Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

A House Is Not a Home

Files

GG5 22

Comments

Anjali Agarwal

I love how invested you both are in Luke and Lorelai! :)

Tobias Keezy

It’s astonishing to see how extensive Richard and Emily’s utter lack of respect for Lorelai seems to be. I think they established in their mind a long time ago that she was a dumb teenager who recklessly ran out into the night with a newborn and nowhere to ago, and they have refused to treat her as having changed or improved anything in the time since. Granted, I think that Lorelai’s insistence that the fact that this happened to turn out okay by a sheer fluke means that it was a sensible decision is a bit ridiculous and probably annoys them a lot. The more likely outcome was probably extreme poverty or danger. Even still, that’s not an excuse to treat your daughter with completely no respect. It’s appalling.

Tobias Keezy

Amy and Dan are such great writers because you can clearly see they’re fascinated with this young mom-teenage daughter BFF scenario, and yet are intelligent enough to write the deep problems with it in a sober way. Lorelai parentified this girl since she was nine or ten, making her more responsible for their quirky home life than she should have been, and turning her into a peer and friend because she needed one, instead of keeping her as a daughter. You can’t be best friends with your kid, especially at a young age. You’re pinning your needs for validation and support on a young child and fitting them into a social role according to your personal needs. What happens when doing right by your kids involves giving orders or making them angry with you and you’re too scared to do it because you don’t want to lose them as a friend? When your daughter makes a dumb decision to drop out of university, you don’t get to just drop out and cut contact like giving the silent treatment to a friend who disappointed you. You need to yell and scream and scold and lecture and do whatever it takes to get them on the right path. And if you have placed your child in this role as an emotional peer to full your own personal support and affection needs, you can’t bear doing that. My relationship and duty to my kids is not contingent on them liking and agreeing with me all the time. That’s not my job.

Tobias Keezy

I don’t think Lorelai ever got comfortable with disciplining her daughter, partly because she parentified her so much that she didn’t have to do much of it, and even then it was just “You and me are pals, so you gotta tell me things, okay. Everything’s all better 😚💓”

Tobias Keezy

I don’t think Lorelai handled things well at all. Punish her, for God’s sake! Raise your voice! Get angry! She turned over in like three seconds. Maybe if she appropriately scolded her and went livid and impressed on her daughter the seriousness of the catastrophe she’s landed in, perhaps Rory wouldn’t have been so certain that she’s right about everything and so confident in her dumb decision to drop out. People who are appropriately ashamed worried about their disastrous choices don’t go out and make new ones so easily. “Don’t worry, Rory. Everything will be fine. We’ll work it all out. 🥰🥰🌹🌹💕💕🧸🧸” SHUT UP! WHAT THE HELL ARE YOU DOING?

James Roberts

Hard agree. I know it was for TV purposes since I'm sure it's easier to film a conversation in a stopped car rather than a moving one. But Rory just hemmed and hawed in the car for like 30 minutes without explaining herself. And Lorelai LET HER???

James Roberts

One thing that never made sense to me was how much stock Rory put in Mitch's opinion about on the ground investigative journalism. Who even knows the last time he's written anything. He's a businessman first and foremost and it's been that way for decades.

Gail Hislop

You nailed it, Rory is a coward and manipulative! She may have genuinely been upset and crying with Richard, but she knew he would melt and then side with her against Lorelai and enable her bad choice to drop out. Her mother was being tough on her and probably the first time that was happening and she didn’t like it. It’s all so childish of her and speaks volumes to her character and her sense of entitlement and that she just moved into that pool house without a word is appalling behaviour to her mother who has done everything to support her and be there for her for her entire life! Even Logan who really is entitled is a better person than Rory is at this point. The end of this season really showed her true colours and they weren’t pretty - particularly following on from last season and beginning of this with her affair with Dean. Richard and Emily are the worst! I was as stunned as Lorelai at their turn around and betrayal of her the first time I watched the series and still am. And when they’d had that lovely discussion with her and agreed to back her up it really was a knife in the back. On other things from this episode I loved Mrs Kim coming in hot with the whole tour plan and supporting Lane! The way Gill responds to her cracks me up. And wow, that cliffhanger bombshell proposal at the end! Imagine we had to wait forever for the next season to air back in the day to find out the answer- you guys get to find out next week. Ahhh the wonders of streaming services.

fire12wife

Luke saves the episode, again! With all of the hurt and craziness in this episode, Luke stood up for Lorelai, and won't let Rory flush her life down the toilet! The look on Lorelai's face as Luke is planning Rory's kidnapping, says everything! She knew in that moment how much Luke loves her and Rory... and she just couldn't help but to feel that he's the one for her, for the rest of their lives! Next Monday is SO far away!! UGH!!!!

