Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello Beautiful People of the Internet!!!!

It is that time again where you help us choose the next anime show!

Please drop your nominations down below and if you see your show already commented please like that comment! We’ll take the top liked shows and run a poll next week!

We can’t wait to see what you pick!

-Wes and Steph

Comments

Ruslan

Apothecary diaries. I bet you would love this show.

nox

CODE GEASS!

Dank Waifu

Made in Abyss, I know everyone knows this is the show for them cmon now

Lorenzo

Blue Lock

Aaron

Code geass similar to death note

Gustavo

Dr. Stone

Molly

Assassination classroom

bizarre☆azar

My Hero Academia Ouran High School Host Club Fruits Basket

Ramms

My Hero Academia

Exit

Made in Abyss 🙏

Isidi

Neon Genesis Evangelion

mark9jr

Bocchi the rock

Jaden

Blue exorcists

Roon

Bunny girl senpai

Lena

Neon Genesis Evangelion 🤌 or Code Geass 🙏

Brady

Vivy

Jaden

Food wars

koreangamer213

My hero academia is a fun story and power type anime

Roon

Your lie in April

Nikhil Dharmavaram

Not an anime watcher but I can't wait for inside reaction🙏

Aravind

invincible

hellodude776

Made in abyss would be an adventure

yusuke

JOJO BIZZARE ADVENTURE

Tasha

Apothecary Diaries

mark9jr

Madoka magica

Jaden

Berserk

Anzo

Sakamoto Days

thugggcatt420

horimiya or apothecary diaries for something lighthearted.

Aaron Pendergrass

My hero academia Blue lock Arcane Wild card: erased

sangoire

Promised Neverland

near.lee

the eminence in shadow

Malik

Overlord!

Rimyuruu Senpaii

I think you guys will enjoy That time i got reincarnated as a slime <3

Anzo

Kingdom

Dank Waifu

This is what I'm saying, idk how people don't see this as the best choice. Its 100% the show that most suits them.

CJ

BLUE LOCK!!

Irongrove

Classroom of the Elite

Roon

Hyouka

Ryler Morgan

Y’all definitely have to try To Your Eternity It’s so good.

Jaden

Overlord

Tanmay

Blue lock and orb

Amh7778

Orb: On the Movements of the Earth

Link

Erased

AVRY

tokyo ghoul

Ramms

I wanna see Wes's reaction to Endeavor from MHA specifically 😅

Anzo

Wind Breaker

dolz69

Overlord

Tanmay

I second arcane and blue lock

Xavier

My hero academia Bungo stray dogs arcane

Adam

Yes, Bocchi! In sub

Whammadoodoo

Apothecary Diaries! Maomao gang rise up

aggie

7th time loop

Adam

Arcane, Bocchi

britt m

My Hero Academia (cause why not lol), Fruits Basket (because it altered my brain chemistry), and Jojo's Bizarre Adventure (for the chaos)~

S0_F5

Saga of Tayna the Evil or To Your Eternity

dolz69

Diamond no Ace

Whammadoodoo

Arcane. It’s about time, y’all!

James Andrew

josee, the tiger and the fish

i luv u 3000

My Hero Academia. It keeps barely missing the vote. 😭

Ale

Arcane

Ale

Clannad

Ale

Your lie in april

Ale

My hero academia

Ale

Assassination classroom

Anzo

Reincarnated as a slime

yusuke

Monster

Nody

Dr stone

Neomatsu

Your Lie in April, one of the most beautiful and sad anime ever

Manting Xiong

Mobile Suit Gundam 00 Your Lie In April Aldnoah.Zero

Anzo

Black Clover

HappyHippo39

Double up on Hunter x Hunter

Demi

Bakuman A really good show, one of the best even. A must watch.

Nellie

Horimiya

Max

Bakuman

Stuart

Arcane

Max

Please this

Gabi B.

Apothecary diaries

Zlez

Overlord

Zlez

Reincarnated as a slime

Koka Suru

classroom of the elite

marco

86 cyberpunk edgerunners Another Nana

Koka Suru

cyberpunk edgerunner

Urizen MIkan

It looks like "Apothecary Diaries" is going to win.

maria

ouran high school host club

maria

yuri on ice

Kamy

Orb

Rynishka Ford

If anyone else wants kuroko’s basketball there is another comment made by James Andrew, please like it

Cam

Code geass

maria

Free!

SLF needs more love

The 100 Girlfriends Who really really really really really love you

maria

erased

Joan Paulino

Plz watch Rainbow! It’s an anime about these kids lives right after the bombs dropped on Japan in the 40’s. Amazing intro also 👌🏽👌🏽

Nellie

Erased

Peter Butchens

Well, since you enjoyed the mystery and suspense of SteinsGate and ReZero: Umineko

Raman

Noragami

Aswin

Apothecary diaries!

XeroHD

Noragami

C

THE GREAT PRETENDER!!

Nellie

Blue exorcist

Z

86 Major

C

BUNGO STRAY DOGS

Db14e205

Golden kamuy

JeanCliene

Isekai Quartet is an easygoing/slice of life show with Re:zero cast, Konosuba cast, and 2 other isekai (Tanya and Overlord) cast members all together in one setting

rvsty

ADVENTURE TIME | (• ◡•)| (❍ᴥ❍ʋ)

Mel

Arcane please 😭

halastair

The apothecary diaries

Matthew Wise

Fate Series (stay/night, zero, unlimited bladeworks, heavens feel)

halastair

I second apothecary diaries

Miri

Fruits Basket Promised Neverland Ouran High School Host Club FREE!!!

ElijahLew

I feel like you guys would LOVE 86 and I'd love watching you guys theorize abt everything in it! Fate is also a good one

Hisoka

I think it's time to start watching One Piece the sooner you start the sooner you finish and it's a masterpiece of a century. You might catch up before it's over and be apart of the hype , if not Berserk , Monster.

Jane Ling

Akatsuki no yona (Princess of the dawn)

ElijahLew

I really hope my fellow 86 lovers come together for this one hahaha we might not be as big as the others but CMON GUYS

CJ

One piece would be better to watch once the remake is there. The hype at that time will get them a lot more viewers than watching it right now would

Carl Carlsonn

Both good options. Fate would be a big undertaking though which is good I'd say

Reddd Hunter

Would love yall to watch 86!

Elías

The eminence in shadow

Valeria

I think we need a little sentimental one: - Given - Your lie in april - anohana

Harrison

CYBERPUNK EDGERUNNERS

Eric

Hard agree

bravadour something something

Bro, id love them to react to it too, but the vn though, not the anime cus ive heard its really bad.

Adi Amosi

Blue Lock the seven deadly sins erased

Ryler Morgan

86 is also such a good anime

Stuart

x4 Hunter x Hunter episodes

Garvi

The 100 Girlfriends Who Really, Really, Really, Really, REALLY Love You

Mario Prime Plays

The remake will only cover East blue. They should just start the live action and then go into the anime.

Garvi

DON'T TOY WITH ME, MISS NAGATORO

F

Apothecary Diaries

The King

The Emminence Shadow

Garvi

Wotakoi: Love is Hard for Otaku

Kasturi

THISSS PLEASEEE

Verse Virus

Reincarnated as a slime Apothecary Diary Overlord

Sean

86 or Cyberpunk Edgerunners

Beth Edwards

I kind of want to see a super niche anime. Like Angels of Death or Assassination Classroom.

Atlas Creation

Apothecary Diaries Orb Made in Abyss Akudama Drive

Aly

Clannad + Clannad Afterstory

alex

Look back the movie

Matthew Fink

It's a movie, but Her Blue Sky is so good

Hena

yeah, I think considering they've seen Rezero, Mushoku and Konosuba, it's the perfect time to see this. it's good vibes seeing them react to funny shows

Claang

My hero academia

Anzo

Fire Force

Mohammad Bemana

Here is a list of 15+my choice: My choice: 1. Shangri la frontier I am at season 1 and it is pretty good 2 season so far Other recommendations: 2. 86 3. ViVy 4. Overlord 5. Fate series 6. To your eternity 7. Grimgar of fantasy and ash 8. Your lie in april 9. Arcane 10. Castlevania 11. Cyberpunk Edgerunners 12. maria the virgin witch 13. Bleach 14. Parasyte 15. Undead Unluck 16. Summer time rendering

Tx Sadz

Classroom of the elite

Anzo

Hells Paradise

og meowmix

made in abyss please!

zengei

The Eminence in Shadow

zengei

Makeine: Too Many Losing Heroines

Adi Amosi

DragonBall Z Abridged

Tony

Been waiting for a nomination post to ask this lol. Would you 2 be down to try reacting to something new? Dunno if you 2 are into musicals, but there's something that's quite popular these days called "Epic: The Musical" basically a concept album of around 40 songs, that people have made animatics for. If it's something that gets the votes, and you 2 are down to react to it, I can put a playlist together? Depending on how you wanna watch it, you can get it done in 1 sitting, split it in half, or split it into the 8 separate "Sagas" It's basically a Musical of Homers "The Oddessey" if you want more info feel free to message me.

