Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

No sense being coy, you know what's coming -- Montreal visit! I won't spoil it, but it was NOT a city I'd been to before, and I'm kind of kicking myself for not having visited sooner.

Here's an issue that's kind of tangential, but at the same time kind of integral to one of the main themes of tomorrow's video: the power business owners wield over things like parking and streetscape changes, particularly on commercial streets, in the US. I don't really get into it TOO much in the video, but in my discussions with locals, it seems decisions on whether to make a street car-free, or to change a street cross-section to create protected space for bikes, are largely handled at the borough level (Montreal has 19 boroughs, or arrondissements), with not nearly as much consultation with affected businesses as we do in the US...for better or worse.

So here's a question. Do we do community engagement, public involvement, whatever you wanna call it, "right" in the US? Do we do way to much of it, get bogged down, and end up giving too many individual people and businesses de facto veto power over projects that seemingly have wide community benefit? Do we do not enough, or the wrong kind, or talk to the wrong people? This is a really vague and broad question, and the answer depends on where you are and which projects you're talking about and how you define benefits and impacts, etc. Yeah, yeah, I know.

But I am interested in hearing personal experiences with outreach and involvement in projects that affected you personally. Any success stories? Or just a lot of frustration and mediocre outcomes?


Files

Previews only

Comments

pigs

In Portland, what always annoys me is the city will do surveys and studies and ultimately find people want safe streets and bike infrastructure. To quote a fellow advocate: "Over and over again in their reports they say the feedback from the public is to invest in safe transit, walking, and biking, but in dollars, Metro plans to spend just 2% of its transportation budget on biking, and 2% on walking, for the next 22 years! 42% of the budget will go to automobile transportation" Portland seems to have gotten better at using public feedback on a project to tweak a project, but almost never cancels a project because of "business interests". Also, what do you do with your cat on your trips? Do you bring the cat with you on your travels?

Christi

I didn't understand why Montreal underground plaza/shopping is acceptable but hated the same in Minneapolis. Yes Montreal has more vibrant street culture - but direct comparison of a city with a population of 425K to a city with a population of 1.76M doesn't make a ton of sense. Does it?

CityNerd

They're both actually about 4M metro population. To be fair, Twin Cities is split between two different downtowns. I didn't really like the Montreal underground much better than the Mpls skyways just based on design stuff, just observing that Montreal's had much less detrimental effect (seemingly) on street life, for a metro area of roughly the same size. And I didn't hate the Mpls skyway, I said pretty explicitly in the video that I had mixed feelings and I actually used it to get to the Twins game!