GM Blog: Episode 57 (Patreon)
Content
Like GM blog 26, this blog is being posted out of order. Also, like GM blog 26, this GM blog is looooooooong. ALmost 19K words long, or near as dammit.
Given its potentially confusing contents, it's important that Episode 57: The Canons of Nuln is explained. It's also important as far as the players are concerned as they make some fun and fundamental choices about their characters that significantly alter the ongoing storyline. These choices also allow me to discuss the importance of player agency with you all and why I feel it's vital that the players make big character decisions for their PCs, not me. You'll understand what I mean by this later in the blog.
If you're not the sort that likes reading lengthy posts, I've dropped a tl;dr at the bottom so you can still grasp the meat of what I'm going to discuss.
For everyone else, buckle up, we've got a lot to cover.
One of the core themes of our version of The Enemy Within is Hidden Faces; ie, everyone is not what they initially seem, be that the PCs, Lieberung, Tuegen, the Wittgensteins, or whomever. Our version of The Horned Rat takes that theme, goes wild with it, and then finishes that aspect of the campaign story by the end of its run. Our The Horned Rat is about completing all the Hidden Faces plots and leaving the PCs with all the information they need to conclude the campaign. And, as this episode makes clear, that included potentially having an additional layer of Hidden Faces amongst the PCs.
And, yes, no matter what the episode may suggest, there was only 'potentially' some Hidden Faces amongst our Glorious Heroes.
What do I mean by that?
We'll get to that later in the blog.
To help with parsing all the information that's about to be chucked at you like a barrel of cold water, I've split this GM blog into six parts.
Let's take a look at what's coming.
Part 1) Set-Up. This explains the episode's contents up to the arrival of the Countess in the Magnus Chamber. It's standard bullet point stuff.
Part 2) The Countess's Thoughts. This presents an in-depth examination of what the Countess thought as the PCs attempted to sway her during the first part of the episode. It's rare that so much rests on swaying a single NPC, so I figured it was worth examining how they did. This is the most extended section, possibly niche reading, but some folks requested it, so I wrote it all out.
Part 3) Choices. This section details the players' choices during the break and the consequences of those choices. This is the bit that most of you have been clamouring for over on Discord. Here, you'll see some player agency in action and how it changed everything for the episode and the campaign.
Part 4) More of the Countess's Thoughts. The continuing examination of the Countess's thinking after the break. This is significantly shorter than Part 2) as the Countess's opinions were already relatively firm and did not change much.
Part 5) Wrap-up. The final few bullet points that discuss the end of the episode.
Part 6) tl;dr. A super quick summary of the entire blog.
So, shall we dive in?
Actually, before we do, I have a warning: this blog contains massive SPOILERS for Episode 58: The Rise of the Horned Rat. So, I suggest you watch that episode, the last episode of our version of The Horned Rat, before reading this blog.
And with that said: Let's go!
PART 1) SET-UP
After airing, this episode left folks asking a lot of questions.
'Is this an alternative timeline? How can Gerhardt, Luitpold, Elrick, and Birdie be simultaneously in the south and adventuring across the Middle Mountains? Seriously, Andy, WTF is happening here?'
Good questions.
Do we have another unreliable-narrator episode that is full of lies? Is this a weird alternative timeline?
No.
Not at all.
Everything that happened in this episode occurred as depicted. Six blessed priests, four of whom claimed to be PC characters you all know and love, approached the Countess of Nuln to advise her about the continuing shitshow that is the politics of the Empire.
So, if you're doubting everything from the episode, stop. You're all good there. This episode isn't a weird multiversal aethyr-inspired dream sequence or anything equally uncertain. It simply presents stuff that happened. And the primary source of confusion – who are these doubles? – is about to be answered.
Coz it was the players who made that happen.
Not me.
And it's massively important for the outcome of our campaign.
So, let's dive into what the bloody hell is going on with this set of characters that somehow included another Gerhardt, Luitpold, Elrick, and Birdie.
Answering this is why I'm doing this blog early. The conundrum, and how I handled it, needs explanation for many of you.
To start the ball rolling on that, this episode sets up our conclusion of The Horned Rat. In other words, this episode is a part of the conclusion for the 'there are doubles everywhere' plotlines that this section of the adventure finally resolves. But to do that, I first need to determine where the last of those doubles are. As the episode makes clear, that includes the possibility that we have doubles within the PC group. And, as I said, I'm not the one who decides if this is the case; it's the players: they get to choose just how messed up their party is.
The fact that our 'Glorious Heroes' may include people who are doubles may surprise you, but it really shouldn't.
Why? Let's go through the four culprits in this episode.
GERHARDT: It's been known that there were multiple doubles of Gerhardt since Episode 1: Wanted: Bold Adventurers – we even met one with the dead Kastor Lieberung. Since then, we have encountered several other Gerhardts, including the ultimate horror show in Karak Skygg in Episode 55: Dead Ringers, where the source of the duplicates was found and then explained, albeit by an unreliable narrator..
LUITPOLD. We also know Luitpold has a 'Shadow' – a perfect duplicate of himself that wanders around independently of him. This was first revealed in Episode 22: The Traitor. Luitpold has been growing increasingly dodgy since then, with things like the mysterious voice in his head or somehow teaching Gerhardt how to use a spell sitting high on that list.
BIRDIE. We also know Skaven used Birdie to help create their BIG RAT sorcery-science, as confirmed in Episode 55: Dead Ringers, so having a double of her, much like the doubles hanging around in the Grey Seer's lab in that episode, is not a great surprise.
ELRICK. The only real shocker here is Elrick. But we'll get to him. It will make sense soon and will be fully explained by the next episode.
Given all of this potential duplication that was available, I wanted to give the players a chance to have fun with it if they wanted to. So, this episode was for the players to finalise precisely what is and what is not happening with all of their doubles regarding our 'Glorious Heroes' and to draw a line under it all. This will be the last wild ride for these 'duplicate' plotlines, as The Horned Rat is the section that finishes off all the set-up for the Empire in Ruins. In the last part, we won't have 'are there duplicates amongst the PCs' plots. Instead, we'll focus on concluding everything set up by the previous four parts of the campaign so we can finally reach our likely epic end. Hopefully without a TPK.
Also, to be clear, I said the players are deciding all of this, not me. Nothing that happens in this episode concerning 'doubles' was chosen by me. This is an episode of player empowerment. I've set everything up so the players can make any choices they want and the story will still make sense, but I had no idea what choices the players would make.
How did I do that? And why?
Well, we'll dive into those details in Part 3) Choices. Let's first establish what was happening in the episode.
As always, we'll do that with some judicious use of bullet points that follow the events as they happened during Episode 57! Watching the episode will help you understand this, so I recommend you do that first, as we're about to get deep in the weeds.
Greenskins sacked Nuln? During the intro, I mentioned that Greenskins sacked Nuln. Did that happen? Yes, it did. Grom the Paunch, a famous and rotund goblin warlord, flattened Nuln a century before our campaign and set up shop in the city for a couple of years as Emperor Dieter IV hid in Altdorf. Grom eventually moved on to continue his rampaging northwards. To know more about what happened, check the Lorebeards episode on Grom here. He's one of the oldest characters in Warhammer, originally hailing from Warhammer 1E's expansion, The Forces of Fantasy, from 1984. Actually, let's take a look at the Warhammer 1E cover. Why? I'll explain in about 15 episodes or so...
Take that, Skellington!
Did this Luitpold have the same visions as the other Luitpold? The intro clarifies that the Luitpold in this episode has had many, if not all, of the same visions as the Luitpold to the north. Both Luitpolds have witnessed the same revelations of Sigmar, and it's been equally confusing for both. So, for example, this Luitpold has seen the Magnus chamber as was detailed in Episode 19.1: The Storm of Shemtek. However, be aware that later in the episode, it may appear to Luitpold this is not the case – that's because Andy unwisely mixes up side-Tales with visions Luitpold has experienced, which I was more than happy for him to do. But we'll get to that later in the blog.
What did the players know about these doubles they were playing? Nothing. The players knew as much as you did before arriving to play that Friday. On the day, I gave each player a brief for what they would be playing for the session. As you likely know, they're used to playing different characters for one-off episodes, but they certainly didn't expect to be playing versions of their own characters! The four involved were amused and slightly confused, but in a fun way. Let's cover all of the player briefs before we began the session.
Andy's Brief. Andy and I discussed the following before we started play:
You are playing Luitpold. You have all of Luitpold's knowledge. However, modify your background as follows: instead of travelling north from Reikland after resolving the Wittgenstein plotlines, you travelled south to Nuln and met there with Elrick, Gerhardt, and Birdie to investigate the Purple Hand you believed infested Nuln, the city where Teugen and Etelka studied, and the city where Lieberung used to ply his trade. After many adventures, you ended the Purple Hand threat in Nuln about three months ago. You have since attached yourself to the local Sigmarites and have been attempting to find a way to directly lobby the Countess to halt the civil wars now plaguing the Empire, wars that have grown worse since the Countess advanced her forces both northwards into Reikland and southwards into Sudenland.
And, after much work, you have succeeded in securing that audience.
With Elrick's help, you have found an obscure law created by Magnus the Pious that requires the sovereign of Nuln to give three hours of her time if six 'canons' request it – ie, six blessed clerics. These clerics must each represent one of the ten cults with a seat on the Grand Conclave, a council that advises the Emperor (for more on that advisorial body, check WFRP 2E's Tome of Salvation. So, you've had to find six cult-recognised blessed clerics of either Manaan, Morr, Myrmidia, Ranald, Rhya, Shallya, Sigmar, Taal, Ulric, or Verena.
You set out to find six such clerics and have finally done so. They are:
1) You.
2) Father Gerhardt of Shallya
3) Father Elrick of Verena
4) Mother Brunhilda (Birdie) of Ulric
5) Mother Birgitte of Myrmidia
6) Mother Adelaide of Morr.
Those are the six PCs today.
Once you reach the Countess and have her attention, you intend to argue the following to the Countess:
Neutrality. The Empire must stand. It must not devolve into civil war. The Countess must stay neutral in the conflict between Middenheim and Reikland and should counsel peace from her position of strength. Further, Sudenland to the south still reels from the recent Chaos invasion from the Black Mountains, so it’s essential to rebuild, not invade.
You are aware the other clerics will have a different set of views on this, but that's the cost of securing the audience.Ed's Brief. Ed's brief was similar to Andy's – this Gerhardt knows everything the other Gerhardt knows, just through different means, you're down in Nuln after deciding to pursue the Purple Hand there, and so on – but with the following additions:
Shallya blessed you on Sonnstill 2512 (midsummer's day) and you have been attempting to negotiate yourway through the female-dominated cult ever since, which hasn't been as successful as you'd like (but, at least, your grandmother no longer expects you to marry, as most clerics of Shallya are entirely celibate!). You have barely seen Birdie, Elrick, and Luitpold since putting down the Purple Hand of Nuln – your time since then has been spent attempting to fit in with the Shallyans.
Luitpold contacted you about counselling the Countess, and you readily agreed to this, hoping to convince her to stop the upcoming war.
You intend to argue the following to the Countess:
Neutrality. The Empire is collapsing into war. This madness must, somehow, be stopped. The horror of citizens fighting citizens must not be allowed to pass. Ever. Peace is the only way forward, and the Countess, as a representative of the civilized Classical gods from the south, must counsel others to peace, and the best way to do this is to stay out of the conflicts found in the other Grand Provinces.Dan's Brief. Again, the brief is the same as Andy and Ed's, but with the following extras:
You always believed in doing what is right, but never expected Verena to single you out for her blessing. It came upon you while hunting down Etelka's master in Nuln, and with it came the absolute loss of your magic, a loss you still keenly feel. In time, for all you still occasionally reach out for the Winds only to find nothing, you have come to see their loss for exactly what it is: a blessing from the curse of magic.
