Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Any questions for what could very well be our last mailbag episode before the writ drop? Let us know!

Comments

NJ

Has there ever been a situation when there was no bump in polling results for a party after their new leader became prime minister (after either an election or previous leader's resignation)?

Jack

It's obvious CBC is in the pocket of The Numbers podcast! Is there any polling on the messaging of either party? Are there numbers on how "Axe The Tax" is hitting these days? What about Carney's rhetoric about Canada being able to stand alone ("Masters In Our Own Home," etc.)? On 338Canada, why do some provincial NDPs have a different shade of orange than the others?

Philippe Tremblay

Hello from Barrie Ontario! I asked this exact question about a month ago and thought it would be interesting to see your answers now: Based on vibes and your gut, what would you price the odds of these events happening? I have also included your previous numbers for comparison! LPC majority: <1% LPC minority: 10% CPC majority:80% CPC minority: 20% NDP losing party status: 49% BQ getting under 29% in QC: 75%

Philippe Tremblay

Thoughts on the EKOS poll putting the liberals at 49.5% and what would that look like on the map?

Ian Gunn

How close are the polls matching Turner's and Campbell's lead up to the writ being dropped? Have there been examples where a new leader is leading prior to the writ being called and they ended up winning? If so, do we know what happened between the different instances? (and saying campaigns matter is true, but anything else :))

Expat Edmontonian

The conventional wisdom is that campaigns matter—a lot. Could 2025 be different, in that external events simply overwhelm whatever happens on the trail and largely determine how persuadable voters cast their ballots?

Logan Stitt

With the polls showing the liberals leading in the 905 and the GTA by significant margins with a massive realignment of the electorate taking place what are the chancing the CPC are able to make any gains the area.

Logan Stitt

With the By election result in Terrebonne Quebec showing a decisive win for the PQ and the CAQ losing a large proportion of their vote, do you think this race is a reflection of the province only at a provincial level and a rejection of the CAQ or a rise in separatism at large?

Marin Anguish

So something which was notable the Liberals surging back to contention is that it was driven in large part by strong support with older voters in contrast to 2015 when it was strong support with young voters (who turned out at an unusual rate) that propelled them to power. I know a lot of recent polls have the Liberals gaining with young voters too, but assuming for the sake of argument that this doesn't hold till election day or that is noise or whatever, is there any historical precedent for a Government's electoral coalition undergoing such a wholesale reversal? If not, might that not be one of the more noteworthy aspects of the Liberal comeback?

Adam Keith

With the Conservative Party likely feeling the need to pull back from the right wing populism that Poilievre has pushed during his leadership do you think there is any space for a People’s Party resurgence?

Patrick Muir

I noticed Pierre's popularity in his own riding has dropped a bit since Trudeau's resignation. Should the LPC boot Mr. Fanjoy and run a "star candidate" in Carleton?

ChadGPT

After two consecutive minority governments, and the unpredictable nature of the US political situation, is there any data supporting the notion that Canadians want stability at the federal govt and will more likely vote strategically to ensure we have a majority government? Could this account for the bump we see with the LPC (now potentially perceived as better suited to handle the current political climate with Mr Carney as the leader)? Would that mean support could be very fluid between the two main parties and damaging for the NDP/Bloc?

Isaac Levy

Of Carney's cabinet, which ministers are the most vulnerable going into this election? Really enjoying the podcast and both of your thoughtful and engaging analysis.

Hudson Gaudreault

Hi Éric and Philippe, Given the past few months, I think it is probably an understatement to say the numbers can move rather fast in the current climate. Considering this, do you you guys think that we are in for a potentially volatile campaign period? If so, what are your best tips for interpreting the data through all the noise and volatility?

Berronar

Eric and Phillipe. How do your models account for varying levels of participation? How would the results change if there is high participation? Everything we see in the data hints to high engagement in the population. Last election, turnout was 62.5%(election canada website), what if we reach 75% or higher?

The Numbers / Les chiffres

Hi there — my model (Eric) does not take into account turnout. It is based entirely on vote share rather than the number of votes.