Tony

Helluva Boss

Tony

Hazbin Hotel

Tony

Digimon

Tony

Dragonball

Tony

Naruto

Tony

Bleach

A Guy

To your eternity would be one. I think you’d really enjoy.

Tony

My Hero Academia

Tony

Overlord

Icaarus

Neon Genesis: Evangelion

Jonas

Made in abyss Heavenly delusion Oregairu

Tony

Danmachi (Is It Wrong to Try to Pick up Girls in a Dungeon)

Tony

Failure Frame

Tony

The Duke of Death and his Maid

Neo Don

To your eternity would be a good one

Tony

The Wrong Way to Use Healing Magic

Tony

Tis Time for "Torture" Princess

Tony

Dead Mount Death Play

Tony

Bofuri

Tony

Rising of the Shield Hero

Tony

I'm in Love with the Villainess

Adi Amosi

the seven deadly sins

Mateo Egey

Please no slime, most generic pseudo politics anime out there that everybody is already reacting to 😔

David Atkinson

An older one but I think it would be alot of fun to see you watch Future Diary's

Tony

Tomo-Chan is a Girl

Ravn

Personally I would really love to see Bloom Into You, it’s so good but I never see reactions

Tony

Don't Toy with me Miss Nagatoro

ViperBreeze

We are kindred spirits. Such an under-appreciated gem outside Japan.

Tony

The Devil is a Part Timer

Tony

Love After Workd Domination

Tony

My Dress-up Darling

Tony

Darling in the FRANXX

Tony

Hellsing Ultimate

The Anime Dude

Kakushigoto since yall are parents, feel like Wes would have a field day with this one.

Delta Force1031

Please no apothecary diaries it’s okay but it’s sooooo boring

Juju 9090

Fruits basket is so good. Apothecary diaries is also really good.

Tony

Avatar The Last Airbender

BlackFlame

I think you guys should either react to Magi which i believe you guys will enjoy a lot, or Kuroko no basket, its a sports anime (Basketball), and the creator of haikyu actually took a lot of inspiration and advice from the creator of Kuroko no basket.

Bilal Rajput

the hypest sports anime ever. BLUE LOCK

BlackFlame

The other one would be Dr stone, a super interesting science fiction anime, its great, it showcases the importance of education, adventure, and what mankind has achieved, i think its something every parent should show to their kid, to inspire them to pursue science.

Tony

Did they? I don't see that in the collections?

HoPascal

and a pretty bad animation... but the manga is very good yes

Yellow_Flash

Yea, hoping we get anything but that

Bilal Rajput

Ass class is not niche though. its widely known

HoPascal

chose 1 anime guy xd

Tony

Just went through the collections page again, and imAvatar isn't there, you haven't mixed Wes and Steph up with another reacts channel have ya?

Delta Force1031

It has a good story don’t get me wrong but we already have steins gate for the slower paced kind of stuff and with rezero about to end especially

Tony

Where does it say I can only suggest 1?

Yellow_Flash

Assclass aint super niche bro 😭🙏 id be down for a reaction though

Bilal Rajput

i think they should watch it after they have watched overload and tanya to ompletely get it

Hi_Hello

Bocchi the rock

S

Bocchi the rock, my dress up darling & the Apothecary Diaries

Ramms

I agree

Yellow_Flash

So it would seem 😭 so many reactors that i watch have already covered it. Im tired of it 😩

Yellow_Flash

Thatd be a nice reaction ngl

JeanCliene

Ideally that would be great but I feel overlord is quite long (4 seasons)

nezo

Durarara!!

HoPascal

I agree totally with you. The visual novel is incredible !!

Yellow_Flash

Only jojos rec i've seen so far 😭🙏 where the jojo fans at?

Musa Stone

Not to p anyone off… but. Eminence in the Shadow and Apothecary Diaries are just so basic and boring. My Hero Academia multiple seasons (5+ I believe) and has a good storyline. Rising of the Shield Hero is a masterpiece of a story, at least season one. Overlord is also very cool, not your basic Isekai. The actions in the show really make you think about morals. Also knowing that you two are into DnD is also a bonus since the overlord world is based on DnD. That time I got reincarnated as a slime is also not bad. Some say it’s also too generic but I don’t think so. You got pretty cool characters and if you are into fighting scenes, oh boy! Eminence in the Shadow is just boring because you got a “overpowered mc” like in nearly every Isekai and that’s it.

Yellow_Flash

Not an anime, but i'd love to see em react to The legend of Vox Machina ✋️👀🤚

RCG

He probably meant that they watched it only for themselves (don’t know if it’s true), definitely not on Patreon or YouTube.

Johan

INVINCIBLE / if you guys are looking to react to something new that’s not an anime, I just think your reactions to episode 1 would be golden

RCG

Baccano!

RCG

Beastars

RCG

Nichijou

RCG

Odd Taxi

RCG

Psycho-Pass

JP77

VIVY - THE FLUORITE EYE’S SONG !!!! It has wonderful music along with interesting topic on AI and Humans

RCG

The Disastrous Life of Saiki K.

Goblin!

Made in Abyss Erased Oregairu I really want to see how you guys analyze these series!

Marco S.

86 - The Eighty Six Cyberpunk Edgerunners

ジョゼフ

my like is for MiA and Heavenly Delusion

Tony

Ahhh I see, that's fair then

ジョゼフ

so underrated, will likely never get picked, but i hope so dearly that it does

Peter Butchens

I watched the anime back in the day, after I had watched Higurashi before and actually enjoyed it even more than the Higurashi anime (another one they could react to :P). The VN's weren't available in english until much later (got them on a steam sale only a couple of years ago). Of course, if you do the VN first, the anime usually pales. But back then that wasn't an option. And doing the anime first, or even just the anime (VN's are not for everyone's taste), can still be enjoyable :)

Mash

Horimiya Your lie in April

Gahn the Otaku

Definitely Made in Abyss. I enjoyed your reactions to Re:Zero, made in abyss has a similar feeling of dread that I want to see you guys work through 😅

Tabii🪷

horimiya a sign of affection ouran high school of the host club your lie in april skip and loafer banana fish gokuen babysitters i think it would be cool if you guys could react to shoujo/ romance anime as well, something light hearted :)

Johan

Rooting for this one! Just hope they’ll be able to read the subtitles fast enough 😂

noel

Given

noel

Anohana

noel

My hero academia

noel

Banana fish

noel

Blue exorcist

xee l33n4

Look back the movie!!

noel

Free!

noel

Bungo stray dogs

Roon

Exactly!! It’s a masterpiece.

noel

Tokyo Ghoul

Vishwa Joshi

Yes please!! this could be such a fun side thing!!

steven

Made in Abyss 86

James

Orb: Movement of the Earth. People will say this anime has Vinland Saga vibes, and hopefully recency bias will help this one win the poll.

Yuuto NN

these are all verry good written in my opinion: - "erased", "The Promised Neverland", "made in abyss": shows for parents (emotional roller coaster and so thrilling) - "psycho-pass", "parasyte", "code geass": old but gold - "zomb100": pretty new, a verry fun watch, u gonna love the characters -"Grimgar, Ashes & Illusions": realistic written isekai, its so underated i loved it -"Record of Grancrest War", "Magi: The Labyrinth of Magic": classic fantasy action some brain rot: "Yojo Senki: Saga of Tanya the Evil", "food wars", "the dungeon of black company", "no game no life", "im quitting heroing"

Joshua Nox

Neon Genesis Evangelion Made in Abyss Durarara

Marethyu

Made in abyss

Thinkace

made in abyss

Promise

The Apothecary Diaries, The Eminence in Shadow, Recantation as a slime

Promise

The Apothecary Diaries!

Marethyu

Call of the night

Marethyu

Tanya the evil

AbstractCat

I agree with the eminence in shadow take but apothecary diaries is definitely not bad

HoPascal

Guys guys, please don't share 100 animes. Just share one that you really like and think that would be interesting to react for Wes and Steph for various reasons (story, genre, themes...). AND CHECK IF THIS IS NOT ALREADY COMMENTED. Personally, I think that would be REALLY great if the anime gives a good experience for everyone, and so maybe a romance or slice of life anime ? That would change the mood of recent animes that we have watched (Vinland Saga, Re zero, Steins gate). (Also I don't like generic anime, wtf anime, be relevant to your suggestions) That's all, please be polite.

