Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 539673764.mp4

Downloads

Content

I have a long long long rant at the end of this recording discussing my overall feelings on Violet Evergarden. I hope you enjoy. I will tell you here, however, that I will be taking a little bit of a break before circling back to the 2 hour movie. I need to chew on my experience with VE. I both loved it and put up my walls around episode 7 and especially 10 and emotionally shut down on the show due to my own very personal experience with grief. It's not the show's fault as I believe the show is exemplary and goes into the trench of sadness, loss, grief, and love and I really commend how earnest and genuine that experience is/was. That said, it skimmed across the surface of my own lived reality and I think that pushed me away slightly simply because at times it was too real. I go into great and laborious detail as to why at the end of the episode. It's a monumental piece that is willing to "go there" and I really appreciate it for how mature and adult it is. I also just find myself emotionally drained and exhausted from watching this. So, it's a very interesting feeling - knowing the piece is so very important and yet finding myself resenting it.

Files

Comments

Daniel

Essay incoming. Broken up into responses to not monopolize the comments section. Sorry, but it's the end of the show so it's a lot. Thoughts Re: the movie and a bit of a break between now and watching it below if they help at all. Wanna throw this out before getting into anything else in this comment: If Marco or anyone else here is interested, the youtube channel Under The Scope did a 50m "Making of Violet Evergarden" video with a lot of information about the original light novel manuscript, the original folks involved, a lot of the processes for the production, the love and investment the creators had in the characters and stories, and all that. It was made before both of the two movies so no spoilers for those in it. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a1Fi5Njzgz4 Fun fact: the series director when talking about how much they put into even "extras" and subtle details, feels the show is best watched straight through, on a binge. That's a little too much for some, but that's how I tend to watch it and agree.

Daniel

Episode 11 is my favorite episode, but my favorite moment in the whole show is Violet's visit to Gilbert's mother. In terms of the show's arc for her, all her interpersonal progress has basically arrived in 11. Then 12-13 are narratively her confronting the other path she could have taken, and starting to live on in the world after doing all that work. With Gilbert's mother we get the acknowledgement that she loved and continues to love GIlbert, now with the knowledge of what that means (and his for her). Accompanied with my favorite OST track (partly because of this scene) "What It Means To Love". https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8e1n4fr8Viw The track that begins with oboe during travel or arrival throughout on the OST is "The Voice of my Heart" The track with the harp at the start is "Never Coming Back" The track with the muted piano and the dissonance you remarked on is "Intertwined Fates" The track with martial sounding brass and a lot of stripped back uncertainty is "The Stench of Fear and Hatred" So Violet Evergarden is my favorite piece of fiction, in any medium, that I've experienced in my 30-something long life so far. In terms of both meaning and enjoyment, which I think can be distinct but in this case overlap, without it being a "ha ha I'm having fun" enjoyment. So yes I'm disappointed that you didn't come away with that same experience, but because I'd like that for anybody that watches this, it's why I recommend it, but not I'm disappointed that you watched it and got an experience from it. At least you still appreciated aspects outside of subjective readiness for the experience--many stop at "I'm bored" or "manipulative" and denigrate it in its entirety. A lot of the negative responses to VE tend to fit pretty neatly into 2 or 3 buckets. One of those is folks that aren't receptive to what it's giving the audience emotionally. While it's disappointing the show may well have just never been the show for them and was never going to be the show for them. I'm not the audience for Downton Abbey, and never will be. A bad fit isn't something I'm going to feel like I need to be defensive about on my favorite fiction's behalf or take personally, especially when someone is acknowledging its virtues despite the bad fit. I get to learn something about someone, how they and others like them interact with certain experiences, and can maybe help make better recommendations. At minimum, you watching it may have gotten someone else new at some point to watch it that loved it or will.

Daniel

WITH REGARDS TO THE MOVIE: With all of that said, I will not spoil anything, but if you feel like you need to take a minute to not be worn down, some options for your consideration: "Violet Evergarden: The Movie" very very strongly affected theater audiences of huge fans in Japan and America when it came out. Like getting the hiccups from crying kind of strongly affected. It's very heavy to people ready to empathize with characters, relate their experience to their own, and in your particular case with people with certain subject sensitivities. Eternity and the Automemory Doll" is an extra story in addition, between the show and the other movie, and its generally much lighter like the earlier episodes of the series. If you were interested in more time with characters and the world, Eternity might be bit of reprieve from what you were withdrawing from in the show. Otherwise I don't think you would be remiss with a bit of a pause to get "right" between the show and the final movie. Though I'm right there with you on the holidays being some of the hardest time of the year, which might complicate being "ready".

Daniel

I personally think the movie is absolutely fantastic, and concludes perfectly, but yes it is more divisive than the opinions on the episodes.

