Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Files

Previews only

TopHat YT

Comments

Yankee Veg

Regarding the dances in long takes, it's amazing when you get to see outtakes, in extras, documentaries, and such, they'll put take after take side by side and though the partners show enough change between takes to spot that they are different, Fred Astaire was so precise and so practiced that each take appeared identical to the rest. He rehearsed so much that the rumors has it only Frank Sinatra worked harder on his dancing, but that's because Sinatra wasn't a dancer and it took so much longer to perfect each dance in his movies. Also, my favorite feminist quote, which you may have heard before is "Remember that Ginger Rogers did everything Fred Astaire did, and *she* did it backwards and in heels." Thank you so much for watching this movie! I appreciate that you are looking through the AFI lists, of which there are many, might also be worth checking out Oscar contenders. Thanks for all you do!

Yankee Veg

OK, two other points i feel compelled to make. Of course Gene Kelly had a more butch style. He's a Pittsburgher! Growing up amongst steel workers and miners, i imagine a lot of the flavor of the city rubbed off. The other point is that given how much you both seem to appreciate the craft of filmmaking, not just stories or performances, you really must check out Vincent Minnelli (husband of Judy Garland, father of Liza). I believe he was the patent holder for a kind of dolly which revolutionized film dancing. He was the artistic director of Radio City Music Hall for years, but also spent time as actor, costume designer, set designer and director which leads to some spectacular results. (My favorite is Gigi, despite the fact that it is jaw-droppingly inappropriate these days.)

Actuarial Lurker

So did the Graduate steal from the timing of this?