Merili

great pretender

Htatki

Apothecary Diaries please

JE RV

Oregairu: one of the best teen romance ever, though it has too much subtext, one of it key points is the importance of communication and clash in perspectives. Mind you, most of the characters cant be judge at face value. Magi: Fascinating fantasy and (sort of) political anime. I can guarantee you will love this one.

Matthew Molnar

Your Lie in April would be perfect with April also approaching

zengei

Puella Magi Madoka Magica

Giorgio

Eighty-Six

Renden

A couple recommendations (and short, spoiler-free explanations) based on the way I've seen you guys analyze anime: Apothecary Diaries (Drama/Mystery/Josei): [24 Ep, Currently Airing] First and foremost, it's a fun show with mild mystery and detective plot elements. Some of the mysteries aren't too deep or mind-blowing, but the main character is just so interesting. Bocchi the Rock! (Comedy/Slice of Life): [12 Ep, 2nd Season Announced] Very funny (and possibly relatable) slice of life show. The scope of the show is entirely focused on one fun character, so no deep mysteries to solve here, just a fun little ride. Ranking of Kings (Adventure/Fantasy/Shounen): [23 Ep in main season, film in production] Really, really facinating story and world. There are times it's really sweet, and also other times 🙂. I can't really say much else without spoiling it, but I really like this one. 86 (Mecha/Action/Drama/Seinen): [23 eps, No news of continuation] I don't usually watch Mecha shows, but this one is one of my favorites. The worldbuilding is unique and the story is great, but be prepared to be serious with this one, as it can be a real heart-wrencher...most of the time. My Hero Academia (Action/School/Shounen): [163 eps (not including movies), Not finished but in last arc] MHA is a popular show targeted at a younger audience, but the power system is fairly unique/interesting. Sometimes the plot points are pretty simple and explicitly stated, but it's worth a watch, and I think you guys would like it. It is fairly long, though. (Other commenters, please correct me in the comments if I made any errors in the episode count or genres. I only made a quick google search or used MAL for most of these.)

Iriza

Clannad + Clannad After Story (I'm sorry)

Bobbie

Code Geass Made in Abyss Summertime Rendering Overlord No Game No Life

Tije Oyedotun

Yu Yu Hakusho !!!! Same creator as HXH!!!

Adel Brahimi

Grimgar of fantasy and ash Ascendance of a bookworm Orb: on the movements of the earth

t

monster

t

ranking of kings

SLF needs more love

Please people watch all the nomination don't just recommend something that is already recommended

kiyo

Fruits Basket (2019)!!!!

Dwight

Akame ga Kill

Dwight

Juuni Taisen

Dwight

Mirai Nikki

Sophi

Sakamoto days

Gabrielle S.

Yess A Sign of Affection was so good!

halastair

I need that Apothecary Diaries reaction!!! It's literally the perfect anime for you two to watch!!!

Sophi

Assassination classroom

Gabrielle S.

Yakuzas Guide to Babysitting

Meia-noite

NEON GENESIS EVANGELION

Mai Pao

Apothecary Diaries!

Jane Ling

One piece live action

Kaasim Alam Baloch

The Idaten deities know only peace. It is a 11 episode Mappa series where the main characters are gods who have different morals to humans which makes it interesting

Zana

Mashle pleaseeeee

Aki

Apothecary Diaries

Alex5AVA6E

STEINS GATE 0!!!!! (Season 2!) You guys NEED to watch this after Steins Gate!!!!!

Roon

Shoshimin series: How to become Ordinary (10 episodes) I wonder if anyone else here even knows about this one.

Javi

Goblin slayer

Ethereal

There should be a moderator that deletes duplicates and multiple-entry comments. Apothecary, Code Geass, Made in Abyss, etc have been mentioned at least +10 times by now.

Ethereal

Hibike! Euphonium, a slice of life high school band character drama.

Ethereal

Higurashi, specifically the original (2006 - 26 eps) + kai (2007 - 24 eps). An unsettling thriller mystery that focuses on a bunch of youngsters in the boonies.

Blessed

Sakamoto days

Ethereal

Talentless Nana (13 eps). Focuses on a group of teenagers with super powers, however there is a hidden hook in the story.

Haldra

1. Psycho pass 2. Tokyo Ghoul(first season) 3. Rascal doesn't dream of a bunny girl senpai 4. GTO

Ethereal

ID:Invaded (13 eps). Since I have a bit of a mean streak. Good mystery thriller show. Recommended.

Ethereal

Land of the Lustrous (12 eps). Great show about humanoid gems in a post apocalyptic setting.

Ethereal

Scum's Wish (12 eps). Psychological (teen) drama. The artist of Oshi no Ko wrote this.

DFrench125

One Piece 😎 (yes this is a joke)

Keegan McCurdy

Reading comments I agree that next should be "Apothecary Diaries". I also approve of "Your Lie in April" and "Rascal doesn't dream of bunny girl senpai"

Dwight

That moderator should also take care of people who make dozens of suggestions ;-)

Scarlet

Sword Art Online

derek

goated show

derek

Invencible, monster, classroom of the alite, hajime no ippo

Rhidian Jones

I'm assuming you mean a show but just in case, 'The Tale Of Princess Kaguya' is the best anime film in my opinion and just best film in general. It transcends anime, you should definitely check it out!

Ralph

86

The Fool

That time I got reincarnated as a slime Or Eminence in shadow

kinetic98

apothecary diaries or blue box (not to be confused with blue lock)

Adam Perez

Idk how can you call Apothecary Diaries basic and boring but not Overlord and Slime

bluepak10

1. The disastrous life of saiki k 2. Run With The Wind 3. ReLIFE

Jay

1. Sword art online 2. Code geass 3. Black clover 4. Your lie in April 5. The rising of shield hero

Dale Tucker

If you want to watch something with a deep narrative and thought provoking images: Highschool of the Dead A classic.

dWr

One piece

Toro E

The Apothecary Diaries 10/10

laizer

to your eternity

Resonant Curse

Berserk 1997, it’s an amazing medieval anime

galyus

Made in Abyss

Edumads

Orb: Movement of the Earth is a new anime that’s good.

cory

Ranking of kings

Bilal Rajput

Season 1 hast decent Animation and the Finale of season 2 hast the one of the best animated Moments in anime period.

DFrench125

You said it not me! 👀 I would definitely love to see it but damn the commitment it would be

yusuke

THEY NEED TO WATCH PEAKKKKK

ytgonzalez7

Code geass Sword art online Tokyo ghoul Akame ga kill

rdcc

Isekai Quartet (crossover of Re:Zero and Konosuba + other isekai)

Elfhir

Puella Magi Madoka Magica

Liv

Link Click!

Syntax

Rewrite. This anime is a little bit older and based on a popular visual novel. A visual novel is like a regular novel, but with pictures, voices and animation (almost an anime but not quite). This a rather hidden gem. It got super powers and is later down the anime its about paralel timelines and different endings because the world is ending.

Syntax

Golden Boy is a very funny and short anime that is an absolute classic with also cool moments. Its only 8 episodes and the main character travels and meets new people very episode.

Cursed Wings

Eminence in Shadow Your lie in April Code Geass 86 Tokyo Ghoul

Syntax

Great Teacher Onizuka. This is also one of my top five all time anime. Itsa funny but sometimes serious and cool anime about a perverted 25 year old teacher that gets bullied by his stundents but turns it around. He isnt even qualified as a teacher and when he teaches he simply plays with the kids. It shows the aspect that school shouldnt be a nightmare and that life is very fun. For example one student blackmailed him that she was in her underwear in his apartment (its an older anime so really no perverted stuff but just jokes) she then tries to kill herself by jumping off his bike. He quickly catches her and they talk. Since they moved to a new bigger apartmant her parents and she never really talk anymore. Onizuka just shows up the same evening eithout a shirt and a sledge hammer and busts down the wall in her house and made the family grow closer since they saw each other more. If you just watch the literal first five minutes of the first episode I prome you that you'll will like it and the viewers too since it would be change of pace from all the other reaction youtubers who only react to the most popular stuff

Skull Knight

Check out Bakuman, it is about two boys who are striving to become manga authors and offers some interesting insights into the industry

Renden

Further recommendations would include: Made in Abyss (Great worldbuilding) Odd Taxi (Short, interesting mystery) Summertime Rendering (Drama/Mystery) Reincarnated as a Slime (Power fantasy/Fantasy politics)

M Darin

Overlord Erased Eureka 7 Assassination Classroom Gurren Lagann

Sam

This one is my pick-up too

Sam

Apothecary diaries is one of the best right now

Zak

For fun and all that - My dress up darling. For a really good story - Fate/Zero.

