Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Send us your questions for tomorrow's members-only episode of The Numbers. Thanks!

Comments

Adam Keith

Who do you think is more likely to retain their seat: Jagmeet Singh or Elizabeth May?

Scott Gillard

Why do you feel the polls are providing an accurate snapshot of what things look like right now? Specifically, what is it about the aggregation of the volume of polls, the pollsters themselves, and your understanding if the science that gives you confidence and the read? (The new inclination by some conservatives to suggest the polls are inaccurate or untrustworthy is terrifying to me)

Michael Makhoul

Hey, big fan of the show and podcast! Quick question: On Thursday’s episode, you alluded to a possible Kamala vs. Trump election. But given the current polling gap, wouldn’t a Conservative victory—if the election were held today—look more like a Trump vs. Hillary situation? Can you explain why that’s unlikely? Is it because Canada typically has three major national parties and at least one strong provincial party, unlike the U.S. two-party system? Does that make a Trump-Hillary-style dynamic less likely here?

Tim

How low in the polls do the PPC need to get before pollsters drop them as a reference point/option?

Gary Adduono

Have we ever seen the polls turn around at the this point in an election? If we loose the PPC, does it all help the conservatives?

Justin Kim

Despite the low polling numbers for the NDP, do you think they can plausibly flip any seats they didn't win in 2021? I'm thinking of ridings with well-known local candidates such as Ruth Ellen Brosseau in Berthier-Maskinongé, or Joel Harden in Ottawa Centre. Are there any other such ridings the NDP could potentially pick up?

Shanti Fernando

I know you speak to each other about polls but are you also friends with the pollsters that you aggregate? Do you have a chance to ask them about their methodologies or challenges that they face?

Kari Bronaugh

I am curious about the territories - are any pollsters including them? And I notice on the CBC poll tracker the territories aren’t mentioned. Too small to make a difference? Just curious because they are on 338.

ChadGPT

(1) Do the numbers outside Ontario, Quebec and British-Columbia matter for projecting the election results at this point? (2) how many days after the debate would you expect to measure the difference it might make in the course of the election? (3) Could Carney lose his chances of a majority with just the French debate?

Tony Prudori

Laure Paquette here, despite the logo which is my husband's. I am primarily concerned with people who do not show up in polling but do show up to vote. I realize this is a Trumpy question, but I've been wondering about them. Also Eric said Tories are underestimated in polls by about 2.5% and I'd like to know why he thinks that. Otherwise, keep taking those vitamins and I hope you can catch up on your sleep this weekend, because debate week will be tough!

Jeni A

Bit of a weird one, but in your experience, do pollsters vote (as individuals, in their own ridings)? Or do they feel that they can’t or shouldn’t, to maintain impartiality? (for the record, I hope they do — everyone who can, should — but curious about how most pollsters handle this)

sanderbling

I have never once been polled by any political polling firm. How do Canadian polling companies find or choose the people that they poll? Is it possible that certain groups of people or demographics are completely missed by polling firms?

Jordan

I’m curious your thoughts on my riding of Peterborough. It’s long been a bellwether riding until the last election when it went to the conservatives. I’d imagine if the conservatives win they’ll probably hold it, but could you see it staying blue even with the liberals rise over the past few months? It feels like there’s a lot of animosity towards the current MP as well but I can’t tell if that’s just the people I’m talking to or if it’s a wider view throughout the riding

ChadGPT

(4) would a weaker BQ help, hurt or have no effect for the PQ in Quebec’s next election in 2026?

