Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Episode 18 will be out within the week as well, going to start getting farther ahead for you in the Ascended tier! I don't want to make you wait a full year for me to get to series end. Extra episodes will just be posted as I get them done, with an ep guaranteed (hopefully) each Sunday minimum as usual.


Also, yeah. Fully denial mode has once again been entered.  Why can't everyone just live happily ever after?

Files

Previews only

Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood 1x17 Patreon Extended

Watch "Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood 1x17 Patreon Extended" on Streamable.

Comments

Antoine Jones

Now that you're further in the series and have already seen the things I'm gonna reference. I honestly think you should have reacted to the original FMA and THEN Brotherhood, while Id give both shows at 10/10 with Brotherhood being the better of the 2 and the original would definitely be hard to watch after seeing Brotherhood first. But if you like story and character depth FMA has a slight edge for a few reasons: 1) Nina and her family are more fleshed out and developed (its 3-4 episodes) before "THAT" happens. Whereas Brotherhood does it all in one episode 2) Hughes and his family are a LOT more fleshed out and get screen time before "THAT" happens (the "Hughes Incident" doesn't happen til halfway through the series, meaning you get a lot more time to get to know him and care even more when something happens) 3) A lot of the things that are merely glossed over or not explained well (or at all) are well explained in the original 4) The original has lots of great plot twists/reveals that I dont think would have been as great or even eye roll enduing if youve seen Brotherhood first or read the manga So yeah Brotherhood assumes everyone has seen the original so Brotherhood just rushes through the first half and lots of the depth, character/world building, development and explanation we got in the original was skimmed/cut in Brotherhood.

CastSenpai

I understand, but if I am to choose between the two, the manga-accurate Brotherhood would still be my choice. Once I am done with BH I may go back on my own time and check out the original FMA!

Antoine Jones

yes they literally SAID they wanna stop Roy from finding out too much because then theyd have to kill him and they dont wanna do that cause they want him for sacrifice