Zak

Noragami would be a good pick as well

Bevan Clyde

Planetes, it's from the same author as Vinland Saga. Also, Beastars.

Joshua

the disastrous life of Saiki K real good comedy

Fùjìñ

World Trigger

Æsir

Undead Unluck

Dieselpunk

Puella Magi Madoka Magica

Æsir

Attack On Titan Junior High

William

To your eternity Invincible Shangri-la frontier eminence in shadow Steins gate 0 Monster and cyberpunk edgerunner

Danial Mughal

Code Geass!! It has a great story, lots of plot twists and great characters.

宏一 大久保

Regarding Wes and Steph's great reactions and analysis to Winland Saga, Orb:Movement of the Earth is highly reccommended and I really want to watch the video.

Fukayo

- 100 girlfriends who really really really really love you - Eminence in Shadow Two lighthearted shows

daeFoxx

Bocchi the rock

Andy Campbell

A Place Farther than the Universe

ARK

Eighty Six

Cheese

Clannad

Salahadine Abaine

NANA is an old school shojo anime i'd recommend. i never finished it as a kid so i don't know about overall quality but i remember being really excited by the romance there

K_Pearl

Blue Lock Lycoris Recoil The Apothecary Diaries Tokyo Ghoul Code Geass Buddy Daddies Wind Breaker

K_Pearl

Hell’s Paradise A Sign Of Affection Your Lie In April The Secret World Of Arriety Spirited Away Howl’s Moving Castle Fruit Basket

Josh Winbigler

Baccano! It's really good and not too long.

Josh Winbigler

Hyouka Great show by Kyoto Animation.

Marcake

UP!! PLEASE LET'S MAKE THIS HAPPEN!!

Marcake

Puella Magi Madoka Magica is a MUST

BaconUp

Orb: On the Movements of the Earth Bocchi the rock Look Back - short film (60min) of an oneshot by the author of chainsaw man 3-gatsu no Lion Apothecary Diaries 86 Dangers in my Heart skip and loafer

Zachary Koogler

I thought it only had 6 episodes? I might have to rewatch if that’s the case

Yorutia

Chihayafuru (One of the best sports anime, perfect for replacing Haikyu!! later.)

Zachary Koogler

Have you watched the production clips on the Netflix twitter and YouTube channels? They currently are in the process of editing and final touch up’s for east blue. They are currently working on drum island.

Yorutia

From the New World

Yorutia

A Place Further than the Universe

Yorutia

Cautious Hero

Wolfgang

Apothecary Diaries all the way

Brad

March Comes In Like a Lion

NeonBaka

"Welcome to SAMDAL-RI" Olease watch this k draama!

Yorutia

Oh wow, this has more votes that I thought it'll get. Chances are slim, but really hoping it get picked.

Yorutia

And if you guys are also taking suggestions for some movies: Suzume Wolf Children Maquia: When the Promised Flower Blooms

spoopyjhope

I checked and they haven't reacted to it

Yorutia

Btw a suggestion: Maybe next time we can poll with Google forms or Typeform? You can restrict access by generating and distributing unique links to members, or require Patreon-registered email addresses and then cross check. I think it is more fair because all votes for the same show can be counted together without duplicated votes, and also much less manual labour for Wes and Steph.

HaNo0onat

The promised neverland s1 only !

Anzo

Kingdom

Julia Lee

Kuroko's Basketball i beg

Jonah rakotoarimanana

People need to like this or mine 😭☝️, we need them to watch it

Aaron Pendergrass

It will take them at least 3 years for them to finish that anime but I’m here for it

Mimosa Khaund

Iruma Kun Welcome to Demon school

G

yesss

G

author never finished it either lol

Md Sheam Bin Sayhid

Prison School, food wars. Guys April 1st is coming… yk what to do 😃

Astor Lefflinker

Cyberpunk: Edgerunners After watching and listening to you guys react and discuss, I think this show would be perfect for you.

Jin Noodles

They meant Parasyte the anime not Parasite the korean movie

Renden

It might possibly be more convenient if, in these new recommendation posts, they placed in it the previous list (with or without votes), and asked simply for either new recommendations not on the list or to remove old options that people don't agree with.

MonkeyUsopp

promised Neverland season 1, it’s a show that would really suit your style of reaction

Zen

Either 86, or Fate/Zero, both have masterclass writing and characters!

haleema khalid

pantheon - english show in anime style but it's so good

Stevey Pleb King

Akame Ga Kill Made In Abyss Saga of Tanya the Evil

Johan

Hard to believe they haven’t gotten to this one yet, soooo good

Nyctophobiasm

Fate/Zero, without a doubt. You two are great in terms of deep philosophical stuff and I feel like you would love the Fate series, especially Fate/Zero. It would be interesting to see how you react to the morally grey Kiritsugu.

Tabii🪷

pretty sure they’ve already watched your name

francis

Blue lock 👍

francis

Amazing anime recommendation

francis

Would love to see this!

francis

A good anime but it's a bit long dont you think?

francis

Not sure if that counts as a anime but a goated show nevertheless

francis

Agreed the story is good but it's pretty slow paced compared to the other contenders

francis

Good show but kinda long

Adam Pitcher

Won't happen but Gantz or maybe a Gantz: O one-shot.

K_Pearl

Oh yeah they did I was trying to remember whether it was “Your lie in April” or “Your name” they watched but I couldn’t remember, thanks for telling me.

Tony

Not much longer than HunterxHunter though and they're doing that

asl

I love apothecary diaries, but it isn't really fun to watch reactions of it for whatever reason

asl

Surprised the best anime to release of all time has less than 1000 likes on here tbh

Elfaria

Akame Ga Kill, 86, Food Wars, Bungo Stray Dogs, and Fruits Basket

franz

SWORD ART ONLINE

Zinfiny

Invincible 🙏 I just know you guys would love it

Abdullah

BLUE LOCKKKKKKKKK, PLEASE!!!!!! YOU GUYS ARE MY FIRST EVER PATREON SUBSCRIPTION, I JUST SUBSCRIBED BECAUSE I CAN'T GET ENOUGH OF YOUR REACTIONS, AND I LOVEEEEE BLUE LOCK, I WANT YOUR REACTIONS TO IT!

aggie

bit of a far fetched one if you were ever doing movies again the spider verse movies are fun and interesting!

huy

Orb: On the Movements of the Earth and 3-gatsu no Lion

TK

Orb: On The Movements Of The Earth [AKA: Poland Sage]

Alex Martinez

Apothecary Diaries Food Wars The Quintessential Quintuplets Fire Force Toradora Code Geass Assasination Classroom Made in Abyss

fubfub

FACTS

BCloud

Toradora was amazing a decade ago, watching that now would be okay at best and mostly going to be boring or even bad

BCloud

Tanya!!!

BCloud

Fate!! 86 ia too depressing

BCloud

Masterpiece!!!

BCloud

Thqts too depressing...

BCloud

Hinamatsuri is amazing!!!

BCloud

Its anime poll not k drama duh

TK

Some Movies: Weathering With You [Next movie in trilogy "Your Name" being the first] Suzume [After "Weathering With You"] Perfect Blue Paprika Look Back Ghost In The Shell Summer Wars The Boy And The Beast Wolf Children Belle The Girl Who Leapt Through Time Akira

TK

Neon Genesis Evangelion [24 Eps + 5 Movies]

TK

Cowboy Bebop [26 Eps + 1 Movie]

BCloud

Top!!

TK

Rascal Does Not Dream Of Bunny Girl Senpai [13 Eps + 3 Movies]

TK

Paranoia Agent [13 Eps]

TK

Serial Experiments Lain [13 Eps]

TK

My Hero Academia [120+ Eps + 3 Movies]

TK

Bleach [200+ Eps Excluding Filler]

TK

Monster [74 Eps]

TK

Cyberpunk Edgerunners DUB [10 Eps] [The Dub Fits Better As The Anime Is Based Off The Game Cyberpunk 2077]

BCloud

Too unique

TK

Grand Blue [12 Episodes] [The Funniest Anime Ive Seen]

TK

Great Pretender [23 Eps]

TK

Dr.Stone [59 Eps]

TK

Terror In Resonance [11 Eps]

BCloud

Masterpiece they need to watch!!

Sa_ji

I know it is a long one but My Hero Academia.

