Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

A few weekends ago went to the Alamo in New York and watched Eternals for the second time.

In the absence of loud teenage boys and my brain constantly trying to fit this film into the larger decade-plus reality of the Marvel Cinematic Universe I found myself actually feeling free to enjoy it. As a result, I can say it is probably the thing that has most made me interested in Marvel since Wanda Vision.

A little bit of background on Eternals and its creator, Jack Kirby.

Jack Kirby was the creator of DC's New Gods. A space opera-type story about the rivalry between the planets Apokolips and New Genesis.

New Genesis is a utopian planet filled with beautiful nature so untouched by climate change I’m jealous just thinking about it, and ruled by the benevolent Highfather.

Apokolips is a nightmarish, polluted, and ruined dystopia (aka the U.S in 2021)  ruled by a big thick ol' rock daddy named Darkseid.

It was an epic story in the classical sense.  Powerful protagonists, world-ending stakes, babies switched at birth, Good stuff.

It didn't do well.

When Kirby left DC he returned to his old stomping grounds, Marvel Comics. There, he decided to make a second attempt at this epic story he was crafting with the Eternals.

Eternals was about an extraterrestrial race of humanoids created by the alien Celestials to defend Earth from their evolutionary tether kin, the Deviants.

History repeated itself and after just 19 issues the series was canceled due to poor sales. Still, the mythology created by Kirby ended up being used as part of the Marvel comic world in other ways. Especially with the Celestials being the capital G, Gods of the Marvel world.

Zhao's adaptation builds upon that transformation of the series.

“In 5000 BC, ten superpowered Eternals—Ajak, Sersi, Ikaris, Kingo, Sprite, Phastos, Makkari, Druig, Gilgamesh, and Thena—are sent by the Celestial Arishem to Earth on their starship, the Domo, to exterminate the invasive Deviants. The last of the Deviants are killed in 1521, and the group's opinions differ over their continued responsibilities and their relationship with humankind. Over the next five hundred years, they mostly live apart from each other, awaiting Arishem's return.” —Convenient Wikipedia plot summary./

When I first watched Eternals, I was focused on “is this film good?” By the time I was sitting in theaters it was already the lowest-rated MCU film ever (even lower than Ang Lee’s Hulk) with mixed reviews from the audience and critics.

That alone was intriguing.

My first viewing was marred by a terrible theater experience with sexist teenage boys to my right and my brain on maximum critic mode. I want to dissect!

In that sense I missed things because I never actually allowed the film to prove its merit to me, I was trying to force it to be something either excellent or terrible.

I knew after I walked out I needed to rewatch it and a few weeks later I did. I really enjoyed it.

Director and co-screenwriter Chloé Zhao, Academy Award-winning female director, had a vision coming into this film and it was to tell a thoughtful science fiction story.

One of the books I saw that was recommended to read as an inspiration for Eternals was the Arthur C. Clarke novel Childhood’s End.

Arthur C. Clarke is best known for cowriting one of the greatest sci-fi films of all time, the 1968 film 2001: A Space Odyssey. In addition that, Clarke was a prolific science fiction writer and considered, with Robert Heinlein and Isaac Asimov, to be one of the “Big Three” of science fiction.

One of the books he felt was one of his best was the 1953 work Childhood’s End. The novel tells about a group of technically advanced aliens who become dubbed “the Overlords,” who arrive on Earth and slowly transform it into a Utopia. Why? Well, that is a spoiler. All this to say that part of the question the novel asks is “What does humanity look like without conflict?” What could humanity become if it had erased all crime, all inequality?

In Eternals, that is something our alien heroes discuss. They are told that they are not meant to interfere with humanity’s wars unless it is to protect them from the Deviants. Still, they are tasked with helping human development along—just at a slower pace than other advanced alien species.

As the twist in Eternals reveals that Earth is essentially hosting the life of a Celestial and that the planet will be destroyed in order for life to continue on across other galaxies, it asks a question about what humanity place is in the grander scheme of things.

This was a large part of Clarke’s own fiction and present in Childhood’s End.

In Childhood’s End, it is revealed that the reason why the Overlords came is that they are working for something called the Overmind. The Overmind is a vast cosmic intelligence that was created from a blending of civilizations that have transcended beyond material existence. The Overmind sent the Overlords there to ensure that humanity did not destroy itself before it evolved to the next stages of humanity: the birth of psychic children, separate from humanity and joined together in one mind.

They eventually are called up to the Overmind, and the Earth dies, transformed into energy that joins the Overmind and feeds a new, different kind of life.

Eternals is the flip of this and in it, Zhao attempts to weave a more introspective film about what it is like to be an alien among humanity. Especially one that can blend in.

While the characterization is rushed, there was more chemistry and bond shown with the Eternals than a lot of team-ups we've seen in the past.

