Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello everyone! If Patreon hasn't informed you with an email JUNE 1st Patreon is implementing sales tax into pledges.

This may not effect everyone but here is important information.

Now, it says that creators can optimize this setting so later this month I will look more into it.  

But I just wanted to inform everyone the update on the Patreon site as a whole.

Files

Comments

Wishmaker007

wow, interesting, a few cents isn't much to me but I imagine some will definitely take this info into consideration, thanks for the heads up SMF :)

Honey bee

Ok 👌 cool I didn’t know this thanks for the info

JamiUwU

I am pretty sure most of the $1 pledges won't be affected at all which is practically 85% of my patreons

Lye Batenkaitos

Crap who would have thought we would have our donations taxed lol

Timze

Damn im already paying bit taxes because of this. :D

JamiUwU

I think Patreon will email users later this month. At least I would hope so

And_

I've already been paying sales tax for many months. Nothing new for me which is why I probably didn't get this e-mail from patreon

iFer

What? Wow I wasn’t expecting those percentages.

James F

Thats kind of scummy, this is donations. They shouldn’t be able to Tax money we’re donating to you guys

Savage Luffy

Everything is gonna be like this at this rate haha... 😂

Calcifer

I am not afraid, I already pay taxs 😎 😭

Empire .

Honestly thank you for making most of your reactions so affordable. For an unemployed student like myself, $1 is very affordable and not too much to ask. Most reactors I’ve seen don’t have this kind of tier so I’m really thankful.

pur3

Well, it's the most affordable tier, a lot of people (including me) don't really have extra money for donating to creators, this way we can support the creator and get awesome content at the same time for a very affordable price!

Marek Pfeifer

Wow Patreon just wow. I guess the greed is getting to them.

Duderson Dude

Just to be clear I’m not complaining and saying I’m leaving. It was just nice to have some services not be hit be taxes, like eBay. But I still use eBay and I’ll still use this. It is what it is

Shendue

Taxing DONATIONS is a bit of a scam. Pretty sure we aren't paying for a service, but just supporting a creator.

Smooch

I already pay taxes with every monthly donation since I first signed up for Patreon so nothing new rlly (at least not for me)

B00ch

sometimes they can't help it (i don't want to pay it) just saying. remember a time when amazon didn't charge tax or didn't do it specifically on your state? lol

fitz_xr

So it's based on my location thank god my country doesn't charge any taxes

KaitouKay1412

ive never seen a tax charge whenever patreon charges me so i guess we'll have to see if that changes

Robert Johnson

Well..when you put it that way it sounds fucking scummy.

Robert Johnson

I didn't think anything of it but the people mentioned they're trying to tax donations, and that's fucking scummy. That could easily be the tipping point for some people and make them pull their donations. Some people just want to give what they want to give and no more, and that extra 50 cents would make some people stop donating. So yeah, fuck that shit. I'm staying, but still fuck that.

Timze

Well i've been paying taxes a while already for pledges. Im finnish and we basically pay taxes on everything so never though about it.

Shendue

You should. It doesn't make any logical sense. If you gift money to a church, do you pay taxes on top of it? If you make a donation to UNICEF, do you pay taxes?

ZackNero03

Thank you for the update.

All Might

Doesn't this kinda go against what patreon stood for in the first place?

Speedwagon

Yeah some creators really abuse with 15$ min to watch full reaction, that's more than I pay for Netflix 4K + Prime Video + Spotify + youtube premium (5.51€ + 2€ + 4.99€ + 0.96€=13.46€ = 14.77$). I'm in France, I used a vpn to pay Netflix 4K with turkish currency (41.99 turkish lira=5.92$), Prime Video for Student is 24€ a year, spotify for student is 4.99€ a month and youtube premium is 0.96€ with vpn to India

iFer

HOLD ON! You’re saying that I’ve been paying almost $60 for all of those when you can actually pay less with a vpn?

GoldArthur

I'm saying this to everyone, not just you, but, I'd really like you to consider moving to SubscribeStar. In my opinion, their platform is more friendly to both you AND us.

Skebaba

It's not a donation if I get REACTIONS IN RETURN. Donation by definition means you get NOTHING in return (besides feel good drugs from brain, in most cases)

Skebaba

WDYM? There already HAS BEEN a 20% tax after Pledge amount for years now, no?

Lye Batenkaitos

How would you even do that if the currencies convert to the same amount? Patreon costs would be the same in Indian rupees as it would in usd, you wouldn’t get a discount if you changed your currency lol

Cains

Let's be real... there are multiple tiers that offer more stuff to you the more you pay. Most people on patreon are not donating, they're subscribing for a service, lol.

Cains

The reality is that this is not donating and honestly trying to call it that should not just give you a free pass to not pay taxes. Like SMF is great I think she deserves normal business anyway, but her reactions are locked unless you pay a certain amount of money to her. You are not donating, you are buying her content.

Azazelop

Calling this a donation is a pretty big stretch. You are clearly paying for content. You are paying for a service, you aren’t donating to SMF.

Leon

Legally in most countries donations means getting nothing directly in return. A lot of Patreon tiers offer direct/regular rewards or advantages, which legally makes them a "service subscription" in and therefore sales tax/VAT applies. Only patreon tiers that offer no rewards can legally be exempt from sales tax or VAT.

Leon

What does greed have to do with this? Sales tax and VAT is something instated by local laws and goes to the local tax system. Sales tax money doesn't go to Patreon themselves..

Voidaken

Am I paying CA sales tax? It doesn't specify if it's MY location or YOUR location.