TK

Sorry i commented separately, I always have a issue with liking comments that have multiple shows put into one comment as there may be shows i like on it and shows i despise, at least this gives the community the option to choose

Sa_ji

Tokyo Ghoul

BCloud

Too long. They better wait for the remaster

BCloud

Code Geass

Sa_ji

It is a great shonen.

Iriza

yahari ore no seishun love comedy wa machigatteiru/my youth romantic comedy is wrong as I expected/oregairu (take your pick on the title, its all the same show!)

Amaimon2D

Grand Blue (12 Episodes)

Iriza

I think you missed the point of eminence in shadow. The fact he's an "overpowerd mc" like a lot of isekai is intentional. It's a parody isekai show making fun of isekai tropes. Everything is intentionally over the top, and while in other isekai shows this is unironically supposed to be cool, but in eminence in shadow it's literally just a dude living out his power fantasies.

Iriza

Durarara

Iriza

Monogatari Series (Kizumonogatari/Bakemonogatari/and so on...)

Calt Being

Grand Blue dreaming (peak comedy)

Matthew Molnar

Just cause eminence does overpowered on purpose doesn’t make it not boring and basic. Might as well watch Daily Life of an Immortal king or any of the other OP MC isekais

minjin batbold

Assasination classroom plsplsplsplspls

Runhua Tang

【Cyberpunk Edgerunners】: Many has recommended this before, since it's not only a fantastic anime, but also a perfect show for reaction. It has actions, romance, social commentary, and a lot of drama to to react to, while only being 10 episodes long. It also attract a wide range of audience, both amine watchers and gamers alike.

Runhua Tang

【Made in Abyss】: A masterpiece in worldbuilding and story telling (They have artists from Ghibli working on the background art, so it looks amazing), but a niche show for reaction, due to its... nature. However, I think it's the perfect show for you guys' channel. "Parents Reacting to Made in Abyss" will get a LOT of attention.

Ale

Oh I would love if they react to it😭

Cristine

Buddy daddies

Runhua Tang

【Fate/Zero】: One one hand, F/Z is part of a huge franchise, so you guys might not get all the refernces. On the other hand... imagine all the fate fans you are gonna get as new audiences. Those people are... very passionate to say the least. Anyway, Fate/Zero is probably one of the best anime of all time and you should watch it.

Cristine

Snow White with the red hair

Cristine

Tokyo revengers

Runhua Tang

【The Promised Neverland】: One of my favorite shows of all time (I watched it with my wife lol). It's also a fantastic show for parents to react to due to its theme around "childcare". Just don't watch the second season, because it doesn't exist. Yes, TPN has no season 2. Such a shame, amiright??

Cristine

Bungo stray dogs

Runhua Tang

【Bocchi the Rock】: If you guys are tired of all the anime about battles, try a slice-of-life show like this one. It was super popular a few years ago, and still is today, with a super dedicated fanbase and a lot of memes. (Seriously, Bocchi fans are built different)

Semi-addict-gamer

Do you mind giving me an idea what is good about it without spoiling it? Not saying it’s bad as I never heard of it, just genuinely curious about it.

Rex Tan

My Hero Academia - Superhero society like The Boys Mushoku Tensei - Rich fantasy world reincarnation Code Geass - Mecha with politics and strategy Your Lie in April - Musical with a little bit of romance

Dwight

Tower of God

Angel Chatfield

My Hero Academia (has Sukuna from jjk voice actor and also Gojo voice actor in it - the japanese voice actors).

Jonah rakotoarimanana

Come on guys everybody that watched Parasyte like as many comments as you can that mention Parasyte (the maxim)

Jonah rakotoarimanana

Don't recommend it anymore just like the comments that already did

zenting

Now that would be fun to watch! :-)

Marco Nodo

subpar shitshow compared to inazuma eleven honestly

Marco Nodo

pure recency bias, just like when dandadan won, since it's airing right now people are thinking more about it even though it's not the best

Marco Nodo

holy shit never would have expected kino no tabi recommended

Calt Being

Would be so helpful for the final arc!

Calt Being

Honestly, anything but this show.

Armando

I’ve never seen anyone react to “Gundam: Iron Blooded Orphans” I think Wes and Steph would enjoy the themes and the overall story, you don’t need to watch any other Gundam because this is a standalone series in it’s own timeline . Not sure how many likes this’ll get.

RCG

One recommendation is all you need - just upvote it! :)

RCG

I didn't know I liked baseball until I watched Diamond no Ace, haha.

RCG

Sure, it seems to be a favorite - it was 2nd or 3rd in the last poll, I think. But that doesn’t mean it’s going to win for sure. Also, Dandadan didn’t win either; it was just a little extra release - but recency bias will always influence polls, obviously. That doesn’t mean it’s a bad show, though. There is no "best"; it’s all subjective.

RCG

They watched Parasite, the movie, which has nothing to do with the anime.

RCG

It's just too long. For a channel like this, which usually watches one episode per week, maybe two, it would take forever. Even if you watched 10 episodes a week and skipped the fillers, it would still take about two years just to catch up. I’d suggest watching the live-action adaptation and hoping for a good remake of the anime.

RCG

I like MHA too, but you can’t compare it to HxH, literally one of the best anime ever, just because it has a similar episode count. I don’t think MHA is too long to react to, but it would have probably been a better show overall with one or even two seasons less, at least for me. I loved it in the beginning but lost some interest in the later seasons, even though the second half of the last season was really great again. Let’s hope for a good finale.

RCG

Season 1 was great, season 2 was okay, but afterwards, it gets really, really bad. Such wasted potential.

RCG

I know a lot of people criticize Blue Lock's animation, and yes, at least the first half of season 2 deserves it, but other than that, it's fine, I would say. The thing is, it's not the animation that carries the anime; it's the characters and the vibe. Definitely one of the more polarizing shows.

RCG

It's not anime, but still a good show. However, it's super gory. I’m not sure how much Wes and Steph would like that. :D

Tony

I'm not comparing them as shows, I was speaking purely on show length

RCG

They watched Parasite, the movie, which has nothing to do with the anime.

Johan

That’s super true 😂 I can already picture both of their reactions in my head, but we’ll see if it makes it to the poll or not

RCG

Let people have some fun. There is no rule that you can't recommend more than one show, and yes, duplicates can be annoying to some extent, but it's not really that big of a deal. If you want to complain, tell Patreon to add a "Load All Comments" option instead of forcing us to click "Load More Comments" 50 times. If anything, delete the comments from people who recommend multiple shows in one comment. Those are the only posts that are actually not useful.

RCG

A very accurate description indeed.

Bobby Vang

We follow Maomao who works in the Imperial Palace of a fictional Chinese Dynasty. It's like a mix of House MD and Sherlock Holmes.

RCG

It's only 6, and I don't think it's something that fits this channel.

pigbo

Invincible!! - adult-oriented superhero cartoon. really strong voice acting cast, good drama, same writer as The Walking Dead. Very fun and gruesome. Parasyte: The Maxim - sci-fi show that starts fun and escalates into a very sad, mature, existential drama/action anime.

Jonas

They already did Mushoku Tensei

BlackFlame

Kings Avatar - Its a very unique anime, its actually a donghua.. an adaptation of a light novel similar to slime, its actually a chinese anime, its well animated, the fight scenes are good, and its actually an Esports anime.

Moon

The Promised Neverland (Season 1 only!)

Moon

Fruits Basket

RCG

GTO is a classic. The only problem is that it’s quite old, and I’m not sure how well it’s aged, to be honest. It’s definitely a bit on the controversial side.

RCG

Too unique? I think you meant it's too good. Such an unknown gem, and it only has 13 episodes.

Balas

If I am not mistaken, I have seen Apothecary Diaries lead, and it's a pretty good show. However, once again some serious stuff is close so I want to bring it to more attention. If am not mistaken Cyberpunk Edgerunners is second rn and that is solid, Overlord is not so close but you can't miss with that one since its so layered writing and both of you are smart to catch on things, especially Wes since he has Psychological background, Tanya the Evil is also close and a solid choice. If I had to add one it would be Parasyte the maxim. We've got enough of mellowed-down shows so far so to take a break and watch something serious would be nice. Also, it would bring you more views once uploaded on YouTube so I guess more members here. Love you guys!

