Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Fate Watch Order POLL

  • Fate Stay/Night: UBW --> Heaven's Feel --> 2006 Fate Stay/Night --> Fate/Zero 17
  • 2006 Fate Stay/Night --> Fate Stay/Night: UBW --> Heaven's Feel --> Fate/Zero 59
  • SKIP: 2006 Fate Stay/Night START WITH: Fate Stay/Night: UBW --> Heaven's Feel --> Fate/Zero 56
  • Fate/Zero --> 2006 Fate Stay/Night --> Fate Stay/Night: UBW --> Heaven's Feel 30
  • SKIP: 2006 Fate Stay/Night START WITH: Fate/Zero --> Fate Stay/Night: UBW --> Heaven's Feel 560
  • 2006 Fate Stay/Night --> Fate/Zero --> Fate Stay/Night: UBW --> Heaven's Feel 35
  • 2026-03-12
  • —2026-03-15
  • 757 votes
{'title': 'Fate Watch Order POLL', 'choices': [{'text': "Fate Stay/Night: UBW --> Heaven's Feel --> 2006 Fate Stay/Night --> Fate/Zero", 'votes': 17}, {'text': " 2006 Fate Stay/Night --> Fate Stay/Night: UBW --> Heaven's Feel --> Fate/Zero", 'votes': 59}, {'text': "SKIP: 2006 Fate Stay/Night START WITH: Fate Stay/Night: UBW --> Heaven's Feel --> Fate/Zero", 'votes': 56}, {'text': "Fate/Zero --> 2006 Fate Stay/Night --> Fate Stay/Night: UBW --> Heaven's Feel ", 'votes': 30}, {'text': "SKIP: 2006 Fate Stay/Night START WITH: Fate/Zero --> Fate Stay/Night: UBW --> Heaven's Feel ", 'votes': 560}, {'text': "2006 Fate Stay/Night --> Fate/Zero --> Fate Stay/Night: UBW --> Heaven's Feel ", 'votes': 35}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 3, 15, 21, 0, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 3, 12, 19, 40, 45, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 757}

Content

Hey Guys! We're very pumped to watch the Fate series with you guys! We'd like your help figuring out which watch order you'd prefer for us to do. To be honest, this is the most intimidating series to start on, feels like a choose your own adventure game! So please bail us out!

We know we won't be able to satisfy everyone, and this is a controversial decision, so please bear with us regardless of which option is picked! We are sorry if there is a watch order we missed. We tried to get all the main suggestions. We are so excited!!!!

Poll ends 3/15 5:00 pm EST

Comments

A.G

Zero-UBW-HF is the best and correct order,its also the chronological order AND release order

DFrench125

Only thing i would want to add is Strange Fake at the end of all of these :)

chefboyarkey

Lmao i went through this with monogatari and gundam. Anime always keeping you on your toes

Bambi

the watch order has been the exact thing keeping me from jumping into this series that i've known is great for so long, excited to be able to finally let group consensus decide and enjoy with everyone lolll

Reminder

because of fans like you people are getting intimidated by Fate. Just let general audience watch in release order, will your life end if you won't say "ZERO SPOILS UBW"? It is vice versa, stop nagging about it

Zen

Skip FSN 2006, start with Zero, then UBW, then Heaven's Feel. Afterwards start on Grand Order, and then Strange Fake. Maybe Apocrypha. Skip Prisma and Extra.

Melisfir

Yes! the correct order is winning!

Roy Mathew

I watched fate zero first and I’m really glad I did. It made fate zero more interesting to me since I didn’t know how the season would end and also made UBW make more sense as well. I feel watching Fate zero before fate stay lets me enjoy them both as their own stories

A.G

On the other hand UBW spoils literally all of Zero, it would ruin the best season....

Tigerclaw

Start with UBW probably

ElijahLew

Im in the camp of the 3rd or 5th choice and i'll honestly just vote for whichever gets the most lol. I dont mind the release order cuz thats what i started with and had no problem, but i also don't mind the chronological order. As long as we skip the 2006 stay night lol. I get there are many die hard Fate fans that want them to watch it but imo its so outdated that its kinda become one of those things you really only watch BECAUSE you are already a die hard Fate fan if yk what i mean. But at the end of the day im just glad we are watching Fate so whichever ends up winning is fine with me!

Reminder

Zero - UBW - HF is great for the first watch, people who claim opposite are just insufferable fans, who can't see perspective of general audience. I started from UBW and i was beyond confused through whole season watching it, made me almost not start Zero. Thank god i found strength to continue, now it is one of my most beloved franchises

KeanuofRivia

Should probably stick to the main storyline for now lol, let them get a break after heavens feel. Then they can come back for tue other fate projects later if they want. The entirety of Fate is alot to commit to all at once 😅

Infinite Winds

This should have allowed voting multiple entries...

Reminder

🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️

KeanuofRivia

It would be so much simpler if the original Stay Night woukd get remade like people want. The original has some necessary info that the others expect you to already know but its just not a good adaptation in comparison to the rest. It's animation was outdated when it released frankly.

