Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

To Live and Let Diorama

Files

GG5 18

Comments

Yasemin

What do you mean "there is not much reason to keep Emily on the show"? She's a Gilmore Girl! :)

Carl Wilson

When Paris is out drunk begging for change in her bare feet and blowing raspberries at everyone, she's doing Gena Rowlands in A Woman Under the Influence (1974), one of the greatest film performances of all time. It's so great to see the show do an unidentified homage instead of its usual name-dropping cultural references.

Gail Hislop

Those 3 girls should never drink! Paris wandering the streets of Stars Hollow, shoeless, looking homeless and begging for money to call Doyle is just so bizarre, Lane losing all perspective and rationality and Rory on the bathroom floor crying at the end was very sad to see. I don't agree with any one who was saying they felt that her accepting that date with Robert in the previous episode was a calculated move. I think, as you said she just realised that she could see other people too and why not go out with him. The whole Twickenham house and the diorama story line was just weird and kind of stupid and makes this one of my least favourite episodes that I generally skip in rewatches.

Allison O

Carole King as cranky Sophie is the best. “And I love Jesus!”

Watch This! with Joe and Kevin

I told Joe after the episode it felt like David Lynch took over the show for a week. We just got to see a bizarro side of everybody.

AmyAin'tMyName

There were some great lines but I agree. The only thing I remembered about this episode is that Luke likes the house.

Carl Wilson

Important reminder that Sophie is Carole King. Other than that, Lane doing Gena Rowlands (see my other comment) and the Twickham House, which I love, I have no idea what's going on in this episode. This one needed a serious rewrite. (a) From a journalist's perspective: Yeah, the writer is under no obligation to make any changes at Lorelai's request, but if you're a magazine that covers the industry (inn-dustry lol) then you might want to maintain a relationship by toning the personal stuff down if your cover subject is upset about it. What you *wouldn't* be likely to do is offer/threaten to pull the whole article - that's more of a punishment for the magazine itself than for Lorelai, screwing up their schedules and layouts for the issue, requiring a whole new cover shoot, etc. None of the way that went was realistic. (However, it does show that there are *some limits to how much Lorelai wants to be at war with Emily, even now, at least for Rory's sake.) (b) I'm with Joe: They just got Rory and Logan seriously together last episode, it's way too fast to sow more discord. Just weak plotting, uncharacteristic of this season. (c) Minor point, but Kirk not having an apartment or having gone back to his mom's by now is too ridiculous even for him. That said, Lorelai playing mother to him in the breakfast scene was very funny. (d) That Zack's big secret was bluegrass was pretty half-baked, though a drunken Lane (has she ever been drunk before?) yelling at Carole King is pretty worth it. (e) Yes, why the hell is Luke listening to Dean? Come off it.

AmyAin'tMyName

I feel like all comments need to end with that now. 🤣

Yasemin

Kirk doesn't know they are not walking around naked in the house while he's there, because he doesn't "know their domestic routine". LOL, cracks me up every time!

Yasemin

It is a strange (and fun) episode, and also a strange Dean scene! :)

Yasemin

I love the scene with Lane and Rory and Paris together.

Joy M

The Muzak line is a great come back from Sookie. Recently I was attending a conference in a hotel. In the bathroom there was piped in Muzak and it was the 90s hit No Diggity in Muzak form.

Sarah P

Since this is the last appearance of Jared Padalecki on the show, I’d like to say . . . I never liked Dean thaaat much, but — the way that his character arch went has always felt very manufactured to me. He’s the perfect boyfriend, until they want to introduce some conflict for Rory, and then they slowly make him more and more of an asshole as the plot demands. This is my first rewatch, and I was surprised by how much that hit me.

Ari

Dean just had to pop up to remind us that he's an immature jerk sometimes.

Yasemin

Why spoil that though?

PJ

Please don’t post any more spoilers while they are watching this show until the end. Let them experience the show without knowing anything about anything regarding the show and characters.

AlecSinWonderland

Warner Bros Studios does this Gilmore Girls theme Stars Hollow Thing every year lately, and they sell Miss Patty’s infamous Founders Punch and let me tell you! It lives up to the hype. I’m a frequent drinker and I was halfway done when it got me totally tipsy 🥴

Onno Smits

Editing out a few sentences from the article is too much work. So instead the alternative is to offer to pull the entire article, including the picture on the cover of the issue, and replace them with something else? How is that _less_ work? This episode is so weird, the vibes were way off.

cruzinbosco

This is one of my favorite episodes, but the Luke/Dean drama makes zero sense. What Dean says doesn't fit Lorelai at all, and he should know better. She isn't Rory; Rory has dreams bigger than Stars Hollow, but Lorelai literally ran away from a life of "more" to be here. She has always wanted this town and it's simplicity and weirdness. It felt like a really forced, frustrating moment just to make Luke doubt his future with her. If the writers wanted to create insecurity for Luke, they should have done it a different way without involving Dean. Maybe he's jealous of Luke? Because the two men are very similar, but only one was able to keep a Gilmore Girl?

AlecSinWonderland

its amazing. Luke was there and Mrs. Kim. 10/10 experience. Will be returning

Flavia Barcellos

Hey guys, is it normal that I can’t see the actual scene from the show or hear what they’re saying here on Patreon? I can only hear you guys commenting, so I have no idea what scene you’re reacting to. I’m so confused 😭