You have been living peacefully in the High Temple of Verena in Nuln for the last four months and have never been happier. Most commonly found in the libraries studying history and law, you have finally found a calling you feel is yours: knowledge, law, wisdom, and calm.
Having found a law that allows six 'canons' to advise the Countess for Luitpold, you intend to argue the following when you meet her:
Support Middenheim. The Countess is uniquely positioned to bring the horrific issues with Karl-Franz (KF) to an end. He is acting erratically and skirts the law of the Empire itself. The fact that the Countess is willing to accept the call of the six canons and attend a meeting with them shows she is already above KF, as she respects the law even when it inconveniences her. KF, by comparison, does not; he bends and warps the law for unjust reasons and is plunging the Empire into civil war. The Countess should continue to obey the laws of the land and rally the Empire, call on a vote in the Volkshall, and bring KF’s rule to an end for corruption much like Dieter IV a hundred years ago (the emperor during the age of the aforementioned Grom the Paunch, which was the reason I mentioned him so early in the episode). The best way to secure the vote for this is to side with Middenheim in return for support in the ballot for the next Emperor. It is the obvious path forward. Emmanuelle should use the law to bring down KF, then become Empress herself to re-establish order.Lindsay's brief. So, no Allamennowyth double for Lindsay? Nope. Allamennowyth has never been duplicated by anyone near Nuln, so there is no handy double wandering around pretending to be her for this episode. Of course, she does have someone that was pretending to be Alamennowyth, as shown in Episode 2.6: Family Ties, where she persuaded her grand-nephew to pose as her in the courts of Laurelorn, but that's far removed from what we're doing here. Instead, Lindsay is playing Adelaide of House Helstein, the same Middenlander Morrian character she played in Episode 45: The Fire is Lit.
You (Adelaide, pronounced, curiously, Ah-del-IN-DAH - it's a family thing and bloody confusing) have retreated to Nuln to convince the Countess to move against the Todbringers in the north. You bear a horrific wound on your neck, now half-disguised with a tattoo of red and black roses. This was received at the hands of the assassin played by Dan in Episode 45 (hence why he laughingly shouts, 'YOU SHOULD BE DEAD! when Lindsay first introduces the character). You know of our Glorious Heroes up in the north and are half convinced they may be Chaos Cultists.
Luitpold has approached you to form a conclave of 'canons' to counsel the Countess. Initially, you would refuse Luitpold because of his close connections to the Todbringers and potential cultist leanings; however, the chance of finally meeting with the Countess was too essential to allow personal preference and pettiness to intrude.
Your argument for the Countess was obvious given her character:
Support Reikland. Middenheim is lost to the Ruinous Powers. Daemons stir beneath the city and cultists sit in the court. You barely escaped with your life when the Todbringers attempted to assassinate you when you uncovered how rotten they were. The north needs to be brought to heel before it endangers everyone.Sage's brief. So, no Ume, either, eh? Nope. Ume, perhaps uniquely, is pretty much impossible to duplicate, meaning that she has no double in Nuln to play. Instead, Sage was given something different to play for Episode 57, someone I get asked about more than almost any character I've ever created for WFRP down through the decades: Birgitte van der Hoogenband. For those who know their deeper WFRP lore, you'll recognise Birgitte from the Tome of Salvation, a WFRP 2E book I co-wrote about religion a few decades ago. Abbess Birgitte and her monastery are shrouded in mystery. A mystery I'm repeatedly asked about. A mystery that will directly impact our game.
The secrets of Birgitte's Monastery of the Dark Maiden are pretty extraordinary. Birgitte carries the weight of those secrets uneasily, having recently learned them, and is in a state of almost perpetual panic because of the dangers she perceives in the current, febrile Empire. So, when Luitpold arrives asking if she'll join a conclave of canons to advise the Countess, Birgitte leaps at the chance. Perhaps she can counsel the Countess to bring this war that threatens her order's secrets to an end?
I gave Sage a looooong brief about the character and had her read the relevant sections of the Tome of Salvation so she'd know what was what. She had a fair bit to take on, which was a little hard for her, but she tackled it brilliantly.
As for Birgitte's planned advice to the Countess?
Support Reikland. Nuln must be strengthened. The Countess should stand with the Emperor as it is the law, and it is the surest way to bring peace to Nuln. The Countess should also 1) pacify Sudenland as it has fallen into disorder, and 2) join with the horselords of Averland who currently stand with the Leitdorfs in the civil issues with the Alptraums. Overall, the Countess should build Nuln into an indefatigable powerhouse of the Empire, ensuring the real decisions are made in Nuln as the Emperor holds court in the north acting as a cover. Most importantly, her monastery must not be disturbed by war.Cath's Brief. So that leaves Birdie, who is, for this episode, an Ulrican. Given her story so far, it won't surprise anyone that a double of Birdie could be an Ulrican. Cath was told much the same as Andy, Ed, and Dan, but with Birdie having learning the ropes of the Ulrican cult after being blessed by the war god four months ago. She then bested the High Priest of Nuln, taking the position. She's now escorted by at least two White Wolves everywhere she goes, with Gerlecht (with a pointy beard) and Sölbrecht (with a big beard) being her almost constant companions. The pair are twins sent by their mother – Etelka of House Toppenheimer, the Elector Countess of Sudenland – to the Cult of Ulric as a punishment to teach them some discipline, which hasn't worked. Etelka has issues with all twelve of her children (which is mentioned in the Enemy in Shadows Companion). For the last three months, Birdie has mostly been attempting to learn what being an Ulrican means from her knights, who mostly pay her no heed at all, or from the two other priests (including the one she bested), both of whom hate her. Of the 50 White Wolves attached to her temple, 45 are currently out campaigning, meaning she only has five White Wolf knights in her temple alongside the two other Ulrican priests.
As for Birdie's planned advice to the Countess:
Support Middenheim. The court of Altdorf is behind everything currently wrong in the Empire. Assassinations and sabotage in Middenland, the collapse of order across the Empire, and the rise of daemons were all put in place by the Purple Hand cultists now dominating Altdorf, cultists that rule their court. You have this confirmed by your investigations and on the authority of many allies (Emanuelle Nacht included) that Altdorf and the Emperor are in Purple Hand control.
With the briefs done, everyone was ready to play. Let's cover some interesting points from the beginning of the episode before we dive into actually meeting the Countess.
Drip, Drip, Blood from Gerhardt's Hands? IT MUST BE KHAINE! No, Gerhardt is not blessed by Khaine. It's maybe worse. It's perhaps nothing. We'll know by the time the break comes. More on that later.
LUIPOLD'S FACE IS SCARRED AND BROKEN! ANDY MUST BE PLAYING THE SHADOW? Not necessarily. Luitpold's face is scarred and broken, just not as much as the Shadow's. Again, we'll know more come the break.
Tight Tights Guard. So, let's talk about the elephant in the room at the beginning of the episode: that guard with the significant endowment. What's going on here? This is a conscious choice of the Countess to have guards in the Imperial Guard (the Nuln 1st Regiment of Foot, a regiment that still calls itself the 'Imperial' guard for all it has not guarded an emperor for a good century and does nothing even close to actual military work) with obvious... advantages. She dresses these carefully selected guards with tight tights to destabilise those intimidated, embarrassed, enticed, or aggravated by such matters. Most believe the Countess just likes guards with big helmets for personal reasons, which is a rumour that she actively supports as it helps others underestimate her.
'Gobby' - Elrick calling Gerhardt 'Gobby' is sourced from Birdie telling the rest of the PCs that Thanquol mistook Gerhardt's name for 'Gobby', confirming this version of the party knows at least a part of Birdie's horrendous background with the Skaven as detailed in Episode 2.5: Under-Altdorf.
'Do I know those names?' Lindsay asked if Adelaide knew the names of Luitpold, Elrick, Birdie, and Gerhardt to confirm if Adelaide knew of the 'doubles' up in Middenheim. Which, of course, she did. This will come up in the second half of the episode.
'It's only the Magnus Chamber.' Gerlecht (one of Birdie's White Wolf attendants) makes this 'joke' about the waiting room where the canons are gathering. The brothers have no idea where they are going and jest that they are headed for 'the Magnus Chamber' (the same chamber from episode Episode 19.1: The Storm of Shemtek) as that's where the Countess reputedly stages her assassinations (a common rumour that is almost entirely untrue), so it would be fine to be taken there, right? Haha...
This aside shows how little the brothers know of the Nuln palace, as they have no idea where they are. This is the twins' first visit, and neither truly believes they will ever see the actual Magnus Chamber.'Can you say what you need to say even though the Countess isn't blessed?' Dan drops a perfect line near the beginning of the episode that calls out a lie said by Adelaide (Lindsay's character). Adelaide didn't want the twins escorting Birdie to listen in on what she had to say to the Countess, so she claimed that her words could only be heard by those blessed by the gods, meaning the twins would have to be left behind. Elrick immediately calls this out by asking if the Countess, who is also not blessed, could then hear Adelaide's words. Adelaide covers this by claiming 'the Elector Counts of this Empire as blessed' to justify her first statement, which is Sigmar doctrine, not Ulrican, and is a sly dig at the White Wolf twins and Birdie.
'Holding a Warhammer and shying away from twelve Blazing Rays of the Sun'. Adelaide's holy vision of Birgitte may be important later in the campaign. So, let's log this one for a possible later blog.
'Justice is Deceitful'. Adelaide also received a vision about Elrick. The meaning of 'Justice is Deceitful' will become apparent in Part 3) Choices when we look at what Dan's choices were.
'She's going to be fucking annoyed!' The Palace Chamberlain withdraws from the waiting room after noting that all six canons have arrived, and he is privately very frustrated (Luitpold and the White Wolves overhear him). This is because he'd had a meeting with the Countess in the morning where he had listed her itinerary for the day, and the Countess had expressed her desire to avoid the meeting if possible. So, the Chamberlain was hoping that one or more of the canons would fail to arrive so that the meeting could be delayed, as all six were required by law to demand a conclave. But all six arrived.
Wait. Why doesn't the Countess refuse the meeting? She is the Countess! She certainly could refuse the meeting and would likely get away with it. But if she did so, she would be breaking the law. The palace Chamberlain knows the Countess may appear flighty and unpredictable, but she plays the game of politics carefully, and her rule of Nuln and Wissenland has many limitations. The Countess is not an absolute monarch (although she is now closer to it than Magnus the Pious would have preferred), and she always works within the confines of the law (or, at least, the LAWhammer version does). After all, it is the authority of the law that empowers her, and she has seen what happens when sovereigns break the law (another story, not for today). And, as the episode describes, Magnus the Pious had it enshrined in Nulner law that if six blessed clerics of Nuln – defined as 'canons' in Nulner law – demanded a meeting with the sovereign, then they were to receive at least three hours of her time (although many cavaets were added to this to account for extraordinary circumstances). So, the Chamberlain knew the Countess would give three hours of her day whether she wished to or not. He also understood that the Countess did not want to do this, so he was angry, primarily because he feared the Countess's ire would fall upon him. As explained later in the episode, the Countess contested the meeting in court, which went to her Law Lords. And the Countess lost.
'She's in a mood today!' The Chamberlain always says the Countess is in the mood, so this is hardly an unusual claim.
