Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I really loved Thor: Love and Thunder.

Marvel films, for me, have gotten to this weird place. When I go back and watch all of them in order, there is a lot of competent but generic stuff. Very white, very male, very cis, very straight, etc. In fact, I watched Thor (2011) recently and the level of diversity and fun element brought to the film from then to now is staggering. There is something to be said that when Marvel fatigue is just settling in, it is when the series is finally diverse.

But let's talk about Thor: Love and Thunder first.

Spoiler Free Thoughts:

Taking place after the events of Endgame, Thor is adrift, he has no real purpose, so like any other white cis male, he is just vibing along with his friends. Quickly he dips from the Guardians of the Galaxy to deal with the chaos caused by Gorr the God Butcher (portrayed by Christian Bale) who gains the power to kill the gods. At the same time he is reunited with his ex-lover Jane (Natalie Portman, Portman, Portman), who has cancer, but has gained the power to weld Thor's previously broken hammer Mjolnir. Jane, Thor, and King Valkyrie are forced into conflict with Gorr when he steals the children of New Asgard and they are forced to rescue them.

I went into Thor: Love and Thunder, with no real expectations. I saw it because of my day job and that was pretty much it. I saw the mixed response and I was on the look out for something jarring or at least something as dense as Eternals. What I found was a fun action adventure movie that made me laugh a lot more than I expected.

In a tweet I mentioned that the film reminded me of the 1999 bisexual classic, The Mummy and I think it is important to remember something: those movies are not critically acclaimed. The Mummy only has a 61% on Rotten Tomatoes, and the even more bisexual The Mummy Returns has a 47%. The movies just happened to do amazingly well at the box office.

And that revelation reminded me of something: superhero movies should be silly and weird like the romps of old. Like Indiana Jones being so revered is the exception.

Thor reminded me of The Mummy. Fundamentally silly, but good pacing, a little sexy, and complete with a himbo. Even the screaming goats made me laugh.

Except for the kinda long beginning, there was no part of the movie I didn't enjoy. Sometimes I am reluctant to (despite my Rotten Tomatoes status) think of myself as a movie critic because I wasn't trained in it. I am a lit major and I respect those boundaries.  At the core of my being, I want a movie to make me forget who I am for the run time. The reason I'll always appreciate Aquaman is because I'd just gotten broken up with and the movie I saw right after was Aquaman and I felt so happy watching it. That's what I want. An experience.

Watching Thor, I just felt fun. I enjoyed it. It made me laugh. And I appreciated the comedic elements.

It also makes me sad/frustrated that we are seeing such a backlash to director personality when MOC and marginalized men are finally getting to be stars. Like i get the over saturation of Taika or Lin-Manuel, but I think we forget that there have not been Latino or Indigenous directors with this much clout in a long time. They should milk it. Everything is made harder by the internet, but also by the (gasp shock) that comic-book movies that weren't Batman could be good.

Well they are and most of them were boring.

Taika brings his humor to this work and while some jokes don't land, I appreciated the Mel Brooks approach of throwing stuff at the wall and seeing what hits.

On a deeper level, what I really loved about Thor: Love and Thunder, especially after rewatching Thor, is that it feels like a full circle of Thor's journey in the MCU. When we first met him he was vein, selfish and incapable of true selflessness. The choices he makes in this film show that not only has Thor opened himself to love, but also to not just needing to be King.  He longed for something grater and he found it.

Fundamentally, I think the biggest problem with Thor: Love and Thunder is the larger Thor issue.

Phase 4 is the first that isn't blatantly moving towards a singular big bad or overarching storyline. It is also the most diverse in terms of both who are the creators working on the movies and TV series and who is getting to be the heroes—and this is precisely the time when the Marvel fatigue is setting in.

In many ways, the MCU had the benefit of low expectations. When Iron Man first came out, no one could have thought this would be a natural conclusion. I mean, a good chunk of the people responsible for the MCU also worked on the much maligned 2003 Daredevil movie. In the beginning, the freak-show effect was that the franchise managed to be good "in spite" of being comic book films. Now, that is old hat. Our expectations have shifted. We now want these movies to be hyper-polished, deep films that continue to build.

Part of it is the fact that Marvel and Disney won't take a break and stop delivering endless content. Part is that Disney, as a media company is ultimately too powerful and controls too much media. But, in my opinion, part of the issue is that the MCU was attempting to "elevate" comic book movies—to make them "for everyone," not just accessible but destigmatized in the minds of audiences who only turn out for the gritty Batman films.

In doing that, you downplay and erase all the things that make comic book movies interesting in the process. Especially when you lack half the IP of the comic book universe you're adapting, you need to ... well, adapt and are forced to do things like give Tony Stark storylines that have nothing to do with him. Creative and interesting stories don't matter because they must fit into the interconnected universe.

Iron Man 3 was an excellent Christmas comedy that touched on Tony's PTSD, but because it followed Avengers, everyone wanted it to fit into that. Then, Tony's progress in that film was instantly erased because the larger storyline needed Iron Man back for Civil War.

Thor has suffered from this immensely. To a degree, all the Avengers have characterization issues in their collaborative films versus standalone features, but Thor got screwed over each time, from "he's adopted" in the first one to getting stuck in a tub for most of Age of Ultron, being fully absent in Civil War, and then ... there is Infinity War.

