Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

The first of three Patreon exclusive videos come up this movie <3 


Enjoy and I apologize for the focus issues, thankfully WandaVision looks better! That video will be up Monday :)

Files

Patreon Exclusive: Soul Movie Review

Enjoy!

Comments

L H

I sooo agree with all of the things you are saying. I just wish I could articulate it as well as you do. So sometimes I just send my friends the links to your commentary.

Astrodabu

Yeah, Soul felt a little too "token." Even watching extras about the movie, you can see the black brain trust that was the creative team, and there's only one black female on the team. I don't even know if Pixar even HAS another black, female employee. I think the comparison to Coco is the best way to highlight how this movie isn't really a movie by and for black people. My only hope is that this is the first meaningful step in that direction. At least seeing a range of different skin tones and hair textures is a biiiiiig step IMHO.

Luke

Omg I had to stop the video for a sec to give props on your Tracee Ellis Ross suggestion because Joan Clayton as 22 would have been perfection!

Astrodabu

The extras of the movie talk about how the barbershop scene was added in at the end because the movie was missing that feeling of black authenticity. Seriously, take out that single scene in the movie, and what makes this movie "black?" This movie was conceived by a white guy to be as a vehicle for a white rock musician. Altering the characters to be black only feels like a surface level "black washing" without the real heart and soul behind it. In another Pixar movie extra, the script supervisor (a white lady) is talking about how Pixar built in a way to indicate gender on their script so they could keep track of how skewed/balanced the gender distribution is...now they just need to apply that same rationale to race & gender fluidity, on screen and behind the screen. It was so frustrating to get a taste of Pixar's New York and then be transported to an amorphous limbo world where deep down inside...we're all just white blobs -______-

Cambriel

Hi. Not sure if you take requests, or if there is a form or something to fill out, but I'd be interested in your general thoughts/reaction (and maybe more pointed thoughts about love and redemptions stories) in response to Xena season 2, the alternative watch order. The alternative watch order being: Orphan of War, Remember Nothing, The Giant Killer, Girls Just Wanna Have Fun, Return of Callisto, Blind Faith, The Execution, Intimate Stranger, Ten Little Warlords, For Him the Bell Tolls, Warrior...Princess...Tramp, A Comedy of Eros, Ulysses, Lost Mariner, Here She Comes Miss Amphipolis, A Day in the Life, The Price, The Xena Scrolls, Destiny, The Quest, A Necessary Evil Stand alone Christmas Special: A Solstice Carol

Evan McGrady

Soul felt like a "Kiki's Delivery Service" and "Whisper of the Heart" in terms of the narrative arc around the artistic journey (Sorry, I don't watch many movies so this is as close as I can get to a 'artist journey') -- I don't know if it was meant to be a cultural narrative but damn, yeah all your points hit.

Niquol

My thoughts on Soul: I don’t regret watching it but I won’t make the effort to watch it again. It felt like bait and switch with advertisements. I went in thinking that it would be all about Jamie’s character but instead it was about Jamie helping a non-Black character found their own purpose in life. He came off Tokenized in his own film. How did that happen? I honestly didn’t care about 22 at all. I love Disney and I have an attachment to Pixar, but I need the folks to do better.

Kaizen

I honestly didn’t love Soul. I liked it and enjoyed it but unfortunately I felt it didm’t deliver the way it could’ve. I mean I honestly thought it would be about Joe’s character and his arc and his journey when watching the trailers but then it was much different. I felt like they tokenized Joe instead of having him be the focus as the trailers suggested he would be, practically making 22 the main protagonist which I felt took away from Joe’s story. On top of that I also feel like they handled the idea of Joe poorly as it ended up making me dislike Joe for the entire movie when he acted like out of all those who died he should get a second chance, as if him not getting to play music gave him the right to be brought back and continue living. He just came off incredibly selfish and 2 dimensional. I don’t regret watching soul, I just don’t think I would watch it a second time.