Citations Needed

Ep. 88: The Mythical Bygone Glory Days of "Free Speech" (Patreon)

Published:

2019-09-25 15:07:42

Imported:

2026-06

Downloads

Download CN88_20190925_freespeech_moskowitz_rouse.mp3

Content

We are often warned by conservatives, liberals and even some on the Left that we live in a time where “free speech” is under threat from far-left forces. “Political correctness” and “snowflakes” have shut down free inquiry, specifically on college campuses, and led to a crisis threatening the very foundation of our democracy.

But the origins of the label “free speech” — as it’s currently practiced — paint a much messier picture. Rather than appealing to the Vietnam-era Berkeley protest glory days, what one sees when examining the history of the concept is a temporary tactic used by the Left in the mid-to-late 1960s that has, since that late 1980s, become a far-right wedge designed to open up space for racism, eugenics, genocide denial, trans and homophobia and anti-feminist backlash. Defense of the right to keep open this space as an appeal to a universal value hides a well-funded, coordinated far-right attempt to maintain a conservative, largely male and cishet version of political correctness.

On this episode, we discuss where the contemporary concept of “free speech” comes from, what its uses and misuses have been and how a rose-tinted time of pristine, perfectly "free" speech never really existed.

We are joined by journalist and author P.E. Moskowitz and Chair of Princeton University's Department of Anthropology Carolyn Rouse.

***

Guests

P.E. Moskowitz is a journalist and co-founder of the media collective Study Hall. They are the author of the books How To Kill A City and The Case Against Free Speech: The First Amendment, Fascism, and the Future of Dissent, the latter of which was recently published by Bold Type Books.

Carolyn Rouse is a professor, filmmaker and chair of the Department of Anthropology at Princeton University. She is the author of a number of books, most recently Televised Redemption: Black Religious Media and Racial Empowerment.

****