'Biggest threat in the room.' Gerlecht claims that, as Birdie is tall and pretty, the Countess may not like her as Birdie could be perceived as a threat. Once, when much younger, she may have acted that way, but she has matured considerably since then. However, the Countess is not above using her reputation for being vain when it suits other goals.
Realising Gerlecht's advice could be wrong, Sölbrecht calls out his brother's concerns as likely bullshit. Gerlecht maintains it is better to be safe than sorry.'Howls in the Wastes.' Adelaide has a vision about Birdie that concerns Ulric prowling the frozen north while the other gods live in paradise to the south, believing they are safe. This refers to the events during the Cataclysm at the beginning of history and is not directly about Birdie herself. That's because it's a loose explanation for why Ulric continues to hunt in the Mortal Realms to this day, which also explains why Birdie exists. But, more on that in a much later blog.
'Fuck, the Magnus Chamber!' When the twins realise they are going to the Magnus Chamber, both blanche for the reasons explained in 'It's only the Magnus Chamber'.
'We've all gone our separate ways.' The four 'Glorious Heroes' of this episode explain that they do not talk much anymore. Adelaide asks if any have travelled to Middenheim, and the 'Heroes' confirm they have not. This sets Adelaide on high alert as the Heroes are either lying, or something rotten has unfolded in Middenheim. Adelaide, after all, knows Gerhardt, Birdie, Luitpold, and Elrick were in Middenheim within the last few weeks as she was there herself (as detailed in Episode 45: The Fire is Lit). But Adelaide doesn't mention this for fear of losing her audience with the Countess – this is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity for her to speak with Nuln's sovereign privately, and she will not endanger it.
Herr Mots. Herr Mots is named for 'Her Man On The Street'. It's a pseudonym for the Countess's spymaster, who sits in on the meeting. The NPC was first introduced in Episode 46.1: Breaking the Siege, where, amongst other things, he explained the Countess's annexing of Dunkelburg and her intent of later securing Ubersreik. In that episode, Herr Mots also claimed that the Countess was pushing into Sudenland and had seized the Runefang there. The NPC was also an obvious shit-stirrer in that episode, quite unlike the Herr Mots we see in this episode who very much sits in the background and advises or attends the Countess when requested only.
Luitpold's Holy Bones. Yes, Luitpold has the holy bones he secured in Episode 9.6: The Lost Child, which the other Luitpold 'lost' and replaced with 'Ranaldan' dice (not dodgy, honest). He uses them for divination throughout this episode.
Gerhardt has Lore (Art). The Nuln Gerhardt having Lore (Art) is noteworthy. This skill was somehow lost by the Gerhardt in the north (which was Ed's choice when we rebalanced the character sheets in our PC Rebuild at the start of 2024). It's worth pointing this out while we're here for reasons that will soon become obvious. In many ways, Ed's choice to lose the skill laid the foundations for this episode. Where did that skill go? Nuln, it seems.
Nuln went to War with Trott's Marauders in the past? This factoid was dropped early in this episode. So, did it happen? The answer is yes. Kinda. Nuln besieged the Marauder barracks near Hendorf. Of course, strictly, there was no formal declaration of war as it was a city-state versus a mercenary company, so it was more of a (devastating) local skirmish. The conflict happened some 30+ years ago, during the reign of Emmanuelle's father, Konstantin, and was a mess. Offended by the Maruaders, Konstantin sent his mercenary armies to 'escort' the Marauders from his territory after diplomatic talks with them broke down. Alamennowyth's wife, Lucita Nuvala (first seen in Episode 9.4: Awakenings), commanded the defence and successfully drove back the Nuln forces in what was considered a military stroke of genius at the time, but she had help (more on that if and when it comes up in an episode). After devastating and debilitatingly expensive losses, Nuln's forces retreated, and the Marauders were allowed to keep their holdings near Hendorf (which, to be clear, were legally theirs anyway, no matter what Konstantin claimed). A description of those holdings, and the Marauders as a whole, can be found here.
'Was that a side episode or a vision?' Andy asked this about Episode 46.1: Breaking the Siege, the episode where Herr Mots was first introduced. And what did I say in response to the question?
'It's up to you!'
EEEK!
Is it going to happen?
TZEENTCH ALERT!
AWOOGA!
The answer I provided Andy here is true: it is entirely up to him to use information that his character knows or just he as a player knows. Lindsay even confirms that Episode 46.1: Breaking the Siege was a side-episode that Luitpold should know nothing about. So, does Andy listen to her?
Let's find out...'I can choose?' 'Is this a trap?' Andy asks this. The answer to both questions is yes.
So, having seen the trap, does he walk right into it?
Yes, yes he does.
Andy immediately asks Herr Motts what he was doing near Carroburg recently. But that information is not something Luitpold knows. However, it is something Andy knows.
MWUHAHAHAHAHAHA!
So...DING, DING, DING! TZEENTCH GAINS POWER! Luitpold has walked into the trap of Sheerargetru, as described in GM BLOG 26, adding +1 to Sheerargetru's knowledge of the players by using knowledge that only the players know, not the PC. I'll use that during the Empire in Ruins finale to good effect, thank you!
The Countess finally arrives. That being the case, we'll move to Part 2 of this blog post. But, before we do...
Aethyr Skims. The Countess is wearing 'aethyr skims' WTF are those? Effectively, the skims appear somewhat like the Warhammer equivalent of decorated nylon stockings that cling comfortably to flesh. They are made by the Aethyr Mills of Ind by 'skimming' spirits of the aethyr. Controversial to some, extraordinarily expensive, and unmistakable symbols of wealth, they are quite unlike anything manufactured in the Old World and have a notably Indish design (which none of the PCs know to distinguish). Luitpold can 'see' the skims because they are spun from soul stuff using techniques unknown in the Old World.
'What do you do?' The Countess asks this. It's a slight nod to the stock question asked by Queen Elizabeth II to the enormous number of folks she met when she was still alive. I heard her ask this to many people back in Thurso, where I grew up: she and her family visited my isolated part of the world frequently on the Royal Yacht Britannia (now berthed here in Edinburgh), which stopped by Thurso Bay when the royals headed off to the Castle of Mey. She never asked me what I did, though. I was just a kid. She instead asked: 'What do you like to do?'
'What do you think, Mots?' During the next part of the episode, the Countess often calls on Herr Mots to confirm or contradict the party's various statements. In truth, the Countess is fully briefed on all six canons and needs ask Herr Mots almost nothing, but she likes others to underestimate her, so she is happy to appear ill-informed. Turning to Herr Mots also gives her more time to think by offering a pause in the deliberations, which she also uses when needed.
PART 2: THE COUNTESS'S THOUGHTS
With the Countess sitting in the room, it's time to dive into what the sovereign of the city-state of Nuln is thinking as the party engages with her. After all, the party is there for one reason only: to change her mind.
How well did the PCs do?
The next set of bullet points goes deep into the Countess's thinking as she interviews the canons. Knowing her every thought may not be your bag, so you can easily skip this section. It can be summed up with the following:
The PCs attempt to influence the Countess. She controls the conversation as she is concerned that the gods themselves may be intervening, but grows confident the PCs are intruding to share their personal opinions on the Empire's ongoing civil issues. As the conversation develops, the Countess suspects something is not quite right with Elrick and Birdie for very different reasons.
There is more than that (26 bullet points and supplementary commentary). Still, it essentially all amounts to the Countess concluding that she will not change her chosen direction, does not trust Elrick, and does not like Birdie. If that's all you want to know, you can skip to Part 3 without fear.
'What does Sigmar have to say?' The Countess listened to Luitpold's opening bid for peace and responded to his speech with: 'Oh, it's politics, that's what you're here for'. She did this to judge Luitpold's response, expecting him to take exception to her flippant description of his supposedly holy views as just 'politics'. She already knew he organised the meeting, and she expected him to have a pressing reason for doing so. Luitpold took her gentle barb with good grace. The Countess presumed this was because he did not want to offend her. She also concluded from this that Luitpold likely called the meeting for personal reasons, not strictly divinely inspired ones (for all he would likely suggest that Sigmar would agree with him). I.e.: She quickly forms the opinion that it was not Sigmar demanding peace, it was Luitpold, and he was using his blessed position to articulate that view. If Sigmar had desired for the war to stop and had sent this cleric to confirm this, she would have expected there to be a stronger, faith-based response from Luitpold to her simplifying the Divine Plan of Sigmar to... 'just politics'. But that pushback did not come for Luitpold, which relieved Countess. Nobody wants to have to deal with the gods! However, then Morr stepped in...
'The War Wolf howls in the North, the griffon cries above the plain, the fox prowls in the city, and all who would stop them are banished or slain.' Adelaide gave a prophetic statement about the state of the Empire. In response, the Countess rolled her eyes and said, 'Oh, gods!' in exasperation before Adelaide could finish her 'prophecy'. But Adelaide plowed on regardless, almost as if compelled to finish. This concerned the Countess significantly more than Luitpold's introduction, as few continue speaking when the Countess is demonstrably displeased, suggesting Adelaide's statements were more likely to be divinely inspired than not, or that Adelaide is just stupid, rude, or brash (a strong possibility given she's northern, for all her quiet tones). As the Countess was unsure of Adelaide, she immediately questioned her. After Adelaide answered her questions, the Countess turned to Herr Mots and asked if Adelaide's answers were accurate. The Countess was not asking Herr Mots if Adelaide was answering truthfully; she was actually asking if the 'prophecy' spouted by Adelaide was divinely inspired or made up by the priestess for political points. Once Mots realised what the Countess wanted from him, he replied: 'Yes, ma'am.' This was an alarming response from Mots, one that made the Countess immediately take a different approach to the Morrian: she was not just blessed, she was receiving potentially valuable visions.
'You're rather pretty.' To measure Adelaide's intentions, the Countess immediately undermined the Morrian by reducing her to a pretty face that should attend one of her parties. The Countess did not mention the horrendous scarring on Adelaide's neck, purely to see how the priestess would react to being called pretty with such a hideous scar. Was Adelaide self-conscious about her appearance? Was she currying for the Countess's favour? Did Adelaide have a grander purpose for the meeting? Adelaide's response answered all of that to a degree: she immediately deadpanneds that she was 'a hoot at parties'. The Countess appreciated this response, not least because it drew upon Morr's wife, Verena, and her sacred animal, the owl. It was witty and layered and quite unexpected from a Helstein, a Middenlander noble household not exactly known for their charm. So, the Countess decided she wanted to know more and immediately ordered Herr Mots to have Adelaide attend one of her Black Powder Week parties later in the year, which the Morrian wisely chooses not to decline. Fortunately, there was no immediate desire to press her 'visions' as Morr's intentions for Nuln, so the Countess was again somewhat calmer. So far she had some simple answers confirmed? Was the girl prophetic? Possibly. Witty? Certainly. Political? Also yes. This last was confirmed when Adelaide saw she had the Countess's attention and pressed an argument that Boris Todbringer had to be stopped.
More politics? The Countess again feigned boredom with the politics. She had concluded that the current febrile issues between the Grand Privinces were probably why the canons had called the meeting. She was interested to see who would back down from that core message when she demonstrated dissatisfaction with the topic. To help this along, the Countess suggested that the canons instead supply her with spiritual advice. Swiftly, Luitpold and Adelaide claimed that is exactly what they were already doing. It was clear that Luitpold and Adelaide seemed to have the most fervour for their arguments. So far, at least. It was time to find out what the others thought.
