Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Good morning everyone!

We don't think we'll be lacking things to discuss in tomorrow's episode! But we're going to include an extended mailbag in the members' version, so leave us any questions you'd like us to answer.

Thanks!

Comments

Adam Keith

The situation in Quebec is wild. A small but potentially decisive group of voters seem to be moving from both the PLQ and PQ to the CAQ. Who are these voters and where are they concentrated? Who are the voters most likely to swing between these three parties going forward?

Christopher Green

How many more by-elections do you think the Conservatives have to lose before caucus rumblings about Pierre Poilièvre's leadership become audible? Kory Teneycke suggested on CTV Monday evening that the upcoming Brantford by-election will be the tipping point.

Nick Ryall

I think in your live stream you alluded to the idea that the conservatives losing so badly in Chicoutimi—Le Fjord had to do with the voters simply liking Richard Martel, specifically. Is that common in Canada to vote based on person rather than party? It seems that most voters in my area vote based on their party but probably couldn't name the most recent representative of the riding...

atnqty

Any alternative ways to support that avoids american platform (patreon/substack/youtube etc.)?

Tim

Apropos of the recent by-elections, what are your thoughts on the difference in how by-elections are called in Canada vs the UK? Given that we inherited our parliamentary tradition from them. For background, in their setup the chief whip of the party of the vacant seat introduces a motion and, upon passage, the speaker then initiates the writ, whereas in our system it is entirely up to the PM's discretion, as long as it's called within 180 days

Adam Berkan

I live in Calgary-Shaw, and I've seen almost no analysis of the upcoming provincial by-election. Have there been any polls? Do you have any projection of how it will go?

Izabelle Bonney-Jones

In the upcoming Ontario by-elections in Hamilton East—Stoney Creek, Scarborough Southwest and York—Simcoe how make or break do you think they are for the different parties. Can the ONDP survive them if they can't win anything especially if OLP do well instead and vice versa. Ford losing York-Simcoe would be really bad but do the PCs have anything to prove in the Hamilton or Scarborough by-elections?

ChadGPT

In every Quebec provincial election, the state of French language versus English language in Montreal is brought up on the campaign trail. It’s usually not brought up within the island of Montreal, but rather other regions of the province as a motivator. I’m assuming this is done because the political parties know it moves the needle but what’s the data that supports this? I know it’s typical urban versus suburban versus rural divide but it always seems to hear that the Montreal portion doesn’t have a voice. We’re just presented to the rest of the province as where French comes to die.

ChadGPT

Sorry, I’m having trouble editing my comment - “versus rural divide but it always seems to be discussed outside of Montreal as to what the solutions are and we don’t get a voice in the debate”

Tyler Spence

Thoughts about the Abbotsford-Mission by-election in BC? What are the chances Kerry-Lynne Findlay loses this riding given the turmoil in the CPBC, the introduction of Centre BC, and non-KLF fans not feeling motivated to vote

NJ

Question for Éric the Historian: have by-elections ever resulted in majority shifting from one party to another in Canadian history (federally or provincially/territorially)?

Rob A

This may be outside the kind of questions you want to talk about, but I wonder why conservative parties in so many western countries -including both federally and provincially in Canada - seem to focus on the harder-right side of their support. Why are truly 'centre right' parties increasingly rare? Ultimately, it seems bad for democracy if centrist voters feel they have less choice at the ballot box.

Luis

So many questions after the 3 byelections: (1) Seeing that the “Nate bump” in Beaches East-York ended up being around 10 points, could we see something similar happen in Laurier St Marie (specially after Guilbeaut’s very public departure) and would that make it a competitive riding with the NDP? Or are we overstating this whole prior MP bump? 2) seeing such disparity between results for the NDP in North Vancouver and in Beaches, could the results also be attributed to “candidate quality”, in that Mr. Tanveer was not as strong of a campaigner as Mr. Caley? Or was Ms. Devine a particularly good campaigner? Should the Liberals rely more on open nominations to get a stronger candidate instead of appointing them? Merci beaucoup!

Skaana 🫍 One Ocean 🇨🇦 Mark Leiren-Young

With seat projections, how do you deal with cases where the overall percentages look decent, but those percentages are spread thin? I'd be surprised if the NDP numbers don't go up considerably under Avi Lewis, but I'm not sold that those numbers translate into seats. Do you go... hey... 15% of the vote has to = more seats or is there more data to pull from? I see the same scenario for the BC Greens where Emily Lowan may score far better overall numbers than past Green leaders and, at best, hold the two incumbent seats. And if I can get away with a second question... 'though it kinda ties into this one as a specific example... you've often projected Mike Morrice as a second Green seat, but he's never actually won an election when there was a Liberal candidate in the race. So is that based on local polling or?

Donald Clancy

Thank you for the bielection broadcast. You mentioned during the broadcast that your estimate was out quite a bit in the Quebec riding. Any idea what caused you be out there?