Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Good morning everyone — we're doing to do another mailbag segment in tomorrow's episode, so if you have any questions please leave them on Patreon or on the Discord. Thanks!

Comments

Scott Morrier

Given how much by-election results can vary from a general election, do you find that using projection models designed for GEs makes it difficult to predict by-elections? Or is trying to model a by-election separately a fool's errand?

Ed Miller

Please correct these numbers if they are wrong, but in round numbers, if an electron were held today about 60 Conservative Members of Parliament or about 50% of the caucus, would lose their seats. Last election my wife, who is a hard-core NDP supporter, voted Liberal for the first time in her life in what was a pure anti-Poilievre strategic vote. I know you have touched on this before but I’d appreciate a deep dive into how long Pierre Poilievre can hold on before a caucus revolt sees him get the door.

Steve Strauss

What do think of the Carney government's bill C5 to spend more money, yet again, in an attempt to create universal electronic health records for every health provider in Canada.

Levi Minderhoud

Thinking about elections in which new governments are elected, do voters typically vote new governments in or vote incumbent governments out? I'm especially thinking of voter turnout and/or raw number of votes here. For example, the recent BC election seems to be a pretty clear case of the people voting the NDP government out rather than voting the Conservatives in based on the fact that the Conservatives got a very similar number of votes as in the last provincial election, but the NDP vote dropped by hundreds of thousands. Is this typical? Or do newly elected governments tend to be elected on a significant upswing in raw votes for them?

Lynne kyba

Given that the D. Smith UCP government is gerrymandering the Alberta electoral map to give the rural voters ( 19% of the population) more seats in the legislature (currently almost half at 41 of the 87 ) do you have a suggestion as to how the democratic “Rep By Pop” principle can be implemented? Do other provinces promote unfair representation?

Shanti Fernando

Rosemont-La Petite Patrie appears very close. Was Boulerice the reason the NDP kept the seat or is it a left leaning riding?

Devo Seamus

Can you tell from the numbers whether it is likely that there were people who voted PQ that favour the Federal Liberals in recent polling - in other words does the math support the idea that Plamondon picking fights with Carney might not be such a great idea?

Jamie

At this point, what would be a bigger byelection surprise; the liberals losing Scarborough North, or the conservatives losing Yorkton-Melville

Ian Thompson

What are, if any the provincial governments in waiting right now?

Sylvius the Mad

With the release of your new projection model at The Writ (great job, by the way), why is it that so many projection models have this problem with being overfit? The Americans seem particularly bad at this, always over-correcting for last election's errors.

Bob

With the Alberta UCP general meeting coming up later this month, can you do a calculation of what the Alberta election results (# of seats per party) would be if the Leave camp left the UCP and started its own political party? I guess you would have to make some assumptions about how many people who voted for “Leave” would stay in the UCP and how many would move to a separatist party.

Tyler Spence

Which leadup, campaign, and result of its 2026 election will be more memorable, BC or Quebec? In BC the Conservatives leading (in April/May), electing Findlay leader, falling apart (losing nearly half of their caucus), the NDP calling a snap election 2-years early (during the municipal campaign) and the Conservatives winning a 2/3 majority with an interim leader. In Quebec, the 5-party race, the CAQ being wiped off the map, the PQ winning with 28% (also going from 3 seats in 2022, to government), and the Conservative 19 seat breakthrough which helped to give the PQ 0 seats in the Quebec City region.

Dónal Gill

Have you seen polling on the application of Bill 101 to CEGEPs? My gut says it’s unpopular but I’m hardly a disinterested party…

One Ocean 🇨🇦 Mark Leiren-Young

In BC the election narrative has become "NDP voter stayed home." But the numbers were pretty reflective of your modelling. Is there any fact-based reason to believe that if everyone was forced to show up to vote that the breakdown would have been any different?