Luke

Zero - UBW - HF (maybe also throw in fsf for fun)

A.G

Ubw talks about who survives at the end of zero and about the fire and what happened with the grail. What does zero spoils about ubw? Its not worse than the vice versa

C

Ok, let’s do this. I already made my point in various comments. But I'm going to repeat it. They should start with the Fate/stay night of 2006. Then continue with the rest of FSN. Why? Because that’s how the original vision of both, the author of Fate/stay night (Kinoko Nasu) and the author of Fate/Zero (Gen Urobuchi) intended the works to be read/watched. Fate/stay night is a Visual Novel that released back in 2004. And is the sum of the 3 routes that compose it. The routes are not separate things that can be watched by themselves, they are thematic sequels to one another and are meant to be watched together. Fate/Zero is a Light Novel that released on 2006. It was wrote with the idea to be read after reading FSN. It have A LOT of spoilers for FSN. It also plays a lot with the premise of being something that you read after FSN with a lot of elements that only make sense if you already know Fate/stay night. Again, this is the vision of the original authors. It is meant to be consumed in this order: Fate route->UBW route->HF route->Zero I know that the adaptation of 2006 does not have the quality of Ufotable's animation. But it still a decent adaptation that have the MOST important character arc of the Fate franchise since it is the one for Saber (the face of the franchise). If 2006 get skipped, them Wes&Steph will never know the end of her character arc. Thing that is addressed in later entries. I know for years the community had trashed on Fate watch order and that probably most of you only like Zero. But please consider it. The order is important for a reason. Is like skipping the early arcs of JJK to just jump to Hidden Inventory and Shibuya because I just like those arcs. Ignoring the whole built up for that moment, the presentation and the whole artistic intention of the author. That’s all, I guess I did what I could. Thanks to the 5 people that actually believed in that order. We fought bravely 🤝

Blood Shot

there is only one order that makes sense. close the polls. It has been decided

mimiyowa

Zero - UBW - HF 2006 anime is so much for nothing.. terrible scriptwriting, off-putting CGI worse than PS2 graphics... just.. yeah...

eXxCeZz

Honestly I don't think you should skip stay night, sure its bad. But it gives you a better grasp at fate. Just don't start with zero it will spoil everything.

eXxCeZz

So you want to start by spoiling HF?

eXxCeZz

100% this

mimiyowa

Hachikuji would never approve.. horrible horrible

Htatki

I don't understand people that want to watch 2006

Zen

It's 03:35 in the morning right now. Thank you everyone, I can sleep like a baby knowing my choice is winning, albeit I have to wake up at 07:50 for work...

Leandro Calderón

Now, I'm begging you to watch two episodes a week, I dont think I can wait that long for you to get to the heaven's feel movies xD

mimiyowa

With the visual novel the animes are based on having 3 main paths (Fate/Stay Night, UBW and Fate/Heaven's Feel) you're basically participating in a choose your own adventure by the way lol

C

Fate/stay night cannot spoil Zero my man. Zero was released after FSN and presuposses that you already read FSN. You cannot spoil something that was never meant to be spoiled.

Reminder

I want them evenly enjoy each seasons and movies, and not be confused 23 episode out of 25 of UBW - then go back in timeline to watch prequel to all of the stuff that they didn't understand - and then go back again to epic movies. Thats just dumb, you Fate fanatics are insufferable

mimiyowa

Everything spoils everything, it's literally 3 different branches of the same story, then a prelude. The main story tells you about the prelude, you literally end up knowing how the prelude ends. Those are just as significant of spoilers as can be. The prelude really only "spoils" in that you learn more about the world of Fate/ than if you had started with the stay nights. I personally watched Zero last for different reasons but I'd never recommend it, I think it's just more fun to start with.

mimiyowa

Trueeee, stop the count, it's been decided lmao

Atomical

Glad it’s looks like we’re starting with zero, but sad that we’re skipping the original stay night, I know it’s old but I didn’t realize how many people didn’t like it. It’s been a long time since I watched the original but I don’t remember it being bad.

mimiyowa

the first two are world building elements, doesn't reduce the enjoyment, I wouldn't call them spoilers imo ... Family relations makes no sense like, at the exception of one maybe but doesn't have a big impact, on the contrary, watching other people react to fate it's mostly excitement while reminiscing about Fate/Zero's cast

C

Yeah, cuz what is the artistic vision and intention of the author? The truth is that is as simple as starting in order the 3 FSN animes. You guys just don’t want to see that. And name anyone that oppose you an "insufferable" and "disrespectful".

mimiyowa

I mean it's like 24 episodes, that's a big commitment for a 1 episode per week schedule and it's not as rewarding to watch. I just don't think it's that good.. it's not the worst anime but it's pretty bad compared to everything else + unnecessary. Hence the reason I'd rather it be skipped

Raketen Sven

YES I was hoping for a Fates poll, you are the best reaction channel to respond to community so fast

Htatki

Huh?

mimiyowa

rip.. good luck, if you don't go and get some good rest you'll wake up and see that the poll is closed and the winning option is 2006 -> 2006 rewarch -> UBW dubbed -> 2006 "people die when they're killed"... so you better go get some sleep okie?

Temojikato

I will NEVER understand why you'd skip the original stay night. It's so dumb to me... Why would you want less Fate. Oh well, at least we're watching

Htatki

"artistic vision" you people ARE insufferable. Recomending anyone to start with the 2006 version in 2026 is the best way to make that person to lose all interest in the franchise as a whole. No one should sit through that shit just to see another route of the VN when there's a superior remake right there

Raketen Sven

Less fates is the worst outcome by far. they NEED to go back to watch it even if its after

William Evans

I will be honest here. Fate/Zero is my absolute favorite Fate/ (maybe Strange/Fake might change that). I get it, Zero is a prequel but Stay Night absolutely spoils the ending of Zero, and Zero really doesn't spoil much in Stay Night. I'm a huge Fate/ stan and everyone I have recommended Fate to and told them to start with the 06 Deen couldn't get into it. Everyone that I recommend Zero to watched other Fate/ anime...the 06 just doesn't hold up over time.