Tobias Keezy

I concede that you can be a good parent without reaching an Emily level of judgmental scorn or Mrs. Kim level of strictness. You can be a successful mother while still being pretty chill, though it’s not easy. But there’s no version of good parenting where you just never scold or admonish your kids. None.

Carl Wilson

People *do take breaks from Ivy League schools - that part's not a complete disaster, though it is a setback for sure. The disaster is that Rory is, yes, a little spoiled, but also so deferential to what she perceives as expertise and authority (always has been) that she can't recover from the Huntzberger thing. And on top of that, that Richard and Emily are such effing monsters to their daughter. Lorelai has always been right to try to keep them out of her life. And yes, at this point, they all need emergency family therapy, like they should be sent to family rehab where they all have to deal with their shit 24 hours a day for a month.

Carl Wilson

,,, But that moment when Lorelai asks Luke to marry her. My heart!

Carl Wilson

Let me just state that I think Lorelai is a fantastic mother, and these claims about her never scolding Rory are baseless - you guys do remember the fights they had over the night Rory stayed out all night, over her sleeping with Dean, etc? As Lorelai said, Rory has mostly been such a well-behaved kid that she grounded herself over having an overdue library book. She doesn't lose her shit at Rory on the boat night because she can tell her daughter's having a meltdown and she needs to understand why. Then she *does lose it at her about the Yale thing and says it is not going to happen, and so Rory goes behind her back to her grandparents. This is not Lorelai's fault.

Stephanie P.

This episode has a million things going on with everyone at once it’s a crazy finale.

Abby T W

It was so fun to re-live this with you guys. This is exactly how we all responded back when it aired, and then we had to wait 3 months after that final scene too. You should have seen the TWoP forums back in the day lighting up after this episode. Just SO frustrating but also so beautifully written to be able to make us all SO invested in Rory that it makes it all the more angering when she starts spiraling. It's almost like we're all Luke, watching her grow up all these years and having so much hope for her, then being shocked and crushed when she starts burning it to the ground.

Carl Wilson

You can't "punish" a 20 year old woman.

Tobias Keezy

Sure you can. When I was in undergrad, my parents still yelled at me when I did dumb stuff. I was still a dependent, technically, just as Rory is. Punishment is more than just a childhood spanking or whatever you’re thinking. You don’t have to just ask like two questions about what happened and then go, “There, there, sweetie. It’s ok. I forgive you for committing felony theft. Everything will be ok.” fifteen minutes later. Immediately next morning, they were cracking jokes about her whole-ass mugshot! Unbelievable!

fire12wife (edited)

Comment edits

2026-10-11 02:00 Lorelai didn't yell at Rory for the yacht thing (I wouldn't have been so nice), but she did yell at her when Rory said she wasn't going back to Yale! She told Rory she wasn't going to let her move back home. and old her to pick another major and/or another school, and that she wasn't dropping out! She was definitely using her Mom card for that scene!
2026-10-13 03:00 Lorelai didn't yell at Rory for the yacht thing (I wouldn't have been so nice), but she did yell at her when Rory said she wasn't going back to Yale! She told Rory she wasn't going to let her move back home. and told her to pick another major and/or another school, and that she wasn't dropping out! She was definitely using her Mom card for that scene!
2026-10-06 01:12 Lorelai didn't yell at Rory for the yacht thing (I wouldn't have been so nice), but she did yell at her when Rory said she wasn't going back to Yale! She told Rory she wasn't going to let her move back home, and told her to pick another major and/or another school, and that she wasn't dropping out! She was definitely using her Mom card for that scene!

Lorelai didn't yell at Rory for the yacht thing (I wouldn't have been so nice), but she did yell at her when Rory said she wasn't going back to Yale! She told Rory she wasn't going to let her move back home, and told her to pick another major and/or another school, and that she wasn't dropping out! She was definitely using her Mom card for that scene!

I🖤Kraken

When they were sitting around the dining room table planning together and you guys were so happy and cheering them on because finally, FINALLY, they were a cohesive, loving, family after all these seasons-- I swear, a tear just slowly rolled down my cheek...😂😥🤣 Oh my sweet, summer child.

LB Mac

At least y'all don't have to wait three months for Luke's answer! Back in the day, the wait for season 6 was torture!

I🖤Kraken

Honestly? It's Richard's fault. He was away for most of Lorelei's childhood and so parenting isn't really his forte. One little cry and he cracked like a walnut. He would have given Rory the moon to get her to stop crying because he emotionally couldn't handle it.

