However, The Duke and I paints a slightly more succinct picture of the situation. In the book, Simon was drunk and asleep when Daphne initiated sex, and he was clearly non-consenting."

To me, the scene is dub-con/assault and no matter how much certain people, including Quinn herself, want to turn this into some deeper moment of female empowerment—it does not come across that way. At all.

Van Dusen said he wanted Daphne to be 'flawed' and 'make questionable choices' but unless you are actually having people see it as that—it doesn't come across that way. Especially since Bridgerton isn't a show like Outlander that deals with leads who are in "gritty" situations. This was assault.

I would compare it to the House of the Dragon scene between Rhaenyra Targaryen and Sir Criston Cole. While I do understand that there was a desire to examine the sex scene between Rhaenyra and Criston because she is a princess and he is a knight, considering both the age gap between them and the way it was filmed and treated, I've always read the scene as having consent. But playing off the courtly love messiness of what happens when people from two stations are intimate and fall apart.

I think there is something to examine through it about Rhaenyra choosing power over "love" or what it means for a Knight to devote himself to a "princess" and how that choice itself can be rooted in sexist expectations. All of that is "questionable and flawed" because of the nature of the show.

Daphne's actions are seen as a necessary stone on the bridge toward her and Simon's future happiness. His consent be damned, and that's fucked.

At least season two doesn't have that. We get ... other issues.

Files

Comments

Ericka O.

Appreciate the audio, thanks.

Stephen B

Id argue simons subdued rage is less about blackness, but that he's a man* in a show that's very feminist. Also, to clarify, are you saying that Rhanera in HOTD being younger than Cole helps with the power dynamics even tho she's basically royalty and has total control over him?