Anzo

Reincarnated as a slime

Atika Fairuz

My hero academia Fruit's basket

Abbas

Cowboy Bebop Your Lie in April Cyberpunk Edgerunners

Jonni

Arcane

C (edited)

Comment edits

2026-10-23 09:00 Ok guys hear me out. It's kinda of cheating, well, in case other people aside from me vote for this it would be for Wes and Steph to decide if this pass. There is this thing I call "The Ufotable Saga". It's basically all the ufotable's shows of Type-Moon property. It consists in: -Kara no Kyoukai (The Garden of Sinners) (10 movies) -Fate/Zero (25 episodes) -Fate/stay night: Unlimited Blade Works (26 episodes) -Fate/stay night Heaven's Feel (3 movies) -Emiya-San no Chi no Gohan (Todays Menu for the Emiya Family) (13 short episodes) -Mahoutsukai no Yoru (1 movie, not yet released) Since every work is connected and they share the same basic worldbuilding I think it deserves to be counted as one big show. I know that it's more complicated than just that, and that its more recommended to start Fate with Fate 2006. But this "bundle" of shows is for the enjoyment of the patreons and wes and steph. Also, the adaptations of Fate/stay night are incomplete one way or another. So watching all this shows together would improve the undestanding of the worldbuilding and the concepts of the shows as a whole. This shows also are of easy access since all of them are on Crunchyroll. So yeah, if you like Fate or the Nasuverse in general, vote for this one. Edit: Be aware that this series deal with mature content and heavy themes. So if you're not confortable with those topics, this series are not for you.
2025-03-22 20:13 Ok guys hear me out. It's kinda of cheating, well, in case other people aside from me vote for this it would be for Wes and Steph to decide if this pass. There is this thing I call "The Ufotable Saga". It's basically all the ufotable's shows of Type-Moon property. It consists in: -Kara no Kyoukai (The Garden of Sinners) (10 movies) -Fate/Zero (25 episodes) -Fate/stay night: Unlimited Blade Works (26 episodes) -Fate/stay night Heaven's Feel (3 movies) -Emiya-San no Chi no Gohan (Todays Menu for the Emiya Family) (13 short episodes) -Mahoutsukai no Yoru (1 movie, not yet released) Since every work is connected and they share the same basic worldbuilding I think it deserves to be counted as one big show. I know that it's more complicated than just that, and that its more recommended to start Fate with Fate 2006. But this "bundle" of shows is for the enjoyment of the patreons and wes and steph. Also, the adaptations of Fate/stay night are incomplete one way or another. So watching all this shows together would improve the undestanding of the worldbuilding and the concepts of the shows as a whole. This shows also are of easy access since all of them are on Crunchyroll. So yeah, if you like Fate or the Nasuverse in general, vote for this one. And the community is very active and is always looking forward for more people reacting to some of the series. I can guarantee that this will attract a lot more fans. Edit: Be aware that this series deal with mature content and heavy themes (Suicide, Sexual Violence, etc). So if you're not confortable with those topics, this series are not for you.

Ok guys hear me out. It's kinda of cheating, well, in case other people aside from me vote for this it would be for Wes and Steph to decide if this pass. There is this thing I call "The Ufotable Saga". It's basically all the ufotable's shows of Type-Moon property. It consists in: -Kara no Kyoukai (The Garden of Sinners) (10 movies) -Fate/Zero (25 episodes) -Fate/stay night: Unlimited Blade Works (26 episodes) -Fate/stay night Heaven's Feel (3 movies) -Emiya-San no Chi no Gohan (Todays Menu for the Emiya Family) (13 short episodes) -Mahoutsukai no Yoru (1 movie, not yet released) Since every work is connected and they share the same basic worldbuilding I think it deserves to be counted as one big show. I know that it's more complicated than just that, and that its more recommended to start Fate with Fate 2006. But this "bundle" of shows is for the enjoyment of the patreons and wes and steph. Also, the adaptations of Fate/stay night are incomplete one way or another. So watching all this shows together would improve the undestanding of the worldbuilding and the concepts of the shows as a whole. This shows also are of easy access since all of them are on Crunchyroll. So yeah, if you like Fate or the Nasuverse in general, vote for this one. And the community is very active and is always looking forward for more people reacting to some of the series. I can guarantee that this will attract a lot more fans. Edit: Be aware that this series deal with mature content and heavy themes (Suicide, Sexual Violence, etc). So if you're not confortable with those topics, this series are not for you.

Laviathian

Record of Lodoss War - The OG DnD based anime (And one of the most beautiful anime opening songs every)

Dale Tucker

Overlord is best enjoyed written. They did the source material dirty with the animation. Also So-Bin's art is so much better imo. Same goes for Tanya honestly, since the show ends in an awkward spot with no word on a sequel. Books ftw

Narawin971

me too ! commenting separately should be the right thing to do.

Matthew Wise

Garden of sinners is pretty complex for someone with no nasuverse context to jump into, I wouldn't be dissapointed if they watched it but I also wouldn't suggest they start there. I haven't seen a reaction to Dean Stay/Night (2006) before and I think it's the friendliest introduction to the series despite it's flaws, so I still personally suggest they start there. Without this version included it leads to an intense argument about whether they watch Zero or UBW first. Zero is intended to be watched after someone has experienced a Stay/Night route but UBW was written with the expectation that Zero has been watched. The argument would happen anyway but I think more people can get behind watching in release order as long as they have seen Stay/Night first as it makes Zero hit harder, and it also means the art/animation quality improves each series.

Sleepy Penguin

Darker Than Black would be a cool watch. I think they'd both have some pretty interesting takes on it.

Beth Edwards

It's about the same length as HXH but just in seasons, and a couple movies

Beth Edwards

It's well known within the anime community, but a surprisingly low amount of new gens and non anime fans know it! I know it was super popular a couple years during and after its release, but I still think they'd like it!

C

Well, it is true that is kind of confusing. But I think watching Garden of Sinners would help them undestand later entries. And is a stand alone tittle that doesn't require other shows unlike the Fate/s. Also, I just want to see them trying to undestand what is going on since they both are very analytical xd. But is true that the recommended order is Fate/stay night (Fate, UBW and HF) first and then other entries. The problem is the adaptation of Fate 2006 is incompatible with the Ufotable ones in various aspects. It's a really complicated matter. The adaptations are messy. Thank you for the comment. Guess I'll see what happend next or if this kind of thing is even allowed in the anime nominations. If not, then I will just recommend the Fate 2006 in the next anime nominations until it wins (maybe in some years).

derek

peak!!!!

Tije Oyedotun

Y’all hear me out… YuYu Hakusho, I feel like they would enjoy an old school anime a lot it would bring a nostalgic feel I think

derek

peak

Nyctophobiasm

they did mushoku tensei a LOOONG time ago lol

Nyctophobiasm

Blue lock is absolutely amazing and will hook you in instantly

derek

Invincible is a must watch!!!!

ZeroKara

Clannad & Clannad:After Story It's more of a Slice of Life early on but it gets very emotional at times. After Story might be the best piece of media I've ever watched so I don't want to spoil too much. Would love if you give it a try!

Rayraf Lets Play Piano

It has been like a decade since i watched Elfenlied. I remember it as one of the greatest Anime i have ever watched, but it could just be nostalgia. Would still love a reaction of it.

Jed

akame ga kill

Anthony Tong

Code geass is peak, especially the dub, it’s just so iconic

Steven

Ranking of Kings, Bocchi the Rock, Lycoris Recoil

Honeybadger

It's almost April, so I guess it's the perfect time to watch Your Lie in April

Easy

If you are interested in a movie (long time since we had an anime movie), you should check out 'Maquia: When the Promised Flower Blooms'. It is a story about parenthood that is a little bit sad yet pretty heartwarming.

S_Cero

Apothecary Diaries

Ellie

ouran highschool host club

Ellie

delicious in dungeon

Molokolulush

Since you guys are parents, please react to both of these movies. 1. Wolf Children 2. Grave of the fireflies

pamela

one piece!

The Strange One

Invincible is really hitting the peak at the moment and it only gets better from there!

Wisperina

not a show but a movie: Maquia: When the Promised Flower Blooms. its right up your alley and i think youll love it

so icy

Apothecary Diaries, please

David

Eminence in Shadow

Bardock

Bakemonogatari is a good multiple series anime, a bit odd but good nonetheless.

Bocchi in Shadow

Jojos Bizarre Adventure (long series) Kill La Kill A Certain Magical Index (Long Series) To Be Hero S1 of Psycho-Pass

RCG

All good, I didn’t really mean it that way either. What I meant is that just because one really good show is quite long, it doesn’t automatically justify any other long show. It still has to be "good enough" to warrant the length. (Not even saying MHA isn’t good enough - I think it is.)

RCG

They have already watched that.

