Princess Watches: The Witcher S.2 | Spoilers (Patreon)
Content
The Witcher season two ended up being a strange comfort food this weekend. While my memories of the previous season were somewhat hazy, it didn’t take me long to get reinvested in the story of Geralt, Ciri, and Yennifer (ft. Jaskier).
Ciri (Freya Allan) especially stood out this season as the mythology around her, and her relationship to the elves was explored. As I watched her arc this season, it was impossible not to think of another pale royal with strange abilities—Game of Thrones’ Daenerys Targaryen. But we will get to that.
Geralt & Ciri:
When we last saw these two, Geralt and Ciri had finally found their way to each other. Geralt is determined to protect Ciri and takes her to Kaer Morhen – the stronghold of the witchers. Ciri is put through the physical rigor as the sole female presence among a bunch of grizzled old Witchers who see her as a spoiled, pampered princess.
Geralt believes Yennefer to be dead and is still mourning her, so puts his energy into being a father figure for Ciri. Figuring out what her powers are and where they come from.
Last season Yen and Geralt were the love story, and this season it is very much the familial bond between Ciri and Geralt. I enjoyed watching Ciri's dedication to becoming a warrior. With female characters, especially those with “chosen one power,” there is a fine like to walk between making them strong in a "realistic" way and having the shit beaten out of them constantly in order to humble them (cough *Laurel* cough).
Ciri is a sheltered princess, so her learning curve makes sense. But we see her determination to fight for revenge, for some sense of freedom from the fear that has been shadowing her ever since Cintra fell. Because we know what Ciri lost and how brutal it was, it is easy to put ourselves in Ciri's shoes.
We find out in season two of The Witcher that Princess Cirilla Fiona Elen Riannon aka Ciri has Elder blood, despite her grandmother being notoriously bigoted against elves. The reason for that is that Ciri’s maternal line is descended from Lara Dorren, a powerful elven mage. Ciri possesses great power because of it, and due to a curse, Ciri has the ability to bring forth creatures from the monoliths.
I have some game/book knowledge about what that all means, but I don’t want to ruin that for anyone, so we will just put a pin in that.
During the big finale fight, Ciri brings forth basilisks. The image of her in white, her pale blonde hair, mystically colored eyes, and the reptile-like creatures beside her screamed Daenerys/Dany.
The Witcher novels and A Song of Ice and Fire are not that similar at all (and the fantasy genre is filled with white-haired princesses), but for nearly a decade, Game of Thrones was fantasy television, and Dany was one of the faces of that series.
Ciri on the show is supposed to be somewhere between 12-13 years old, and while Freya Allen is twenty years old, she is dressed in clothes that are loose and styled in a way that is meant to highlight her youth and innocence.
This season, she’s likely 14 at the most, considering the time that passes in-show. The people around her treat her with a parental protective eye.
In contrast with Dany, who was also meant to be thirteen in the book series and aged up to sixteen in the television show, the GoT series always wants us to see Dany as a sexual being.
Sexual assault is part of her storyline from the beginning, and even men who seem to want to protect her, like Jorah, are romantically and sexually interested in her. There is no adult figure who actually wants to protect her without some sort of agenda.
While Ciri is training with the other Witchers they do push her physically as a warrior, but no one is being lecherous towards her. They tease her for being a princess, but when it comes down to it they want to protect her.
My surprise at that only highlights how normalized we are to series like this, always having the threat of sexual violence be a part of the story and excused as “necessary.”
Ciri has lost everyone she grew up knowing, has been betrayed, on the verge of death, and has powers she can only begin to understand—we don’t need sexual violence as an add-on to her story.
Of course, The Witcher hasn’t completely ignored sexual violence, but this season there was no rape at all, and that was honestly refreshing.
Another thing I thought was interesting was how Ciri’s powers connect to the elves.
The Witcher has clearly set up the elves as a stand-in for Indigenous and other historically persecuted communities—a cliche trope at this point.
Ciri is part elf, but that was hidden from her in order to protect her from those who would try and use her. It sets up Ciri in a place to be a liberator to one group and an oppressor to another, depending on which side she chooses.
One of the criticisms of Dany was that she was a white savior who was a descendent of invaders, using a mostly brown army to help to reclaim her throne. Game of Thrones never really knew how (or honestly wanted) to deal with that aspect of her character until the very end when they just decided to make her a mindless warlord over the course of two episodes.
Due to the world of The Witcher being much more diverse, we manage to avoid those undertones, and by having Ciri be a bridge between these two societies, we get to have more conversations about who gets to lead a group into salvation.
Yennefer:
I have mixed feelings about Yen's storyline this season.
After Yennefer burns pretty much all of the Nilfgaard troops allowing her other side to get reinforcement, she ends up losing her magic and being captured by the remaining forces of Fringilla’s army.
