Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

So... Good Talk

Files

GG5 16

Comments

Jane Avery

Haven't started the reaction yet, but before I forget again I wanted to say that I'm so impressed with how many of the references you get! I've watched GG multiple times and I still find myself looking things up. Also your cats are welcome on screen anytime 🥰

fire12wife

OMG! I cannot wait for next week's episode!!! Luke was diabolical this episode! He was just completely miserable without Lorelai! That makeup kiss at the end was one of the best kisses on film! it's a very close 2nd to their first kiss last season! I feel SO angry at Emily for what she did, and Rory had every right to say those things to her at dinner. You don't just come back from your 2nd "honeymoon" and act like nothing ever happened! I loved seeing Lorelai just hang up on Emily repeatedly! That was amazing! Great reaction as always, guys!

AmyAin'tMyName

Lorelei left her parents when Rory was a baby. They barely had contact for years. You'd think Emily would understand that Lorelei is willing to cut off contact. I don't hate Logan, but I can't love him. Maybe it's the actor's face, but he's always smirking and it drives me nuts. 😆

Stephanie P.

I really liked Rory and Jesse, but Logan is more of her match and more mature than her pervious boyfriends. He has his faults, but so does Rory. I don’t get the impression that Richard knew about the Chris situation. I don’t think he had a problem with Emily doing it though so it’s up for debate if that makes him on the same level as her about her and Luke breaking up. I really think he’s not in the same boat as she is personally. He’s not great but his attempt at meddling in the relationship was wanting to get Luke to franchise his business and be more successful. Just like this episode he tries to get Lorelei to sell her inn to be more successful. Richard’s M.O. is financial success, and it’s a lot of the reason he bonds so much with Rory because he sees himself in her in how driven she is. Emily cares the most about image and being proper and social expectations. She was hell bent on Luke and Lorelei breaking up no matter what, so imo she was more of the wrecking ball in Lorelei’s life. I could see why her and Rory wouldn’t lump Richard into this particular drama because he was more passive in what was happening regardless if he has good intentions as well.

Gail Hislop

Richard- 'however misguided her feelings are'- he may not have been aware of what Emily did, but he is still enabling her bad behaviour and not calling her out and acting as if Lorelei is in the wrong. Emily 'i feel I know what's best for her.' That is what is so annoying about her, she will not take responsibility or accountability at all for any of her actions against Lorelai and still wants to control and manipulate every aspect of her life. Including going to Luke! The fact that at that Friday night dinner she didn't acknowledge to Rory that Lorelei wasn't there, she just acted as if it was normal, showed that she knew she was in the wrong and that Lorelei wasn't speaking to her. Being surprised that Rory was angry at her though shows how self righteous she can be. I loved that Rory called her out on it and said the things she said and acknowledged that she had an obligation to be there, but not in how she had to behave when she was. I cheered for that scene. And it's the first time she had ever been disrespectful to either of her grandparents, so that said a lot to them about how bad what Emily did was. Great episode all round and yes that was Judy in A Star is Born (probably the most definitive version of it as a musical) singing 'The Man that Got Away' appropriately as Luke comes knocking at the door. And side note the original version of this film was in 1937 starring Janet Gaynor as an aspiring actor who is initially mentored by, but becomes romantically involved with an older actor with a drinking problem. It is a drama and the source material for what has become the other 3 versions, but with those having the female lead as a singer. I'd recommend adding it to your black and white old Hollywood movie watch reactions.

Stephanie P.

Just to be clear, I don’t think Richard is great either. Him and Emily are essentially two peas in a pod. However, that line delivery, “WHY DON’T WE HAVE STOOLS IN HERE?” always cracks me up in this episode. Lol.

Carl Wilson

The original Star is Born was a non-musical version with Janet Gaynor from 1937. Then came the Judy, Barbra, and Gaga versions. Haven't seen the original myself, though I've seen the other three. It's such a wild story to be such a perennial through 80+ years. They all have some incredible scenes, but especially the Judy version.

two pennies no waiting (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-15 02:00 Emily's contrition is something for the audience to forgive Emily but not for Lorelei to forgive her. My husband and I do Rover sitting, typically I am the preferred human but on the occasions it's my husband, I am a jealous, petty betty and quote Emily's whiny tantrum all the time. "cause you're the favorite." haha Kelly Bishop is impeccable as Emily. it's like Imelda Staunton as Umbridge haha.
2026-08-25 01:25 Emily's contrition is something for the audience to forgive Emily but not for Lorelei to forgive her. My husband and I do Rover sitting, typically I am the preferred human but on the occasions it's my husband; I am a jealous, petty betty and quote Emily's whiny tantrum all the time. "cause you're the favorite." haha Kelly Bishop is impeccable as Emily. it's like Imelda Staunton as Umbridge haha.