'One trusts you speak with a singular voice?' The Countess said this to all six canons. It was a ridiculous statement as Luitpold and Adelaide had already given two different political positions – Luitpold: Peace and neutrality; Adelaide: Join with Reikland. But the Countess cared nothing for appearing foolish – indeed, she often thrives on it. She was fishing to see if the other canons would independently bring their positions to the table. She was also curious to see just how divided the group was and whether they knew how divided they were. If she had to be trapped with the six 'canons' for three hours, she would, at the very least, find out why. And if it did not like the answer, she would make sure that they, as the culprits, regretted wasting her time.
'No!' Elrick immediately and firmly answered the Countess's question. Elrick's intervention not only confirmed that the canons knew they were divided, but it also suggested that someone intended to tackle that: Elrick. If that were the case, the Countess expected Elrick to then lead the conversation so he could steer the other to his way of thinking. So, to see if that was the case, she threw a casual barb to make it harder for Elrick to slip into a prepared speech and force him to adapt his arguments.
'So, the gods can't decide?' The Countess challenged the group to explain why it was there. Were the canons speaking on behalf of their gods? Or did they bring personal opinions to the Countess? Or was it both? As canons, as blessed priests that their cults claim commune with their gods, they were presumably inspired to provide counsel that would please their deities. The Countess had no desire to anger any gods purposefully, so she was keen to determine why each canon was really petitioning her. Were they divinely inspired to be here? Were they opportunists? Were they both? Or was it something else?
Elrick steps in. As the Countess suspected would happen, Elrick stepped in, making it clear that he intended to steer the others. Elrick explained that the gods were undecided. The Countess again disapproved of what was being said with a muttered, 'Gods!', making it clear that she was frustrated by his position. But Elrick plowed on with determination. He claimed Karl-Franz was unfit to be the emperor and that Nuln should join arms with Middenheim. She was a little concerned at this. It is well known that, according to some hardliner Sigmarites, it was tantamount to heresy to claim the emperor, as Sigmar's representative on the imperial throne, is unfit (where 'heresy' here means saying anything that invites the Chaos Gods). Sigmar does not make mistakes according to such, clearly nonsense, thought. A Verenean taking that line was a shock as it was just... seemingly unwise. Under normal circumstances, at least. But it soon became clear that the Verenean had a clear target with his words as he quickly moved from trying to convince her to trying to convince the other canons, and he knew his audience. So, Elrick clearly had an alternative motive for attending the meeting beyond simply directly influencing the Countess. This was confirmed when Adelaide and Luitpold responded firmly to Elrick. The Verenean was challenging their beliefs on purpose, forcing them to justify them before the Countess. The Countess then wondered if that was what Elrick sought to accomplish: to convince all the canons to his way of thinking in front of the Countess so that she was left with only a single obvious choice? Once she concluded that was likely Elrick's intention, she interrupted him as she did not want his argument to dominate.
'Who are you trying to advise, each other or me?' After breaking the brewing arguments with that rhetorical question, she turned all attention to Birgitte to see what the Myrmidian's position was and how strong her convictions were. Under the pressure of the Countess, Birgitte quickly wilted and apologised. This reaction slightly ingratiated the young priestess to the Countess. Capable enemies seeking to influence or outwit her were usually well prepared and capable. This girl appeared to be neither. So, the Countess moved to confirm it.
'I'll put it down to you're foreign.' The Countess insulted Birgitte directly and then told her to '...leave it at that!' And Birgitte wholly folded. That left the Countess relatively confident that the girl didn't have enough backbone to lie to her, so she then asked why Birgitte was attending the meeting, expecting the truth to follow. Birgitte offered some lines about Nuln following the rules of law but siding with the strongest side to ensure Nuln was strong before Elrick took over the conversation again. The Countess, seeing the young girl's uncertainty, concluded Birgitte's neophyte observations were almost certainly based on her personal preferences and were not a divinely inspired position, which would likely cause her to be more desperate and probably certain, maybe without knowing why, so she allowed Elrick to sideline the Myrmidian to see who stepped in next.
Adelaide hates Todbringers! Instead of the conversation developing, bickering ensued. Bickering that revealed Adelaide personally hated the Todbringers enough that she insulted them directly. And that insult caused Birdie to step in.
'That's exactly what a Helstein would say!' Birdie, a Helstein, calling out Adelaide, another Helstein, for insulting the Todbringers almost made the Countess explode with delight. After all, the Helsteins famously hate the Todbringers, but not this Birdie? The Countess wanted to know more. So, she interrupted Elrick's control of the conversation to interrogate Birdie directly and ask if she was calling Adelaide a liar for her damning comments about the Todbringers.
'Yes.' Birdie's answer shocked the Countess. Bickering families are commonplace, but calling a blessed servant of the gods a liar is not a common occurrence in polite company. So, the Countess decided to root out what was happening here. Was Birdie just rude? Or blinded by her desire for the Countess to support Middenheim? Was she willing to say anything to win the day? Or did she have some ulterior motive?
Sigmar Intervenes! Before the Countess could determine the truth of Birdie, Luitpold spoke up for Adelaide by claiming that the Morrian spoke no lies! And, astonishingly, upon hearing that, Birdie immediately backed down and apologised! To repeat, an Ulrican apologised because she was called out by a Sigmarite? The Countess struggled to hide her surprise and was immediately convinced something must be up with Birdie. Her position was contradictory and difficult to understand. The Countess immediately reflected on everything she knew of the Ulrican that she'd learned from Herr Mots to tease out what was happening here.
Verena wants control. The resulting lull was enough for Elrick to retake control of the conversation, and he chose to bring in Gerhardt. The Countess allowed this, happy for Elrick to ensure all voices were heard as she contemplated what she thought of the curious Ulrican.
'Your Imperial Highness.' Gerhardt laid it on thick, suggesting with his opening remark that the Countess should be both pushing to become empress and for peace. He suggested that she should bring the Empire's civil issues to an end and presumably use the existing laws to have Karl-Franz removed for corruption, much as Dieter IV had been a century before. So, according to Gerhardt, Nuln should sit it out, wait, and avoid all conflict while politicking for peace. Very Shallyan, but not delivered with very much conviction. However, that was no surprise. The young Jungfreud clearly wished Karl-Franz removed for personal reasons likely stemming from the annexation of Ubersreik, but he also felt compelled to press for peace as any good Shallyan should. There was little to nothing that suggested Gerhardt was divinely inspired in his position, just well-spoken and keen to marry his personal feelings with what his god would likely prefer. The Countess decided Gerhardt was easy to sideline in this conversation – she could likely predict everything he would say, so she had no pressing reason to ask him any more questions. For the moment, at least.
The Countess Breaks a Little. Birgitte brought up the recent invasion by Tamurkhan (to learn more about that Chaos Lord, watch this Lorebeards episode), believing it to be a good way to bring the Countess onside by flattering her about recent Nuln victories. But Emmanuelle instead grew stony. She harbours many nightmares from the invasion and her cold reaction was genuine. This emotional response annoyed the Countess as she revealed some of her true feelings without intending to, so she took an opportunity Birgitte introduced to change the conversation to Marius Leitdorf's rebellion in Averland (Marius is an ex-(and potentially future)Elector Count of Averland; find out some more about him here). But the ensuing discussion about Marius didn't stabilise her as much as she would have liked, and the Countess finds herself responding to Birgitte more emotionally than she would prefer. So, she calls Herr Mots to produce the letter from 'Marry-me Leitdorf' to give her space to calm down and bring the conversation back on track.
'I think your age is betraying itself.' But it didn't work. The Countess's temper flared. Rather than hold it tight, she unleashes a little of it on Birgitte – not because of the ongoing discussion about Marius, or because Birgitte originally brought up the invasion that caused her so much horror, but because she was interested in the girl and wanted to measure how well the newly installed Abbess took it. There were no complaints and no signs of outrage. The girl wore her heart on her sleeve and clearly had much to learn. After dressing Birgitte down (inexperienced, unsure, naive), the Countess, feeling much better for letting some steam out and also learning that the Abbess was almost certainly going to be a future ally, moves on and decides to tackle the most pressing problem she currently sees in the room: what is going on with Birdie?
'What do you think, Ulric?' The Countess's patience was thin enough to move straight to the woman she liked least: the apologetic Ulrican. Something about Birdie rings false, and the Countess needed more so that she could to judge the girl. When Birdie replied that Nuln should ally with Middenheim, a group that Birdie had already apologised to the Sigmarite for supporting, the Countess called out the contradiction to study how the Ulrican answered. However, before Birdie could reply, Adelaide immediately interrupted to attack the Todbringers again. Emmanuelle had no time for this as she had already decided who and what Adelaide was – devout, witty, political, hated Todbringers – it was Birdie she was trying to pin now. So the Countess interrupts and threw some mud to see if it stuck: she explained to Birdie that Boris had married a cultist of the Ruinous Powers (a 'fact' previously told to her by Herr Mots), whom he laid with and he eventually murdered with his own hands (hinting that there was no trial or any news spread about this), and demanded that Birdie explain why she thinks the Countess should ally with such a fellow. Birdie doesn't show shock or horror at this (did she, a Helstein, already know about it?); she simply claimed that Boris murdered his wife and cleaned the house, which, apparently, shows Boris's better nature. The Countess is somewhat taken aback by the bloodthirsty, cold-hearted response and takes a beat to process it, half convincing herself that this 'canon' could be a cultist, too!
Elrick steps in. Elrick again stepped in as the Countess considered this ridiculous thought (surely Mots would have told her if that was the case!) and regained control of the conversation. He asked Adelaide to restate what her position was. This intervention surprised the Countess a little as Adelaide had already stated a different position to the one Elrick had initially offered. Elrick had wanted to support Middenheim, much like Birdie. Adelaide wanted the opposite. As Adelaide restated her impassioned position, the Countess began to suspect Elrick of... something. She couldn't articulate what it was yet, but it was definitely... something. He sought to bring balance to the conversation – which could be him representing the scales of Verena – but he could also be seeking to steer the conversation to an intended outcome that was different to his original stated goal. If that was the case, had he lied about wanting the Countess to support the Emperor? Unlikely. Yes, Elrick intended something with his interventions, but the Countess was unsure what that was yet.
Dunkelburg. Before the Countess could tackle her growing uncertainty regarding Elrick, the subject of Dunkelburg was brought up. The Countess had secured Dunkelburg in the south of Reikland (as explained in Episode 46.1: Breaking the Siege), a duchy ruled by Karl-Franz's stated heir to be the next emperor, Wolfgang of House Holswig-Adenauer (as confirmed in Episode 10: To Grissenwald). As far as the Countess was concerned, the duchy was now a part of Nuln's lands and always would be. Others bringing up Dunkelburg as if they had a say in the matter was sufficiently annoying that she decided to bring that part of the conversation to an end – she had already talked this out with the Wissenburg Prime Estates at length and was quite bored with the subject. She could feel her simmering temper and didn't want it to slip from her control again. So, she fell back on one of her pre-prepared questions, one she already knew the answer to. That would give her time to settle and think.
'Who called this meeting?' Luitpold immediately confirmed that he called the meeting and explained why: he believed the End Times were coming. Indeed, it soon became apparent that Luitpold was a true believer of the 'End of the World is Nigh'. The Countess didn't believe in such things, so was somewhat disturbed by the conviction Luitpold threw behind his words. So she asked Herr Mots what his position on 'The End Times' was to give herself time to think, fully expecting her spymaster to confirm such talk was nonsense. But Mots did not do that. Instead, he did the opposite. This genuinely disturbed the Countess. Indeed, it upset her so thoroughly that she immediately changed the subject again.
