Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

The Ishval War! It's time to start getting more answers. Kimbly seems like a *great* guy, as expected. How could he not be with such endearing... passions...

Love for focus on Roy and Riza though, this episode definitely presented a lot of interesting moral areas a lot of media doesn't like to focus on as well, so respect for that.

Files

Previews only

Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood 1x30 Patreon Extended

Watch "Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood 1x30 Patreon Extended" on Streamable.

Comments

Cam C.

it's honestly harder watching knowing that this happens in real life far too often. when watching the show, it's much easier to empathize with both sides because you are personally getting to know the individuals involved and how they feel about it (that of course in no way excuses their actions, as Riza was saying). in real life, you just hear about the overall fight and the end results. Roy and Hughes' talk about soldiers being tossed aside like garbage during and after the war brings to mind the way governments often leave their veterans to fend for themselves physically, mentally, and financially once they return home (US specifically, i'm not knowledgeable about other countries' treatment of their veterans). Obviously there's a lot more going on in the background of this story that's not as applicable, with the sins and Father and all that. But even the experimentation of prisoners of war/prisoners in general holds comparable to projects such as MKUltra mind control experiments, the Agent Orange experiments, the Soviet "Chamber" experiments, Nazi experiments, etc. Mostly to be used in an effort to gain more advantage in their respective wars, just like the philosopher stones were. it's sick to know that if we had this science/magic in real life, governments and their militaries would be exploiting it even worse than in this horrific fictional story. Welp, definitely got a lot darker there than i intended to, but i suppose that was the intent. just like its characters, this story really wants everyone to open their eyes to the atrocities we humans do to one another. Kimblee was right when he said the only thing worse than death is averting your eyes from it. i am immensely grateful that fma gives the soldiers depth and supportable personalities and morals while still holding them accountable for what they did. i remember watching this as an adult for the first time since i was younger and being worried that they were gong to use Envy as a scapegoat so that the viewers could fully back the military characters like Roy and Riza. Very glad that instead they make sure we can back those characters because they hold themselves accountable and are trying to fix their mistakes, even at the (justified) risk of them becoming convicted war criminals. idk if this word vomit is even coherent, this episode just gives me a lot of feelings lol

Anonymous

I want to give you so many props for your comment you can't imagine, beautifully said:) I think this is one of those episodes I simply can't watch without shedding a tear, because it's so tragic and terrifyingly realistic at the same time. What makes things even more depressing is the fact that manga author interviewed the real war veterans for creating this part of the story, so you can watch it with the knowledge that feelings and emotions of these characters are based on the perspective of real war participants. War truly creates a generation of broken people on every side, so there are no "winners" or "losers", only survivors. And it's not like the government is always very eager to treat these survivors at least respectfully, which is kinda depressing as well. Sorry for the babbling, I just felt the urge to reply to your cool stuff:)

Anonymous

Since I'm gonna be here from now on, time to re-post Interesting Kimblee Fact #1: Kimblee's name in the English Dub, the Crimson Alchemist, is a mistranslation. The original Japanese has him as the Crimson Lotus Alchemist. In some eastern cultures, red lotuses are symbolic of fiery explosions, which idk if you noticed but Kimblee blows shit up so it works.