RCG

Cant speak about Fate, I havent watched it yet. But just because there is more of something doesnt mean its good. Thats what bugs me about a lot of other shows. Shounen fans especially can be such fanatics sometimes. You can like a franchise and still be honest enough to admit that not every part of it is perfect or that some parts are even bad.

Raketen Sven

@Rockycitygirl Maybe its just some like me, but I have always when I start a series, watched every single thing possible attached to the series, including games, books manga or whatever else, and Fates is one of those series that did that for me. Similar to if you love one piece you will have everything one piece, 1000 episodes is nothing with passion

Raketen Sven

Everyone please remember that what you vote for will be about 5 and 1/2 months to complete. (24 Episodes every week) I do love the newer Fates animation a lot, it wouldn't hurt to go back to 2006 Fates after they finish like they did with AOT OVAs

Raketen Sven

As the first impression I agree. they need to see peak first and go back if possible

Gavern

I could give you a list of over a dozen things that gets spoiled in all three routes from Zero. Four things in the first episode alone. The biggest of which to me being that they spoil Saber's identity, which should be a big reveal, not just blurted out in the first episode like its nothing.

RCG

Genuinely surprised. Judging from all the comments about the watch order, I thought this would be way closer but it seems we will have a pretty clear winner. This show better change my life or something.

Raketen Sven

Im curious, for people like you who have not seen it, which of the options did you pick? What swayed you? I would love to hear your perspective I won't judge

Sam Tolan

Zero was my first Fate and it instantly became a top 3 show for me, went into ubw with way to high expectations and didn't really enjoy it so curious to see if you guys have a similar experience.

Gavern

Everything that the orginal "spoils" about Zero, is stuff you are supposed to know going in. You are supposed to know who the main character is, and how the main plot is supposed to go. Gen Urobuchi, the creator of Fate/Zero, said himself that Zero spoils the main series and you shouldn't start with it.

Raketen Sven

'autist'? as in autistic? or autism? that is quite disrespectful I'll be honest. I don't even disagree with the other things you were saying

C

Yeah, cuz the intention of the original author is not artistic vision. Also, I started with 2006. And here I am. My nick is COUNTER FORCE. And the insult just proves my point. And UBW is NOT a remake of the Fate/stay night 2006. Is another route.

RCG

I just clicked one of the options to see the votes and then removed it again. No reason for me to vote without knowing anything about the show. I'll rely on the people who have already seen it and hopefully know what they're talking about :D

William Evans

You are assuming that they don't know who Saber is already. Most people in anime know at this point.

Infinite Winds

For anyone already familiar with Fate and not living under a rock this was a forgone conclusion. It's unfortunate but, though a worse option will win it is by no means a bad one.

Gavern

I just want to say, Zero definitively spoils over a dozen different reveals from the main series. Gen Urobuchi, the author of the books for Fate/Zero, even put a disclaimer at the beginning of the first volume saying you should already have finished Fate/Stay Night before reading. Here is a quote from him during an interview: "I thought that Fate/Zero was a story you couldn't understand without playing Fate/Stay Night. Surprisingly, there are people coming to Fate through Fate/Zero. However, because it's a story that plays with the spoilers of Fate/Stay Night, unless you read stay night first there is a lot presented you won't understand or identify. " I firmly believe that new watchers should start with the adaptation of the original creators work, not a spin-off done by somebody else who himself agrees his work shouldn't be the starting point.

Sarkkoth

The bottom option was literally how I got into it. Not going to lie the 2006 version was mediocre but it laid the groundwork for the other shows which were amazing.

Gavern

I have seen quite a few reactions Zero first, and I am just hoping to see my favorite reactors have a reaction to the reveals as actual reveals, not something they were waiting to be revealed because they already knew.

HopelesslyImmersed

I knew the masses would show up and pick the best order 😎

Gavern

I mean, it is likely they don't. W&S don't seem like the kind of people deeply ingrained in the anime community, otherwise they wouldn't really need polls to find out what they should be watching, and would have already seen the older 'must watches' and not done reactions for them.

Cong Hui

Considering this is a reaction type and you're guaranteed to do all of it anyway, I would have thought it worth doing 2006 after all but I guess not.

Gavern

What remake? There is no remake of the Fate route. The 2006 anime is the only one that covers it, and is the only series to focus on Saber as the focal point.

Gavern

I know it's a stupid meme, but it very succinctly tells you exactly what zero spoils. Do not open the link if you haven't seen fate: https://i.imgflip.com/8g70qy.jpg There are other things on top of that, like Saber's identity that it spoils as well.

Green Oak

Sorry but UBW spoils MUCH bigger reveals for Zero

Gavern

Sorry, but anything that FSN 'spoils' about Zero, you are 'supposed' to know going in. That's how prequels work. This argument has been done to death, but you wouldn't tell someone to start with the prequels when starting Star Wars because the original trilogy spoils Anakin's turn to the dark side.

