Princess Watches: First Kill Discourse Is ... A Lot. (Patreon)
Content
If you've followed my channel for a long time, you'll know that the depictions of Black people, but especially queer Black women/femmes in urban fantasy and genre television is something that is close to my heart. There is a reason I have my tiers (except for my white queen Laurel) as Black women who have been wronged by their shows, fandom, and writers.
When I first got the screeners for First Kill, I was like "woof this did not get much of a budget" but when Imani Lewis showed up as Calliope Burns I knew that I'd watch the entire thing.
Cal looked like girls I knew, girls I grew up with. Long permed hair, dark skin, full lips and nose, a stud nose piercing (one of the entry-level piercings you could persuade your parents to get), and the duel desire to be both a child and adult. When I would see moments of her brother Theo sleeping in a bonnet, the effortlessness of the Burns family's Blackness didn't feel put upon. Despite all the flaws of the show, this was something different for me.
Fandom doesn't like Black folks. They can't say that out loud, but it is clear if you've been on Tumblr, FF.net/Ao3, etc for as long as I have. Black female characters get scorned, especially when paired with white men with whom people want to be in MLM relationships, even when the writers themselves are not interested in doing that. Black men are introduced as love interests but killed off. Black women are tokenized and mistreated, only to have their showrunners never deal with the internalized anti-Blackness they promoted.
It is exhausting. But what makes it more exhausting is the gaslighting. The pretense that it isn't true. That is the only reason people don't ship Kelly and Alex and much as Maggie and Alex in Supergirl is "writing" when every couple in the show was trash. That killing off Dolls on Wynonna Earp was no big deal because the actor "wanted" to leave. That Iris West-Allen is the worst thing to happen to The Flash even though they have failed to come up with good storylines for most of the characters post-season two.
I've been re-watching one of my favorite post-awakening shows, Lost Girl, and the whiteness of that show is something that always gets to me. Five seasons, five major love interests for Bo, none of the people of color. A true mess for a show that was filmed in Toronto, one of the most diverse cities on Earth.
Even the most recent Charmed could not be bothered to ever fully deal with its colorism and hire dark-skinned women (or dark-skinned people period) in reoccurring roles.
The Vampire Diaries delved deeply into the personal lives of Elena and Caroline, but Bonnie was up there with Matt in terms of depth. And even Matt got to date Caroline, which gave him some quality screen time.
I could go on with Tara on True Blood, and Abbie on Sleepy Hollow, and talk about the handful of exceptions like Mattie in Carmilla or Dutch in Killjoys, but those characters are not nearly as exhausted as the white-led shows.
I have watched so many mediocre shows for several seasons for positive queer rep, even when it was whiter than my 17% Scottish blood.
This is why the discourse around First Kill really doesn't sit right with me. How many vampire teen shows (a) focus on wlw couples and (b) have a Black lesbian co-leading character? With equal screentime and established family life? It just doesn't exist like that. Beyond Carmilla the web series, we have not had many mainstream media leading lesbian vampire stories between equals that weren’t created to be a sapphic predatory narrative.
To pretend otherwise is just poor intersectional pop culture analysis.
First Kill is a cheesy show, but I also grew up watching Xena and Hercules and early Buffy: The Vampire Slayer, hell even Lost Girl had some clumsy CGI in the beginning. A part of me just wonders if maybe we have forgotten the era when shows had bad first seasons? Hell, every Star Trek fan I've ever met has told me to full-on skip multiple seasons of an incarnation. Parks and Rec/The Office (US) have infamously skippable first seasons.
I'm not saying that First Kill is some hidden masterpiece, but the more I watch it the more I'm brought back to those early days of The Vampire Diaries, which was also very cheesy at first until it found its groove in the second half. Why were we comfortable allowing that show to grow and not this? I'd rather give First Kill a second season to get a better budget and focused storytelling than write it off as tired for coming after decades of heteronormative vampire stories.
There is plenty of good faith criticism of First Kill and I hope it happens. Representation is not a catch-all for quality. It is possible to hold both into account and I think it is better for pop culture analysis and journalism to do so. What is a cliche for some groups isn't for others and I'm happy that I got to watch Heartstoppers and First Kill with my partner this Pride Mother. The theme song is a delight and every time I see Cal fanart or gif sets with her in them, it makes me feel good about being Tumblr. Which is a weird thing to feel in the year of our Lord 2022.