Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Okay so after discussions in discord I let people know that I do enjoy the sub better. I just like how the characters are expressive. My personal opinion I am more of a sub fan for most anime’s. I did enjoy the dub but I do prefer the sub a little more.

I came to this conclusion after editing and posting my reaction and during it I enjoyed it.

Please let’s not make this a dub vs sub war.

If you don’t want to follow my journey because of my choice that is 💯 your call and I will not be offended because we all have our preferences 😄

I just don’t want you guys to fight with each other I really want to keep this a positive and friendly environment.

Comments

Fugglez

Couldn't have said it better myself!

Daniel B

As long as the translation is accurate (EP1 had some questionable translations tbh) and you are able to follow the subs/dialogues, it's fine. Many people prefer the dub version because it's one of the best anime dubs, not because it's "better".

Raphael Lyons

Well it wasn't really a fight there was a large majority for the dub in the comments

Jonathan.m

Aye aye captain 🃏

Jechtsphere

Let’s just stop talking about it. It’s over with really. Nothing left to say.

Lonayx

Thank you !!

Ikky

Niiiiiice, do what ever you prefer!!

Wishmaker007

I personally like the dub but I got jojo and one piece to look forward towards so I’m good :)

Anthony Suarez

I've seen the dub twice already so i'm actually kinda excited to watch sub for the first time

Armando

Talking about discord can someone plese help me because i just join in the $10 tier but i still can't access to the server even after trying everting in the help section.

Infinity House Productions

I think now it's about which version you see first. Because that voice becomes the voice you associate with that character.

Voidaken

It really made no difference. If people are fighting over it, they're just being too protective of the nostalgia of their first time with the show.

Gaffar

vote this guy up... ya people give argument by experience and emotion, not by reasonable research

John Bayer

I mean some people just really prefer the dub. I have no problem with her going with sub and support it, but I know I won't be able to watch the reactions simply because I don't enjoy the sub for this anime, nothing wrong with that. Same way I can't stand JoJo in dub.

Weedzel

dub JoJo is an abomination

GoldArthur

Ok, this is annoying. As far as I could tell, the only people threatening to leave were sub elitists. I don't care if you've chosen to do the sub, but I can't stand that you're not only ignoring the threats by the sub elitists, but even worse, acting like the dub fans were the instigators. This is the second time you've done this and it's incredibly rude.

Ali6B

Lol

bLuGhOsT

Cause the sub voters are happy and don't need to say anything :D

bLuGhOsT

I'm late to the connecting of patreon to discord, how do i get amongst this discord server?!

Raphael Lyons

Well duh but I was talking about when she asked about what we would prefer

James Gibson

I'm not as much a sub snob as I was in college, but I still perfer them, especially in stuff like Jojo, where the dub loses alot of expressiveness & charm. But there are dubs I do like occasionally.

Jasmeet Singh

SMF: We are hurt. i knw i dont want to be a part of this sub vs dub debate anymore now that i ve seen hw things are turning out. i m aware that sub makes more sense aftr votes and problem with ur comments clashing with the beautifully done dub voices. disappointed guy here, still, saying that, pls stop raining on the parade of dub fans. even if in ur personal opinion sub feels better, dont make things light on such a sensitive subject which, clearly, it has passionately turned out to be for the fans. also, "after a discussion i do feel that i do enjoy sub better." do u even realise hw immature this statement is, judging after just one episode, do u really think that's fair on ur part to say that. <-(rhetoric) i mean couldn't u just feel sorry that u dont have df to erase ur memory to record both experiences. whatever happened to u spreading the positivity? since subs fans are getting what they want, why do i (dub fan) feel being vindicated as a part of ur problem on the channel, including ur comments in ur ep 3-4 rxn. its obvious that u r tired. pls take a break if u must and look after ur health.

Leorion

Go to your profile settings > apps > connect Discord and you should be added automatically.

Leorion

Go to your settings > Apps > connect Discord. You should be auto-added.

Shendue

That not necessarily the case. I've seen Full Metal Alchemist Brotherhood dubbed in my mother language, the first time, but I don't mind it either way. It's just that some english dubs (FMAB, Death Note, Gurren Lagann) are good, but several suck balls (OP, HXH, MHA). It depends.