Tobias Keezy

Naming a handful of occasions of reprimand in five years isn't really strong support for that point, especially since basically every instance was surrounded by context where they said it was so unusual and uncommon for it to happen.

Yasemin

To be fair, Rory is not Paris. She has been put on a pedestal her whole life and is not equipped to deal with real world criticism. Also, it is to be questioned if it truly was her "lifelong dream" or more a dream that has been projected onto her by Lorelai (at least in parts), as Lorelai was not able to go to college herself etc. Maybe go a bit easy on Rory here. :)

Yasemin

Your "no no no no!" in the end was everything. I know your schedule won't allow it, but I do fully support the "go to the next ep" idea, lol. I love the contrast between all the fun with Gil and Mrs. Kim and the band, versus the drama going on otherwise.

Yasemin

I can see where Richard and Emily are coming from, even if it does not make them look pretty here. They should have involved Lorelai in a different way, I agree. But Lorelai told Rory that there was no option to come back home (not even for a bit of a break and thinking things over?) so it's not a surprise that she would go to her grandparents at this point, and that they'd react this way. I do get Lorelai's disappointment, but her not even trying to listen to Rory's feelings (no matter what the apparent reason for her confusion might be) does backfire, obviously.

Dani

I hate this version of Rory so much but in some ways, it probably needed to happen. Rory clearly is ill equipped with real world disappointment and that's something she has to get through. Lorelai blaming Logan completely and immediately always annoys me. It goes back to the idea that Rory would never do anything wrong unless led astray by a guy. It's pretty insulting way for Lorelai to react. Also, if she thinks her daughter is so easily coerced then that's clearly a problem that might have something to do with her predicament, yeah? Richard and Emily definitely went about this the absolute wrong way but giving Rory breathing room where Lorelai didn't want to wasn't inherently a bad idea it just wasn't something they should've agreed to without talking to her first. They shouldn't have come to an arrangement with Rory after already coming to one with Lorelai. This was a conversation, even if they now sided with Rory, to have all together.

NOam Gold-Utting

I honestly have what may be a hot take which is that Richard and Emily are 100% in the right in this episode, especially Richard. Rory is very clearly in crisis and Richard loves Rory more than anyone, including Emily and Lorelai, she's the person he has never crossed, never gone against. I think he was genuinely concerned about her emotional state enough to be worried about what the 3 of them ambushing her would trigger given the place she was already in when she came to him. His plan was what you guys suggest in the outro, get her somewhere stable and safe, which given that Lorelai had already said she couldn't move home left them with no option but with Richard and Emily and then try to work on her to get her to come around. That part of his plan only falls apart because Lorelai refuses to allow it, which is fair given the circumstances but still. He very clearly articulates that the idea is to stabilize her and then get her back to school, which given his Yale connections wouldn't be difficult. Like I said, hot take but this is the point that I really start to realize how not great of a parent Lorelai is, her response to Rory is always, 'its my way or Im gonna be so unpleasant or silent or negative that you'll eventually have to do what I want'.

Onno Smits

She doesn't have _any_ soap in the entire house?! Yeesh, that is disgusting...

AlecSinWonderland

The more I watch, the more I come to the realization that there was some truth to what Mitchum said, although I do believe that he said was out of some kind of mean place, but Rory kinda proved him right about not having a certain "It". I imagine how Paris would have handled Mitchum, And it takes me back to that time Richard pushed back on Paris for her 'Locker first aid kit Idea' and she completely stood her ground leaving no trace of doubt in her pitch. Paris would have countered Mitchum in all his pretentiousness whereas Rory completely folded.

Roland

I have to say I loved the Frat Bros, just another Friday night, bailing Huntzberger out of jail AGAIN. 🤣🤩 I never got arrested at that age, but man we did some dumb sh1t back in the day....

Roland

So in order to give the Gilmore fans the full authentic reaction experience you'll wait three months before the next episode? :D

fire12wife

Yeah, they are! Fans of the show will forever be debating which one of Rory's boyfriends was perfect for her, but with Lorelai... it's Luke, it was always supposed to be Luke!

Naomi Bronner

What, were they supposed to list every single example of her calling Rory out? I guess a statement is only true so long as you dismiss all the examples that contradict it as outliers. But here are a couple of other notable ones: she gets angry with Rory when Rory tells her she kissed Jess while she was still with Dean and she gets angry with Rory when Rory has sex with Dean while he's married and tells her it's wrong. Lorelai isn't a perfect parent because nobody is, but I actually think it's pretty reasonable not to make a huge deal out of the little things, or to be an authoritarian parent who has no respect for her daughter's autonomy (like Lorelai's parents were and continue to be), but to firmly call her kid out when she feels strongly that she's making a mistake.