Then those remaining forces are slaughtered by the elves who capture the two mages. The elves are being led by the elf Francesca, who has been having visions of a robed figure in white.
Yennefer and Fringilla both have similar visions but of someone in red and black. They end up being led to the Deathless Mother, a mysterious witch who offers them all power in exchange for something.
Yennefer doesn’t accept, but still ends up freed. Fringilla decides to follow the elves and forge an alliance between the elves and Nilfgaard.
The remainder of the season is Yen struggling with her lost magic and running around. While Yen remains very competent the entire time (she blows fire in someone's face), I very much, in general, hate the storyline of "a woman loses powers so she can learn to love."
Literally, the only time a woman losing her powers actually made for an interesting storyline was in the comics with Storm.
Other than Yen not being able to magic her way out of situations right away, this loss of magic doesn't really lead to anything of value until it comes to the point where the Deathless Mother tells Yen to bring her Ciri.
Not knowing that Ciri is Geralt's surprise child, she is willing to give the girl up and it leads to one road trip with Zuko style episode where Yen helps Ciri use her magic, forms a maternal attachment to the girl, and then ... well, set up for the rest of the series.
As I haven't read the books or played the game, I don't know the relationship between the two was established in that canon—but this seemed rushed. And just a way to force conflict between Ciri/Geralt.
We know Yen is a ruthless purple-eyed bad bitch. She has thrown people under the bus for the sake of power, but we also know how deeply she longs to have a child of her own and once she knew that Geralt was Ciri's father ... I just don't think she would have done this.
She already has seen what magic has stolen from her. I just think she would be clever enough to find a new way.
Plus, it would have been just more fun to see Yen and Geralt both training Ciri and having them divided about what should take more attention—magic or the sword.
Fringilla and the Elves:
Last season when we saw Fringilla, she was the niece of an important member of the Brotherhood of Mages, who was snubbed for a big position in favor of Yennefer leading to her being aligned with the evil Nilfgaard.
As a result of her time there, Fringilla turned into something of a blood mage, but season two evolved it beyond that.
Once Fringilla arrives at Nilfgaard, she gets a new outfit, great new hair, and attempts to actually protect and help the elves. This was a turn I hadn’t expected since last season she’d come across as more of a zealot than anything else.
Fringilla’s role in Nilfgaard is interesting to watch because when it is just her running things, there is easy confidence and empathy she radiates. In her conversation with Francesca, they both speak about longing for partnership. As soon as the men of Nilfgaard arrive, everything Fringilla does is under a microscope, pushing her to be crueler.
Then her relationship with elves begins melting away from one of partnership to one of manipulation—something that she seems uneasy with. Fringilla seeks out guidance from her uncle, but he responds to her in such a pompous way that it makes Fringilla decide: it’s time to murder.
Using her sorceress training, she weaponizes her knowledge of botany to poison the leadership of Nilfgaard. Fringilla paralyzes them and kills all save one as she monologues about not letting anyone steal her shine again. It’s a stunningly acted and choreographed scene.
To quote Stefani Joanne Angelina Germanotta, “I don’t believe in the glorification of murder. I do believe in the empowerment of women.”
Sadly Fringilla ends the series in an awkward place for our girl boss as the Emperor returns and imprisons her for not being harsher with the elves.
What I love about Fringilla is her moral complexity. I am so happy to see a dark-skinned Black woman in a fantasy series serving a bigger function than just diversity decoration. Her actions have consequences on the Continent. She is someone who can help bring a baby into the world with warmth one episode and then brutally kill a bunch of men later.
That is the representation that matters.
Elves as a metaphor for colonized people is, again, not new, but I did love how unapologetic the elves were about looking out for their own and not giving a fuck about humans unless it had to do with maintaining their own freedom and power.
Good for them.
Even in storylines that would be cliche in other places, The Witcher has the chemistry to make it work.
Closing Opinions:
I missed the non-linear timeline. I never found it too confusing and it does distract from the fact that on its surface, The Witcher is a basic fantasy series.
I enjoy all the mythology we have learned. I especially think the idea of how all the different races were split and then forced together is something I can't want to see explored in the prequel.
I loved all the Black characters having some fresh looks. I appreciate the sacrifices the white cast made for their edges to look like trash.
The actress playing Francessa is a mixed raced Black woman, and they made her look a whole Caucasian. Collect those white bags, my light-skinned kin.
The monsters remain super awesome! I love the design of them all. But did they have that woman die with her tits out?
Geralt not being as naked this season makes it inferior to season one. They put the bath scene in all of their marketing last season, don't play these games with us Netflix.
The more I find out about The Witcher mythos, the more I want to read the books—so I ordered them!