Becoming Elizabeth is a special kind of Tudor Trash (Patreon)
Content
Wow. Just wow.
Becoming Elizabeth is the latest in the post-The Tudors/The Other Boleyn Girl land of pseudo-historical bodice porn that attempts to mix modern girl boss energy, middling storytelling, and historical women.
Starz previously dabbled in the Tudor era with their adaptations of Philippa Gregory’s terrible-yet-engrossing novels, which gave us: The White Queen, The White Princess, and The Spanish Princess miniseries. While the network is no longer working with the creative team behind those projects, they have moved forward in time with Becoming Elizabeth.
Becoming Elizabeth stars Alicia von Rittberg as the future Queen Elizabeth I, a teenager who at the death of her father King Henry VIII becomes caught up in the politics of the era. Especially the Catholic vs. Protestant divide personified by her older sister, the future Mary I (Romola Garai), and younger brother, and current King, Edward VI (Oliver Zetterström).
I am used to bad historical period dramas. Especially in the past decade. When I saw Becoming Elizabeth, I really had no expectations. The cast looked mostly fine and after just finishing up Wolf Hall, I needed something light and fluffy.
Then the series decided, in an infuriating sequence of events, to make Catherine Parr (Jessica Raine), one of Henry VIII’s only surviving wives and Elizabeth’s guardian, a sex-starved manipulator. By most historical accounts, Catherine was a loving stepmother to her stepchildren and was particularly attached to Elizabeth and influential in her life. She was also brilliant and a bestselling author in her own time. Becoming Elizabeth’s Catherine Parr is unrecognizable.
Even actual moments of neglect and potential gaslighting from her husband are turned into Parr’s own jealousy manifesting in near sexual abuse. There is one incident where Parr allegedly took part in an undressing game with Elizabeth and Thomas, but Elizabeth and Parr had a mother-daughter relationship that we do not really see here. I’m not saying Parr never did anything wrong, but I am saying that this show leans heavily into malevolence when ignorance is more likely.
The show then renders Elizabeth as a jealous child who adores a man who historically allegedly molested her.
Thomas Seymour was the brother of Jane Seymour (Henry’s third wife, and the one who gave him his long-desired son and heir, Edward). Through his nephew, Thomas Seymour had a powerful place in court.
He was in love with Catherine Parr before she married the king, and they rushed into marriage following his death. This was a huge scandal because it meant she didn’t have a period of mourning, and because, in the very unlikely idea she could have been pregnant, it would have impacted the succession.
Elizabeth was only around 13/14 years old when she came to live with Parr and Seymour after her father died. Historically, Seymour showed “affection” toward Elizabeth by tickling her, slapping her on her behind as she lay in her bed, and coming into her room in his nightclothes. This was all gross behavior that was not just inappropriate because of her age, but Elizabeth was a Princess and in the line of succession at this point.
In Becoming Elizabeth, Elizabeth is aged up (slightly and played by an actress who is nearly 30, to facilitate sex scenes when she’s playing a 14-15-year-old) so she can actively desire Thomas Seymour and be upset when he marries her stepmother. Gag me.
Maybe it’s because I’ve been listening to SIX (an excellent, tongue-in-cheek musical featuring all of Henry’s wives singing about their mixed triumphs and tragedies) a lot, but didn’t we decide awhile ago not to handwave this sort of predatory behavior anymore in adaptation? For a show that wants to depict the childhood of one of England’s most important monarchs, could they have taken the time to actually explore her trauma and the events that really shaped her?
But then how would we get the sexy moments?
That has become the most frustrating aspect of shows like this. They reduce women and girls into whatever archetype the narrative needs them to perform, even when those women bucked expectations for women at the time. We see Catherine “Fucking” Parr, as the show calls her multiple times, as some sex-starved woman who can barely keep her hands off Thomas Seymour.
Which, fine. But you know, could we have established her as one of the most intelligent women and intellectuals of the English Protestants, before seeing her fucking? Is that too much to ask for?
Lady Jane Grey (a cousin who will be briefly proclaimed queen after King Edward’s death), is introduced as being a slightly antagonistic force to Elizabeth, and Mary, well … she’s there being Spanish and Catholic. It is a whole lot of nothing, but I guess … at least the music is fun?
I am now three episodes in and I find myself feeling like Tudor history is both overexposed and underwritten. It is frustrating that with the little bit of progress we have with diversity and finally getting basic coloring for historical figures right, there is also this inability to write two female characters well at one time. Catherine Parr has to be stripped down for Elizabeth to rise. Mary is in the background. Jane is ... well I don't quite know what’s going on there yet.
A whole ass mess of trash, but I'm sure we will get more. Especially since there are eight episodes total.
Anyway, if you haven’t listened to SIX go and watch all the talented AMVs people have made. Here is one with Catherine Parr to wash the taste of this series out of my brain.