There is a sense of love and shared history in the way they speak to each other and treat one another. Even with the exposition and plot all having to consume a big chunk of the film's narrative, the characters still got moments to show us who they are.

I especially enjoyed Sersi, even more, the second time around. It was nice for her powers to be passive but still shown to be strong and meaningful to the group. Her empathy and kindness for humanity were played as a strength—not a weakness.

Considering the film is coming to Disney+ soon and audiences who may have been turned off can finally check it out. I would say to give it a chance, especially if you like science fiction.

Eternals feels like a science fiction film that struggles under the weight of the MCU brand.

If it wasn't for the over-saturation of Marvel along with the tropes that have been the bane of critics for years, I think the response to Eternals wouldn't be so mixed.

It isn't an empty void of meaningful quiet moments. There is a beautiful richness to each moment and because it is forced to do so much in such a small amount of time—there is not enough space for it to breathe.

Yet, I found myself engaged with the film, the lives of these people, and wanting more of it. To me, this series was given the scope that I wanted Loki to give me.

More than anything, I think it shows one important thing about Kirby's stories—they are fantastic tributes to speculative fiction, but they are not for everyone. And that's great. I think that it is easy to forget that within the realm of comics there are just as many genres as in traditional literature.

I am glad Eternals was made and I think within the next few years, as it finds an audience beyond the generic Disney/Marvel brand it was looking to attract, people will give it the credit it deserves.

While not without flaws, the movie is filled with possibilities, ideas, and more than just tugging at the heartstrings of nostalgia and popularity. Plus, its a pro-choice movie!

What did you all think?

My Takes:

  • Ikarus and Sersei had no chemistry, but I believed that they shared this path together which made the final scene impactful.

  • Sprite's relationship woes were very bleh and I think they had an great opportunity to do something else with her and went for the most cliche option.

  • Everytime Kit's character and Ikarus were on screen together I giggled. Stark boys are back!

  • Why did they make Kumail Nanjiani bulk up so much if they weren't going to give him shirtless scenes?!

  • Angelina Jolie should be Wonder Woman.

  • Gilgamesh x Thena forever.

  • Also, Druig and Makkari.

  • I think that a lot of people read that Phastos scene way more literally than what it actually explained on screen.

  • I really love and appreciate the diversity in the Eternals, but I hope we can get to a place where that kind of diversity is the norm and not half the press tour of the product.

Files

Comments

Juli No Fooly

Thank you for the detailed opinions! I was waiting for streaming anyway before passing judgement, though mostly because I've read the Gaiman eternals and only that version >_>

Andrew Sparling

Well said, I'm going to definitely check this out again. I think Sersei being recognized as one of the most powerful of Earth's Protectors without needing to be aggressive is an excellent change and I hope we got a wider range of heroes in the future

Zara Brill

Pretty much agree with all your points. Didn't dislike the film as much as I thought I would and honestly found a lot to like (mainly Thena+Gilgamesh). Still really didn't like Sersi, Ikarus, and Sprite which put a damper on my overall enjoyment since they are so prevalent. I also kind of wish that Loki had been a movie and The Eternals had been a series instead. I wish that we got to spend more time to know these people before the big conflict at the end. Still vaguely interested to see where things go from here but after seeing Spiderman my MCU energy is draining very very fast.

Dora Mercedes

Angelina as WW would be a dream come true. I also really loved Thena x Gilgamesh. And I agree a second viewing is essential.

Affectionate Manatee

I'm catching up on all your reviews now, and I really agree with everything you wrote. "To me, this series was given the scope that I wanted Loki to give me." -- Really agree with this part! And the other commenter who said that this one should have gotten the TV treatment and Loki the movie one (I felt like Loki was way too long for no reason). Although Sersei and Ikarus had no chemistry, I have to say I liked the dynamic of Sersei and Kit's character! It was cute to see him with heart-eyes whenever she was around (wish he was around more!)

Brittany Fuller

All of your final Takes are exactly how I felt after seeing Eternals, especially the Sprite stuff. I thought it was a much better movie than it was being given credit for and that the baggage of the MCU definitely weighed it down and clouded impressions of it. I hope we do get to visit these characters again in some form because I really got attached to them.

Ry

I finally watched it on D+! so now i have opinions haha! Honestly Im sadly dissapointed. I came for Salma so ofc sad to see her demise from the start. Dissapointed they killed 2 POC characters but kept Druig alive when his white butt literally played power dynamic colonizer god on ppl of the Amazons and yet those ppl spoke spanish and were clearly non indigenous tho supposedly hes "kept these people safe" mmmhm. I agree with your point about Sprite and rly wanted to like her but that storyline/motivation was really really meh. I just wish i had more time with the characters I enjoyed and less time with the characters i hated (ikarus, druig, tbh sprite after the love reveal). Overall I dont hate it I just am really dissapointed and sad. I really could not get over the gross Druig being god over the poor helpless brown ppl thing.