Fabien

Zero was a novel, so the anime adaptation is way better. UBW was only a route in a visual novel (thus a video game, F/sn) which contains 3 main routes and multiple choices. It's honestly impossible to really adapt Fate/stay night (the visual novel) in anime. The point of F/sn was to do its 3 routes, in order: one named "fate", then UBW, then Heaven's feel. Each route gave "hints" about the truth behind the overall story, in some rare cases you could guess in advances, for example the identity of Sakura (revealed in Heaven's Feel) in earlier routes. Not only it's difficult to "adapt", but also: - you spoiled yourself with Zero, so a few surprises weren't actually surprises for you. - Ufotable added useless stuff that weren't in the visual novel. So yeah, Zero is the best anime adaptation of the Fate saga. But, F/sn remains the masterpiece of that saga, even if it's a visual novel.

DFrench125

Not sure if they will actually do it but I’m sure with all the praise it’s gotten this season it might have a chance

Fabien

Let's just say this is the popular choices (because a lot of people only watched zero, or prefer zero), not the choices of the fans of the saga. If you care about the correct order (you don't have to tho), it's not that one. Even if there's no perfect order because the adaptation butchered stuff, it's clear following the order of the original material (thus the narrative order) is still the most faithful option.

Fabien

It's the other way around, Zero spoils F/sn, and it's not really a debate. What you're saying is the same as saying Star Wars ep 4 spoils Star Wars ep 3 because it tells you Anakin will fall to the dark side. But it was meant to be followed that way. Zero was meant to answers questions you had in F/sn. Of course, I understand prefering Zero as an anime, since it's the best adaptation. And everyone is free to like what they like. My only point is, saying F/sn spoils zero is absurd, it's kinda crazy.

Tim Kane

Every time a reactor runs this poll, it ends with a bunch of people writing essays about how the uneducated masses don't respect "the intended watch order" and losing in a landside Hail democracy

HopelesslyImmersed

I don't mind if they revisit in the future, im just excited that we're here :D

Fabien

The thing is, there are 2 sides: those that care about that licence, and the general public that know nothing about it but want to see Zero first because it's the best anime. For example, Green Oak above is the second category, those that don't really know what is what, but they are the majority. So it's decided, end of the story. Of course, I'm like you I think it's a bit of a shame, but it's their choice. It's also the fault of the anime studios who adapted the Fate saga, and who messed everything up. To the point that the obvious choice, doesn't seem that obvious anymore.

Gavern

Doesn't mean we can't argue our opinion.

DFrench125

Oh for sure, it’s gonna be a ride

HopelesslyImmersed

Aint that the truth? The kind of people that would get upset at the reactor for not unlocking their giga brain and putting all the context clues together for the most minimal of reveals. And then taking it to the comment section to write another 5 paragraphs of the importance that they dared miss

Luke

It always boils down to them just not liking zero so they don't care if it gets spoiled.

Gavern

I hope we get a Fate route remake sooner rather than later, so this war can finally end... -_-

Luke

Doesn't matter what the author says Zero is just straight up the better rated anime so it makes sense to watch the order that spoils the worse show of the 2.

Gavern

By definition you can't spoil a prequel.

Luke

Except you can, knowing if every single character is going to live or die impacts your enjoyment of the story.

C

And in Zero's case the author plays and works with that in the story. Because he wrote the thing presupossing that the viewer already played FSN. You can enjoy even more Zero knowing how it ends. That’s the point the the author wanted to do.

Luke

Just because he's the author doesn't make him right, the fact people who have seen both overwhelmingly say start zero proves that.

Matthew Wise

Haha, I fully expected this to be the result but maybe not quite by that degree of a landslide. I was hoping fate 2006 might be included as i've never seen it reacted to and I thought it might appease some of the fans who prefer the stay/night then zero watch order, plus it does make fate zero better in my opinion, but I'm still happy with this.

Zak

looks like democracy is delivering a win for once

Shiroufan11

well, for all the arguments in the comments up until now it ended exactly as one would expect, anyways fate fans lets not be annoying about this

Rostislav

For this reason, I like technocracy more than democracy 😂

C

Ok, I don’t understand. Why are people lying? Zero is gonna win, you guys don’t need to lie in order to archieve that lol. You're just creating misconceptions and misinformation about the franchise. Fate/Zero is a prequel released after Fate/stay night ✅ Fate/Zero spoils A LOT of Fate/stay night ✅ Fate/stay night spoils Fate/Zero ❌ Fate/stay night: Unlimited Blade Works is a remake of Fate/stay night (2006) ❌ Fate/stay night (2006) is UNWATCHABLE GARBAGE ❌ Like, cool that you people like Zero and want that first. But stop lying.

C

WHAT? You guys really think you know more than the author 💀 It’s his work, he wrote that my man. How can you even say that?!

C

No one is going to complain. It is what it is. That’s democracy. I just don’t like how people are lying to protect their agenda.

pylonsf4

How doesn't Stay/Night spoil Zero? HF explicitly explains the ending of the fourth grail war

Shiroufan11

that's like saying the original trilogy of star wars spoils anakin becoming darth vader, an integral part of zero is knowing the inevitable outcome that awaits the characters

C

Yes it does… so? Fate/stay night released in 2004. Fate/Zero in 2006. The author himself says he wrote Zero thinking of it as something you watch after Fate/stay night. It also plays with that premise. There's literally a giant timer both in the novel and the anime… Fate/stay night cannot spoil something that was never meant to be spoiler. Every Fate spin-off is a derivative of Fate/stay night. That includes Zero. Next you guys are going to say Fate/stay night spoils Fate/strange Fake or something. Like what?

