Movie Thoughts: Saltburn (Patreon)
Content
Oh Saltburn.
The eyebrow piercings you are going to be responsible for.
Before I saw Saltburn I read Yhara Zyad's review of it on her Patreon (go check that out) and she dragged it in a beautiful way, referencing to the films she felt it was "homaging." Go check out the full review, but I just want to share this amazing quote:
"[...]Fennel does nothing to deliver on its potential. Instead, she becomes too engrossed in the act of shoving incongruent scenes of depravity into the film, scenes not intended to provide satire or commentary but to shock and awe and maybe get social media abuzz about how scandalous it is. When in reality, for all of its squalid attributes, it's about as scandalous as leaving a toilet seat up."
We don't deserve Yhara.
Despite being someone who has disliked everything with Fennell's writing credits attached to it, from Killing Eve Season Two to Andrew Lloyd Webber's Bad Cinderella and Promising Young Woman, I still want to support ~women in cinema~ so I decided to go see Saltburn for myself with a good friend of mine.
Saltburn is about a scholarship student named Oliver Quick (Barry Keoghan) who gets involved with the English elite at his posh school. Quick develops a particular attachment to Felix Catton (Jacob Elordi). After a personal tragedy Felix invites Oliver to his family estate—Saltburn. There, Oliver's obsession escalates pushing out the old guard and becoming a parasite.
There are some sexual sequences in the movie that have certainly lit up the minds of viewers, but ... I read smutty fanfiction almost every day so my smut levels are high. A dude going down on a woman during her period isn't going to shock me.
Love the boldness though.
If you've been on TikTok you've probably heard of the infamous bathroom scene. I won't spoil it, but it certainly will have its audience. But it didn't shock me.
I think the attention the sex has gotten has more to do with how sex-less films have gotten than anything truly groundbreaking or pushing the boundary.
Back and forth online it has been debated if Saltburn is really as "weird" as people think it is. In my queer movie critic spaces, I've seen a lot of shrugging and feeling as if the aspects of the film that are being so hyped are not that interesting. That Fennell wants to write for weirdos and yet it is clear she is not really one. Her ideas of pushing against the sexual norms are still within a very particular lens.
Then on the other side, people are really having a fun time and enjoying the adventure. Bisexuals are attracted to men again. Truly a Yule miracle!
For me, I edged back and forth. I laughed a lot during the film at just how absurd everything was and without the full commitment of Barry Keoghan this film would have been ass out of luck. He was the twink who was promised.
But, in the back of my head I remembered Yhara bringing up the film The Talented Mr. Ripley by Anthony Minghella and based on the Patricia Highsmith 50s novel. The film is about a young man named Tom Ripley (Matt Damon) who, through a series of lies, is asked by a shipping tycoon to bring his son, Dickie Greenleaf (Jude Law) back to New York from Italy. I can't get any further without spoiling both films, but there were so many parallels between the two movies it stops feeling like just inspiration.
I mean there is a homoerotic bath tub scene in both!
Watching it reminded me of how I have overwhelming felt about Ari Aster films–bored because they remind me of better movies. Maybe not entirely with the acting (because he can bring together talent), but certainly with the story. They are well done movies, but if you know anything about narrative and genre you figure out where they are going quickly. Rather than the story they live or die by the charisma of the talent.
Saltburn is full of talent and I'm glad I saw it because it is, by far, Fennell's best work. Even the discourse, which I have enjoyed because I have no stake in it, has at least illuminated the range of kink in my friend circles.
Plus, that murder on the dancefloor scene was more satisfying than anything in Promising Young Woman. It is a solid installment in the "be gay do crimes" universe, but I think it is built upon much better films.