MikeyNike

ngl it took me years to pick this show back up. My mind wasn't as distant to my past life situations so every episode was a mental punch in the face to the point where I started blanking out while watching it and realised I wasn't enjoying it. So I really see where you're coming from lol. Anyway it was a great watch. can't wait for the fate episodes

Ocean

As Daniel said in his well-written comment, I would suggest "Eternity and the Automemory Doll" as the movie of choice if you are considering watching a Violet Evergarden movie. It is comparatively more relaxed and tolerable of the two. In the case that you do decide to watch Eternity, I would look forward to your reaction to the music and the movie's artistic beauty.

Ocean

Hello Daniel, I highly appreciate your comment; it is wonderful to see your thoughts on equally my favorite piece of media. When it comes to the form of anime, Violet Evergarden has been at the top of my list since it aired in 2018. You raised several points that I agree with, and it is always a treat to discover new content about VE. I have not seen "Making of Violet Evergarden" before, so I thank you for bringing that up. It is clear how much intention and care were invested in making this series, but that video will offer more details that are definitely welcome. If you and anybody else would like links to informational content about Violet Evergarden, here they are: "A Veterans Reaction to Violet Evergarden" (1 Hour) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MkKO3Dx2sDc&t=372s A rather well-known one in the sphere, but it is still worth mentioning. This video interviews a United States military combatant, who discusses his initial reactions, personal stories, and how Violet Evergarden is so valuable. One of this video's main questions is: "What happens to the affected people after war?" I find this video extremely informative, and it adds another layer of appreciation to this series. There are movies like "Saving Private Ryan" or "All Quiet on the Western Front," which go against the romanticization of war. But VE uniquely portrays the trauma through how the ripples of grief flow through time, far after the treaties are signed. Therapist Reacts to Violet Evergarden (30-60 min per episode) https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLky2mhEqz2DyIJyxF3OVOBx_mCy8ur1qV&si=htvLRrenjTBxS24G A therapist's take on VE. Benoit Kim is great for informing you of introductory psychological terms while also being engaging and entertaining. I found his analysis to be insightful as well; he and this show in general have influenced my career goals! Now, I seek and treasure forms of media that wrench the soul to the point you feel sensations that you never felt so deeply before. Pieces like Violet Evergarden act like a catalyst for me to contemplate deeply about... life. When I watched this show, it brought forth so many topics that I wanted to pause, sit, think, and maybe even write about. It hurts so much, but it feels so good at the same time. It really is a weird feeling, like putting on glasses while the frames are burning hot. In addition, what makes VE so attractive to me is that it is deep, dark, disturbing, and introspective, yet in a stunning way. This piece of art contrasts with many other pieces of media of the like, whether that is "All Quiet on the Western Front," "Neon Genesis Evangelion," or "Land of the Lustrous." All of which are phenomenal, but can be psychologically horrific and existential at times. Violet Evergarden does something different that is hard to describe. As a person in their early adulthood (~18-20), I am fortunate enough not to have experienced any major losses in my life, and I savor these precious moments deeply. The people I'm with, love, care for, annoy, tease, etc etc, every day won't be there someday. That is a fact. Many pieces of media, but especially VE (episodes 7 and 10 specifically), helped me realize this at a young age. I was lucky not to experience such pain, so I had sufficient emotional support to watch VE. I cried, a lot, and still cry with every rewatch, but the pain I felt was through a window, not by relation. This encouraged me to develop empathy, allowing me to recognize others' pain and strive to support them effectively. This is where Marco's thoughts on Violet Evergarden come to play. He has undoubtedly felt more pain than I. Although I can try to understand and sympathize, I'll never really know what it feels like. People who dislike this show, like you mentioned, call it "manipulative" or "boring." Marco shows valid reasons and personal anecdotes as to why he dislikes it while appreciating what it stands for. I value his insight because it reminds me that pain (and how we process it) changes how we connect with stories. Even though VE touched me deeply, it did so through empathy and imagination rather than lived experience. For Marco, he KNOWS, while I can only try to understand. It's a fine but significant difference. He has wounds in some places that I might not have. Our different reactions don't make either of us right or wrong, but rather they show how art connects to us depending on where we're at in our lives. And ultimately, that's what I value most: how the stories of Violet Evergarden create bridges between people who have felt pain and those who are trying to understand it. To practice empathy, to recognize others' pain, respect it, and care more deeply because of it. Ah, I've written more than I thought, so I will not discuss other topics like the music (My favorite is "The Love That Binds Us"). Thank you, Daniel and Marco, for providing the content that prompted me to respond!

who is this guy

I fully understand your reasoning for having problems with the show and I respect that. I think you described your position very clearly and earnestly. I do love this show but it's definitely not my favorite. In my case, I just value more than just characters and emotional connection, I also highly value an interesting world to go with those characters, it's a little hard to explain. I guess I would say I enjoy deeper plots, whereas this feels solely like a character journey that would be able to exist within a rich world. Also I recommend checking out Steins;Gate as a show that has genuinely impacted my life (plus the music is quite good). TL;DR: Great show, I respect your stance on it and I also agree that it's not a favorite, though for different reasons.