Misgendering Ezra Miller Isn't Helpful (Patreon)
Content
Ezra Miller is currently center stage for their involvement with allegations of grooming and kidnapping.
Miller has been a subject of controversy since 2020 when they were caught on camera choking a woman in Iceland. No charges were filed, but Miller was asked to leave the bar and the viral video came and went without major incident—except in circles where memories are long.
This year, Miller was arrested twice in Hawaii: "first in March for disorderly conduct and harassment at a karaoke bar and again in April for second-degree assault after they allegedly threw a chair at a 26-year-old woman in a private residence."
Sara Jumping Eagle and Chase Iron Eyes sought a protective order from Miller on behalf of Gibson Iron Eyes (this was the name I was told they go by—if that is wrong feel free to let me know), an 18-year-old who had reportedly been living with Miller since December 2021.
Controversy has been circulating around this because a video came out of Gibson on Instagram refuting these claims and asserting that there was homophobia/transphobia in their parent’s actions.
Their parents claim "Miller met the family during protests at the Standing Rock Reservation in 2016 when Gibson was just 12 years old. From then, Miller and Gibson developed a friendship. In 2017, the parents claim, Miller flew Gibson, then 14, and a chaperone to London to visit the set of Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them." In 2016, Miller was twenty-three years old.
June 16th of this year, The Daily Beast published a report that "a mother and her 12-year-old child traveled to their local courthouse in Greenfield, Massachusetts, and were granted a temporary harassment prevention order against Ezra Miller after alleging that the actor menaced their family one evening in their downstairs neighbor’s home and acted inappropriately toward the nonbinary youngster."
Everything about the Ezra Miller case has been disturbing. The allegations are dark and with the GOP chomping at the bit to weaponize this case of a nonbinary actor being accused of grooming and assault, it has been disappointing to see people play fast and loose with Miller's pronouns, even within some "woke" social circles.
Pronouns have been political for a long time and to pretend otherwise is just not accurate. Pronouns matter and part of the reason we (the royal progressive we, I guess) have wanted to normalize it is to make space for all people and decenter cis language. That work does not go away because of a single bad actor.
Sometimes it feels like movements live in fear. Fear of the boogeyman that right speaks about is under our own noses and in order to protect ourselves we put up these purity tests in order to ensure that we separate "the good ones" from "the bad ones" among us. The older I get, the more political I get—the more I know that isn't the case. Whenever we fight for the humanity of all, there will always be grifters, bad actors, and just bad people among us.
Liberation is not about perfection. It isn't even really about goodness. It is about the larger goals.
Ezra Miller is a wealthy celebrity accused of ghoulish things, but it is dangerous to act as if ignoring their pronouns is based on some moral judgment. People mock pronouns for people they find annoying or grating (ie. Halsey or Demi Lovato). More so, they are quick to say they honor them in public, but still hold binary thinking in how they process things. Because Ezra Miller is "male presenting" and has been accused of harming a cis woman and nonbinary people who are femme presenting, that is being weaponized to dismiss their pronouns and consolidate them into maleness that is inherently reductive to other nonbinary people who may present in one way or another.
It is reinforcing the same TERF idea that nonbinary and trans AMAB people are predators in disguise.
That is the danger of turning Ezra Miller's actions as an excuse to ignore their pronouns. Especially since we don't need to. They have documented proof of bad behavior. This is someone who has the privilege and has wielded it against young people. That is not a gendered action. Those are the actions of a predatory person. Why does that need to be turned into something by us? The Right might do that, but why do we?
A cynical part of me feels that it just reflects the truth of how people actually see pronouns. They see honoring them as a privilege and one that can be rescinded like any right. They also want to appear to be "correct" and feel like honoring the pronouns of an alleged groomer is worthless.
I feel differently because, as a Black woman I have often had to sit with the reality that loving Black people and fighting for Black liberation in my own ways, also means that it would include Black people I have no political or moral alignment. Homophobes, transphobes, colorists, etc.
As Angela Davis says: "Neoliberal ideology drives us to focus on individuals, ourselves, individual victims, individual perpetrators."
There will always be Black people who I have nothing in common with, who may even hate me, but I do not wish for them to be enslaved by the state, mistreated due to their race, or murdered by the police. I don't believe that because I'm such a morally superior person, I am very petty actually, but I also know that the work is bigger than theirs. I know that my fighting for that will help those who need it the most, including other Black queer people like me.
Ezra Miller is an individual. But our actions in response tell our collective communities that we give them a temporary pass at their humanity. Misgendering someone is not a punishment for bad actors who use particular pronouns. At least not to me. It is, just like any sort of sexism or homophobia, an excuse to punch down. To hurt everyone when you could just choose kindness. It is a habit many of us indulge in, myself included, but as I have tried to grow, I try to really fight those parts of me that respond to frustration with ignorance.
And if the reason Miller is able to have so much power over these young queer people is that they presents themself as someone honoring their identity, how are we helping protect them and future kids if we don't honor pronouns consistently? Nonbinary and trans youth are vulnerable because they are not able to trust people around them to honor who they are. They are afraid of transphobic dog whistles and when we misgender Miller, we expose ourselves as willing and able to believe those dog whistles.
We need to be loud about protecting these alleged victims, while also showing we are able to protect nonbinary people and call out predatory behavior within our communities without TERF-ism. That should be the norm, and we need to lead the charge in normalizing it.
Plus, it has already been constantly reported that nonbinary/trans folks are more likely to be victims of sexual abuse. Let's not use one huge case to play into the hands of bad actors.