'Herr Mots – Man on the Street.' The Countess took some time to explain the name of her spymaster to give her mind time to rally. She would not typically divulge this, but she was flailing a little at Mots's revelation concerning his opinion on the End Times: did he really believe the literal end of the world was coming? She was going to have a stern word with him afterwards! But, as soon as she is finished with her explanation, Luipold charges on with: 'I've seen visions of Magnus's time. I've seen the debates he had in the chamber that was here before.' Nope. She didn't like that at all. However, the Sigmarite cleric went on to passionately explain that that was why he was petitioning her: he believed an Incursion of Chaos was coming. The Countess could see his reasoning now: he thought peace in the Empire was imperative to ensure its strength, a classic Sigmarite position. Such talk left her thinking of the recent invasion by Tamurkhan again, and she wondered if it was just a feint for a more significant attack to come later, much as she had been advised by her court Celestial a year previously. Not liking the implications of this, she determined to move on when Gerhardt, the quiet canon of Shallya, then spoke up to support Luitpold's claims. Hmm. She decided to steer the conversation to another topic entirely, not liking this one at all, especially not from so-called 'canons', and this time went with a pointed question that could not be easily avoided.
'Tell me what you think of the Mutant Edict.' She asked this of Gerhardt first. His support of the End Times argument made her curious if Gerhardt had any other unexpected views.
Gerhardt: 'Against.' As was half expected, she received an obviously biased reply from the Shallyan. The Countess would have expected a Shallyan to stand for the Edict, but this one was antagonistic to the Emperor for personal reasons involving Ubersreik, which he let overrule his faith in this instance. A little disappointing, but understandable.
Elrick: 'Against, but...' The ex-wizard said precisely what the Countess expected him to say: the Mutant Edict was bad law that needs to be changed, but it is the law.
Birgitte: 'Against.' Again, this response was not a surprise to the Countess. However, what came next near-dammit blew her away...
Luitpold. 'For.' Sigmar went with... FOR? WTF? The Countess immediately became very suspicious of Luitpold. She queried his answer, but Luitpold's conviction, as he explained his reasoning and what happened previously with Magnus the Pious, was almost convincing. Luitpold was perhaps more than simply the self-serving Sigmarite she'd initially suspected.
Birdie. 'Against.' Birdie being against the Edict and claiming her position arose because '...I believe Karl-Franz has a reason for it,' not what that reason could be, or because she believed mutants were bad, did not surprise the Countess for all it was an odd response. She was already deeply suspicious of the Ulrican, and this answer only made her more so.
Adelaide. 'For.' The Morrian's answer also surprised the Countess. So much so that she queried the Morrian's position. The 'unpalatable but understandable' speech that resulted was almost enough for the Countess to start believing that maybe, just maybe, Karl-Franz wasn't mad, especially when Herr Mots then confirmed that what Adelaide concluded was 'not unfair'. Then, against all odds, Luitpold the Sigmarite nailed the pro-mutant argument home even harder with further reasonable evidence.
The Countess found herself considering that Karl-Franz may have been right with his ridiculous Mutant Edict. Just like Magnus was right to legalise Wizards. And it appeared she wasn't alone with this change of mind.'I want to change my position.' Upon listening to Luitpold and Adelaide's arguments, Gerhardt shifted his opinion to 'For'. This is what the Countess had originally expected Gerhardt's position to be, but it was nonetheless unexpected to see him change his mind. Was it a clever ruse on his part, knowing what Luitpold and Adelaide would later say, allowing him to then gracefully change his position to the one he already had? She wouldn't put such manipulation of a conversation past a Jungfreud, but she wasn't sure if the young Shallyan was such a master of debate. He seemed too unpolished. But perhaps that was a ruse also?
Support KF? WTF? So, against her own better judgement, the Countess was potentially considering Reikland as an ally, as if there may be some wisdom in what Karl-Franz was doing and he was the emperor, the most likely figure to bring the mess to an end. Given that she intended to meet Reikland's ambassador after the canons, she was already beginning to form questions she would ask him. Further, Mots had also advised her previously that he considered Reikland the wisest route. He suggested using Dunkelburg as a bargaining chip in that negotiation (forcing Reikland's hand not to contest its annexation in return for her support). Perhaps she should listen?
'Where do you stand?' The Countess decided it was time to clarify the core matter at hand, the very matter she was now considering: where did each canon stand on the civil issues plaguing the Empire?
Adelaide: Support Reikland. This is exactly what the Morrian had been saying from the beginning.
Birdie: Support Middenheim. This is what the Ulrican had repeatedly said from the beginning.
Luitpold: Support Reikland. This surprised the Countess a little, for all it should not have. The Sigmarite had previously presented peace was the way forward, so she did not expect that Luitpold would suggest that supporting the Emperor would be the best route for that. She had expected Neutrality from his earlier arguments. This Sigmarite was more interesting to her with each utterance. A man of conviction, yet still a man who was capable of developing a position and articulating an argument.
Birgitte: Support Reikland. This seemed sensible from Myrmidia. It was the tactical choice and the safe choice. The girl supported the outcome to guarantee Nuln's continued strength, which was Birgitte's stated goal earlier in the conversation.
Elrick: Neutrality. This surprised the Countess a little. But only because it seemed a little out of place for a Verenean position. She expected justice to be called for, but instead, he called out the emperor for breaking his own laws, which strictly he had not, but did not suggest moving against him. The Countess's suspicions of Elrick and his motivations deepened significantly at this. The Verenean was clearly showing his colours.
Gerhardt: Neutrality. So Shallyan. So predictable.
Because of all that, as the break arrived, the Countess had formed some strong opinions concerning the canons and their advice. In alphabetical order:
Adelaide. The Countess was charmed by Adelaide's dry wit and insight, so she found the Morrian intriguing enough to pursue further. Also, Adelaide's visions and insights, if real, could be useful as more than a party trick, especially as her hatred of the Todbringers would likely make her more straightforward to manage than most Northerners. Of all the canons, this was the one the Countess personally liked most.
Birdie. By comparison, Birdie was the canon the Countess liked least. She was a poor Ulrican, a worse noble, and someone with inconsistent opinions and positions. Because of this, the Countess was deeply suspicious of her. Indeed, quiet part of her thought the girl may have sworn to very different gods than the one she claimed.
Birgitte. The Countess was considering taking the Myrmidian under her wing to educate the girl in proper politics and secure her as an ally. The Countess thought she could gain the support of the city-state's Myrmidians for a generation if the girl were fostered correctly. The Myrmidian was biddable and young enough that the Countess could likely secure her for life.
Elrick. The Countess did not trust Elrick at all. Indeed, she half-believed that he might not even be a Verenean, for all such thoughts seemed ridiculous given the circumstances. If not for the law stating she had to give three hours of her time to the six canons, she would likely have had him dismissed. Given his general demeanour, her current suspicion was that he was a Grey Wizard (but she is admittedly a little paranoid in that area). She firmly believed the Grey Order had previously attempted to influence her by infiltrating her court on multiple occasions. Although not publicly known, she had banned the Grey Order from her city for personal reasons (more on that later). Of course, that did little to stop them from passing through or even attempting to establish a presence in Nuln, but it gave her an excuse to eject them as and when she wished with little argument from them.
Gerhardt. So far, he had done nothing to attract her attention. He seemed to be a somewhat typical noble priest, with the usual push and pull of loyalties between cult and house this can entail. He had said nothing to impress her, so she put little weight in his opinion even though it matched her current preferences.
Luitpold. She was genuinely impressed with the young man's convictions and ability to articulate them. Yes, he was unpolished, but he was also passionate and convincing. At that point, she planned to have him watched and possibly brought into her court if he continued to appear useful.
So, here is a quick summary of what the Countess has concluded so far:
1) None of the canons have convinced the Countess that their gods have driven them here. Instead, she believes they were all speaking on their own behalf, for their own personal beliefs, and not that of their gods. She is rather relieved about that, too.
2) Adelaide and Luitpold were the most devout and taken with their positions. They were also the most convincing. But not convincing enough to shift her opinion on the ongoing conflicts in the EMpire, for all she is now thinking that Karl-Franz may not be quite as maddened as she once thought.
3) Elrick was intelligent, structured in his arguments, and somewhat contradictory in his position. He manipulated the ongoing conversation frequently, leaving the Countess deeply suspicious of his true motivations. By the halfway point, she suspects Elrick may be an agent of the Grey College. His methodologies reek of Grey Wizard to her, and she believes they frequently make inroads into her orbit. Under other circumstances, she would kick him out – he's suspicious enough, and she trusts her instincts.
4) Yeah, the Countess did not like her at all. Too blunt. Too bloodthirsty. Too contradictory. Too passive. Too UnUlrican. Like Elrick, the Countess would love to kick her out – life's too short; if Birdie is what she says she is, she can petition again and be more convincing – but the law is the law.
5) Gerhardt is not worth her time. A predictable Reikland noble lost in a cult he does not understand. She almost pities him. But mostly because she knows his father.
6) Birgitte may appear to have received most of the Countess's ire at this point, but she rather liked the young, naive abbess and was considering taking her under her wing. Either by having her attend her court over the winter or something more direct, depending upon how the girl and her cult responded to the offer.
7) The Countess was thoroughly unconvinced by the End Times talk, but was disturbed by it.
8) COUNTESS'S DIRECTION: The Countess had not heard enough, so far, to shift her preferred position, which was to continue Nuln's march through the Vorbergland in Reikland, to ignore Middeheim, to annex Sudenland as quietly as possible, and to ignore Averland. That position could be summed as: MOSTLY STAY NEUTRAL IN THE MIDDENHEIM/REIKLAND CONFLICT.
But then it all changed. The break occurred. I give each PC a choice.
Want to know what those choices are?
PART 3) CHOICES!
This is the part that so many of you have been asking questions about. What were the players actually playing? How long has this been planned? WTF IS GOING ON!?
Well, during the break, each player was given a choice about the PC they were playing. And this choice was, in every case, pretty big. The presented choice also explained to the player WTF was going on with the character they were playing.
Notably, each player decided what would happen here, not me.
This isn't one of those situations where I screwed with everyone and pull the narrative rug from under their feet. This was quite the opposite. The players were the ones who were to decide everything. They had complete control.
So, why did I do it this way?
Because the players must have agency over the major decisions for their PCs. We GMs present the world and its inhabitants, and that can sometimes include things that can significantly change PCs. Of course, the players negotiate through that world, but if that world significantly changes a PC, then I always prefer for the player to be the one who decides how. It's their character. Their avatar. The thing that lets them have fun in the game world. So, if that character is to potentially undergo a massive change, I prefer to have more than just a buy-in (such as the one that the Roleplaying Content and Consent form kinda provides) – I want the player to actively choose the change and want it to happen. So, my players were given complete narrative control over what would happen next. I didn't demand anything. I gave no preference. I left it to them to go where they wanted.
Want to know what they each decided for their characters?
ED
Ed was given the following choice:
Was the Gerhardt he was playing in Nuln:
1) The Real Gerhardt?
2) A BIG RAT Skaven creation?
After much consideration (which, thankfully, Ed flat-out loved agonising over), he decided that the Gerhardt he was playing in Nuln was the real Gerhardt and that the one in the Middle Mountains was a BIG RAT duplicate.
Oh boy...