pylonsf4

That's besides the point. It spoils Zero, simple as that

ElijahLew

I feel like i've barely seen anyone who voted for the 70% in the comments LOL . Feels like the 100 comments out of the 400 voters are the ones who voted otherwise. Super interesting stat honestly hahaha. But pls keep it calm yeah guys don't go too overboard with fighting down here in the comments :')

C

No? It was never spoilers, so no. Or you know more than the author, Gen Urobuchi now? Like saying that the early arcs of JJK spoils Hidden Inventory.

pylonsf4

Huh? Do you read your own posts? In your original post you said Stay/Night doesn't spoil Zero. Then what do you make of Kotomine literally retelling the entirety of the last night of the war to Shirou in HF? In what way isn't that a spoiler? I'm not even arguing watch order, you're just overcomplicating everything and straight up lying for no reason

C

Was never a spoiler to begin with. Fate/stay night released on 2004. Fate/Zero released on 2006. Again, like saying the early arcs of JJK spoil Hidden Inventory. Spoilers of JJK S2 ahead: "What?! So the early arcs spoil that Gojo survived, that Megumi is a Zenin and that Geto is bad?! Cannot believe the early arcs actually spoil me on that. I should have started with Hidden invetory"

ElijahLew

Shiroufan you literally said what i've been wanting to say but I didn't know how to word it! Also I get that many die hard fans consider Zero a "spin-off" but to anime onlys Zero feels like a season 1 which is why most people who got into Fate from the anime media (like me) started with Zero.

Gavern

It's not a spoiler when you're 'supposed' to know how it all goes down. That's what a prequel is, getting added context for what you already know.

Kinx

You’re supposed to be confused, what’s the point of a mystery show if everything is revealed at the beginning, instead of at the end

Green Oak

Fate 2006 is genuinely REALLY bad. It was bad when it released and it's bad now.

Green Oak

So glad Zero is getting watched first so wannabe Fate enthusiasts can realize they were wrong

pylonsf4

Kind of crazy how disingenuous you guys are being. Early JJK would indeed spoil hidden inventory if you were doing a chronological watch of the series. OG star wars spoils the prequels. Watch order is simply out of the author's hands at this point, and you should respect that people have a different view of it than you

C

You’re not making any sense. And you’re disregarding the author's will and intention just to spread a fallacious argument. No, your opinion, nor mine is more important than the author's opinion about his own work and creation.

Gavern

Why do you guys feel the need to be insulting? And since when does winning an internet poll mean we're wrong? 99% of the time, the winner of anime polls are the shows/characters with the most 'aura' and 'peak animation'. If you don't believe me, just look at the last winner of the anime awards 'anime of the year'. Do you really think Solo Leveling was picked because of its story and characters?

pylonsf4

Ever heard about "death of the author"? That applies here, buddy

C

Death of the author is not a complete disregard of the authors intention in the message of a literary work my man. Is just that appeals to more than one interpretation of the work and meaning of the text. Nothing to do with watch orders btw.

Runhua Tang

W&S are already getting the definitive Fate experience from this comment section lol. You know what? They should play the original eroge first haha.

Gavern

That's your opinion. It holds a 7/10 on both IMDB and myanimelist, and is just as highly rated on other sites. The only reason it's consistently voted to be skipped in reactor polls is because the kind of people who watch reaction videos are typically in it for seeing the 'hype moments' or 'good animation' which the 2006 series doesn't lend itself too. That doesn't make it bad.

Tim Kane

Don't need an essay if your argument is self evident. And if you're dropping a multi-paragraph thesis on Japanese visual novel narrative structure and multiverses to strangers on the internet. Congrats, you've earned your own tier in a galaxy-brain meme

LeeviGr

I mean of course, the majority doesn't have to complain, because they are already winning

Luke

I can say it because its the general opinion, if I was going to watch star wars for instance and the creator said watch it this way but 75% of people said watch it another way then I'm going with the majority.

Gavern

Yeah, it would have been nice if they listened to our arguments and decided for themselves. At least then it wouldn't feel like one side is forcing them to watch it a certain way.

HopelesslyImmersed

Technocracy is the ideal on how goverment should be run, but using in this context is goofy 😆 You want the finest experts to dictate your taste in watch order?🤔

Ryne

I do hope that we can at least leave the watch order arguments behind when they actually start watching the series.

Cong Hui

I mean, even if it's truly bad, it's a reaction. You can have people reacting to bad stuff. And there are going to be some things you miss by skipping 2006, like the Fate route ending, which I genuinely do love.

pylonsf4

I genuinely cant tell if you're trolling or not at this point

RCG

I can already see some of the people who didn’t vote for the winning order complaining for the first few episodes. xD

HopelesslyImmersed

The minority is being very vocal trying to dissuade part of the majority to their preferred poll option. Tbh the current poll just caught me by surprise. I didn't think the difference in opinion was that huge. But still... 😆. Its okay, maybe people are celebrating way too early. There's is 7k participating, and 2 days to go. May the preferred option of the masses win ✌️

Ryne

Oh, it's absolutely going to happen. The way I wanted isn't even an option, but I'm satisfied with the current winning option.

RCG

The crazy part for me is that all the other options are really low and also very close to each other. It seems to me like everyone who’s complaining about the current winning option isn’t even aligned on what the “better” option is but rather that they just don’t like the winning one. Since you only have one vote in this poll, it really shows that there are a lot of small camps versus one big camp. I said it earlier already but I really thought there would be at least two options coming very close to each other.

