Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi everyone, we're recording our next episode of The Numbers tomorrow (instead of Thursday), so if you have any questions for the members-only portion of the episode, please send them along! Leave them on Patreon or on the Discord. Thanks!

Comments

atnqty

Is there or will there be options to support without going through american platforms (patreon/substack/youtube)

Nick Ryall

What percentage of federal ridings elect their MP based on the actual candidate rather than based on the party?

Rod

When you run simulations, rather than simply average poll numbers, what additional information is revealed?

Dónal Gill

In the QC election, who for you are some of the (potential) star candidates with impactful name value that could push their vote share above that of a generic party candidate?

Scott Morrier

I apologize for my last question a few weeks ago about EKOS, I didn't mean to piss off Philippe! 😂 Laurier-Sainte Marie was held by the NDP until 2019, when Steven Guilbeault flipped the riding with a significant margin. Before the 2025 election broke the trend, the margin of victory for the Liberals decreased after 2019, with the margin being ~5 points in 2021 (37.96 vs 32.86). If the NDP put the same resources into Laurier that they did Beaches, what are your thoughts on the NDP's chances of flipping this seat? Or are those resources better spent in Rosemont-La Petite-Patrie, and we should expect an environment closer to 2025? Follow up question: Do you both think that the NDP should try to win both Rosemont and Laurier, or do you think trying to do could result in losing both?

Marc Parsons

This sort of aligns with Rod's question above, but I'm wondering if you could speak a bit more about the Vote Projection versus Seat Leading part of your projections, Eric? More generally, for both of you, what is the role of statistical models (that is, those that adjust for certain factors such as demographics or past polling errors like in the Vote Projection part of Eric's projection) in electoral projections? I'm a postdoctoral researcher in statistics and meta-analysis, so this type of modelling really interest me. Thanks!

Rob A

More a comment than a question, but maybe something to discuss. One of Carney's great advantages, besides his impressive skill set and rolodex, is that he has no record as 'a politician'. Even though he is now a political leader, Canadians still see him more as a skilled manager with a personal desire to put the country on the best path. Being 'untainted' by any political labels or history is an incredible advantage, particularly at this time of crisis. Maybe this even creates an opportunity for politicians in general to recast how they present themselves - as thoughtful people with clear ideas and preferences on policy, rather than primarily as party leaders - and for voters to see politics and policy in a more mature, less partisan-driven, light. That would be an incredible gift to the country.

ChadGPT

After the Quebec provincial debates this week - which three ridings would you want to check first to see if the needle moved? Also, given how tight the polls - what would be your methodology preference to get the most accurate results if possible

ChadGPT

For the Quebec election - the BQ leader and prime minister have been quiet (or distracted?) when it comes to the prospects of the PQ winning. Is this strategy or just coincidence

Scott Brown

What can be read in the tea leaves from the Calgary-Shaw by-election? Can any inferences be made from this regarding the likely outcome of the upcoming referendum? Should Danielle Smith be concerned about next year's general election? Does this have any indicative value regarding federal politics? I know this is just a single data point, but a 40% voter turnout points to a fairly solid data point.

Lynne Kyba

Hey Eric and Phillip. I was so happy to see the Alberta Separatist UCP lose the Calgary Shaw by election yesterday. Who was the polling company and why did they get the numbers so wrong in that by election? Love your show Lynne Kyba. (A Calgary Lougheed progressive conservative )

Jack Smith

As an Ontario resident currently vacationing in Quebec, I'm fascinated by the election dynamics. One thing I'm noticing is a surprisingly low correlation between posters for a given party, and their reasonable likelihood of winning that riding (PQ posters all over downtown Montreal, PLQ signs near rivière du loup, etc). I feel like in Ontario it's a decent heuristic that a party's support in a riding could be inferred from how visibly they're advertised, but I'm not seeing that here. Is that a reasonable observation? Not quite a numbers question, but interested in the perspective of two guys who know Quebec well.

Skaana 🫍 One Ocean 🇨🇦 Mark Leiren-Young

How do you factor - or do you factor - support from unlikely vs. likely voters? I've been looking at polling (Ipsos, I think) around climate as an issue. It's scoring much higher numbers in the 18-24 range, but I'm wondering if politicians just tune that demographic out because they ain't gonna turn out in the same numbers as 55+? This strikes me as one reason that the BC Greens and federal NDP may get a boost in polls that doesn't convert into votes. Thanks!

Christopher Green

I’m a little early for the next mailbag, but I wanted to Éric, knower of many Canadian political history things, whether a party leader has ever before resigned their leadership while in the middle of a by-election campaign for their own seat (as Kerry-Lynne Findlay just did).