Craig Sweetnam

Dear Numbers Team, As a long-time amateur pollster and a fan of 338Canada.com, I apologize for becoming a Patreon member only recently. While I don’t gamble, I understand that seasoned gamblers often advise against betting on their home team due to personal biases. However, I would be willing to wager that Scott Reid in Lanark-Carleton will lose his seat in the next election, despite your classification of it as a likely Conservative seat. I recognize that Conservatives have represented this area since Confederation, but several converging factors make me believe this riding could challenge your model. I have three main reasons for my belief. First, the candidate; second, the demographic growth within the riding; and third, the organization of the relative parties. Typically, incumbents receive a significant advantage, but I’m not convinced this holds true in this case. It has been years since Scott has effectively communicated with his constituents. Many of my Conservative friends and I have found his office to be lacking in the essential services that constituent offices should provide. Having held his position for so long, many believe a change is needed. In an election year where change is a significant rallying cry, an MP like Scott, who has been in office for an extended period, will struggle to present himself as an agent of change. Additionally, the trucker convoy has further complicated Scott’s position. While he may have solidified support among the Conservative base, his handling of the convoy alienated many constituents who opposed it. Next, let’s discuss the demographics of the riding. Although the riding of Lanark–Carleton is geographically large—one of the largest in Southern Ontario— most voters live in three fast growing towns: Smiths Falls, Carleton Place, and Perth. The first two are fast‑growing bedroom communities; the third is evolving into an artsy, retirement hub. I believe the demographics are shifting heavily in favor of the Liberals. Liberals are winning the sign war in all three urban areas —a proxy for local enthusiasm and organization. Mid‑campaign, that’s usually a red flag for the incumbent’s ground game. Consider the most recent provincial election, where Bonnie Crombie was far less effective at attracting voters than Mark Carney will be. Moreover, the polls point to the NDP and Green Party garnering a smaller percentage of the vote federally than provincially. While provincial dynamics differ, I believe the stronger federal Liberal leadership under Mark Carney, compared to Crombie’s provincial performance, suggests higher potential for consolidation of ABC votes in this federal race. And greater turnout for the liberals. The central question is: what kind of consolidation around the liberal as the ABC candidate can we expect from the other non-conservative voters? Given that we have a more popular leader in Carney and less popular secondary leaders in the NDP and Green Party? The NDP candidate was only appointed shortly before the deadline, and I’ve noticed only a few NDP lawn signs without any candidate name and only on a few major intersections where the other two candidates have bigger signs. All of this leads me to believe that the polls indicating a two-person race are accurate. While I agree that this historically has been a more Conservative riding compared to Pierre Poilievre's riding next door, I have lived, owned a business, and been active in both areas for most of my life. I think your percentages could be off this election, and there's a strong possibility that the Liberals will perform better in Lanark-Carleton than they will in Carleton. My only uncertainty stems from Poilievre's personal unlikability numbers, which you would expect to be most impactful in his own riding. However, with new demographics entering the riding and the current climate favoring change, I believe that if voter turnout is strong, which I anticipate it will be, this election could result in a very close race that may well go to the Liberals. At this moment, I would classify this riding as leaning Liberal. Door‑knocking reactions mirror those of winning campaigns. I have placed signs in locations that have displayed conservative signs in the last three elections. I’ve even met lifelong Conservatives like myself now canvassing for Liberals. Anti‑Trudeau sentiment has faded when the leader on the ballot is Carney, not Justin, for all but the most die-hard Conservative. Many fear Poilievre’s rhetoric and Trump’s influence and see Carney as the steady choice. While Pierre Poilievre's rallies draw large, vocal crowds, door-to-door interactions reveal a different dynamic. Though some express strong anti-Trudeau sentiments, most recognize he is not on the ballot. The previous personal attacks against Trudeau, often fueled by misinformation, seem less impactful now. While an enthusiasm gap exists, Canada's accessible voting system—including advanced polls—means basic motivation is often sufficient for turnout. Ultimately, highly enthusiastic voters still cast only one vote, just like those who vote with less fervor. I believe in the polls because many people are genuinely fearful of Poilievre and Trump and want nothing to do with them. They feel that Carney is the best candidate for this position, and I think Carney's popularity has a real chance of significantly influencing this particular riding. Do you think I’m crazy for believing that the changing demographics of the riding, the relative popularity of the leaders, and the stronger local organization of the Liberals compared to the Conservatives could result in this historically Conservative riding flipping to Liberal this time? Part of me hesitated to send this email because I didn’t want to alert the National Conservative Party about how poorly this local campaign is being managed. However, with only a couple of weeks left, I doubt they could turn things around even if they wanted to try. My biggest concern is apathy, which may affect both sides. I’ve heard people say, “You could run a monkey as a Conservative in this riding, and they would win.” That sentiment tends to suppress voter turnout. The question is, which side will it affect more? Given the better organization the Liberals seem to have this election, I don’t think it’s far-fetched to believe this riding could change hands. Keep up the great work. I hope I’ve presented a case that challenges your model slightly. I still have faith in the polls, in you, and in your model, as it is robust enough to withstand minor fluctuations in one or two ridings.

Dan McElroy

Any thoughts on The Economist’s election predictor? Or commentary / explanation of its methodology v the more standard “if the election were held today” model? In Economist model 7% chance of Tory majority and 6% chance of Tory plurality. Seems counterintuitive they’d have a (slightly) better chance of majority v plurality.

Michael Smith

Can you explain a little about how you judge individual ridings? One dismissive criticism I heard this week after the "don't believe the polls", is that those predictions are based on the last election. You guys are so fun to watch. You're friendship comes across so strongly.

Devo Seamus

How do you treat the polls that are updated daily - do you only include the latest in the model, some kind of average or something else?

Vivian Unger

I agree. They have a great chemistry and a good time together, and that's an important part of their appeal.

