Princess Watches: Emily In Paris—Entry Level Whiteness (Patreon)
Content
There was something very surreal about watching Emily in Paris while I was staying in Mexico. The show is infamous for multiple reasons, and with the lowest expectations, I walked into the series expecting delicious trash and boy was I fed. Both seasons are the perfect kind of shows that would have aired on The CW.
I’d suspect that the cast of Katy Keene felt green with envy that Emily has been allowed to coast on a surprising amount of mediocre-to-bad writing but serving enough scenery and fashion porn to still make you look.
So what in seven the Hells is Emily in Paris?
It is the story of Emily Cooper (Lily Collins, a 28-year-old Chicago native with a marketing degree who ends up transferring to a Parisian luxury branding firm named Savior. Emily is there to deliver an American perspective to the brand, and naturally, hijinks ensue.
The company’s main characters are Sylvie (Philippine Leroy-Beaulieu), Luc (Bruno Gouery), and Julien (Samuel Arnold).
Sylvie is the head of Savior. She is sleek, elegant, and over Emily’s bullshit. Sylvie is the voice of reason, wondering why an American with so little experience with the French language and culture thinks she is qualified to do this job. Me too.
For my Gilmore Girls fans out there, Sylvie is the “Emily” of this show. The older woman we are supposed to dislike, because they are a snob, but drops so many truth bombs on our mediocre protagonist that it is hard not to just nod your head and worship as she completely tears apart the blandness that is Emily.
Luc and Julien are the sassy queer duo at Savior. Luc is a Black man and while he is not a GBFF, between the two he doesn’t get much to do until season two. He is primarily a comedic presence, and honestly, I forgot what his job was until they finally allowed him to give a presentation … that Emily interrupted and “stole” in S2.
Julien is a white man and gets to be, as one character described it, a “mad professor type” he is eccentric, thinks about sex a lot, loves French films, and of the three Savoir staff is the first one to offer a genuine olive branch towards Emily seeing that she’s not evil—just mediocre.
When it comes to the work element, every episode is Emily bringing in her American perspective to a French idea and watching how she stumbles into success at impressing another client. Everyone speaks English around her so that she can be up to speed (and don’t worry, she’s taking a French class that we see her in sometimes).
Now don’t get me wrong, sometimes Emily is right, and you guys know how I feel about the French. But because the show is so blandly apolitical, it ultimately doesn’t say anything about what the French truly do fail at in terms of their treatment of the Me Too movement, imperialism, racism, xenophobia, etc.
It is mostly just them having sexy affairs that Emily doesn’t understand, and rather than treat that seriously, the idea of sleeping with clients becomes another silly, lol stupid American aspect of the show.
Beyond her work friends, Emily also befriends in Paris: Mindy, Gabriel, and Camille.
Mindy (Ashely Park) is the Chinese-Korean daughter of a rich Chinese man, but wants to be a singer rather than take over the family business. She bombed her performance on Chinese Idol and is now living as a nanny in Paris. Half of Mindy’s dialogue is talking about the cultural aspects of China and France with semi-to-full on racist pieces of dialogue that sound like they are leftover from All in the Family.
They aren’t even clever or exciting enough to be offensive, and they are just dated and ridiculous for a show about an American perspective. For the majority of S1, Mindy is the only woman of color we see in this show, which takes us to one of the problems often mentioned when it comes to Emily in Paris.
The overwhelming whiteness.
Paris is one of the most diverse countries in the world, and due to imperialism/colonization, the Francophone community is very large (yours truly included—run me my money France). So Emily’s mostly white backdrop is jarring to see, mostly because it goes uncommented on.
I mean, do I think that a fancy French company would only employ one Black gay man, have no real diversity, and that a white woman in marketing might only end up in a mostly white environment in one of the diverse places on Earth? Yes. But again for a show that wants to point out American exceptionalism and American perspective—you’d think that would be seen as an issue in the series.
We have a whole scene in season one about Emily discussing if a perfume commercial with a naked woman walking down the bridge with clothed men is “sexy or sexist?” And turning it into a Twitter poll for #content. But we never have a meaningful conversation about what that means.
Last year, Franch dealt with their second wave of the Me Too movement that (TW) dealt with decades of incest and child rape that were covered up, because, "French law criminalizes sex with a minor under the age of 15 unless the relationship is consensual — creating a gray area in the law that makes it difficult to convict perpetrators."
To quote from The World article I linked, "France faced its first #MeToo wave in 2017. A movement known as #BalanceTonPorc or #SquealOnYourPig garnered mixed reactions — even skepticism." We've seen France's art world continue to stand behind people like Roman Polanski and Woody Allen and Johnny Depp. We've seen the way in which women have had to speak out about this, but are often not heard. How normalized it is that a mixed reaction became the norm.
France, like the US, also has racist tactics it uses against Black and Brown people, a discriminatory stop and search procedure known in French as “contrôle au faciès.” The French equivalent of Stop & Frisk.
