Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Good morning everyone! We'll be back this week on Thursday with a regular episode of The Numbers, which will include a mailbag segment for Patreon members.

So, send us your questions for the mailbag! Leave them either as a comment on Patreon or on the Discord. Thanks!

Comments

Scott Morrier

Many people online are using the recent EKOS numbers showing a wide Liberal lead, a Conservative drop and an NDP surge to make all sorts of claims, despite EKOS standing alone as an outlier from the polling consensus. They're claiming that EKOS catches momentum early, but polls such as this are meant to measure current intent, not future trajectory. I'm wondering how wise this approach is, as if a snapshot misses current reality, being 'right on direction' in hindsight shouldn't then make the poll accurate. At what point do we stop calling a solo outlier an 'early signal' and start calling it a missed call?

Mike Bacon

With the Liberals in power now for over 11 years, we would normally start to see some voter fatigue and a growing desire for change. But it seems to me that Mark Carney has done what few other new leaders of an incumbent party have done. He's convinced the country that he is a fresh start and reset the clock on the Liberal mandate. The only other time I can think of in history where this has happened was when Pierre Trudeau succeeded Lester B. Pearson and breathed new life into the Liberals. How many other leaders have taken over an incumbent party to win the following election? It seems far more common to have the John Turner / Kim Campbell scenario where the new leader is dragged down by the baggage of a stale government. Maybe this is a good question for Eric's quiz.

Clark Kernaghan

In the western provinces there is a huge overlap in provincial NDP and federal Liberal voters, with each one often serving as the anti-conservative option. Many political observers have pointed out that the provincial New Democratic Parties in the West are more moderate than their federal counterparts. But I’m curious how voters view things. If voters were asked to place their leaders on a political spectrum, would people put Kinew/Eby to the left of Carney, or are they all viewed as occupying the same space? And do we even have any data on this?

Donald Clancy

Why is it that as donation money is a good predictor of leadership outcomes, donation money doesn’t seem to determine election outcomes as much?

Scott Morrier

This is also an interesting question when expanded to include some Progressive Conservative parties as well. Many Houston/Carney and Ford/Carney voters

Luis

With recent polling showing that support for the Liberals is slightly dipping and the NDP numbers are slightly improving, could the future QC byelections in Rosemont and Laurier be more competitive between the NDP and the Liberals? Specially seeing that those are more progressive ridings and Avi Lewis mentioning (anecdotally) that there is “buyer’s remorse” in QC. Any news on potential liberal candidates in those ridings?

NJ

Frank Graves, founder and president of EKOS, recently spoke about his concern that online panels are not reliable any more because they are getting more and more AI bots and fewer and fewer real people in them. What are your thoughts on that?

ChadGPT

Any thoughts on Count Binface?

Skaana 🫍 One Ocean 🇨🇦 Mark Leiren-Young

I just switched from Substack to Patreon because I was curious about the mailbag episodes and had a couple of questions for you. Apologies if you've answered this before and, if you have, please just steer me to the link or episode because I haven't heard or spotted it. I'm curious about how you address "inefficient votes" in your projections. I believe Avi Lewis will dramatically raise the NDP's overall vote count in the next election and the NDP will get a lot more of their deposits back. I'm certain Emily Lowan will do the same for the Greens in BC. I'm not sold Lewis can hold the five seats the NDP currently has, never mind pick up new ones. 'though, hey, things can change in three years... And I wouldn't bet on the Greens holding the two BC seats they have and don't see a winnable seat for Lowan unless her Island MLA steps aside for her. But do you look at, say 15% and think... that has to = x # of seats?