Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

hey gang, I have a bit of a personal/moral question I wanted to impose on you all. So bare with me as I mentally navigate this one. I know there is a culture of reaction content to movies, anime, etc on channels and I know the fair use/copyright situation with this is certainly a bit hairy. That said, I suppose I have been feeling a desire to provide non-patrons with reasons to join to watch full episodes or simply wanting to provide people something free since patreon isn't a viable option for everyone when it comes to anime. Lately, though, I've been feeling like maybe uploading episode reaction content to the weebball channel is maybe irresponsible and/or inappropriate. I know there are plenty of channels that do it. But I was wondering your perspective on the matter. Maybe we just hyper chop the episodes down so it's not just the like full episode? Maybe I don't do them anymore and stick to music reactions which feel morally "better". Is morality even a thought? Just curious what you thought about it.obviously - it's two fold. Get people to enjoy content with a creator they like and/or get them to join the patreon. Hope you don't mind me being candid about this - but I wanted to discuss it with people who are supporting financially since I assume you have a vested interest!

Comments

IAmABacon

Im not sure how else you'd promote your patreon without posting something to youtube. I only joined your patreon because youtube randomly recommended your frieren reaction. Otherwise, id never have known you react to anime! I definitely think you should post, and in whatever format you are comfortable with. The people who wont sign up to patreon will not do so whether or not you post to youtube, but the ones who will will have a higher chance if there's more chances to find out about it.

Nyohoho

I know many YouTubers now who barely do full reactions on Youtube, if it's on youtube, it's so cropped down, hidden, low volume, flipped, well I'm sure you've seen those, and tbf, it's not really enjoyable. And if they show the full episode, they only show like 10 mins of the 25 mind episode, it is hard to satisfy everyone. Obviously not everyone will want to join a patreon to watch anime reactions or have the financial capacity. I feel like u could do a very cropped down version. Like ep 1-3 of an anime for one video, showing only the big moments or highlight reel and telling viewers if they want full reactions, come to the patreon. I mean that's how most YouTubers do it. It's how it's been done for a while now. And you can continue the music reactions on the channel normally

Nyohoho

I will say i didn't really get the morality/inappropriate/irresponsible part

Verilain

One of the reasons I love your music reactions is that you go through and analyze a whole piece and not just the cool moment where the drop is. That doesn't translate to anime though. I also understand that in a 23 minute anime episode there's not much to say during a lull. If you were someone to follow because of your knowledge in the field of animation, maybe a full episode run would be warranted because you could point out techniques or cool bits and bobs like you do with the music. So instead, I think a chopped down version for YouTube is warranted with Patreon getting an uncut version? But also one of the reasons I'm here on Patreon is that you were going to be reacting to anime and I wanted to hear your takes on certain series or songs from anime.

Michael

I understand it's a difficult decision to make, mainly because I don't want you to do something that leaves you morally conflicted or with a bad feeling about what you're doing, so I'll talk about my experience this month since I decided to subscribe to your Patreon. The main reason for my subscription was to watch your reactions to my all-time favorite anime, "Gurren Lagann," and I can say I don't regret it. Your reactions and analyses were truly unique and gave me a completely different perspective on something I've been following for years. In my opinion, I would love to continue seeing your reactions to anime like Edgerunners, which you're currently watching, or other anime that I also really like (Cowboy Bebop, for example). In any case, I would suggest you analyze the opinions of the other subscribers and make the decision that makes you most comfortable with your content.

Glyphica

I feel like most "appropriate/morally correct" way to do it would be maybe uploading your thoughts on shows once you have completed them to youtube. Like a sort of recap on your thoughts of a show, maybe not as much of a review but sort of like sometimes at the end of a last episode you talk a lot about your thoughts on it. You could also chop it down to a lot of your analysis of the show, the music, etc. Whether that would be per episode or per series could depend on how much of it there is. I feel like the 2 above ideas would give people a reason to come to patreon to join the journey and see more expanded thoughts/analysis. This is coming from someone who generally isnt a big fan of people uploading full reactions to youtube though, so other people may have a different perspective. Analysis of specific scenes and music that goes with them is a different story though.

Cipper12

I'd say there's really nothing wrong with that. People on Youtube get to enjoy your reaction to the important bits and what you have opinion about and people who can afford Patreon can just pay for that bonus full reaction (watching you being so into Gundam Witch from Mercury falling silent to about 70% of the episode has been super fun ngl). Nothing unethical about people who can afford to support you supporting you. Obviously it's annoying watching reaction on YouTube that's chopped to hell, anti-copyright filtered, volume lowered but that's just how things are. Unlike other comments here, I'm on Patreon cuz I saw your Witch From Mercury ost reaction and you mentioned how much you enjoyed it and that the reaction are on Patreon. It was the first time I saw MarcoWeebBall but I watched enough of your main channel content to know that I would not regret paying for this for a while.

Cosmo Reverb

I'd say go for whatever doesn't put your main channel in danger. Whether that's hyper-edited videos, just your thoughts on a series, or whatever.

TyrantMantis

It's not entirely clear to me from the post if this is a dilemma of feeling as though providing some of your Patreon content on YouTube is in some way cheating your Patreon members, or a question of whether posting reaction content containing full episodes is potentially amoral due to bordering on piracy. In either case, I don't really think there's a problem. If it's the former, you absolutely have a right to 'advertise' the content you're providing and providing examples of the full content is a great way to do that. For my part, I wouldn't be a Patreon member if not for the Frieren reaction being on YouTube. I really don't think it's irresponsible/inappropriate in any way. If it's the latter, the reality is that anime is trivially easy to acquire through less-than-legal means. Absolutely nobody anywhere on the planet is using reaction content on YouTube as a means to illegally watch anime. It's not worth thinking about as a moral question.