Emily's contrition is something for the audience to forgive Emily but not for Lorelei to forgive her. My husband and I do Rover sitting, typically I am the preferred human but on the occasions it's my husband; I am a jealous, petty betty and quote Emily's whiny tantrum all the time. "cause you're the favorite." haha Kelly Bishop is impeccable as Emily. it's like Imelda Staunton as Umbridge haha.

Carl Wilson

My theory is that Richard found out after the fact about Emily's visit to Christopher, but before the vows event. He was probably fairly supportive, or at best said, "Well, I don't know how that will work out but perhaps it's worth a try." He's otherwise been just as bad as Emily in his general treatment of Luke. I think Rory and Lorelai are being too easy on him, but narratively he's the only plausible bridge. I accept it as a plot device. But there is something vaguely sexist about him being treated as at least neutral while Emily becomes the total villain. After all, it was Richard who effectively broke up Lorelai's *last relationship! Not to mention nearly breaking up his own marriage by being an ass to Emily and not listening to her for a long period leading up to their separation.

JustALilTired

YAY Luke and Lorelei together again! There are indeed 4 versions of A Star is Born, I’ve never seen the original but all the remakes are great and stand alone quite well, Judy’s is my favorite though 😉

two pennies no waiting

This is my favorite season, I am so jazzed for next week's episode. It's almost like I just watched the broadcast promo "Next Tuesday on Gilmore Girls..." lol

Carl Wilson

Yeah, I have a hard time with the smirk too.

Carl Wilson

Let's not be too generous about the franchise idea. Remember that Richard's idea was basically to have his buddies take Luke's business away from him and just have him be like the pitchman for the chain they would run. Because they clearly thought he was too much of an idiot rube to do anything more, but he'd be more presentable in their circles under that arrangement.

sandrinegeller

Yes i am glad you discussed how jess was a bad boyfriend. i was so confused when i watched this show after hearing so much about rory and jess. they were not a good couple. logan is much more an intellectual and personality match for rory. don't get me wrong, he has his faults, but so does rory and i think they make sense. he kind of talks her out of her mental freak outs as we have seen already and is able to keep up with her intellectually and personality wise as he is more upbeat and quick witted (jess was too but in a different way).

Tobias Keezy

I get that it's supposed to be over the top and comical, but Luke's crashout in this episode was so absurd that it took me out of it. I thought it was poorly written, poorly acted, and poorly directed. The overacting when he's yelling at people makes me cringe. There's a point when some shows stop being about anything real or close to real, and increasingly start to be about themselves, for their own sake, and get a bit too ridiculous. I think Gilmore Girls starts to go down that road in these last few seasons

Stephanie P.

What Richard suggested to Luke was insulting, I agree. I don’t think Richard deserves a father of the year award. It’s objective, but I think what he suggested to Luke is still less intrusive as Emily deciding she wanted to tank Lorelai and Luke’s relationship and involved a really sore spot in Lorelei’s past by involving Christopher. Richard and Emily are similar but Richard didn’t drive a knife into Lorelei’s relationship like Emily did even if he was a snob to Luke about his business.

Yasemin

As much as I love Emily as a character, I don't think she acted "selflessly" here, but in a rather calculated way, as she wanted things to go "back to normal" (in her mind). Part of me always wishes they had cut the slapstick humor about Luke acting out and screaming at customers, while also having him approach Lorelai at some point, without Emily having to give stage directions for that to happen....still a beautiful last scene though.

fire12wife

Lets not forget the Male Yale party that both Richard and Emily threw to get Rory a new "acceptable" boyfriend, and the birthday party Emily threw for Rory with all of the Chilton kids she hated without asking her, then expected her to give this big speech.... and when Rory yelled at Emily and refused to do it, Emily yelled at Lorelai and called her a bad mother for letting Rory act that way, even though it was HER fault that Rory did it! I hate Emily with every fiber of my being, nor am I fond of Richard. The games they play with Lorelai's and Rory's lives are beyond ridiculous! That's exactly why Lorelai wanted to get away from them in the first place!

Roland

Thanks for the great background information. I hope the lads take up your suggestion!

Roland

Yep, I agree, Luke's behaviour really didn't mesh with the rest of the episode. A single bad serving, a single customer screamed at to leave, probably would have hit harder (and could maybe have been darkly funnier).

fire12wife

Kelly Bishop's real first name is Carol! She changed it during her time on broadway!

Watch This! with Joe and Kevin

I remember when the last one came out and that song was all over the radio. How long until they make the 5th version?

Jiiinx1753

I think, even if Richard was aware of what Emily was planning on doing, Lorelai, probably expects him to not like Luke and things like that. But Lorelai is also aware that Emily is far more manipulative and does rather than just say, whereas Richard doesn’t really get involved in Lorelai‘s life or business, he’ll say things to her, but not actually go out of his way to make things happen the way Emily does. I think that’s why Lorelai gives him a pass but also, I think there was an episode in the past where Rory asked Lorelai, “do you think grandpa knew what was happening” and Lorelai said, “no this is all Emily”.