Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

OK, this is probably jinxing it, but I am right now about as far ahead of schedule as I've been since last year. Today's video was basically done over the weekend, and I actually recorded the A-Roll part (narration in my "studio") for NEXT week's video yesterday. I needed to make my time as flexible as possible for this week's visits to Seattle and Portland, because I have a lot on my to-do list in those cities that isn't going to allow much time for sitting around editing, etc. -- probably just early mornings.

Anyway. Today's video is all about farebox recovery ratio, in other words, how much of a transit service's operations get covered by fares alone. The New York commuter train services, shown above, run around a .50-.60 recovery rate. Places that offer "free" transit (hint: it still gets paid for, just not by fares) have a 0.00 recovery rate. It all gets explained in the video. Anyway, one thing I don't really get to the bottom of in the video, which I STILL don't have a great answer for, is...what's the "correct" farebox recovery rate? Is it 1.00, meaning fares pay for all operations? Or is it even higher than 1.00, so fares can pay some capital costs too? Or is it 0.00, because fares are regressive and we should be using progressive taxation to fund transit? Or something else? Or... is it not one size fits all? And if not, what does it depend on? I'm interested in people's perspectives/philosophies on this!

Files

Previews only

Comments

Tasnim T

I definitely think 0 is ideal. That being said, if some amount of farebox recovery makes it politically feasible to have transit when it wouldn't be possible otherwise, then I think it's a worthwhile trade. Allowing for people to work and live easily without cars is still a considerable financial benefit for less affluent people (and everyone else) despite the cost of fares.

CityNerd

Yeah I think it really does always come back to politics, and that's gonna vary from metro area to metro area.

Brooke Austin

Even if we’re going for pure “fairness”, i.e. no one is subsidizing anyone else, I think it’s fair to shoot for lower than 100% fare-box collection rate, given that people who take public transit are not availing themselves of the massive subsidies allocated to drivers, in effect saving everyone money. Considering the social externalities of driving as part of this would also be reasonable. I guess it’s all about what the city wants to incentivize, right? Heck, maybe that number is even negative? An unnamed large tech company on the east side of Seattle I heard pays their employees like five bucks per day if they arrive not by car. Quite possibly a purely self-interested move because the campus has very limited parking. It’s cheaper to bribe the employees to not drive. Of course, paying people to ride the train would probably result in very silly outcomes 😅