Tony

Ah I see what ya mean now, that's fair

Laviathian

I think the issue with eminence's difficulty of holding viewers is that the twist and interesting part of the story happens late almost halfway into the novels. Essentially making the currently available season 1 and 2 of the anime like a long prologue.

eXxCeZz

The whole series is a masterpiece

eXxCeZz

I feel Bleach is a good pick if you skip the fillers, wouldn't do it until you finish HxH though. Another masterpiece many people haven't watched or skipped over is "Monster" its about a Surgeon that turns detective. The Fate series is prolly my top pick (Zero, UBW and Heaven's feel).

eXxCeZz

Nasuverse is great!

megazord10384

Dr. Stone! I think Wes especially would have a great time learning about science and stuff. He actually enjoys what the show is about to its core.

Reminder

here are already 750 comments, well anyways my recomendation - Grand Blue

kiyo

theres so many good recommendations, the poll is boutta be crazy 🤣😭

Anders

Jojo's Bizzare Adventure

Danny's Mod

Psycho-Pass, i dont understand why people wanting them to react to shows which got like a million other people reacted to them, Psycho-Pass is a top tier anime where barely anyone reacted to it

Lex Kelly

arcane and cyberpunk would go so hard 😭

Mina K.

ONE PIECE

Mina K.

My Hero Academia

Mina K.

Fairy Tail

Mina K.

The Rising of the Shield Hero

Mina K.

Tokyo Ghoul

Mina K.

Kimi ni Todoke

Mina K.

Seven Deadly Sins

Mina K.

Blue Exorcist

Mina K.

Soul Eater

Ethereal

Specifically S1. They can skip S2 though.

Weston Lowry

YES PLEASEEEE this would be great for them

Weston Lowry

Im only worried about how many nipples are shown in that show

Weston Lowry

Clannad would be perfect for you guys

Renden

To save Wes or Steph some time, I have made a complete list of all the anime that has been recommended so far, and then also included the amount of times it has uniquely been recommended. (Edit: I have also included highest upvote count.) There were 248 different anime, shows, or movies recommended. The only thing excluded were K-Dramas and content already watched on the channel: Apothecary Diaries had 35 separate recommendations, My Hero Academia had 29, Made in Abyss had 26, Eighty-Six and Code Geass both had 23, Arcane had 16, Your Lie in April had 15, Blue Lock and Cyberpunk Edgerunners had 14, Overlord and Slime had 13, Bocchi the Rock, Fruits Basket, Orb, and Eminence in Shadow had 12. More can be found on the online doc. Note that this does not include upvotes or comments, it is simply the amount of times an individual recommended the anime. Using the upvotes would be too difficult to monitor, because there would be a lot of overlap where someone could like every single post with their favorite anime on it. As a result, this is NOT a good ranking system to see what is most popular, BUT it does organize all of the recommendations into a complete list. I still would think having a poll would be best, but this cuts out some of the legwork of scrolling through all the suggestions and removing repeats. I will post the link to the spreadsheet in the comments if you would like to see the full list.

Robin

Free! Iwatobi swimmingclub

Anzo

Mashle

Zane

Made in Abyss

LanerQo

Made in abyss

TK

King shit, doing the Lords work

Oohisa

World Trigger. Its incredible, but it's long so unfortunately nobody reacts to it

Molokolulush

Bonus: They're just movies so it's not a long term commitment. Please do consider it!

Calt Being

Wes and steph deserves to watch peak comedy. But unfortunately this will not win.

TK

The only sad thing is if a certain anime wins 10% of the profit should be given to Potocki

Asim

Have they watched Code Geas ??

Mina K.

Also One Piece (not as a joke)

Seojun

Vivy: Fluorite Eye's Song

Calt Being

Boku no Pico!!! (Insane plot twist)

Claang

I agree

RCG

Thanks, I guess? The thing is, the number of times something gets recommended doesn’t mean much, especially since people were advised to avoid recommending duplicates if possible. That’s why they go by the most upvoted - you only take the comment with the most upvotes for that particular show, so you can’t "cheat" by making multiple recommendations for the same show and upvoting them all. But in the end, these are just the recommendations for the official poll, and I’m pretty sure at least the top 10 to 15 recommendations will make it in anyway. Whether they were recommended once or twenty times, they’ll get enough upvotes because they’re popular enough, and their exact placement in the top 20 doesn’t really matter - it’s just about getting into the poll right now. It gets a bit more questionable around the top 15–20, probably, but let’s be honest shows that barely make it into the poll most likely don’t have a real chance of winning anyway.

Justus

Hajime no Ippo

Renden

Even though the information is not conclusive, there certainly is a correlation between upvotes and unique recommendations. I'm sure you can see that simply by looking at the top 10; those are shows that are pretty popular and have gotten a lot of upvotes. There were very few single unique recommendations that had more than 10 upvotes, while almost all of the major shows' duplicates had anywhere between 20-50. As a result, what this DOES accomplish is give a vague idea of what the most popular shows are, potentially so Wes/Steph can look at every show below the '2' recommendations and decide not to include them in the poll. This was the whole point of the post: to list all the recommendations in one place. The additional feature of seeing the unique recommendation count is mostly irrelevant, but I included it to help me keep track of counts, and as a way of helping to filter (even if only slightly) more popular recommendations from the less popular ones. You're right, the information isn't conclusive at all and couldn't be used in any real study...but that's also not what this is. Realistically, I just wanted to save Wes/Steph an afternoon of infinitely scrolling through and cross-referencing the poll with the almost 800 comments. They are almost certainly busier than I am, and this is my area of study anyway. All in all, the only thing I did was basic data entry (I didn't even have to write a formula!) which isn't hard, it's just time consuming with no 'export to csv' button.

refo44

Please do Clannad will be perfect for you ( And it has the best parents of all anime, the dad and mom of one of the protagonist), The Apothecary Diaries is also a masterpiece MaoMao is one of the best female protagonist ever written. And I also want to recommend Naruto (without the fillers). For movies I also recommend this anime movies about the meaning of family: Tokyo Godfthers and Summer Wars.

F l y

86 eighty six

RCG

I would even agree with you that, most of the time, there is probably a strong correlation. I don't really want to argue with you, nor am I motivated enough to cross check everything, but there are definitely outliers. Take one of my recommended shows, Saiki K., for example. In your sheet, it only has three unique recommendations, but the most upvoted comment stands at 36. If I look at just your top five, the most upvoted comment standings are: #1 Apothecary Diaries – 45 upvotes #2 My Hero Academia – 31 upvotes #3 Made in Abyss – 28 upvotes #4 Eighty-Six – 31 upvotes #5 Code Geass – 39 upvotes So, based on your measurements, Saiki K. would fall out (or at least almost fall out if the threshold is set at 2), but based on the upvote measurement, it's among the top contenders. If you're doing this just to pass the time or because you enjoy it, that's totally fine, but please don't try to change the rules midway. I - and I'm sure others, too - tried to avoid duplicates, and now you're essentially punishing the people who played fair.

Brad

Ping Pong the Animation

Gatha Naranath

honestly my hero academia, LISTEN....THE ONLY REASON PEOPLE HATE THIS SHOW IS BECAUSE THE FANDOM IS SUPER WEIRD. Theres a bunch of shippers and just overall fetishizers. BUT THE ANIME IS AMAZING OKAY I SWEAR. it has a perfect balance of action and comedy and the character growth is great too. seriously

Zak

A rouge shout but please, PLEASE react to Berserk from 1997. The animation is old, but the story is golden, and it has a complicated emotionally charged plot that I feel you'd enjoy. Berserk stands alongside Vinland Saga as one of the greatest adult manga/anime stories ever told.

Lucas

You guys would love Reincarnated as a Slime, its wholesome and epic with a bunch of characters. Not really an intense show, but has tons of beautifully animated fights with a few movies as well.

Renden

I actually agree with you, but I didn't want to take the time to actually check the upvote counts on all of the posts...but I ended up doing that anyway. I took the top three upvote counts on each anime (including the original poster) and ordered the list based on highest total votes and also highest average votes (of however many posts there were): #1 Apothecary diaries had 46 at its highest #2 Code Geass at 40 #3 Parasyte the Maxim at 40 #4 Slime at 38 #5 Saiki K at 37 While at average votes it's: #1 Apothecary Diaries at 45.3 #2 Code Geass at 36.7 #3 Slime at 33.3 #4 Eminence in Shadow at 31.0 #5 My Hero Academia at 30.7 You were right about Saiki-K in particular, but Parasyte also ended up suffering because of low recommendation count. Saiki-K only had three separate people recommend it, and one of those only had three upvotes. In case you couldn't tell, I like doing this kind of thing. All of this is available on the spreadsheet.