That meant:
Nuln = 'Real' Gerhardt
Middle Mountains = BIG RAT Skaven Creation
Well, gosh. We now know the Gerhardt we've been following through the Power Behind the Throne and The Horned Rat is a BIG RAT duplicate. That's what Ed chose, so that's what Ed got.
What he didn't expect was what came after making the decision. Because he chose option 1, 'The Real Gerhardt', he also received the following bonus:
The Gerhardt Skaven Creation in the Middle Mountains gains a Fate Point if:
The Countess chooses Neutrality
That was the position Gerhardt had already argued for before the break. And, unbeknownst to him, it's also what the Countess was leaning towards! So, would he score a Fate point?
If he'd chosen option 2, he would have had this bonus instead:
Gerhardt in the Middle Mountains gains a Fate Point if:
The Countess chooses Reikland
Cos that's what the BIG RAT controller wanted (and we'll get more about who that is in Episode 58: The Rise of the Horned Rat!).
DAN
Dan was given the following choice:
Was the Elrick he was playing in Nuln:
1) Christoph Engel?
2) A BIG RAT Skaven creation?
For those who may not remember, Christoph Engel was the Grey Wizard from Episode 9.5: The Wizard's Way, the one who took a special interest in Elrick. His name has popped up several times during the campaign, and the wizard has been noted for his high position in the Grey Order. Further, as shown in Episode 39.1: Human Skool, where Dan played a Grey Wizard, some Greys can appear as others when they are seeking to influence and spy (a capability Engel definitely has for those of you who know the character from Vermintide).
Dan didn't like the idea that the BIG RAT may have copied Elrick at any point, so he chose option 1. So...
Nuln Elrick = Christoph Engel
Elrick was never copied by BIG RAT.
That meant Dan was given the following, as Engels, the character he was playing, had an agenda:
Elrick in the Middle Mountains gains a Fate point if:
The Countess chooses Neutrality.
This was the position Elrick had already argued for. And, as with Ed, it's exactly what the Countess was currently considering. So, he had a good chance for a Fate point here even though the Countess already suspected him as a Grey Wizard.
If he'd chosen the opposite, he would have had this bonus instead:
Elrick in the Middle Mountains gains a Fate Point if:
The Countess chooses Reikland
SAGE
Ah, the first of our non-doubles. This choice is, well, you'll see...
Was Birgitte, the Abbess of the Monastery of the Dark Maiden and leader of the Leorican sect of Myrmidia:
1) A vampire?
2) A human?
I'm not going to explain this yet. However, I will say that Sage went with option 1 after having a good thought. That means...
The Monastery of the Dark Maiden is directly tied to vampires.
Sage was then given the following bonus. Because, if the Leoricans are associated with vampires, EVERYTHING changes for them. And they have a preferred outcome:
Ume in the Middle Mountains gains a Fate point if:
The Countess chooses Middenheim.
Uh oh. That outcome is not what Birgitte argued for before the break. There, she was pushing for Nuln to support Reikland. Will her change of heart be spotted?
If Sage chose 'human', we would have had a completely different story for the Leoricans, and she would have had this as her bonus instead:
Ume in the Middle Mountains gains a Fate Point if:
The Countess chooses Reikland.
ANDY
Andy was given the following choice:
Was the Luitpold he was playing in Nuln:
1) The Real Luitpold, with the Shadow in the north?
2) Luitpold's Shadow, with Real Luitpold in the north?
For those who may not remember, Luitpold has a double of himself running around that looks, acts, thinks, and even receives the same visions as him, as first confirmed in Episode 22: The Traitor. This was our opportunity to resolve this part of the story, and Andy loved it. After asking some questions to make sure he chose the best story from his perspective, Andy went with option 1.
Wow. Err... that was big. So...
Nuln Luitpold = Real Luitpold
Middle Mountains Luitpold = Shadow Luitpold.
So the Luitpold we watched wander through the Power Behind the Throne and The Horned Rat was actually a hungry spirit from the Shadowrealm. Uh oh. Episode 58 was going to be fun, as it's the last episode of The Horned Rat, so that plot will be resolved.
That meant Andy was given the following bonus, as Luitpold in Nuln has a goal, and it was Andy's to decide. Yup, unlike everyone else, Andy had free will here. That meant:
Luitpold in Nuln gains a Fate point if:
The Countess chooses either Reikland, Neutrality, or Middenheim - Andy's choice, to be made during the break.
Andy spent very little time deciding on this. He immediately went with what he had already argued: Reikland! So:
Luitpold in Nuln gains a Fate point if:
The Countess chooses Reikland.
Andy didn't know that the Countess was still leaning away from that outcome before the break, but it was also fair to say that Luitpold had been convincing in the first part of the episode, so he might be able to swing her to his position.
If he'd chosen the opposite, he would have instead had the following:
Luitpold in the Middle Mountains gains a Fate Point if:
The Countess chooses Neutrality.
Why? We'll never know coz it didn't happen...
CATH
This choice will be easy to guess given Birdie's story so far, but here it comes anyway:
Was the Birdie that Cath was playing in Nuln:
1) The Real Birdie?
2) A BIG RAT Skaven creation?
Cath took almost no time to consider this. She liked the Knights Panther version of the character and wanted that to be the real Birdie, meaning that what the Skaven Engineer told her in Episode 55: Dead Ringers was a lie. So...
Nuln = BIG RAT copy
Middle Mountains = Real Birdie
It seemed a Big Rat Skaven creation had infiltrated the Canons! I loved that! It was kinda massive, in fact, as GM Blog 58 will discuss, as it decides what the Skaven Plot with the duplicates is. More on that later. Cath then got the following:
Birdie in the Middle Mountains gains a Fate Point if:
The Countess chooses Reikland
That means that BIG RAT tried to take control of the Birdie duplicate and demanded a change in direction towards Reikland and supporting Karl-Franz! That would be a toughie, as Birdie was blessed by Ulric and had vociferously argued for Middenheim previously. Further, the Countess was not really leaning to Reikland.
Yet, at least.
If she'd chosen the opposite, Cath would have had this instead:
The Birdie Clone in the Middle Mountains gains a Fate Point if:
The Countess chooses Middenland.
But that didn't happen.
LINDSAY
And, finally, the last of our non-doubles. This is what Lindsay had to choose:
Was Adelaide:
1) Adelaide?
2) Sheru-tar Gee'taru? >:O
This enormous choice was far more important than Lindsay first realised. Upon initially hearing it, it felt like an obvious choice to her. She liked Adelaide and wanted her to be the real deal. She also didn't want Adelaide to have been eaten – which is how that daemon copies others in LAWhammer – so she went with keeping her character alive. So...
Nuln Adelaide = Real Adelaide
But that also meant...
Sheru-tar Gee'taru was not in Nuln, so was at large elsewhere.
Lindsay didn't consider the last bit until after she made her choice. And then she wished she'd perhaps made the pesky daemon plaguing the PCs be in Nuln, as far from the Jaegers as possible. But that didn't happen; we were fixed to Adelaide's agenda. That also meant:
Alamennowyth in the Middle Mountains gains a Fate point if:
The Countess chooses Reikland.
That shouldn't be too hard for Lindsay to pass off. It's precisely what Adelaide had argued for before the break.
Maybe Nuln was destined to support Reikland, after all? We now had three PCs potentially about to argue that line!
If Lindsay had chosen for Adelaide to be the daemon, we would have instead had:
Alamennowyth in the Middle Mountains gains a Fate Point if:
The Countess chooses Neutrality.
But that was not to be.
So, all six players had made their decisions, and the entire story had changed because of it. Not only was Gerhardt in the north now a Skaven copy, but the Luitpold with him was a SHADOWY DAEMON-THING. That was going to be fun to resolve in the next episode!
If the players had chosen differently, all the PCs in the north could have been the 'real' versions. But that is not what they chose.
The players wanted to tell a different story.
Episode 58, the conclusion to all of our 'duplicate' stories and the conclusion to our version of The Horned Rat, was going to be fun! After all, Andy was now going to be playing a Shadowy Daemony-thing!
The last thing I'll say is that I had no idea what the truth of our Glorious Heroes would be before this episode. Yes, I was aware certain PCs could be 'doubles' if that's what their players wanted, but it would always be the players' choices that decided whether that was the case or not, not mine. That way I could be certain they all liked what happened, even if it utterly screwed with their characters.
That also means that all the stories I'd been spinning up to that point were designed to allow for both potentials for all the PCs in question. Not too hard to do in practice. But hard enough that I had to be careful with the storytelling.
But now I had answers. It was time to put some of those to use.
And with that interlude over, we dived back into play. Here comes...
Part 4) More of the Countess's Thoughts
It was a long break for those watching live. Many decisions had been made, and the players were super excited to see what impact their choices would have and if they could score any extra Fate points.
If you've watched the episode, you already know what the Countess concluded by the end. But, let's see how she got there.
I'll cover what happened next in much the same way as Part 2) The Countess's Thoughts.
'There are forces at work.' Herr Mots was too subtle with his hints to guide the Countess with this comment, so she demanded that he be blunt. Her patience was already wearing thin. And what Mots said next sets everything off for part 2...
'Not everyone may be what they say they are.' Herr Mots said what we all know straight. Mots is the kinda guy who can spot this stuff. Why? Well, no point mincing words: if you've been paying attention, you'll know that Herr Mots is 'Djoros of the Thousand Masques', Alamennowyths 'master', the Avatar of the Mistwalker in the Mortal Realms, the elf in the Tier 6 slot of the Path of Shadows (so, somewhat like the equivalent of Grand Theogonist of Sigmar, but for the elf god Ladrielle), a character first introduced in Episode 2.6: Family Ties. And, while he may have been 100% human at that point, he could still sense that there was altogether too much Grey magic in the Magnus Chamber and that he couldn't trace its source. That being the case, Mots was certain that at least one of the people in the room was not what they claimed to be. So, he told the Countess openly. And she responded in kind...
'Does anyone wish to admit it?' The Countess, vaguely amused by Herr Mots openness (he's not known for it) and already half-convinced Elrick was a Grey Wizard, starts with a direct question. Adelaide, as outraged as her broken voice allowed, dove right in to claim she was definitely who and what she claimed to be. The fact that no one bar Adelaide expressed surprise that claims of false identities were being bandied around genuinely fascinated the Countess. There were no cries of 'ridiculous' or 'how dare you' or anything similar. Instead, they all just eyed each other warily. The Countess was quietly delighted by this. The canons had almost expected Mots's claim! What an exciting development! They were all used to this kind of accusation barring, perhaps, Adelaide! And none, barring perhaps Adelaide, had the guile to hide it!
'Well, this is an exciting game!' This was a 100% genuine response from the Countess. She was quite taken by the canons' responses. They were all so... shifty! She loved the way the mood in the room changed and immediately started wondering if she could duplicate it at one of her Blackpowder Week parties, perhaps with a prize attached. The Countess was ready to invent an entirely new genre of Hidden Roles game for her court after this!
Anyone have a cool name for the new party game she's concocting?'How many do you think, Herr Motts?' The Countess was now pulling apart all the conversations she'd had so far. She had already decided that the most likely candidate for duplicity was Elrick – the shiftiest, and also the most balanced and guiding in his responses. It stank of a Grey Wizard, and she rather despised Greys for childhood reasons, so she almost wanted an imposter to be a Grey. But what if there were more than one imposter? With that thought teasing her mind, she asked Mots how many of the canons could be imposters. His response was designed to annoy, ending with: 'Did you not tell me yourself that you can make your own decisions?' (which also hints at an interesting conversation from the past).