Naomi Bronner

I genuinely don't get where the "Lorelai projected her own dream onto Rory" shit comes from when it comes to journalism. Like sure, does Lorelai maybe want Rory to be successful in ways she wasn't able to? Probably. And we can debate how hard she pushed her toward this (I'd like to point out that when Rory was initially struggling at Chilton Lorelai told her explicitly that she didn't have to stay there if it was too hard, and that she didn't want Rory to go to Harvard if that's not what Rory wanted; she would be proud of her either way). But journalism? When does Lorelai ever express even a remote interest in journalism outside of reading her daughter's articles? Do we ever even see her reading a newspaper? Journalism is Rory's lifelong dream because she has autonomy and her own interests outside of Lorelai. And Lorelai, who is a good, if flawed, mother, supports her daughter's interests even if she doesn't share them.

Yasemin

I don't know what "shit" you are talking about. :) But well, Lorelai also freaked out when Rory applied to other colleges than Harvard, so there's that (and yes sure, that was also because of her reactivity to Emily and Richard, but still, huh?). As for journalism...that is not my main point. :) But rather the fact that she was never able to go to college and therefore...as she now also stresses "ok well, then study something else but don't you dare quit college!". PS: Yes we do see her read a newspaper, Richard's visit to Stars Hollow comes to mind, lol.

Naomi Bronner

People love to bring up the Harvard / Yale thing as an example of Lorelai being a bad parent, but they conveniently don't mention how that storyline was resolved. Like yeah, Lorelai did freak out when Rory applied to other colleges, and it was weird and bad, but then when she realized that Rory genuinely wanted to go to Yale, and it wasn't just her grandparents pushing her into it, Lorelai encouraged Rory to go to Yale. She even replaced all the Harvard merch with Yale merch while still dealing with the inn fire, it was a really sweet gesture. So no, that is not an example of Lorelai being rigid and forcing Rory to follow the path Lorelai set out for her, it's an example of Lorelai being stubborn at first, but then realizing she's in the wrong and adjusting her behavior appropriately. But yeah, I do think journalism is relevant here, because you're suggesting that Rory's dreams and ambitions aren't her own, that it's all stuff that Lorelai pushed onto her. And that's just not true. Rory likes journalism because Rory likes it. If the writers wanted to communicate to us that Rory was studying something because it's an interest of her mom's, they would have had her study like screwball sitcoms from the 1950s, a subject that Lorelai clearly has a real passion for. Lorelai does not have a real passion for journalism (her reading a newspaper once when her father is at her house and she's awkwardly trying to break the tension between them is not the same as expressing passion for the topic) but Rory does. It's her own interest that she came up with, separately Lorelai. So I think it's understandable that Lorelai is upset that Rory is seemingly giving up on something she really loves, and it's not just her projecting. Do I think she handled any of this well? No, I think that despite what Gilmore Girls would have you believe, it's not actually that weird to take a semester off. But I also think it's not completely unreasonable to expect your kid to have a plan for what they're going to do in this off semester, beyond just sitting around the house. I don't like this storyline, and I think that the show's attitude about the whole thing is just weird, but I also don't think it's fair to say that the problem is that Lorelai is a bad mom who projects all of her desires onto Rory without taking what Rory wants into consideration. That's just not true. It's become a popular internet hot take but it's not actually backed up by the text.

pumpkincarvingjen (¬ ´ཀ` )¬

Guys the video is asking me to sign into YouTube to view... but I already am signed in, it opens a pop out window and the option to play never appears. Is it just me?

Yasemin

This isn't black and white, and it's not "just her projecting" (hence, I said "in parts" first). Also, who said anything about her being a "bad parent"? :) It does play a role though. People aren't one-dimensional, and neither are complex relationship dynamics. Also, Rory is an introvert. Doesn't mean she couldn't be interested in journalism, of course, but she doesn't strike me as the type who really wants to "go after" stuff. A strong interest in literature does not automatically make you a reporter.

AudeAudor

What punishment? Lmao. I think at first, you listen to your kid, "what is going on, tell me", you say you'll figure it out together. You say you're disappointed in the bad deed they made yes, but you figure out solutions and listen to your kid. And THEN, if it's not working and the kid keeps doing bad decisions, you raise the voice, you say "if you're not gonna at least try to listen and do the solutions we both discussed about, then you take your responsibilites". But you do not punish! Especially, as said before, a 20 years old. What's the punishment? You get out of my place? I don't give you any money anymore? (right, that could be it. But that's on Richard and Emily who agree to put her in the pool house then.)