Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Comments

Cristy

Thank you, Actuarial Lurker! Love this movie because of the well written characters and the talented cast performances. I can't wait to watch your reaction.

Erin Mileur

Joy Davidsons (Debra Winger) first husband and the father of her two sons is William Lindsay Gresham the author of Nightmare Alley which was adapted in 1947 and 2021 to film.

Actuarial Lurker

Gentlemen- thanks for reacting and glad to share this: First this WAS based on real life since CS Lewis wrote an anonymously published book (which I have NOT read) "A Grief Observed" which was a memoir of his experience of Joy's death and its impact on his faith. This was Oxford, its just Magdalen College that was 500 years old at the time. The script was adapted for film by William Nicholson who was nominated for the Best Adapted Screenplay Oscar for this work, He was later nominated for writing the script for Gladiator (and lost again). Debra Winger was nominated for the Best Actress Oscar for this role but lost. It won the BAFTA for Outstanding British Film, and Attenborough, Hopkins Winger and Nicholson were nominated for BAFTAs for Director, Actor, Actress, and Adapted Screenplay but lost.Hopkins won the LA Film Critics Best Actor award for this film and Winger was runner up for Best Actress. Hopkins had THIS role and Remains of The Day in 1993 so his Oscar nomination was for that film. Winger was beaten out by Holly Hunter for The Piano and was up against Emma Thompson for The Remains of the Day. Nicholson lost the Screenplay Oscar to the writers of Schindler's List...

Actuarial Lurker

Joy Davidman was only 45 when she passed away in 1960, was considered a child prodigy and graduated with a Masters in Literature from Columbia at age 20 and won multiple national US poetry awards. She had TWO kids, not one, so that was the major poetic license for the film. Douglas is still alive, aged 79, was raised by CS Lewis and his brother and helped publish CS Lewis work and preserve his documents after Lewis' death in 1963. Brother Warnie was a founder of the "Inklings" at Oxford an informal literary club that included Tolkien. C.S. Lewis was a High Anglican (essentially indistinguishable from a Catholic except for allegiance to Rome) and as you noted his work and Tolkien's were threaded through with Christian symbolism....Lewis' "Screwtape Letters" are considered a major work of Christian apologetics- I've read parts of it, my wife ALL of it- and its plot is a junior demon being tutored by a senior one on how to throws smaller and then larger woes and hardship at believers (ala the Book of Job) throughout their lives to attempt to erode their faith. Screwtape is structured as an epsitolary novel (like Dracula) and essentially teaches the reader how to plow through hardship very much as Lewis did himself in this film

Actuarial Lurker

Richard Attenborough was famous for directing Gandhi, A Bridge Too Far, A Chorus Line, Chaplin, Shadowlands, and Cry Freedom and of course as the grandfather billionaire from Jurassic Park

Clare Manion

I’ve been so curious about this one (I looked it up after seeing it on the list), and it was wonderful! Heartbreaking, but wonderful. (Thank you Actuarial Lurker!) About a year ago, I read ‘The Fellowship: The Literary Lives of the Inklings’ which is all about Lewis, Tolkien and their group of writer friends at Oxford. (I’m very much a Tolkien fan. He’s the reason I majored in Linguistics, as dorky as that sounds.) Anyway. That book covers a lot of this story, and the group Lewis meets with at the pub is probably intended to be the Inklings. On Joy’s argument with Jack – I understood it as she’s calling him out on his resistance to vulnerability and genuine connection. If he has positioned himself so that he can always be the one with the answers, as the one who takes the philosophical view of everything, up above it all, that inherently disconnects him – prevents him – from ever having to really feel anything... He’s hiding. I wouldn’t blame him – his mother died when he was a kid, and his father was awful, so the impulse to create that separation is understandable... But then Joy shows up. They clearly like each other a great deal, but she wants to talk to him as an equal, not a student or something. One cannot be an equal from above, unwilling to truly engage on such a fundamental level. And so she calls him on it...Anyway, that’s what I saw that exchange. And he figured it out eventually. "That's the deal..." is such a great line. A beautiful movie all the way around. I’m sure I’ll watch it again, many times over.

ScarlettMi

I really resonate with that moment when Douglas checks the wardrobe and knows there won't be anything there, but still feels that disappointment. There was definitely a childhood version of me that may have checked the back wall of a closet or two... just in case. I always associate this film with the other VERY BRITISH movies that Hopkins had come out in the immediate aftermath of The Silence of the Lambs. In my head it's an ultra-British Hopkins trilogy: Howards End, The Remains of the Day, and Shadowlands. (Side Rant: I hate that modern publishers have Narnia in the wrong order. Wardrobe should always be first. Magician's Nephew is a wonderful prequel that belongs as the penultimate book.)

Actuarial Lurker

My sentiments- and better put! I found it ironic and wonderful that Her name is Joy and that she brings both Joy but then grief to his life and that is the only real way that he feels anything

Sammy Fan

I have never seen this movie before. I loved it. Thank you for sharing this. 84 Charing Cross Road is a film that Anthony Hopkins did with Anne Bancroft a few years before Silence of the Lambs. I think it's another overlooked gem.

GDF

Sad thing is, 3 years after this C.S Lewis himself would pass away.