'You're lucky I have no plates.' The Countess is famous for flinging them when she's in a mood, a Nuln piece of gossip that happens to be partially true (but mostly when she's gifted another set of decorative plates from one of the other Electors). The Countess is quite aware of her plate-flinging reputation and often leans into it to verbalise her displeasure. And being taunted by Mots was not something she'd let stand without letting him know. Reasoning, correctly, that he didn't actually know the answer to her question, she immediately started interviewing her canons herself.
'Who wants me to war with Reikland?' So she started by asking what the canons advised her to do next. She did this because she wanted to watch the canons' reactions more closely. Elrick immediately stepped in to answer, followed by Luitpold, who emphasised that the war should be stopped. But then Adelaide lobbied hard for siding with Reikland. Swiftly followed by Birgitte, who began to argue in a completely different direction. And, really, the Countess loved it all. There was a genuine puzzle that Mots had laid at her feet, and she aimed to detangle it. Her annoyance at what had come before the break melted away, but one thing did prickle her a little as it made it harder for her to read the canons.
'I am in the room. Talk to me.' The canons started to argue with each other, ignoring the Countess. But the Countess wanted them to pitch their arguments at her so she could watch their faces as they engaged directly. However, upon seeing Birgitte and Elrick argue about whether the laws of the Empire mattered, she realised she could learn just as much without having to be the centre of attention, especially once Gerhardt also stepped in with his attempts to channel the arguments to his line of thinking. So she let the canons fire at each other and sat back to watch. Sadly without popcorn.
'IT'S A CRIT, BABY!' And then Andy Critted a test to receive a vision to support his position. And, as I said to Andy at the time, it was gonna suck for him. Why? Because his vision was about to suggest Luitpold go in a very different direction to what would secure Andy a Fate point for Luitpold. What did the vision suggest? It suggested that the Countess was best siding with whomever was with Alemennowyth. And Alamennowyth, as Adelaide confirmed, was in Middenheim. So, would Andy ditch chasing the Fate point and change his argument from supporting Reikland to supporting Middenheim?
'Perhaps two women can do what two men cannot, and save the Empire?' Adelaide claimed that Alamennowyth was with Princess Katerina in Middenheim. And this was enough to persuade Luitpold. He was immediately convinced that Emmanuelle+Katerina was the ONE TRUE WAY, and Andy ditched chasing a Fate point and instead lobbied hard for the Countess to support Middenheim. The Countess was stunned at the speed of this turnaround. Luitpold even went so far as to suggest that Emmanuelle marry Katerina! The Countess was amused by this, and suggested her court may be disappointed at the diminished chance of an heir. But Luitpold was having none of that and claimed...
'I understand there are magical means, right?' This excited statement from Luitpold that there may be ways for women to conceive children together genuinely excited the Countess in turn. Could she have a child with a woman? Or, more hopefully, could someone else carry a child to term on her behalf? However, at the thought of having children, her mood turned somber. She thought back to her youth and the pain that lay there. And when the conversation turned to discussing making correct decisions, the Countess slipped a very real opinion:
'We can all make errors of judgment.' This was heartfelt. The Countess was thinking of Karl-Franz and the Altdorf court with that comment. More on that later in the blog. Elrick, upon hearing that, replied that one should learn from such moments, attempting to support his argument with her observations, and all the Countess could muster in reply was: 'We can try.' She was briefly overwhelmed by one of the largest mistakes of her early life and was very close to sending everyone from the Chamber, the law bedamned – they could reclaim their time later. But, three things stopped this: 1) She obeyed the law, unlike her father; 2) The canons were a puzzle; 3) Bloodymindedness.
'I still stand by what I said: the emperor is the emperor.' That sole line from Adelaide almost broke the Countess. She would have preferred for Karl-Franz, the source of much of her heartache, not be mentioned in the conversation. But she could not and would not let it defeat her. Nevertheless, the Countess fell silent in response.
'I am in the room.' The Countess eventually pulled herself together and interrupted Luitpold as he explained Alamennowyth's prophecy, turning the focus of the argument back to herself. This, in turn, led to Luitpold explaining about Alamennowyth and the Purple Hand. The Countess let this wash over her, occasionally interrupting as Luitpold and Elrick wrestled to control the conversation.
'We must divine a way to uncover the imposter.' Adelaide then broke their argument. She had had enough of the general chat and interrupted with her desire to remove the potentially corrupt element from the room, a point she had opened the episode with (her words were only for the blessed). And she was vociferous about it. The Countess strongly approved of this as it brought the conversation back to what interested her: the game of uncovering the imposters. And that led to the Countess asking the question that set us towards the end game: 'Who are the imposters?' And Luitpold then received a vision as Andy deployed one of his talents...
'Two are false.' The game was afoot. Luipold had a vision that two of the canons were false. This both fascinated and terrified the Countess. It fascinated her as she may now have an answer she could trust. It terrified her as Sigmar's presence might have literally been in the Magnus Chamber with her. She asked Mots if Sigmar had really just visited them. Mots suggested that he had. For the Countless, this was a definitive moment. It firmly moved Luitpold to the 'trust' pile rather than the 'distrust' pile. So, when Luitpold claimed he'd received revelation that two in the room were false, she decided to believe that.
A Double-sided Vision. As we continue with the Countess's thought-process, let's also note that Luitpold recognised that there are not just two imposters in the Nuln group, he also saw that there were also two imposters in the other group in the north. What's that about, eh? Well, let's not dwell on that too much just now – Episode 58 will cover it. First, we will wrap up the Countess and her thoughts. Not much to go now.
Actually, one more thing before that...
'Herr Mots, is this what to was like with Magnus?' This was a very telling quotation from the Countess. Emotionally vulnerable and somewhat caught up with the game she was pursuing, the Countess let this line slip. In essence, it confirms that the Countess knows that Herr Mots knew what once happened in Magnus's court, which confirms the Countess knows Herr Mots is more than just a 'spymaster'. Given the conversation up to that point, if any character could have been expected to divine what had happened in the court of Magnus, it would surely have been Luitpold, the man who claimed he had had visions of the place, but she instead turned to Herr Mots. Very telling.
Anyway, back to it. We're almost done.
THEY ARGUE MORE. The Countess watched the unfolding arguments with interest as she mulled which two canons were likely imposters. Luitpold continued to counsel war with Reikland, going against his personal beliefs as a Sigmarite. Birgitte counselled the same. Elrick doggedly stuck to advising peace, but then we got this line...
'Karl-Franz is under the sway of the Ruinous Powers!' Andy fell into Sheerargetru's trap for a second time – he was drawing from information gleaned from Episode 46.1: Breaking the Siege, not from information Lutipold knew, when he said this. But that trap was already sprung for the episode, so I won't penalise him twice, as that could quickly spiral out of hand. For not unsurprising reasons, the certain claim that KF had fallen was pretty damning for the poor emperor, especially when Luitpold ropes in Mots to provide the proof of it all. Mots wouldn't be drawn by Luitpold, but the Countess forced him to confirm or deny Luitpold's claims. And Mots confirmed that Luitpold was not lying about what he believed to be accurate. This is the final proof the Countess required that Luitpold was not one of the imposters. So, it was now time to find the two who were.
'And I do have a rather pressing appointment with the ambassador from Reikland.' So, the Countess tried to make one of the imposters slip. The importance of what was being decided in the meeting was underlined when she explained that she was about to meet the Reikland ambassador. She asserted this to pressure the canons, then immediately demanded that each confirm what they advised her to do. So, they did:
Adelaide: Support Reikland. Her position was unchanged; she also admitted that she believed supporting Reikland would end in Death (hardly a ringing endorsement!).
Birdie: Support Middenheim. Birdie did not shift her opinion from part 1, which is the opposite of what would earn Birdie in the north a Fate point. Cath decided that Ulric overrode the BIG RAT (her choice entirely) and that Birdie would not shift her opinion.
Luitpold: Support Katerina (Middenheim). This is noteworthy change of opinion, and it would also stop Luitpold gaining a fate point in the north. That's now two PCs 'doing the right thing'.
Birgitte: Support Middenheim (and war in Averland and Sudenland). This is also a shift in opinion. The Myrmidian seemed to have been swung by Luitpold's vision and his arguments. And this would also gain Ume a Fate point if the Countess agreed to also back it.
Elrick: Neutrality. Keep out of the war. His position was unchanged. And a Fate point would come his way if the Countess agreed.
Gerhardt: Neutrality. His position was also unchanged, and it would score him a Fate point if the Countess was convinced.Silver Hammer/Flame. Having held it for most of the meeting, Elrick then called out Luitpold for initially saying that he was from the Order of the Silver Hammer before the break when he said he was from the Order of the Silver Flame after the break. And he used this to accuse Luitpold of being an imposter.
However, the Countess knew that Luitpold had been a member of both orders in his time, and recently. She also knew that meeting her (and seeing her ridiculous Attractive 8 talent; check Rough Nights & Hard Days for more on that) can be stressful for many, as can meeting royalty. People often fluster and make mistakes in her presence. However, spies and fakes, those desperate to convince others of their identity, rarely made such errors. So, Elrick's accusation failed to land, but it did do something else:
1) It provided further evidence for the Countess that Luitpold was not an imposter as he he's was just too unpolished to get that far and be successful.
2) It pushes Elrick yet further into the imposter territory in her eyes as the accusation was purposefully held and timed for maximum effect.'Four of the individuals in this room are in Middenheim.' Then Adelaide drops the bombshell she'd been keeping for the entire meeting: she admits that she knows that four of the canons in the room have doubles in Middenheim. The tension rises when Birdie and Gerhardt then claim that Adelaide's assertions must be lies. But...
CRIT NUMBER TWO! Luitpold does an augury on Adelaide and his rolled bones tell him that the Morrian is, as a source:
GOOD
Not only that, but his Crit scored three key facts about Adelaide. So, he learned that...
1) Adelaide was definitely blessed by Morr.
2) Adelaide was Morr's Eyes in the Mortal Realms (whatever that meant),
3) Adelaide was faithful in what she said about the four doubles in the north.
And with Luitpold's bones giving a clear result, and with that result being shared, the Countess had enough to make her decision as to who the imposters were. But she wanted to confirm her suspicions to be sure.WHO IS THE IMPOSTER? To confirm her thinking, she turned to Birgitte, whom she was now sure was not an imposter, and asked the Myrmidian who she thought was an imposter. She then asks everyone the same thing. And this is what they each claimed:
Birgitte: She called out Luitpold and Elrick. The Countess had already concluded Luitpold was fine, so she discounted that. So, one vote for Elrick.
Birdie: Suspected no one and wasn't willing to make a guess. The Countess found that DEEPLY SUSPICIOUS!
Gerhardt: Birdie and Elrick! And... as you know if you paid attention during Part 3) Choices, Gerhardt was correct with this guess!
Elrick: Luitpold and Gerhardt. The Countess doesn't trust this as she doesn't trust Elrick, but it was interesting to see who he picked.
Adelaide: Gerhardt and Birgitte. The Countess is unconvinced by this, especially the choice of Birgitte, but then this happens:
Luitpold: Gerhardt and Birgitte. The Countess took this much more seriously as she was certain Luitpold was not an imposter and was also slowly concluding that he was a decent judge of character, so this shakes her suppositions up to this point. She was certain Birgitte the naive was not an imposter, but now the most reliable seer at the table had singled her out. Further, she had also discounted Gerhardt, too, as he seemed innocuous. But now both Adelaide and Luitpold were fingering the same canons. However, then the following occured:GERHARDT FLIP-FLOPS: Gerhardt changed his accusations, clearly hurt that his 'friend' Luitpold should call him out as an imposter. So, he accused Luitpold of being an imposter in turn! This confirmed to the Countess that the noble Shallyan's temper and character were suspect, just as she had earlier judged, and that also made it less likely to her that Gerhardt was an imposter. The Jungfreud boy was simply a reactionary young man out of his depth. But, if that was true, then Luitpold and Adelaide, both of whom the Countess was also certain were not imposters, must have it wrong with their accusations, no matter how certain they sounded. So...