CD Elio

I feel like the way I'm seeing the discourse around the watch order I conclude that the 2006 version needs a remake of some sort cause I heard from online that every fate adaptation sucks if you compare it to the original source material but if you are just an anime only it is pretty amazing. The recent Fate Strange Fake discourse prove this anime onlies like it but the OG Novel readers are disappointed because of so many scenes didn't get adapted

Tim Tim

Oh wow, my suggestion got are winning (I proposed to skip 2006 stay night, and start with fate/Zero)

Gavern

In the wider fandom it is more mixed. But people who like to watch reaction videos typically fall on the side of the spectrum of wanting to see reactions to the hype/cool moments. Which I will admit, albeit grudgingly, starting with Zero lends itself to.

Tatsuke44

Since the Fate/SN 2006 will get skip by looking at the poll result, i will just copy paste the after part of what I said from the other post. After that you can watch the other Fate series that still connect to Fate/SN series but at the same time not, anyway you can watch this at any order: •Fate/Apocrypha •Fate/Grand Order (this one is abit incompleted since it is from a game adaptation, and it only adapt some of the game chapter) •Fate/Prototype (This one is an OVA 1 episode) •Fate/Kaleid (Um... This one has some questionable scene to show but if you can bypass that some weird scene in the series, this one is a good decent Fate/series that has some really cool fight) •Fate/Strange fake •Fate/Extra Last Encore (The story is very confusing if you're not familiar with the game Fate/Extra) •Fate Grand/Carnival (This one is best watched after you have watched every Fate/Grand Order) •Carnival Phantasm ( This one is a bit confusing to watched since the charcter that shown in the show is Fate/SN + Tsukihime. Tsukihime is one of the Visual Novel game that Type moon created which also created Fate/SN that also originally a Visual Novel) • Emiya-san Chi no Kyou no Gohan (Think of this like slice of life that connected to Fate/stay night) • The Case Files of Lord El-Melloi II (This one is conncted to one of the character from Fate/Zero) Other series that outside Fate/ Series but is done bv Tvpe moon: •Tsukihime (Skip this if you like since this one is a shit adaptation) •Kara no kyoukai/Garden of sinner (This one is my personal favorite outside fate series, but need some correction on how tc watch this due to the story timeline is not based on released date of the movie aired) • Mahoutsukai no Yoru (This one is not aired vet, but is set to aired this year. This one is also one of my favorite in term of Visual Novel that Type moon released)

Ethereal

I chose "Skip Fate/Stay Night 2006 -> UBW ..." considering it's an unremarkable production headed by Studio DEEN, who isn't known for their stellar quality. So I'm pleased that the other Skip option is leading at least.

Ethereal

It's not the release order (re: source material). And yeah, it's chronologically correct but prequels are called prequels because they're created after the original material, so they're meant to be consumed after too. My angle is that Fate/Zero is better written than Fate/Stay Night so it'd kind of be a writing downgrade (though animation-wise it'll be an upgrade for sure). That's one of the reasons I recommended UBW first.

Ethereal

Sadly 2006 Fate/Stay night is just a bad outdated anime. Even at the time it came out it was underwhelming, and when Ufotable's adaptation was announced, fans were ecstatic. I love another series Umineko (also adapted by Studio Deen) but I wouldn't recommend the anime adaptation.

Tim Kane

The 2006 DEEN adaption was the first Fate thing I've ever seen and I'd 100% recommend skipping it for first viewers. Its not even about animation quality or how good the Fate route itself is. Its just not a faithful adaption and does this weird chimera that pastes in random stuff from other routes. If you're worried about "spoilers" from other routes, the 2nd DEEN opening straight up just has a climatic scene from another route in it interjected randomly that it doesn't even adapt.

Gelondil

While I've made jests about them watching Carnival Phantasm, they should probably hold off on adding any Fate series past the 3 (4) the poll is about and leave the others for another anime poll. Unless, of course, they become addicted to the series, and want to give it the BTS treatment by watching EVERYTHING. Which I wouldn't be entirely against! But at that point they ought to just watch F/SN too, because there's far worse titles on this list. :D

C

I have been rewatching it. It’s decent and definetely not bad as people make it sound. Even have some cool extras that can only be found in there. Also the key moments are great and the OST is like another level. Best Fate OST easily. Just listen to La Sola or Unmei no Yoru. I feel a lot of people are afraid of Wes&Steph don’t liking it and dropping the series. But that is for them to decide, not for us. So it’s a shame that the one that is winning is the one that erase his existence. Truly sad 😞

Gavern

We can all at least agree its awesome they'll be hearing one of the contenders for the best Yuki Kajiura soundtracks right? ;D

mimiyowa

there was one Studio DEEN anime that I was surprised was from Studio DEEN tbh

C

Says the guy that "quote" Death of the Author as an argument. You’re just putting yourself above the author for no reason at all. Using the free interpretation as a shield lmao. Who I'm gonna believe and give more credit to? A) The creators of the franchise B) Random person on the internet A pretty 🦐le decision in my opinion.

Hayate

My choice is in the minority (2006 -> Zero -> UBW -> HF) but to be honest, it's not that big of a deal. 2006 is purely from my nostalgia perspective and to make UBW hit harder, like a "wow the quality is insane" (also because Oozora Subaru watched in that order) Zero doesn't spoil the rest of the series. You just don't understand some stuff and you get the answer later. People who say Zero spoil the rest of the series is because they watched Zero while already having all the pieces together. When I watched Zero, I just didn't understand wtf was going on when "that" happened and it took me a few years to understand from UBW and HF, which is a totally fine way to watch the whole thing.