Deagor

Sure, because patreon was meant to be a place to "toss a coin to your witcher" but in a lot of area's - reactors especially - its become a subscription service where you pay money for content so saying THIS is going against what they stood for is kinda strange when we've all kinda been using it for its not intended purpose for over a year now.

Deagor

*shrug* I've been getting taxed @ 23% like I do for everything else in my country for patreon so absolutely nothing changes here. Not to start any culture wars but I'll never understand the American opposition to taxes. Tell them a coffee costs 5 dollars and they'll pay it no problem, tell them it costs 4.50 with a 10% sales tax and they'll lose their damn minds. I know taxation without represenation was a bit of sore point in the past but this isn't that. So ye, this was already a thing for many of us, its really not a big deal if you can afford 5dollars a month you can afford 5.50 - and if you can't then you probably shouldn't be giving your money to other people. I still manage to keep up 40euro worth of subscriptions on patreon @23%

Green Oak

Subscribestar is very rough around the edges and is most definitely not kinder to us. Unsubscribing instantly cuts off all benefits even if you paid for that month. With a few other issues here and there it's a better idea to stay here. Especially since swapping platforms will always cause a chunk of people to lose interest.

Banti

I mean, does it really change anything? If 50 cents cause you financial trouble you probably shouldnt have pledged in the first place.

GoldArthur

That doesn't mean it wouldn't be possible to get things going there, at the same time and see how it goes. I haven't heard of any "rough edges" from them in ages, despite tons of benefits.

GoldArthur

The problem for many is having to provide exact locale info. There's no law against using fake info SO LONG as taxes aren't involved. Now they are.

Shendue

If that were the case, there would be a fixed price and the content creator would be legally obliged. Both are not the case. You clearly have no idea what you are talking about, "lol". Several content creators even offer pledges where you get absolutely nothing in return. And, even if you do, it's akin to giving a tip to someone who's basking on the street. It's not like you are paying someone to paint your fence. I can see why they are doing this. They don't want the IRS or whatever country they are based in's tax system to sue them for someone taking advantage of the platform to circumvent taxation, which is certainly doable. But the fact is, they should check it on a case-by-case basis. They don't because it's a huge workload, so taxing everyone is easier on their behalf. They even decide the taxation regime via an AUTOMATED ALGORITHM that is searching for TARGET WORDS on description. This is the epitome of sketchiness, and probably illegal, should one sue for it (nobody will because the legal expenses and potential success won't be worth the effort for mere pennies).

Banti

The tax rate is determined by the country set in your profile settings. I dont consider giving my country as "exact locale info". If i had to give them city, street name etc. that would be a problem maybe. Also laws concering fake information also vary from country to country.

GoldArthur

Not in the US. In the US you have to provide postal code, because tax rates vary on local levels.

Banti

Well i can only speak for my account settings. There isnt even an option for a postal code. Only for the shipping adress which is not required to fill in.

Misushi

so wait, I have already been paying this tax crap all the time and thought it was a normal thing to do. Does that mean if I only had set a different country than mine I wouldnt even have to pay that?

GoldArthur

Considering that that is illegal in MOST countries, I doubt that would have been a viable solution.

Banti

I wouldnt risk it for a few cents to be honest

Azazelop

For most channels, you are doing both. You are paying for a service while supporting the creator. So it seems a little extreme to consider it a donation. I’m sure some creators use it just for donations, but most creators make content in exchange for the pledges you are making them. That’s like calling a Netflix subscription a donation to Netflix. I understand that creators have much less content than Netflix, but the idea is the same.

Deagor

And once everyone moves from patreon to subscribestar then subscribestart starts doing exactly what patreon is doing now. The fact you think it would be any different is - politely, cause I don't want to insult you - naive

Green Oak

I don't think you know what rough around the edges means. The site is very very clunky and less optimized than Patreon. No more benefits than Patreon and it has more negatives. Making the switch to a similar but worse platform makes absolutely no sense especially since it WILL follow in Patreon's foot steps and like the other commenter said, not to be rude to you but if you genuinely think SubscriberStar won't do what Patreon does then you're naive. It's an idea with good intentions but overall I think it would do much more harm than good.

Green Oak

When you enter in your card you are giving your postal code

Deagor

It'll be your location

Allen Reck

This small amount isn't exactly the hill I want to die on as far as taxes go, but I disagree with the example you gave. The $5 coffee, the coffee shop made the coffee not the govn't. When you work you get taxed, when you spend money you get taxed, when you make an investment and it makes money you get taxed. They take money from you every which way, and all we have to show for it is all sorts of corruption and bloat. Just speaking for myself that's why this American gets hot and bothered about taxes. Again not going to complain about this particular bit of change.

Deagor

Ye, and that's fair. I mentioned the general American dislike for tax but I guess I oversimplifed. I standby that being a thing but obviously its a bit more complicated. But I would say it all comes down to how much you accept/respect your gov. I consider the taxes a good thing, if your gov uses them to fund things you actually use, roads, hospitals, Farmers, fisheries etc. etc. if your gov isn't using your taxes for those things and is instead squandering it then I might be a bit more upset about paying tax. But my gov generally speaking using it decently so I'm ok with paying it

Speedwagon

Yes, it works fine for Netflix and youtube premium/google drive too. I used Hola vpn to pay with other currencies, then I don't have to use the vpn anymore than once, it worked fine with my basic french credit card. Netflix and youtube and others stuffs are really really cheap in some countries. Turkey is one of the cheapest for Netflix and India for youtube. It doesn't work with some service providers like Spotify family or patreon

Banti

Yeah for US residents it makes sense since different states/provinces have different tax rates there.