'I had an opinion, and it's now been shattered.' The Countess wasn't exaggerating when she said this. Let's sum up where she was at that point.
- Luitpold was receiving visions from Sigmar. So, she was convinced he was not an imposter.
- However, the Countess had also determined Luitpold must have some facts wrong, even though he was arguing just as strongly for them, as she was absolutely certain that Gerhardt was not an imposter. So, that meant there must by a difference between visions that were revelations and undeliable and visions that he did not fully understand, so drew conclusions from them. The second type, the visions, the Countess figured, Luitpold could, and likely did, sometimes misinterpret. But, the problem was that he nevertheless argued that is visions were as definite as his revelations, and that was problematic, making him less trustworthy as a source.
- The only times Luitpold received revelations, he learned, as far as the Countess could recall:
1) That two of the six canons were imposters.
2) That a mysterious figure in Middenheim was the correct route for Nuln to ally with.
3) That Adelaide was not an imposter and that she had not lied about seeing four doubles in the north.
- Revelation 1 confirmed the number of imposters.
- Revelation 2 confirmed the correct direction Nuln should lean, assuming she wished to change her mind.
- Revelation 3 confirmed that Adelaide recently saw Luitpold, Elrick, Gerhardt, and Birdie when she was last in Middenheim.
- That meant Luitpold, Elrick, Gerhardt, and Birdie were the obvious options for duplicates, especially as Luitpold confirmed with his 1st revelation, two of the six were imposters and it was 'double-sided'. Ie, there were two imposters here and two imposters in Middenheim! So, it was certain that the two imposters must be from the Luitpold, Elrick, Gerhardt, and Birdi group. And given it wasn't Luitpold...
- That meant the Countess was left with a choice of Gerhardt, Elrick, and Birdie for the two imposters.
- Her gut immediately thought it was Elrick and Birdie, and had from the beginning. However, both Adelaide and Elrick had pointed out Gerhardt as a potential imposter, so she could not discard that as a possibility. It was time to reassess what she knew about the Shallyan, Verenean, and the Ulrican.
- Gerhardt: He mainly discussed Shallyan peace balanced against his understandable hurt at the Emperor's attack on his household. He seemed innocuous and a little foolish, which was made all the more evident when he was accused by Luitpold of being an imposter and Gerhardt childishly lashed out. Gerhardt was, as far as the Countess could tell, just a scared young man chosen by an uncaring god negotiating a situation where he was out of his depth.
- Elrick: By comparison, Elrick was controlling and accusatory, balanced and clever, and surprisingly accommodating of different views even when they stood contrary to his own. He was also attempted to undermine Luitpold's revelations by accusing him of having a fabricated tale concerning the Sigmarite's religious order. Because of this, the Countess remained convinced Elrick was an imposter and was almost certain he was a Grey Wizard in disguise. Everything he said and did reeked of Grey Magisterial training.
- Birdie: By comparison, she had no idea what Birdie was, beyond the vaguest feelings she was just wrong. The Ulrican had barely said anything for over half the meeting, which for an Ulrican is odd. She had also flip-flopped, and when called for an opinion, she had retreated. Worse, when was told to apologise by a Sigmarite, she had, and without any proof that she should do so. Birdie was just... not right. But did that make her an imposter?
On the balance of the choice before her, yes. So, just like the players during the break, the Countess made a choice: she decided the most likely imposters were:
Elrick and Birdie.So The Countess Has Elrick and Birdie Arrested. And, as it turned out, she got it right in both cases. This was extremely lucky, as much of her evidence for her conclusion was drawn from before the episode's break, when neither Dan nor Cath knew they were playing imposters! But, the Countess wasn't to know that! She almost went with Elrick and Gerhardt. But, ultimately, she didn't think Gerhardt had enough guile to pull the wool over her eyes.
MIDDENHEIM, HERE COMES THE GUNS! Given that was the case, the Countess, upon reflection, was also swung by the Middenheim argument, and largely because of Luitpold.
So... Ding, Ding, Ding, Sage secures a Fate Point for Ume as that was what she was gunning for! Poor Andy did not, for all he did the heavy lifting. And Cath didn't either, although she did support that position.
A big decision by the Countess there. And we got there through a mixture of PC argument, lucky dice rolls, and circumstance.
As mentioned earlier in the blog, the Countess had intended to stay neutral, but her belief in Luitpold's revelation was strong, and the arguments he made to support it were compelling. Adelaide and Gerhardt were clearly blinded by their personal situations, so she discounted their recommendations. And Birdie and Elrick she outright ignored as they were her chosen imposters.
By comparison, Herr Mots had strongly counselled that she back Reikland and bring the sorry mess to a swift end. The Countess would have gone that way if there were compelling reasons to do so, but she could not see one that she was willing to accept.
Which, to be blunt, suited her preferences fine. Why? Well, that's explained in Part 5) Wrap-up.
Part 5) Wrap Up
This last part is comparatively short but super important for what will come next in our campiagn.
'You can fuck off!' So, at the end of the episode, the Countess is enormously blunt to the Reikland ambassador, but she's letting loose some steam that's been building for more than a decade. This is not the diplomatic situation that Reikland expected. The Countess has previously been a reliable, although sometimes capricious, ally. So, why does the Countess go so hard with the ambassador? Well, Ludwig Schwartzhelm, the ambassador in question, was fully aware of Emmanuelle and Karl-Franz's 'childhood relationship'; indeed, he encouraged it. What do I mean by this? Well, the problem was that it wasn't Karl-Franz's childhood, it was just hers. The age difference between the two is 8 years, almost 9 (that's assuming we go with the Enemy in Shadows Companion's ages - which LAWhammer does - but if we went with Warhammer 8E's version found in the Warhammer: The Empire, the age gap is a much larger: 15 years).
They met at functions down through the years – especially at the Balls, the 20 formal functions held in Altdorf every year. Emmanuelle was the joy of Nuln at these events, and Karl-Franz the pride of Altdorf, and the pair 'grew up together', if such words can be fairly used when the age gap is that wide.
The pair eventually hooked up when Emmanuelle was young enough to know no better and Karl-Franz was old enough to know better, especially given they were not married. Later, Emmanuelle came to rule Nuln at the tender age of just 17.
Many in Reikland claimed that Emmanuelle only became Elector Countess afterwards because she had seduced their new emperor, Karl-Franz. The truth was far from that.
So, the Countess, now 27, finally shared her much more mature opinion of Schwarthelm to his face. And she was delighted to tell them where he, Karl-Franz, and the whole bloody court of Altdorf, could go.'I'm off to speak to the Ambassador for the Trott Embassy.' The Countess has been receiving overtures from the Trotts. She has also been roundly dismissing them. But, because of the events of Episode 57, she has decided to change that position. So, who is the ambassador she has decided to meet? It's none other than Lucita Nuvala, who was sent by Alamennowyth to Nuln to bring the Countess onside against Reikland back in Episode 9.4: Awakenings.
So, that plan appears to have landed unexpectedly well because of our southern Glorious Heroes.'He should have said that when I was pregnant.' And there we have the line that explains why the Countess was so angry with Karl-Franz and the court of Altdorf. What a freaking mess. This episode confirms that in LAWhammer Emmanuelle fell pregnant to Karl-Franz and that a marriage did not result because of court pressures in the imperial capital. So, does that mean we have a child of Emmanuelle and Karl-Franz out there in our game? Well, that would be telling. But, if we did, the child's birth would likely involve a witch/midwife named Angela Hebamme who may have also delivered KF and Emanuelle as babies. Who is this witch? One place you can find her is in Adventures Afoot in The Reikland. But, that's another story.
What about the Greys? Oh, yes, I said I'd explain why the Countess banned Grey Wizards in her city. It's all because of one man: Immanuel-Ferrand, KF's older brother, a Grey Magister and spymaster of the Empire. She despises the man, primarily because he is responsible for the court in Altdorf turning against her. She believes he has been using the Grey College as a personal weapon against Nuln in support of his family. And she's correct.
Final opinions. Lastly, here's what the Countess of Nuln thought of our southern Glorious Heroes by the end of the episode:
Adelaide. The Countess was charmed by Adelaide's dry wit and unusual visions, so she intends to see through her invitation to the Morrian to her private parties during Black Powder Week. However, she doesn't put much stock in the woman's insights as Adelaide could not see past her prejudices to the truth of the situation she was in. So, Adelaide is someone to potentially tie to her court, but not someone to rely upon.Birdie. She really disliked Birdie and had her imprisoned. But what she learns from that imprisonment terrifies her. More on that in a much later blog-blog.
Birgitte. The Countess liked the Myrmidian and will invite her to attend her palace over winter to provide her with a better political education. Which, it could be argued, is a huge mistake on her part given what Sage chose. But, more on that later, too!
Elrick. Elrick was arrested then somehow escaped from her cells. A Verenean escape her justice by choice? The Countess moves from suspicion of Elrick to outright hatred of the man, quite certain he is a Grey Magister. She is not so foolish as to not realise that there is almost certainly a second Elrick in the north who is not an 'imposter', but she is unlikely to ever trust that one either.
Gerhardt. Not worth her time in the slightest. She imagines the 'imposter' in the north is worth even less of her time and would likely have him arrested on sight for being some form of spy or double-agent.
Luitpold. To begin, she was impressed with the Sigmarite and was considering bringing him into her court, but it became evident that the man leapt to conclusions and lacked the wisdom to tell that he did so, making it particularly difficult for her to discern his holy revelations from his personal delusions. Because of that, she decides he is more potentially more dangerous than useful, so determines to use him rather than listen to him. Emmanuelle sends him north bearing secret letters to the court of Middenheim, which, Luitpold claims, he can and will deliver.
Part 6 tl;dr
Six supposedly blessed priests meet with Elector Countess Emmanuelle of Nuln. She finds out that two of them are imposters and correctly identifies them. The first imposter is Elrick, who is actually a Grey Wizard using illusions. The second imposter is Birdie, who is actually a BIG RAT Skaven creation. That means the Gerhardt and Luitpold we see in this episode are the 'real' versions, leaving the Gerhardt and Luitpold in the north as 'imposters', as will be examined in Episode 58: The Horned Rat Rises. It was the players who decided to do this, during this episode, and they could have chosen differently if they had preferred. I didn't know what they would choose until they told me on the day, but I prepared for all potential eventualities.
...
And that's that!
...
Phew!
That was a freaking huge post, and it's likely full of errors as I don't have the time to proofread all of that as fully as I'd like given I accidentally used multiple tenses all over the place when writing it, and quickly edited it after so it made more sense. So, if you spot mistakes, please let me know. I'll fix them.
More importantly, I hope it clears the episode up for you all.
I suppose I now need to write a Gotrek and Felix (and Alamennowyth) short story. That's not something I thought I'd ever be doing.
As always, if you have any comments or questions about this blog or feel I missed some important stuff from Episode 57 that needs to be discussed, post here on Patreon, where the PCs can't see, or in the #all-access-lawhammer channel in LAWhammer, where, it's worth again noting, the PCs can't see!