Cong Hui

I would love to see them do Today's Menu, though. Given its length they can probably do it in 2 videos of 6 episodes each.

Saber

Tbh I would like to see them watch the 2006 stay night. Although the quality doesn’t live up to ufotable (understandably) I do think people exaggerate it. Imo they adapted the story much better than ufotable did with ubw and heavens feel. It still has its own charm but I know everyone prefers the newer adaptations due to the flashier fights which idm.

A Guy

I don’t know why zero fans always get so aggressive. It’s best not to watch a prequel first, especially in the case of zero since it was written with you knowing what happened in mind. I just hope they don’t kick up a storm after zero is done because they are infamous for the bad stuff they say about fate stay night

Gavern

Just correcting a misconception you seem to have; the spoilers isn't 'that'. I'm not even sure what 'that' your referring to. The spoilers is stuff like Saber's identity, certain characters backstories, who killed whom, and everything else that is treated as a mystery in the main series. Watching Zero first removes most of the mystery of what is very much a series about mystery.

S0ulSp4de

I know it will not win, because people forget that a lot of fans were made by the deen adaptation. But I go with the last one, it's the order I watched it too.

Ethereal

Good job sifting through the comments. The poll is representative of all the options available.

Rostislav

@HopelesslyImmersed I am a fan of the idea that you should surrender to the author's vision. But in general, it's not critical, and I'm glad that Fate won overall

Sorin

The vast majority of people that vote for zero first are not really "fate" fans. They are Zero and maybe Fate Strange Fake fans.

banlungx001

feel like a game of swap 4 number with every combinition possible

banlungx001

speak for yourself sir , i start with fate 2006 , play the novel , then consume every fate content afterward , AND i am in favor of zero>ubw>hf , because the 2006 version is just that BAD , it would be one thing if it only going for the saber route , but trying to incoporate the key moment from ubw and hf with their NOT aged well animation is a SIN

banlungx001

calm down , let them finish HF first

banlungx001

fuwamoco tries it AND drop it after 1 episode , those doggo just dont know a good one when they see it.

banlungx001

everytime i bring this up in a poll , some people just goes "long show is not a bad show" , and here we have hero academia and one piece which is like 10 times of your 5 month example , even with double/triple episode per week LOL

banlungx001

the minoirty here say zero spoil ubw and hf right? well guess what , the 2006 version spoil UBW and HF to an even more absurd degree , (a.... iden... , r... stab.. sa... , s.... kan... bya....) in a low-not-aged well quality to boot

Luke

That's just not true, I started 2006-ubw-zero and recommend zero first. 2006 was meh not bad not good, didn't bother looking for more fate media after finishing it till ubw started airing. As for "real fan" Ive watched mainline 5 times start to finish at least, watched nearly all the spin offs, played fgo for years and even read a bunch of fanfic. But I guess to the elitist vn players that's still casual.

banlungx001

it s not that much of a freedom , the game force you to play in the order of fate , ubw , and hf route anyway with a good reason.

banlungx001

@Irithylia it s a fate route with 2 key scene spoiler from ubw and hf and top it off with the spoiler of the biggest twist of the series in that deen episode 14 , that s my argument.

C

Yeah, they are the only ones insulting people. What is their problem? We are the "insufferable", "disrespectul" and "autistic" for defending our ideas, but they are the ones being toxic and insulting. Like, what?

Green Oak

it's the other way around though? The poll is clearly in favor of Zero first yet the comments are nothing but people throwing tantrums because Zero is first.

Green Oak

Because every single Fate poll ends this way. With Zero being first and weirdo zero haters throwing tantrums about watch orders. It's cathartic to see crybabies not get their way

Eika Mikiku

Thanks everyone for voting for the only right order. Having 2006 in the list has a lot of duplication of ideas behind the war which are explained in zero very thoroughly. Same ideas are also get explained in UBW somewhat. Unless a person cares for a specific VN ending adaptation that is in the 2006 version, it doesn't particularly bring much to the table, and it's visuals are inconsistent with the other ones. So technically, to cover the ENTIRETY of the original fate stay night VN, the 2006 version is needed, as it's one of the 3 main endings, but it just has a lot of duplication with UBW, which would make UBW kind of duplicated, story-wise that is.

Ein Diskent

nice im actually surprised when i chose the majority. im very happy that the community knows the right way to watch it for fate newcomers. they dont need to see the 2006 one for sure

C

No? Most of the comment are people saying: Zero->UBW->HF. Then there are some comments questioning why people hate 2006 so much (like 3 comments). And finally comments like mine that try to disprove the lies that the community so casually propagates as a gospel. Literally 0 people are saying anything against the results of the poll lmao. You guys just distort everything to your convinience. And again, the ones insulting are only the fans of Zero.

humphrey-t-humphrington

I had to delete my comments because people were saying I was nagging or otherwise speaking to me in insulting ways and stuff after I politely said I don't think zero should come first, i just don't have the time or energy to deal with people being rude and aggressive for zero reason and it seems like F/Zero fans are always super rude for no reason even though they're in the majority

Green Oak

"- Ufotable added useless stuff that weren't in the visual novel." The visual novel is a porn game. Ufotable is the only reason it exists as anything more than cheap hentai

Green Oak

there's no better watch order lmao.