Rod

Is there such a thing as "under-polling?" I'm thinking of NDP incumbent seats. An orange dot in a sea of blue. Suppose a regional poll in Northern Alberta included twenty seats, so that only 5% of the poll respondents lived in the NDP-held seat. Would they poll enough NDP respondents in this district to have any impact, greater than the margin of error, in the regional poll? How do pollsters handle this when using the regional poll to project individual ridings?

Alexandre Lessard

If Bloc Quebecois looses half of his seats at the end of the month. Could it have a negative impact on sovereignty movement and hurt PQ in the next Quebec provincial election and give a boost to the PLQ.

Jack

Which single province should the NDP dump all their resources into? The federal New Democrats could reinvent themselves as a regionalist party - but which region? Bloc BC is the obvious choice - but maybe the numbers are pointing them elsewhere?

Gabriel

Why pollster have difficulty to poll rural Alberta and Saskatchewan

camperjr

I had a debate with a friend that if Erin O'Toole was still leader of the Con's, he would be winning massively. Thoughts?

Alex Woersching

338 is giving the Liberals (John Aldag) 78% probability of winning Langley Township--Fraser Heights, 49% vs. 43% for CPC. Does that seem fair considering the CPC candidate, Tako van Popta, is a two-term incumbent for part of the new district and some voters may not like that Aldag left the Liberals last year and ran with BC NDP in provincial elections last year. Also, Aldag is a replacement candidate after the original candidate dropped out for health reasons. Is there any evidence for a replacement candidate penalty?

Benjamin Goetz

The Conservatives, Liberals, and NDP all failed to get a full slate of candidates. The PPC and Greens also fell way short. Can you talk a little bit about this? First of all, how many ridings could there be an impact on the results with there not being PPC/Green candidates on the ballot? Secondly, The Liberals not having a candidate in Ponoka-Didsbury, AB won't make a difference in a very safe Conservative riding, but how do you think things will play out in Quebec Centre (with no Conservative candidate), and South Shore-St. Margaret's (with no NDP candidate)? Will the lack of a Conservative candidate in Quebec Centre mean a lot of that vote goes to the Bloc Quebecois and makes the race more interesting? Or does some of it go to the PPC? In South Shore-St. Margaret's, how do you think the lack of an NDP candidate will impact the race?

Larissa K

With the debates coming up this week, and with it being the first campaign for both front runners, one of which a new politician, I’m curious what impact the debates will have. I know it is a slightly different set-up but what was their impact in the past?

Hudson Gaudreault

Hi Éric and Philippe, I thought of this question recently (specifically when watching the Wisconsin SC race a few weeks ago) and was wondering if either of you knew the answer. Do you know of anybody in Canada who has tried to make a NYT Needle/Nate Cohn style live election night model like in the States? Although there would definitely be some key differences, I feel like the general idea of using the pre-election models as a prior and then updating the projections as we get results on election night could be adapted to work up here. What do you guys think of this in theory? Do you see any limitations or reasons that something like this wouldn't work up here?

The Numbers / Les chiffres

Hi Craig — thanks for sharing your observations! You bring up lots of things that we can't take into account in our models. It's certainly possible that we could see a surprise in that riding, but there's nothing in the data that we work with that would suggest it is likely to flip. I note that Reid won virtually all the polls in Perth, Carleton Place and Smith Falls in 2021, so for him to lose that riding he'd need those voters to flip. We'll find out soon enough!

The Numbers / Les chiffres

Hi Kari — pollsters include the territories, but the samples are so small (sometimes 2-4 respondents) that they aren't reported separately and wouldn't be useful anyway. So, the Poll Tracker doesn't present any numbers for the territories as it would be just conjecture. Both of our models make projections for the territories, though, and those projections are presented on 338 and at The Writ (for subscribers).

James Sayegh

It seems Nanos is using his polls, which clearly show the same results of every other poll and a LPC majority, as click bait and cherry picking numbers to try and spin a narrative of a minority and tightening race . Isn’t stuff like that concerning?

True North, Strong, and Liberal as Hell

Given that Mark Carney is a new leader with high name recognition but little political baggage, how might that 'blank slate' status affect late deciders and swing ridings compared to more polarizing figures like Poilievre? Can your models capture that kind of momentum shift, or is it too unpredictable? Jim Elliott

Barb Pearce

In what election, starting the day it was called, saw the greatest slide in numbers for the front runner? Conversely, what party saw the greatest gain in numbers during the election period?

Cat Aulakh

To what extent do you factor in who actually responds to polls demographically speaking? One would think this leaves out many age groups and favours others. I feel this needs explaining :)