Right after Ragnarok, a film that actually perfectly used Chris Hemsworth's comedic chops, leaned into the queer agenda and saw Thor fully ascend to be king and reunite with his brother, Infinity War killed off his entire supporting cast, save Valkyrie. The majority were killed offscreen.

Thor is so powerful that his presence completely shifts the tide of a battle, so his conflict can't be about strength; it has to be about who he is as a person. When we first met Thor, he was arrogant and vain, only wanting war and to be king of Asgard. His entire story has been about humbling himself and loving someone beyond himself. That has led to him giving up being king, which culminates in him (spoilers)

For me, that is a natural character arc for Thor and shows how he has become someone who cares about the collective community and people other than himself. The problem is that Thor has been underwritten, and his storyline has had to maneuver around everyone else's story. Imagine what could have happened in Loki weren't killed off? If most of Asgard weren't killed off? Choices that were not made by Ragnarok and Love and Thunder director Taika Waiti, but ones he inherited.

Thor is a character who has been adrift at times and has not been helped by the lack of a singular journey for him, as a character, at this point. I think Thor: Love and Thunder is fun, silly, and reminds me of why I enjoyed The Mummy and The Mummy Returns (neither of which are critical darlings), but the issue that exists is forgetting that these need to be contained stories with smaller endgames. We don't need a larger big bad, but we need more of a purpose, for the characters themselves, for these movies to keep going.

Let's Go Deeper (Spoilers):

Okay. I think if nothing else would have won me over, seeing Roy fucking Kent as bisexual icon Hercules and Jane getting to go to Valhalla and met by Idris Elba was perfection.

With Gorr, his story of meeting his own god, seeing they didn't care about him, and then killing them—a serve honestly. Christian Bale is a great actor and he could play the Joker. I loved that his version of Gorr was intimidating, but scary enough for kids.

As someone who is spiritual, but grew up in the Catholic church due to schooling I felt for Gorr. Faith is complicated for everyone and for me, it has been a huge part of my identity. I identify as a polytheist/pagan, but I still really rock with Jesus. But I remember for so long being "good" as a child because I was afraid of Hell. Funny enough, part of how I believed in goodness was through Sailor Moon.

The idea of Thor's axe being jealous of Mjolnir was hilarious. I get it, when your boyfriend's ex is that iconic.

For so long Jane x Thor felt mid, but Taika really made these two feel fresh and romantic despite all the time apart. I loved the way their relationship was portrayed as a breakdown of emotions. It was great.

But the moment that solidified the film for me as great was when Thor (temporarily) gave his power to all of the kids. Seeing a little girl in her tutu merk shadows, and then Axl going out and being a bad-ass. I thought to myself, damn if I was a kid this would be amazing. And I think ultimately, I enjoy Thor for the same reason I enjoyed The Mummy as a kid—it is fun enough for me to enjoy in the moment, and saucy enough that as I grow up it'll be even better.

To tackle some issues I've seen:

(a) Thor deadnaming Axl: Since the character is not trans nor the actor, I feel like saying "deadname" is not exactly right. I felt like considering that Taika is Brown this is more about assimilation than trans identity, but I think its a discussion worth having regardless and I'm glad that Thor eventually just said the right name and kept doing it correctly.

(b) Jane's cancer being used in a trope-y way: I can not speak to this on the level of cancer. As someone dealing with long term mental illness tho, I appreciated Jane's autonomy regardless in how she went out. Especially with stage 4. As a macabre person I have thought about my end and if I could go out helping the people I love, I would prefer that personally.

(c) Is the movie gay enough?: Absolutely. Maybe it is the fact that I have an asexual partner, but for me "romance" is not the end all-be-all of representation. What matters is normalizing LGBT+ people in media. I enjoyed all the moments that acknowledged that

Comments

Roz Mosis

Thank you for your thoughts! I have a feeling that in a few years (maybe a whole decade) a lot of people who'd seen this movie as a young person/child will probably revitalise it and declare it as a misunderstood classic. Horny high fantasy/rom coms tend to take a long time to really find an audience (see also Labyrinth, Practical Magic and, as you mentioned, The Mummy). I've been pretty negative myself, especially on twitter, since I'm so attached to the comics (esp Mighty Thor), but the longer I think about it, the longer I realise I actually like it.

Linda Maleh

Enjoyed reading this! But ummm saying Thor chooses not to fight Gorr and be with Jane instead while she dies is definitely a spoiler. Planning on going to see the movie this week…

Princess Weekes

oh fuck! I'm so sorry! I thought it was cut out because it was in my draft! I'm sorry and I hope you still see it!

Linda Maleh

Yeah I figured it was an oversight. Just wanted to point it out so you could edit it. Will still probably watch this week, this is what I get for waiting for so long to go see the movie

Mizz

this was a great read! i pretty much agree with a lot of what you said, tho ive never really got the MCU fatigue thing (i think cause i just...dont engage with stuff im not interested in...tho i do experience MCU fandom fatigue lol) i also agree that taika waititi really came in clutch for jane and thor. i felt so strongly for them in this movie. and thor learning that the gods were more concerned with themselves than the ppl who have faith in them. its interesting for sure. (tho seeing thor and val not go into a romance was a bit sad, like i just keep feeling like any time theres a black love interest for a yt character they always get pushed aside, but i know thats a wider media thing rather than just an issue i have with love and thunder). theres like more i wanna say but im at work lol. this write up was great!