Zak

and watching zero second removes all jeopardy from zero.

Gavern

Except you're not supposed to feel the jeopardy. You're supposed to feel the hopelessness of knowing how it's all going to end.

Random

TBF the Saber ending is the most popular; hence, the reason it was produced first, albeit by a not so great studio.

Gavern

Again with the insults. Why can't you be civil? Also no one in the comments here has said they hate Zero, just that its not the appropriate place to start the series.

Gavern

I mean, being the only show that has a focus on Saber is what it brings to the table. That's a pretty big point in it's favor.

Infinite Winds

Despite my pick not winning, I'm just so hyped for Fate/Zero, I can't fucking wait

Chief Yoshi

tbh I still think ubw- hf - zero is the better watch order because the visual novel came out before zero’s light novels, but I’m glad we’re at least all in agreement to skip the 2006 adaptation. Imagine being stuck for weeks watching that before getting to ufotable. It’s the one thing we can all agree on lol

C

At this point this guys read the comment and twist it to give it a meaning that is not there. Truly the 'death of the author' right here lol. Like, no one had said that Zero is bad and that is not worth it or something. We're just appealing to the release dates, the words of the authors and the spoilers. No one have anything against Zero as a work of fiction here. And obviously we're not using hate as an argument. But we are the "irrational" ones, right?

C

Well, the poll is over. Again, thanks to that 8% that voted for FSN first. We unfortunately couldn’t win, but we did what we could and that’s good. Let’s hope that after they're done with the most requested Fates (Zero, UBW, HF, SF, etc.) Wes&Steph can go back and react to the Fate/stay night (2006) and see the character arc of Saber. Until then, congratulations to the winners. I hope you guys enjoy it. And thanks to Wes&Steph for considering our watch order for the poll P.D. Refrain for over explaining of what is happening in every chapter. Let them figure things for themselves and just answer when asked and is not spoiler. Have a nice day!

ElijahLew

No way Michael B Jordan just talked about Fate /Stay Night after the Oscars LOL

mlg

I'll never understand the madness of watching prequels first but it is what it is.

Green Oak

Because it perfectly sets up the main story and the main story dramatically spoils the prequels reveals.

Green Oak

Lil Nas X dressed up as Gilgamesh for the met gala

Green Oak

"see the character arc of Saber." and that arc being a trained king falling in love with a teenage boy and using the power of love to win? There's a reason FSN is hated and it has nothing to do with it's age or appearance. It's just by far the worst part. The berserker fight is also one of the worst fights in anime

C

Yeah… because she getting over her griefs of her rulership and the fact that she start to see herself more as a human after seeing herself in Shirou's ideal and form of life and how wrong is that way of living. Accepting the conclusion of her reign and falling in love because she is not the perfect machine called king anymore, but a human being. All that just evaded you somehow even if it was slapping you in the face. You're not the smartest cookie Green Oak. Next time try to pay attention to what you're watching. Also, get over it man. The poll is over. You guys didn’t even lose and still you have the actitude of a sore loser.

mlg

Yes, that's how prequels and main stories work.

Nguyễn Hữu Minh Tuấn

If you take the time to do some research online, you'll find that Fate/Zero is not confirmed by its creator as a prequel to Stay Night . The storylines of Fate are written by multiple authors, and they are very reluctant to interfere with the timelines of other authors, which is why each piece of content in Fate is separate and there are virtually no timelines that influence each other; there are only references

Fabien

Green Oak-> It's insane to me to read people saying Fate stay night "spoils" Zero. It's a prequel, even if it was written by another author it followed what was written in Fate/sn and the directions from Nasu in the matters related to F/sn (only what wasn't related, such as characters like Rider and Weaver, were entirely Urobuchi's work). You're supposed to know how the fourth war ends when you starts Zero. BUT, when you start Heaven's Feel, you're not supposed to know Sakura is the sister of Rin, and that Illya's father was Kiritsugu. Now THAT'S a spoil, see the difference ? F/sn, of course, doesn't spoil Zero, but Zero sure spoils F/sn. That's how the story was intended from the start.

Fabien

Nguyễn-> Nonsense. The Fate franchise and its universe were literaly invented by Nasu. Everything else was added to it afterward, with Nasu's blessing (for the most part) and cooperation. Urobuchi's work, Zero, respects every bit of lore that was contained in F/sn about the fourth war. Find me the quote that would suggest otherwise. Even the title, Fate "zero", is a reference to the fact that its a prequel.

Fabien

Could you at the very least admit that order spoils half of Heaven's Feel major twists ? Heaven's Feel was made to be experienced before Zero, but also after UBW (and after the first route), as it's the last route of F/sn. But yeah, no proper adaptation exists for the first route of Fate stay night, named "Fate". The 2006 anime isn't really an adaptation of the first route, it mixes several things.

Fabien

Luke-> All of you are just ignoring the main issue: Zero spoils (heavily...) Heaven's Feel, and HF is to be watched after UBW. Thus Zero is to be watched after both, regardless of if you watch the 2006 series or not. Admit it, you don't care because you yourself never experienced HF as it should have been experienced, so you don't think it's something to be protected as it never left a big impression. Since you were spoiled.

Fabien

"Zero doesn't spoil the rest of the series." I'm dead. It's insane how people don't know or understand anything about this series, Zero literally spoils most of the majors twists of Heaven's Feel. Like Sakura being Rin's sister and Illya being the daughter of Kiritsugu. Your order choice was one of the most absurd out of all of them.