Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

So, a few times in the past couple months I've mentioned the idea of doing a video on RRFBs (tune in later today if you want the acronym spelled out in the most painful way possible...or just google). Well, today's video is SORT OF that.

What it's really about is the generally ridiculous approach US-style traffic engineering takes to try to "accommodate" (what a condescending word!) people walking and biking, particularly when crossing busy streets. I talked about this some in my podcast with Jason (Not Just Bikes), but I expand on it in this video and try to articulate the problem with a little more detail and a little more force.

It's a different video for me...I guess? It's a little like the one I did on ridiculous intersection and interchange configurations last year. Anyway, I'll be interested to check analytics later today and see if people are tuning in, because it's one I think is "important," for whatever that's worth. (Note it's also the first time I felt like I needed a sort of content warning at the front of the video, because the underlying reality is, a lot of the locations where you see devices like this are places where people were struck and killed.)

My question for you all is: when you see dayglo signs on your street, does that make you feel safer, or does that make you feel like you're in a place that's probably unsafe by design? Ugh, I don't know how to ask that without it being a leading question. There's no doubt, I think, that individual treatments like this make locations safer *in a vacuum* -- so I guess I just want your general impressions of this kind of signage and infrastructure where you live, if you have any. Good? Bad? Mixed bag?

Files

Previews only

Comments

Nancy Hirsch

What are your thoughts about the "20 is plenty" programs popping up across the US? As an active transportation planner, I feel like this is a no-brainer that could be tied to land use, essentially any residential property mandates an enforceable reduced speed with potential for raised crosswalks to support slowing down. As Detroit continues to design behemoth vehicles of death, only speed reductions will solve most fatal crashes.

CityNerd

I love 20 is plenty. I didn't really dwell on it, but I love that Albuquerque uses an 10mph sped limit on bike boulevards. When I worked in Portland, I believe they changed many of theirs (which they brand "Neighborhood Greenways" because they envision the streets as being great for walking AND biking, and providing enhanced crossings for all non-motorized road users) to 20mph. I kinda like 18, it's so specific and eye catching. But yeah, for posted speeds that low you kind of do need speed humps, raised crosswalks, filtering, etc.

Cathy Douglas

Thanks for doing a video about my question, Mr. Nerd. I can now claim internet fame as "Unknown." I had an interesting interaction with a fellow pedestrian crossing at an RRFB-empowered intersection yesterday. It's just a two-lane street, not that big but very busy since an Amazon fulfillment center went in. You have to cross it to get between my neighborhood of public and affordable housing, and the other side, where there are schools and a bike network and decent blue collar jobs. I was doing my volunteer job, which is taking care of a garden patch near the crossing. When I was done working and packing up my gardening stuff, I noticed a guy waiting to cross, standing at the edge of the sidewalk for several minutes, watching the cars go by in either direction but not pushing the beg button that would activate the RRFB. When I was ready to go home I joined him at the crosswalk. We stood there silently for another two minutes watching traffic go by without even slowing down, though both of us were obviously waiting to cross. Finally both lanes of traffic were clear. As we were stepping out into the street, he pushed the beg button to activate the RRFB. I looked over at him and asked, "You waited all that time, why did you just push the button now?" He said, "You can't be too careful."

CityNerd

Haha, I try not to use names on suggestions that come to me in direct messages! That vignette is pretty depressing. That's something I wanted to talk more about in the video, but I cut it -- the fact that our transportation system puts all the onus on the pedestrian (and bicyclist, mostly) to decide what's safe and what isn't, how much of a risk to take or how "conservative" to be.