Voidaken

That's just called being mature about it. I also don't mind either way despite what language I heard it in first. But you're always going to be sentimental about your first time(I know for a fact that your mother language dub has a special place in your heart).

Flare

SMF you have some crazy fans.. just do what you want to. The people who truly appreciate you will watch no matter what. <3

Mamox

wtf get a grip dude its not a big deal

Mamox

for real. I enjoy the sub more but literally couldn't care either way. I just want to see her experience the show dub or sub. The dub is fantastic anyways for FMA: B so who cares what she picks? One guy above wrote a greek tragedy about her choosing sub and its so pathetic... SMF your fans like you either way and picking which you enjoy best is the way to go. People be crazy - who cares people!

Jasmeet Singh

what's wrong with if it did become one, that too thanks to SMF. first its going to stigmatise the mood around her rxns, not only for us, but for her going thru this as well. second, it's fmab after all. our beloved dubbed and childhood show belittled by our fav but naive reactor. doesnt the secondly explain how anti-climactic it feels even going into the opening of this show. why me expressing my concerns is perceived bad. some questions for u to ponder over

Robert Sommers

She said she lied the sub better, that isnt raining on your parade lol

Jasmeet Singh

i m sorry i didnt get that last one. what's it in reference to?

VengeanceCookie

Do wich ever you prefer. I for one can enjoy both Sub and Dub and really dont understand why this is such a big deal. Just dont let this debate ruin your excitement for FMAB. People on the Internet get offended by every Choice nowadays anyway :)

Robin Greed

actualy not true. It was 50/50 and she just chose what she prefers.

Robin Greed

both sides said, they would leave. Its literally the same. Cant please everyone

Robin Greed

Most of the guys who are so butthurt about this debate, are new to this channel anyways. they just came in for FMA. I dont think any long time watchers on her channel care THATmuch

GoldArthur

Ok, Zura, point me to one comment from a dub fan saying they would leave if she went with sub, because I read all of them and didn't see any. Meanwhile, I saw countless from sub elitists.

Ali6B

JmanTheOmega, “I'll pass. Sub elitists can have their fun. Seems they always do. Personally wont be watching this here. You should really start looking into dub vs sub on your own time before seriously considering something. The arguing wasn't worth it” make it harder to prove you wrong next time

GoldArthur

Ok, point proven. Tbf, i was referring to the comments from while she was still deciding, of which, I saw no dub fans threatening to leave, but countless sub fans threatening it. In any case, it's pretty obvious it was happening more on one side, and to act like it was the opposite, AFTER picking the sub, is like salting the wound.

GOAT

and this is why we have this post smh

camel.d

If that is what you prefer that is cool. I liked the sub better too myself. Either way it's normal to see toxicity whenever there is a close vote especially for a topic like sub vs dub, but I say go for whichever version you preferred and enjoy it. I also hope this becomes the case for the future too, if every time you are going to watch an anime you do a vote for a dub vs sub of course there will always be this rivalry and hate, giving too much choices becomes a hassle then.

yoselin ortega

I wanted to watch it in dub but I'll still watch it because I like the anime and want to see your reaction.

Eric

lol youre a little shit bro, shut the fuck uo haha man if i was a reactor and had cunts like this watchme id straight up come to your house and shank you haha

Jasmeet Singh

Michael black, this post is why i commented. perspective much?

Jasmeet Singh

Eric, yah, u know how its is bro and no one else. thanks for the dose of sexism and also filled up my cup of ad hominem for the morning.

Barry Smith

I never thought dubstep would be this much of an issue.

Sherv

I'm a dub fan for this show, but seriously guys every youtuber literally watches the dub, so whats the problem if one reactor actually watches the sub? Its really not a big issue. I guarantee every person making arguments have watched the show already 2 or 3 times from other reaction channels. Just chill and enjoy Fullmetal how you want to, SMF.

Sean Ornelas-Linter

I just always prefer dub if it’s available, I can enjoy subs if that’s how I need to see new episodes, but i can watch more episodes if I’m not moving my eyes back and forth so much, words to show and back, but that’s just how I personally prefer to watch. For ppl who prefer subs, great, enjoy, for ppl who prefer dubs, hopefully a future new series will get chosen with dub reactions. I’m hopeful things will work out well for everyone eventually

Robert Morris

Dude the original is in Japanese, it’s from Japan, it’s not weird for her to like the original. In fact it seems pretty normal.

