Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 537141865.mp4

Downloads

Content

I'm going to be honest with you here. In this episode I get quite personal and a bit agitated and angry about the show and the "gratuitious" sadness I've noticed since episode 8. It hasn't soured the show for me, but, I really do feel a lot of mixed feelings towards the viewing experience. It feels a bit heavy handed and almost like "grief porn" in a way that is very difficult to explain but I tried my best to articulate it. I do hope since you all are here willingly you'll come with me with what I'm trying to express - I don't expect you all to agree at all or anything but I did want to touch on how I'm feeling towards this episode in particular after the real mess that was episode 10 for me personally. I know we joke that we don't talk about episode 10 but I've really come away feeling a bit distraught over it! Not in a way that is toxic or anything but just in the delivery being so gutwrenching. It's all very well and good for the character development of violet and I enjoyed her development very much but it also left me totally exhausted and a bit emotionally drained. The reason I write all of this in this particular episode is simply because I'm sharing some unbelievably personal information about the death of my father because it's pertinent to my feelings. So, I'm feeling slightly nervous to discuss my reasoning for my feelings. I do ask for your gentleness and especially for your kindness in the event that you disagree with me, which is valid and reasonable since we all come to this with different life experiences. I just feel I owe it to you, who pay for this, to know. Thanks as always! Marco

Files

Comments

Shanknbake

Totally understand when u were saying u will be relieved. I havent been able to watch it since the first time ive seen it in 2019. It hit me hard enough i still remember the entire show. But watching you watch it also has got me reliving those old emotions and i feel tired these days haha. We are excited to see your next reactions. I love this show but i still cry just as hard

James Long

Before you watch the 2 hour movie, there is also a 90 minute movie I recommend you watch. It’s called Eternity and the Auto-Memory Doll. I think it is good to watch that on between the end of the show and the big movie. It offers a change of pace.

Daniel

Episode 11 is my favorite, by a decent margin, so I'll try not to get too defensive. I can feel my guard go up when people call this show "gratuitous" or manipulative, because I feel very strongly that the show is utterly sincere in its messaging, and those descriptions in my mind carry a ring of accusing cynicism or disingenuousness. Not to say necessarily that you are accusing that, but that's the reflex I get that drives some defensiveness and probably presumptuousness. You're not alone in your take. From observing a few people and different responses to the franchise, I suspect some of it just comes down to personality and how one personality relates to "negative" feelings vs how another does. Some folks seem averse to experiencing and feeling those and reject or resent things or occasions that evoke them, almost seemingly like to experience them is a fail state; Others not so much. While I do tend to feel pretty spent or worn out any time I watch this show and movies, I binged it straight through in 2018, and then again with a friend the next evening. It ultimately all feels therapeutic, cathartic, healing--with tissues. The "tired" is more like after a really hard workout, rather than the kind of tired that comes with burnout. That being my read on it, my bias is obvious so I hope that wasn't received as unkind, uncharitable, or too harsh. I have a hard time relating to the opinion you expressed, but I try not to begrudge people it apart from some disappointment that they come away feeling worse instead of what I wished everyone came away with. Episode 11 is my favorite for a few reasons. The biggest one(s) end up being personal. Others being story and animation along the lines of what you touched on. I've been in a few circumstances where people might live/die from my choices, and dread or panic over "what if" I didn't do absolutely everything I was capable of. Also where people died out of my control but I still felt and feel responsible for one reason or another. I've also had many many thoughts of needing to apologize to my parents that my life hasn't turned out how they hoped for me. The scenes in the cabin and at the end always uncork something that needs a release, or I'd just keep burying things and keep on keeping on. As far as story and animation. This is basically Violet's character development reaching its telos. It's Violet in her fullness of feeling, understanding, and expressing. In Ep 10 we see her empathize with and comfort someone, but she still suppresses how she feels at the time, and is almost overwhelmed by it all. In 11 she's no longer overwhelmed and can still do the rest. This plays out in the animation, where the animators clearly paid a LOT of attention and gave a lot of time to her expressivity and the microexpressions on her face in the cabin, particularly the 30sec shot of just her face as Aiden is thanking her, asking her to send the letters, and saying he doesn't feel alone. That tickles my mirror neurons every time, because I've felt my face doing exact reacting exactly as hers does trying to speak through those feelings and be there for someone. Maybe that's my bias, I've personally related to her quite a bit from start to finish. There's a lot of "making of" and "behind the scenes" stuff for VE, and in there the directors and staff were explicitly focused exhaustively on the expressivity of her face ("particularly the eyebrows) and how it changes over time, often circling back to make revisions to the more subtle. That really starts to show as she comes into her own more, and the ~30sec shot of just her in the cabin is one of my favorite sequences from the whole franchise, from flat affect to almost gritted teeth as he speaks to her and she reassures him.

Yuxin

One of the messages that the series tries to emphasize above all else (it may even be on par with the message of the meaning of love) is the message of "Do not glorify war". War has nothing good in it and they want to make that very clear. That and it also serves as an anchor point for Violet's character development.

T.J.Adams

Personally, this episode hit me as hard, if not harder, than episode 10. I was in the Army Infantry and had close friends I served with who've died both in and out of combat. I myself never got deployed and was never physically there for any of their deaths, but this episode makes me think a lot about the fact that, at some point, I was talking to them for the last time and didn't realize it. It makes me feel guilty for not having been there with them. Feeling overwhelmed emotionally by these past few episodes is completely valid; as you said, everyone has different experiences, copes in different ways, and is affected by things differently, and people should be able to respect that.

who is this guy

I remember the first time around, this episode actually got me a bit harder than episode 10, though this time around it changed. I do find your opinion on the show's hard tones pretty interesting though, as I can't really relate to it and I find that kind of cool in a way. I'm someone who actually struggles to experience these deeper emotions in my real life and I'm always really happy to be able to feel these things when I consume media of this type. I personally don't really get exhausted with the emotional punches because I'm just enjoying the moment and the energy of the scene. I'm not someone who has really experienced extreme grief or loss in my life and I often question how I would react to those moments. I'm scared that when these moments come, I won't actually care or even cry and that bothers me a lot. That's why I appreciate media like this that can allow me to feel for these characters and comfort me in a way, that I am capable of feeling this way and that I can care.

IsaacDoesStuff

It makes perfect sense to feel that way. It's okay.