Rewatching| Bridgerton Season 2 (Patreon)
Content
[NOTE: I am currently recovering from some mild lower back surgery so sitting is ... hard. I will have the audio recorded soon and will make sure this post is updated accordingly! Sorry for the delays. My ability to sit upright should be better soon! 5/15/2024]
We are less than a day out before we are due for another season of Bridgerton. This one with Penelope and Colin taking the focus to become the first main love couple on the show. Yay? Revisiting season two of the series was filled with some high points of sexual tension, chemistry, and just full-on everything that makes enemies to lovers so delightful. At the same token, some things are just very and truly grating to the appeal of the season. Let's get into it.
Our High Highs
I don't think we were prepared for the majesty of Kate and Anthony. Simone Ashley and Jonathan Bailey are doing the romance gods proud as their respective characters. The longing and agonizing desire between them throughout the season carries everything. Anytime you get frustrated or bored with someone, Anthony will sniff the air as Kate walks by, and all is right with the world. I love them together, and everything about the chemistry they shared made it even better when we finally got their kiss and sex scenes. Everything felt earned.
Kate and Anthony are also great characters who explore the dynamics of what it means to be an older sibling carrying on the family burdens. Both lost their fathers, and the hole of that loss has led to them making decisions that put themselves last, sometimes in really self-destructive ways.
For Kate, she feels she must earn the love of her family since her mother, Mary, is technically her stepmother. Mary fell in love with Kate's father and ran away with him to India, leaving behind a substantial family fortune. With her father dead, Kate feels she needs to step up and provide for her sister and mother. She puts that burden on even when it makes her cold and almost more like a drill sergeant than a sister. Kate keeps secrets and performs adultification herself while infantilizing Edwina to the point where the latter really is living for Kate without realizing it.
Anthony watched his father die, and in that moment, he became a man, head of his family, and superseded even his mother. The flashbacks are intense, and while Anthony has moments where you want to smack him so hard, you understand why. It is traumatic to have to decide if your mother should live or die. To realize that for two of your siblings, you will be the only father figure they will ever know. To be the eldest of eight and not be able to live for yourself. Anthony is not always a good brother, but it is easy to understand why.
What makes Kanthony so well-matched are those shared traumas and the flawed desire to do well. My friend JoAnn told me the other day that the mark of a good romance storyline is seeing how the characters have changed because of their love. When Daphne mentions that she never saw Anthony cry during the death of their father, it is a huge insight into his character. Anthony tells his mother he doesn't want to be in love because of the pain it would cause him or the people he loves.
That is why his tears at hearing that Kate has awoken from his coma are so narratively effective. He has grown. Kate didn't make him grow, but his feelings for Kate allowed him to finally access parts of his humanity that had been stuck.
ROMANCE BABY.
It also illustrates why Daphne and Simon are extra disappointing. They didn't genuinely grow or evolve. Simon was guilted and forced into wanting a child he didn't want to have. Something that the series seems to endorse.
Being selfish and leaning into the feelings they had for each other was something Kate and Anthony slowly accomplished together. It was beautiful and awesome and I can't wait to see what insights into their relationship we get in season three.
Lows
Alright, whoever decided to drag out the engagement for this long needs to be scolded repeatedly. It was such a poor handling of the storyline that it just made everyone look bad. I feel bad for Edwina, and while I am ride-or-die for Kathony, it doesn't erase that they were carrying on an emotional infidelity—one that was public and hurt someone they both claimed to care about.
In many ways, love made them reckless, but it was not an excuse. Edwina may have crossed a line when she said "half-sister," but she said it in anger.
Anger that I think is hard to fully grasp at first watch, but once you rewatch and realize the scope of the lie, it is borderline unforgivable. Having read the book (where this does not at all happen with a long-long engagement), it is a frustrating change.
I get why they didn't want another book where the engagement happens because two people were caught in a garden in a compromising position. Plus, I don't think even Jonathan Bailey can sell the image of him attempting to suck bee venom from Kate's breast.
It would have made great memes, probably.
The Featherington storyline is not as horrible as I remember. Having watched Rome again, I remember that every moment we had with Polly Walker was a gift. Plus, I think it is important for us to understand why, in this universe, Penelope is Lady Whistledown. She is a wallflower, yes, but she is also in a financially and socially compromised position. Even before her father died, the family is treated as a joke among the Ton. Not as respected or loved as the Bridgertons.
Lady Whistledown is not just a scathing pamphlet; it is a nest egg from a girl who has not been given any attention on the marriage market and may one day have to take it out on her own. It is a kind of economic freedom and power that is important—and one that Eloise, for all her pontificating about wanting to be knowledgeable and educated, seems to not understand.
Which brings us to...
Lowest Lows
I really just do not like Eloise. I try not to fall into the trap of not liking complex women when they teeter too close to being annoying, but Eloise, I'm a hater.
Eloise says a lot about wanting to be educated and not to be limited by her gender, but she never seems to be doing anything else other than scolding. Yes, she always reads as a shorthand for her personality, but we are also told that Bella Swan is a well-read person. I think of Mary Wollstonecraft, who was the second of seven kids. Who found solidarity with other women of intellectual pursuits (Jane Arden and Fanny Blood). Who became a governess and wrote about the education of women.
Since the series takes place around 1813, Mary Wollstonecraft has lived and died, leaving behind her magnum opus. Female writers like Maria Edgeworth and Mary Hays are alive and well in her world. Yet she doesn't seek them out. She rarely seeks out the fairer sex to do anything except mock and talk down to. Rather than use her position and privilege to educate herself and find a partnership with someone who will respect her intellect—she sulks.
All this I could forgive—if this wasn't a romance ensemble. Having read all the Bridgerton books, not only does Eloise fall in love and marry, but she excels as a stepmother. The characters in both incarnations are different animals. A change that makes sense in some ways, but if Eloise's endgame is to be married and have domestic bliss—at least now—why is she being so deeply obnoxious?
She's not going to end up being a free love swinger or a groundbreaking thinker like Mary Shelley (who could make a cameo anytime with her scandalous relationship with Percy Shelley since that happened in 1814). There is very little road for this to go other than paying lip service to the idea that, yes, we are in the Regency Era and women have limitations.
Yet even within that, Eloise Bridgerton has fewer limitations than most. It is frustrating to watch someone who has so much power and privilege for her gender be so petulant and anti-feminine in the show's attempt to have modern "feminist" ideals. I want more for this character, more for these ideals.
Discourse has been going on about who is the real bad friend between Eloise and Penelope. I will say that Eloise realized Penelope was Lady Whistledown because, for the first time since we've seen them on screen—Eloise listened to what Penelope was saying ...
Hopes for Season Three
Besides, of course, wanting some Kate and Anthony, my biggest desire is for Penelope to have a great romance story. And a really good sex scene or two.
Quite a few things are changing from the book, so I'm interested in how the conflict will unfold and what it will mean for Polin. Hopefully, Eloise has some actual politics behind her words now.
One also hopes they will be setting up Benedict not just to be a boring sad art boy once more. Rumors have been flying about who his love interest will be, and I'm looking forward to seeing if they are confirmed.
I'm ready to be amused.