"It’s done totally at the discretion of the officer-involved; you never know why you are being stopped. But you can draw your own conclusions—that the people who are stopped are being treated that way because of their race. It starts at a very young age, at 12, 13, or 14. To be stopped in the middle of the street, to be picked out of a group; to be spread-eagled, but never sufficiently so, to have your ID checked, to be frisked, in front of everyone. And all for nothing. And this happens over and over again. Maybe several times on the same day." (via Open Society)
When it comes to race and ethnicity in France they are one of these countries that want to be seen as "color-blind" but also has citizenship issues that keep the "privilege" of being a French citizen restrictive. Especially against people from countries that would ruin the French culture in their eyes. Even when Emmanuel Macron argued about restitution for African art, Europe shit the bed and so did a bunch of French people.
I concede that Emily in Paris is a self-indulgent wish-fulfillment show that is not meant to hold up to the kind of pop culture analysis of the thinking person. However, I would not be doing my job if I didn’t point out the whiteness that allows it to be this kind of insular series. If Emily were any other race, but white, she would have a much different story and struggle going to Paris with so little experience.
Hell, a WOC with that little experience wouldn’t be able to go. And if she did, she’d at least be going because she spoke French.
Much like Piper in Orange Is the New Black, Emily offers the entry-level whiteness that enables the audience to move carelessly throughout the world with little fear of a mistake that could get her deported, shunned, or profiled.
At the end of the day, she is white, and that whiteness will allow her to be able to come into meetings, offer the input of any 18 year old with an Instagram and claim that that knowledge comes from having a Masters in Marketing/Communication.
But none of that is really the thing that frustrates me about Emily in Paris, if I’m being honest—it’s the love triangle.
Remember Emily’s other French friends, Gabriel and Camille? Well, let’s get to them.
Gabriel (Lucas Bravo) is a handsome chef who finds Emily’s lack of knowledge endearing and helps her around the apartment, makes her omelets, and becomes her first real love interest. Eventually, they kiss after Emily makes the first move, due to Gabriel saving her work dinner with his amazing cooking.
After Mindy, the next real friend in Paris that Emily makes is Camille (Camille Razat), who assists her in buying some flowers and is just a very nice French person. It’s a cute bond, and they have great friendship chemistry. What could go wrong? Well, we find out that Camille is Gabriel’s girlfriend!
Gabriel is the only person, at the beginning of this love triangle, who has all the information. He knows that he is in a five-year relationship with Camille, and he also knows that there is this attraction between him and Emily that led to a kiss.
At no point does he act responsibly with any of this. As the friendship between his girlfriend and his … I guess potential side-piece(?) grows, he never decides to be a good person. Emily isn’t innocent in this, either, since she could also be honest with Camille, or, at the very least, stop lusting after Gabriel. But this is an MTV production, so all the main characters are playing clown games.
Season one ends with Camille and Gabriel’s relationship being in a weird place and Emily, thinking that Gabriel is leaving … they have sex. It’s shitty because at this point Emily and Camille are good friends, and they are only broken up for a second. Doing it simply to know what it would feel like is really awful on Emily’s part.
Season two takes this to a new level when Gabriel ends up staying in Paris and Camille is dealing with the deep sadness of losing someone that she loved for five years, and Emily is trying to do better, but at the same time, no one is helping her make a good choice. During her birthday party, Camille sees the cast iron skillet that was precious to Gabriel and realizes that they slept together.
Camille is positioned in the second season, following this point, to be the manipulative snake because she’s trying to keep Emily and Gabriel apart—but for me, that is kind of bullshit. Especially their “pinky promise” not to go after Gabriel. Emily was dating and going away with someone at the beginning of season two. She moved on to the superior Alfie (Lucien Laviscount), and so when Camille gets back together with her ex-boyfriend without talking to Emily about it … I get it. Why would she honor a promise when no one—not Emily, Gabriel, or even Min, who she has been nothing but friendly too—cared about her feelings?
I’m Team Camille. Emily has shown herself to be nothing but a cheater and bad friend, which is an interesting character flaw journey, but when it comes to the love triangle, we know very much who the trash is. Gabriel. It is always frustrating to me when a show treats a connection between two people as a reason to act recklessly with the people around you (you hear that And Just Like That?).
Also, Alfie is superior in every single way—most importantly he is single and wants to commit to Emily without causing problems in her life. A king. Plus he’s a gorgeous English Black man with a sassy personality and amazing back muscles.
Bue despite all this bitching ... I did watch both seasons of Emily in Paris over three days because it is (sigh) very easy to watch. Despite having characters in their late twenties and up, it feels like you are watching 2000s Gossip Girl or 90210 and I grew up on that garbage. It is trash I enjoy and I don't respect myself for it—but here I am.
At the end of Season Two, Emily is offered a choice between staying in Paris to work at Savior, and date Alfie, but also have to see "her great love" Gabriel date Camille or go back to Chicago. We all know what she's going to pick. Season three will bring on more mess and honestly, can't wait to see it and the outfits.
What do y'all think of Emily in Paris?