Anzo

Mashle

Yorutia

Either metric has a certain bias towards certain shows. It probably won’t matter at the end, but for fairness sake, we can really use a better system in the future. Just so everyone can feel heard, and make any defeat easier to accept knowing it’s all fair and square. For this time, let’s just stick to the most upvoted suggestions, since it’s the announced and established rule. Number of mentions can be a tie-breaker. (And of course, Wes and Steph have the final say on everything.)

RCG

As I said, the sheet itself is cool - if you enjoy doing it, great! Depending on the situation, I also like creating sheets to track certain things. (By the way, good catch including the original poster in the upvotes - though it doesn’t really change the outcome since it affects every show. ^^) It was really just a coincidence with the Saiki thing. Since I was the one recommending it this time, I happened to notice it getting a lot of upvotes. Also, it's not really about "my show" winning or feeling heard. For me, it's more about sticking to the rules that were laid out from the start and not changing them for no apparent reason. Especially if it's literally the opposite of what was said at the start. That was really my only issue.

Jonah rakotoarimanana

I don't think it is that kind of show ? I might be wrong but I don't remember it being that ecchi.

Tije Oyedotun

Now you thinking DIFFERENTLY! I like that loll

xD Alex

86, Made in Abyss

Iriza

I watched all the kara no kyoukai movies with only having watched pretty much everything fate, and also Tsukihime. I was a little confused in the first movie, but as I kept watching them the format made sense, and I absolutely enjoyed the movies, and at least think I fully understand everything. But even when I was confused, the movies were just so damn entertaining to watch, I'd recommend it for sure! The animation, the score, the world... It's all fantastic.

Xandra

Nana

Xandra

Arcane

Kindyh Bordat

SAGA OF TANYA THE EVIL (Youjo Senki)

Kindyh Bordat

There are many superior series proposed here. MHA is too family friendly

Kindyh Bordat

Vivy fluorite eyes song (Underrated absolute peak)

qwerty314621

I think yall should watch *title card*

Billbob

Agree but kinda loses all its cuteness when you find out how the manga ended...

bravadour something something

Haven't watched Higurashi yet but I am pretty sure its peak. As for what you said about the umineko anime compared to higurahi, that's a very surprising take. As I said earlier I heard that the anime was bad and that higurahi anime was peak in comparison, but you tell me bro. What did you like more about it (obv no spoilers for higurashi, appreciate it!)

banlungx001

gundam witch from mercury

Wonka

Apothecary Diaries

Adi Amosi

Shokugeki no Soma

jan riha

neon genesis evangelion

jan riha

Samurai Champloo

jan riha

Fate/stay night

Bocchi

Bocchi the rock!! would be SO MUCH FUN

Laviathian

Would be awesome, but don't know if my heart can take the rollercoaster again

Iriza

I hate it cause it's cringe mainstream shounen whose western fans have only seen like three anime other than MHA, which is demon slayer, hunter x hunter, jujutsu kaisen. And to them these are the greatest anime of all time, even though they're just basic shounen anime, lol. The Crunchyroll anime awards says it all😂

The Holographic Channel

Yeah, I heard what happens in the manga but I block it out. The show itself was heartwarming

The Holographic Channel

How did I not think of Monster? Way too many great suggestions here - there seems to be more popular picks but I hope they eventually get to this one too

The Holographic Channel

There's also the 3 parter Golden Arc movies that's not too bad and probably has less time commitment but the 97 version is probably still the best

Yorutia

15 years and still waiting for the manga to resume...

teju 00

Diamond no Ace

sev

Steins;Gate movie and then Steins;Gate 0. it's basically the sequel

near.lee

redo of healer

near.lee

haruhi suzumiya

RCG

yikes

RCG

I just realized that we have quite a lot of shows ending close together. We'll probably get more than just the winner of the poll, which is actually pretty cool.

Ari

Link click “I shout cause it’s so underrated”

Ari

Totally link click

Yorutia

Btw, since you guys have been watching Alice in Borderland, I wonder if Japanese TV dramas (doramas) are also something you’d consider reacting to? Because there are some really really good stuff out there. My all time favourite is Tonbi (2013), which would hit extra hard for parents. Ghost Writer (2015) is also insanely good. And then there are phenomenally popular (in Japan) shows like Hanzawa Naoki. (Sorry if it’s too irrelevant to the nomination, but considering Alice in Borderland is in the “anime time slot”, I think this is still kind of relevant.)

Adams

Hi based on your reactions i think you will like those: Manga/Anime: - The big 3 (One piece, Naruto S, Bleach) - MHA, Arcane, Code Gueass, Reborn K Drama: - Mr Queen ( historical/funny ) - Good Manager ( business/funny ) - Devil Judge (law)

Arūnas Pupelis

Did you ever reacted to seven deadly ssins, Naruto or DBZ? Im new here btw

Kret

Apothecary diaries as it is a different genre from what you're currently watching in anime

Kret

Made in abyss

Kret

Overlord

Kret

Rascal Does Not Dream of Bunny Girl Senpai I found really good and like another of my recommended it's a different genre from what you have mainly been watching but it does get emotional

applejuice man

Bartender Glass of God Amazing and very chill anime about a bartender who is trying to perfect his craft. The characters are awesome (12 episodes long, is on netflix).

Brandon

Puella Magi Madoka Magica plz make it on the list

H

Arcane

H

Akame Ga Kill

H

Tower of God

H

Classroom of the Elite

H

Sword Art Online

Luke Collins

You guys would love Arcane, Wes would adore the animation and intricate details of the show and Steph would enjoy the plot and complex storytelling.

NoSoupRice

bruh have mercy on the poor couple

Ronald Bohne

"86". An emotional masterpiece with perhaps the best mecha visuals in the business. Same studio and composer that did Solo Leveling.

Rico

Kuroko No Basket

Danny's Mod

i would love to see reacting to psycho pass, there are not reactions to the show at least not from people i like to watch, so i would be really happy if you would do this

Mo

Wistoria

Enigma

hinamatsuri

Enigma

beelzebub

iyArashi

Seeing as they're watching Code Geass right now, I'd throw in another staple from that era: The "To Aru" series (or "A Certain..." series) starting from the first with "To Aru Majutsu no Index" (A Certain Magical Index).

Temojikato

Rather just all of mainline Fate ! Stay night, zero, ubw and hf

Krimsonwulf

Dunno if this is still open but Dangers in my Heart. If you can survive the chunibiyo cringe the first couple episodes it is SSS+ tier romcom with one of the best FML of its season. 2 seasons of it, both completed, roughly 25 episodes if memory serves if not 26.

JohnnyRA

Yu Yu Hakusho

backseat

Gurren Lagann :)

Filipe Batista

I would like to suggest : Ajin Seishun Buta Yarou Wa Bunny Girl Senpai Kiseijuu: Sei no Kakuritsu (Parasyte) Psycho Pass Durarara! Rainbow: Nisha Rokubou no Shichinin

Lucjusz Kusiński

Eminence in the Shadow guys, you'll like it so much i guarantee

Zain

Saga of Tanya the evil Please you have to try it😁

The Holy Crusader [VA]

Probably gonna get stuck in the bottomless pit of shows to watch but here's my recommendations for ye: 91 Days, 86, Orange, Black Bullet, Drifters, Kingdom, Aldnoah Zero, Seraph of the End, Full Metal Panic, Jin-Roh (Movie)

Gamer Kun

Code Geass Clannad Seven deadly sins Plastic Memories Kanon Angel beats

Silver Heinsaar

Shinsekai Yori Higurashi series Monogatari series Gintama (although prob too long) Bakuman Kingdom Kino's Journey Hajime no Ippo Overlord Monster Chihayafuru

Haingchhay Say

Fairy Tail, Inazuma Eleven (All series), HTTYD (All 3 movies), officer black belt, now you see me (1 and 2), Sonic (1, 2, 3), etc.

Rodrigo Klaus

Classroom of the Elite, Tsuki ga Michibiku Isekai Douchuu, Welcome to Demon School! Iruma-kun

Cronshaw

You guys would like Apothecary Diaries, really fun show that blends mystery with court (the royal kind) drama. I always recommend Black Lagoon but it never seems to make the cut. It’s a really stylish homage to 80s and 90s action movies. It does get quite dark.

Rostislav

They have seen Apothecary

Finisterre

I'd love to suggest Halo Legends, a bunch of unique animation styles throughout the season

Kosh1942

Arpeggio of blue Steel

Just Mav

Tensura (That Time I got Reincarnated as a Slime) as a nice isekai, and Horimiya as a nice RomCom-Anime. Last one Has only two seasons and is actually finished!. :)

Aiden Chang

You guys should start one piece and you can upload youtube videos by the arc