Robert Morris

SMF I speak both languages, just go with Japanese with eng subs. Trust me it’s better. I can do something most people can’t, which is to compare.

Jasmeet Singh

nothing wrong with that. but it is weird to say that after an extended discussion on discord (and not on patreon), she has come to the conclusion that she likes the sub better. not that she thinks it ll make more sense to do subs since xyz, but come to conclusion for liking something (<-BS), that absolutely makes no sense. to me, it almost seems like sub-nazis forced it down her throat, figuratively speaking.

GoldArthur

Jeremiah, I intend to. I don't have a problem with the sub. I just thought the dub was a better choice. That said, that has nothing to do with what I was talking about.

Jasmeet Singh

watching it in sub with her. plus it makes more sense for rxns as i ve mentioned above.

Nox

Differences in opinion cause conflict. This is human nature. You ultimately have to make decisions on things like this yourself and not put it up to voting because it is YOUR channel after all. It's impossible to please everyone so just be decisive. There will be less stress and bickering and people will decide what to do from there.

jay

Yes, absolutely go with what you yourself like. The reactions feel more genuine when you are able to appreciate them at your comfort and to your liking.

jay

Nobody is raining on your parade. She watched her own reaction and decided she prefers one over another. There's no science behind it.

Jasmeet Singh

as biotechnologist and a psychology student i takes offence for absence of science in ur argument and claiming it to be right. too dogmatic for me to accept what u say from now on. im flagging u

JmanTheOmega

These are pretty much my thoughts, too. Trying to be 'nice' and fair just comes off as indecisive. The whole back and forth thing that that went on for days only brought tension. She does the same things for polls on one piece. Makes a poll about skipping filler. Even if the poll shows "skip filler" She still just does what she wants in the end and does filler. You cant make everyone happy, just makes you seem indecisive and insincere with what you say in the end.

Jim serra (Safe)

Well tbh if it's your full time job I think it's better for your business to do sub only or you will lose all the non-native speaker. Your choice. I thought the dub would be okay with so much positive comments but I find it so bad. (non action acting was boring and with the same tone EVEN between different characters :o, action acting was okay but same as non action part I don't see the emotion beneath it and for girls voices everything was wrong). It must be a native speaker thing anyways I will stay away from dub for now on.

Steven

She said that the final decision will be up to her, because the poll was very close. She watched both dub and sub, and she preferred the sub. She’s not disrespecting the dub, you can enjoy it in your own time!

Steven

Please, I ask everyone to stop talking about it in the future. We should all be talking about the actual anime, and not the language it’s in. Both are good in their own ways. If you prefer English dub that much, feel free to watch it on Crunchyroll or somewhere else while also watching her reaction at the same time.

Jasmeet Singh

and again, i support her for the sub decision. but again, are you dumb or something, she's not the perfect being u r making her out to be and she did offend dub version and dub fans. plus having discussions on discord are validated more by her than those on patreon. and after a margin of 4 votes she is acting like we dont even exist and clearly the sub won like its all black and white and declaring that sub is better aftr just watching one ep of dub, which mind u she did like in her rxn. then aftr a cpl of days she comes online with random logic that sub has expressive quality in voices and stuff like that, as if it's lacking ftom the dub. plz dont get me started again patreon kid, and get urself a username first.

JR

100% disagree; I actually started Fullmetal Alchemist watching in English on Adult Swim and Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood too. I finished the original series in English, but only got halfway through Brotherhood in English due to watching other things. Eventually I had the time to watch FMA:B but it was a few years since I had started it, so I started over. I tried the first episode in dub, decided to change to subs for the second episode, then stuck with subs all the way through because I simply enjoyed it more.

Jcw490

I would be really surprised, if not FMAB then what would possibly end up being watched in dub?

LuckyXStudios

I love both though I lean towards the dub more just because as an English speaker the amazing performances hit me deeper. But I'm still on board to join you for your FMA journey :)